Cover Image: My Heart in Braille

My Heart in Braille

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

"My Heart in Braille" is a fast-paced and engaging graphic novel that delves into the lives of two teenagers facing distinct challenges. One grapples with academic struggles, while the other, a brilliant student, confronts the daunting prospect of losing her sight. In the midst of adversity, an unlikely friendship blossoms.
This endearing narrative expertly captures the essence of its main characters, painting a vivid portrait of their personalities and struggles. The depiction of the character going blind is handled with sensitivity and authenticity, offering a realistic portrayal of disability representation.

In summary, "My Heart in Braille" is a touching and poignant tale of friendship, resilience, and understanding. It's a quick but impactful read that skillfully explores the complexities of its characters' lives. This graphic novel is a worthwhile addition to any reader's collection, offering a unique perspective on the strength of human connections in the face of adversity.

Was this review helpful?

My Heart in Braille
By Boris Chamberlain and Anne-Lise Nalin
Thank you to Netgalley. for the copy for an honest review
This is a cute YA romance comic, it is very short but sweet story. The artwork is is cute I love it.
I found the story a little bit of a let down, it felt incomplete and a bit rushed.
Rating 3 stars

Was this review helpful?

4.5 stars

A beautiful graphic novel. I just wish it was longer. My Heart in Braille is a great story with stunning art that I think had more potential. Though I really liked it and like the characters I think there was a bit more room to dive more into each person.

But that being said I still thoroughly enjoyed myself and will probably read this again. I may even buy it.

Thanks to Net Galley and the publisher for allowing me to read this in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

A cute YA romance comic between a boy who has trouble at school and a smart girl with a secret.
The drawings are lovely, all curves and tender renditions. The characters are all very defined and expressive, even with the low action. The colours are beautiful and definitely help set the mood.
This is a very cute story, good for the youngest teens too.
There was something that bothered me a little, though. I am not a fan of self sacrificing love stories, and I feel like this one was perhaps not built on the healthiest grounds. Victor never revealed his own passions but plunged right into Marie's. If this is just a first volume with reciprocity coming, this is fine, but this didn't look like it... so I'm a little reserved.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and the publishers for an advanced copy in exchange for my honest review!

3.5
It is a very short but sweet tale about two teens falling in love despite all their differences. Victor, infamous for doing poorly in his studies meets Marie-Jo, a straight-A student. After months of studying together, they end up falling for each other. This story happens at a break-neck speed, and you never get to sit and learn about the characters. Everything you learn about anyone is entirely through exposition. The overall story is very sweet, but I feel like it's trying to make itself out to be more than it is so it comes off as a bit pretentious. The art style I absolutely adored, however! The art was phenomenal and was a huge reason why I finished this graphic novel!

Was this review helpful?

"My Heart in Braille" is a lovely comic book, wonderfully illustrated.

It tells the story of Victor, a garage-band teenage boy struggling with school work who strikes an unlikely friendship with Marie-Jo, a straight-A student who dreams about playing the cello professionally. It would be best for me not to tell you more about the story, as Marie-Jo's (rather obvious) "secret" is revealed later on in the comic.

To me, it was pretty clear that this comic was, A) adapted from a novel, and B) translated from French into English. The dialogs felt a little unnatural and stilted, and I felt some things were missing from the story or some elements of the plot never solved. I feel like the adaption from novel to comic could have been a little better, had the comic been a little longer. Also, as a native French speaker, some wordings/phrases sounded like a direct translation rather than an interpretation into English, making some sentences feel unnatural and it distracted me a little.

Overall though, it is a sweet and interesting story, perfect from middle-aged kids, and beautifully illustrated, so I would recommend it!

Was this review helpful?

My Heart in Braille is inner working through the visual, an exploration of characters and literary elements, a wonderful and immersive example of what comics can do.

Was this review helpful?

The first part of this graphic novel it seems like the story is mostly about Victor's struggles at school. Victor was a really likable character and I really felt for him, with the way almost all adults in the story seemed constantly to be disappointed in him. I kind of got the feeling that he might have ADHD, with the way he seemed to struggle to remember stuff and blurt out things in class, but this was never really mentioned. Instead, the solution to Victor's problems comes in the form of Marie-Jo, who helps him study so that his grades go up. I wish instead of the message that you just need to study harder if you're failing your classes the story would have focussed more on why Victor was failing his classes. I also wish that some of the teachers had listened more to Victor expressing his struggles and offered help in some form.

Initially I liked seeing Victor and Marie-Jo together and it was nice to have some much needed disability representation. However, the second part of the graphic novel focussed more on Marie-Jo's struggles and I wasn't a fan of how Victor wasn't just supporting her; it seemed like her problem became his whole identity. He seemed to have so much anxiety around it (more than her) that their relationship just didn't seem very healthy anymore. Additionally, Victor keeps one of his main interests secret from Marie-Jo, because he feels like she might look down on it. While the big reveal that I was dreading never happened, the issue was also never addressed and it remains unclear if he was ever honest about it.

Some of these critiques are maybe not the fault of the graphic novel, as this is apparently an adaption of the novel A Friend in the Dark. And there were definitely parts that I did like. As mentioned earlier, Victor himself is wonderful and I loved his friendship with Hussein. It was also nice seeing such a strong father-son relationship in a young adult book. The best part of this graphic novel was absolutely the artwork. It had lots of character and the colours were beautiful.

Was this review helpful?

A sweet story of friendship, music, keeping secrets.

I thought this comic was a lovely read, the relationship between Victor and Marie-Jo was so sweet. I loved the ending. The illustrations and colous were lovely and added a lot to the story.

Was this review helpful?

I have such mixed feelings about this one. The cover itself is stunning and the artwork is beautiful. However, the writing was a little all over the place and felt incomplete. The band for instance, what happened? I also wished the story focused more on the relationship and character development.

Thank you to netgalley and the publisher for the arc in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Victor is struggling to find his place at school, finding it hard to concentrate and apply himself. He is drawn to Marie Jo, a hard working student who he ends up being tutored by. During their sessions he realises Marie is hiding a secret and he is compelled to help her as best he can.

The art is beautiful beyond believe, some do the best graphic novel art I’ve seen.

But I wanted to love the story so much more. I’m intrigued by the concept of the story, but I feel the translations meant the emotion of the story was lacking and overall I felt the pacing was off. Victor and Marie Jo go from zero to 100 in a handful of panels and I just couldn’t be invested in their relationship. I’m genuinely gutted as it had potential for me, and I’m so happy for those this worked for.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the copy of this book in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I thank NetGalley, the publishers and the author for providing me this ARC in exchange of an honest review.

This is the graphic novel based on a 2012 young romantic novel and has been made its way to the big screen as Le coeur en braille aka Heartstrings. It has at its core the touching issue of a person losing sight and slowly transforming into a Person with Disability.

It is a heart touching story of two young students who are at divergent ends of the school spectrum. The story also lightly touches upon the case of premature eyesight loss
Mary Joe is a straight A student and a divine cello player with a passion and love for classical music while Victor has almost no interest in studies but is interested in modern music and plays with friends as a rock band and also has a passion for replica cars. His uncanny knowledge of cars comes from the quizzes he has with his father, an aficionado. The twain meet and hit off mainly for Victor to improve his grades and Mary Joe volunteering to help but slowly their trust improves and they start having an amazing chemistry in everything.
A real short love story.

The story like most graphic novels/manga has a post script at various points highlighting the humor.

The book gives a nod to the quandary of the PwD's and how it is a difficult weight to bear and how it is even more difficult to share with others and still get people to help but look you in the eye as an equal without the pity.
The story tugs at a myth of Ariadne's thread which helped the Minotaur slayer Thesius to escape the labyrinth.
The friendship between the duo tugs at heartstrings and when Mary Joe opens up with her secret and also confesses her love, Victor offers his help and in the process we also see the gradual transformation of Victor. There are bittersweet moments like every other YA romance story.

My only qualm was that the loss of eyesight is given the name of a degenerative disease but loss of eyesight happens to new born and extremely young kids naturally but people in their adolescence do not get degenerative eye disease naturally, it can only happen with some accident or other reason. Considering that PwD's and their issues are a big challenge in society and I myself being an activist of sorts this was a vague issue and was offered in passing although it is the very crux of the story. Despite the power of the rest of the story this brought down my satisfaction levels for this story. I would have liked more details although to be fair this is a very short graphic novel.

A recommended reading and a heart-touching love story.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and the publishers for a free copy of this book in exchange for an honest review!

First of all, the artwork in this graphic novel is absolutely stunning. I think that was my favorite part of the book. Apart from that, the story didn't really work for me. I did not feel emotionally connected to the characters. I like the representation of a degenerative eye condition, but the whole plot was about hiding her visual impairment and keeping her from attending a school for the blind. It was beautiful to see how committed Marie-Jo was to her music. The romance was sweet, if a bit immature. I feel that some of the dialogue may have been a bit lost in translation. For instance when Victor says the line that became the title of the book, I didn't really understand what he meant.

It is a quick young adult romance, and worth reading to appreciate the gorgeous illustrations!

Was this review helpful?

Victor and Marie-Jo's short little love story is adorable, with special focus on their shared connection with music and how they both evolve with Marie-Jo's growing blindness It's very sweet

Was this review helpful?

the graphics, colors, and layout are visually appealing. Victor and Marie-Jo are adorable. I will say the pacing was quick and a bit confusing at times. Wish there was more story about the band situation. Other than that it was fairly short, but had a fun time reading it.

Was this review helpful?

This was such a cute little story. I really enjoyed the visuals of Marie’s step counts to all the different locations, and I LOVE a musical-based story. I highly recommend reading this whilst listening to some cello for the full experience. I will say, I wanted to know about the band and I wish Victor hadn’t given everything up for Marie. It’s sweet, but I wanted him to have a success of his own!

Was this review helpful?

My heart in Braille is eye pleasingly wonderful, Even the font used & beautiful illustrations.

The story is about Victor. He loves vintage cars dearly and making music in his garage with his friends. But school is hard for him and he seems to always say the wrong thing or maybe he is just misunderstood by people around him. When he meets Marie-Jo, who plays cello and is brilliant in her studies, the two strike up an unlikely friendship, and before long both his grades and his attitude improve.

But it's not all flowers for both of them. So when one day Marie-Jo tells him her secret, Victor is dumbfounded. But he tries the best of his ways to help her out.

This is meet cute romance but I thought this book is about Victor and his struggles which are just sidelined when he is asked to help Marie. I would have loved it, if author had explored the limits and struggles of what Victor was facing and going through.

Overall a good read but could have been better.
Rating -3.5 stars

Thank you Netgalley and Europecomics for providing me with ARC in exchange of an honest review.

#netgalley #myheartinbraille

Was this review helpful?

This graphic novel follows two students and their friendship as it evolves into a romance. The cover art and title really intrigued me, along with the summary. However, the book was overall disappointing. The plot was thin and so spread out over the short amount of pages that it was somehow slugging. I didn’t believe the romance and it was very cheesy at points. I thought the plot line around blindness was not given the time and care it deserved either.

You may want to give it a try if you enjoy high school friends to lovers with a slower moving storyline. But I will sadly not be picking up a book from this author again.

Was this review helpful?

Author Joris chamberlain has created a heartwarming adaptation of the original French romance novel by Pascal Ruter. The characters are sensitively portrayed. He captures all the teenage angst and the emotional rollercoaster caused by the situations. His partner, artist Anne-Lise Nalin has provided stunning illustrations that capture the moods and setting.

I received a copy of this book from Europe Comics and NetGalley in exchange for an unbiased review.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Netgalley and to the publisher for this eARC.

2.5/5

Unfortunately I can’t say that I would recommend this book to anyone. I absolutely LOVED the art in it, but the love story was not convincing. Vincent and Marie-Jo’s relationship honestly seemed toxic- Vincent didn’t have much of a life (that we saw) other than hanging out with MJ and doing her schoolwork for her.

Also, the story itself was confusing and felt rushed. The way that it jumps between scenes so abruptly had me flipping back to make sure I hadn’t skipped a page.

I’m surprised that this graphic novel was so short because there was a lot of opportunity for this. I would have liked to see Marie-Jo playing in Vincent’s band, for example. And it would have been nice to see the pair realize that hiding Marie’s blindness and cheating in school is neither sustainable nor morally right. Then they could have opened up to the adults and we could have seen Vincent stand up for Marie and help her navigate life as a blind person.

Was this review helpful?