“The fact remained, there was more to what happened to them when they were children than even they knew.”


This book had a different kind of domestic-thriller vibe than the other books I’ve read by Sally Hepworth.

She tackled some hard-to-read topics like child abuse and the foster care system. It made the stakes feel a little higher and the ending more important.

Even though I had the twists figured out pretty early on, it was still a really compelling and hard-to-put-down book. I was deeply invested in the pursuit of justice and getting the ‘bad guy’ held accountable.

The main reason a person would not want to read this book would be if they were triggered by child abuse or their own experiences in foster care. I can see how this might not be a good fit for that.



The basic premise is that three sisters (not biologically, but bound by their shared trauma) spent a few years together in the foster home— Wild Meadows— under the care of Miss Fairchild who was anything but fair to children.

They eventually found a way to get out from her abusive hand.

Now, 25 years later, they’re forced to relive their trauma as old human remains have been found under the foster home. They have to confront their past, their fears, and their trauma, as they are both witnesses and suspects in the new investigation.

“Her testimony is compelling… You three had troubled childhoods and Norah has well-documented issues with violence. We’ve also seen enough to know that the three of you would do just about anything to protect each other. A lovely trait among sisters— but also a pretty powerful motivation to lie.”



Hepworth did a good job of creating three distinct personalities for the sisters and the ways they coped with their childhood.

We had:

Jessica: She lived with Miss Fairchild the longest and had experienced more of her narcissistic behvavior and manipulation. As an adult she is a home organizer which pairs well with her OCD. She battles her OCD with taking Valium, often from her clients’ houses… because most of them apparently need them too.

“No one repressed more toxic emotions than she did… All that repressed anger and nothing to show for it. She’d been repressing anger about it ever since.”

“Panic was her constant state of being, as familiar to her as breathing.”


Then there’s:

Norah: She was second to arrive at Wild Meadow having come from a mixed-bag of foster homes prior; she had learned to use violence to both protect herself and cope with her trauma. Her adult job is ‘helping’ people pass psychometric screening tests for employment by cheating and doing it for them. She also dates, not for relationship, but transactional sex that results in handyman chores done around her house.

“If there was one thing Norah had learned from growing up in foster care, it was how to take care of things. Her methods were a little unorthodox, perhaps, but they had to be.”

“One of the things that Alicia had always admired about Norah was the fact that she was a committed liar. Not to be confused with a good liar; Norah’s gift was the ability to come up with a lie on the spur of the moment and remain committed to it against all logic and reason.”


And lastly:

Alicia: Meant to be there only while her grandma was in the hospital, worse came to worse and her grandma died, forcing her into foster care for the duration. As an adult Alicia is a social worker, seeking to care for foster kids better than she was.

“Alicia wasn’t known for her wise, well-thought-out decisions. She was the one who threw caution to the wind, who took risks, who acted first and thought of the consequences later.”

“If there was one thing foster kids needed, it was fight.”


Jessica takes charge, Norah was the fight, and Alicia was the heart.

It was heartbreaking to read about their stories— what led them there— and what happened to them after.

Hearing four-year-old Jessica think that her mother died of sadness and worrying that she might too if she was too sad just wrenches you.

“Jessica didn’t know you could die from being sad. She remembered being very careful not to cry about her mother in case she died too.”

Even though I don’t share Norah’s love of dogs or care for some of her decisions, when you read a story like this you really love a character like Norah. Her strength and her fight is essential and it bolsters the reader and gives us hope that she won’t let her or her sisters be taken down. You cheer for her fight, for her resilience, for her spirit.

I love how Hepworth shows how even in trauma, relationships matter so much. Their sisterhood was what got them through. They had each other. Resilience is a really interesting and inspiring thing to study in real life when you hear people’s stories and how they came out of it.



The chapters of the book go back and forth between present and ‘before’ and change between the three sisters’ POVs. Hepworth did a good job of writing distinct voices for each character.

We also have these ‘mysterious’ chapters of a woman speaking with a therapist about her childhood. We aren’t told right away who it is, and even after we find that out, there is suspicion to be cast on the verity of what we are reading.

[I have a spoiler comment about that at the very end of this review.]



I don’t know much about the foster care system and how it differs (or not) from the US to Australia, but I think Hepworth did a good job in her portrayal. Obviously the story revolved around the hellish side of foster care, but she also shows Alicia as a social worker and really caring about the kids and wanting to sincerely help them.

I know several families who do foster care. In the healthy and right way. Hepworth acknowledges the ‘heroes’ of the foster care system in her acknowledgements at the back of the book which I think is important. It’s not all bad. And there are lots of people who are diligently fighting for these kids and for making the system better that we can’t forget about that side too.



It was really poignant to ponder how the social workers had told the girls they were ‘lucky’ to find that home with Miss Fairchild.

Jessica contemplates it: “If you were lucky, it implied that your good fortune hadn’t been earned. You couldn’t question it, or take it for granted. You had to be grateful. Because what had been given to you could just as easily be taken away.”

I like how Alicia is honest about it with the kids she works with: “Trish is a wonderful foster mother, and it’s very generous of her to keep you on [after you turn 18]. but you’re not lucky. You lost your parents. You lost your grandmother. You’ve spent the last few years living in uncertainty. Having a stable home until you finish school is actually a lot less than you deserve.”

“Love and security were the most basic of rights. Forcing these kids to believe they were lucky to have that was even more damaging than what some of them experienced in care.”

It really puts things into perspective, doesn’t it?

It reminds me of my significant role as a mother and the job and privilege I have to be the adult in my home to provide a safe, secure, and loving environment for my kids. Being a parent is much more than that but it can’t be less. And the significance of that is monumental. My heart aches for the children, young and old, who have been robbed of those basic needs.

Whether tragedy or parental neglect and selfishness, so many kids have been led to believe that they are not worthy of love. That they have to earn it and that it can easily be taken away.

More than anything I pray those kids find Jesus. He is the only one who will never disappoint and the hope he brings more than makes up for the losses they’ve endured. In him they find unconditional love, joy, grace, peace, mercy, comfort, patience, kindness, and gentleness. And his hope is secure- it can’t be taken and it can’t even be earned. It’s only a gift to be received. An eternal home for them to belong and be cherished.

To know how much I’ve found in Jesus, I can’t imagine how freeing and life-changing that would be for someone who never even knew a shadow of that love and security!

The Bible even uses the language of adoption when it comes to being part of his family. Each of us is grafted in, adopted as sons and daughters! (Romans 8:14-19; Ephesians 1:5; Galatians 4:5-7; Psalm 27:10)

At the very least, I hope if you read this book it can cause you to pray for the foster kids and families in your community.



Recommendation

This is a heavier book than some of her others and at times hard to read. But if these topics aren’t triggers for you, I would recommend this book.

It’s a fast-paced story with characters that will have you investing in either their triumph or their demise.

It reminded me a little bit of Ashley Audrain’s The Push.

Hepworth, of course, has her signature ‘gasp-inducing’ last chapter, but I feel satisfied with the ending and my spoiler comment below will explain why.


[Content Advisory: 24 f-words, 18 s-words; a little bit of sexual content in the form of a brief sex scene and a character sexting; two characters are in a lesbian relationship and it’s a somewhat prominent part of the book]


SPOILER COMMENT

......



.......




......


[ Okay so let me just talk about Dr. Warren for a sec. At first blush he is a terrible therapist and we eventually find out that Fairchild is playing him and manipulating him to better her defense at trial because he’s a sadistic pervert. BUT… I have a different theory.

And this is where I’ve landed because I think it’s plausible, but also because this kind of story requires justice in a big way and for me to end the book thinking Fairchild is getting off is just not going to work.

So here’s the deal… Dr. Warren isn’t incompetent.. he’s actually brilliant and devious. He knows what she is and he knows how to get her to talk. HE is playing HER. She thinks she has pulled one over on him, but I picture her experiencing a rude awakening when he’s actually gotten her to confess something in her sessions that he is able to help the prosecutor use to put her away for a long time. She was arrogant and thought she could get away with it, but nope. She dug her own grave.

Dr. Warren was pretending because he could see through her; he wasn’t pervertly drawn into her antics. Somehow he has trapped her in her own game. And justice is served.

Hepworth leaves this up to the imagination and this is what I’ve come up with. Feel free to adopt this theory as well. (hide spoiler)]

I REALLY enjoyed the plot of this one. It was so engaging and suspenseful. I inferred one of the twists but not the big one. I enjoyed the dual timeline and the physiatrist parts so much. Trying to piece this one together was a charm. I just wish there was more characterization. I didn’t feel invested or attached to any three of the girls. Honestly I felt more for Holly than anyone, which was fantastic writing on Sally’s part. I’m really glad there was no plot point left untied.

4.5 ⭐ rounded up- thanks to Netgalley and Macmillan Audio/ St. Martin's Press for the audiobook and e-book arcs of this novel. This was such a fun psychological thriller to read- I definitely did not want to put it down. Short chapters and multiple character perspectives are my favorites! I also enjoyed getting the multiple different timelines. I loved the bond that the sisters had from growing up in a foster home together while still each having their own personalities. This book took some wild turns and definitely kept me guessing. I didn't want to put it down! I only wish we might have had different narrators for the sisters in the audio version.

This was an enjoyable thriller and that last chapter made the book. I have enjoyed several books from this author and look forward to reading more of her books. This mystery is set in Australia and about three girls that grew up in the same foster home. It was well done and twisty.

This book was a great mix of intrigue and mystery with relatable characters. The story telling with multiple perspectives and timelines was enjoyable but at times a little hard to follow. I can see it being a great mini series though!

While initially I found the ending unsatisfying, once I got to the very end I felt it was a lot more satisfying

I finished this book a few hours ago and I’m still in utter shock by the ending! Wow just wow this is my second book from the author and so far both been absolutely amazing. New auto buy author for me and I’ll definitely be reading more of her work! I love how each character was unique and how they all interacted with eachother it was very realistic representation of a sister relationship.

Sally does it again. I love her writing, it flows, it's quick, it's not confusing. The story of these 3 foster sisters is deep. I loved hearing how the grew up. The tension builds and it keeps you guessing. It is always such an enjoyable read when it comes to this author.

This was so good! 4.5. Very solid mystery/thriller. Fulfilling twists and ending. I loved the buildup for the relationship between the girls. The ARC had soooo many grammatical errors/typos, but I'm sure those will be fixed for publication.

Sally Hepworth is one of my favorite authors and I was so excited to get an advanced copy of Darling Girls! It was definitely one of my most anticipated reads of 2024.

Jessica, Norah and Alicia are foster children that were placed with the stereotypical wicked foster mother, Miss Fairchild. She doesn't seem so bad to start with, but things quickly become weird and then worse.

The story jumps back and forth from when they were young to when they're all grown and they have to go back to the farm because some old bones were discovered.

The ending was definitely a twist that I didn't see coming.

Thank you to St. Martin's Press for the ARC through NetGalley.

This was my first Sally Hepworth, but it definitely won’t be my last.

We have three grown women who grew up in the care of Mrs. Fairchild and what happened within the walls isn’t all roses. Told in third person and first person for alternating chapters, I enjoyed watching this unravel.

Thrillers no longer really surprise me and I saw most things coming, I still felt the story was compelling and the characters were really fleshed out. Each girl had to work through their own experiences with their foster mother and their past trauma.

I enjoyed the touch of looking at ways of healing and how these experiences affect people into their adult lives and subsequent relationships.

There are some pretty dark themes, so be aware of that going in, but this one you’ll have a hard time putting down.

4.5/5 stars

Darling Girls is a domestic suspense book that focuses on 3 foster sisters: Jessica, Norah and Alicia.

The book is set in Australia and has multiple points of view. The story has a past/present timeline, which isn't always my favorite. However in this case the past was very interesting.

The three foster sisters all stayed with Miss Fairchild. And we go back and forth between their time in foster care and the present (where something is discovered at the house where they all lived).

I found both timelines to be quite riveting. I really enjoyed seeing how the girls bonded as children. And I really enjoyed the mystery in the present. I was especially interested in how all three women functioned as adults. And I was very curious about Amy.

Overall this was an intriguing mystery with some really fun reveals. And the last chapter was epic!

This book is not my normal genre but all the hype made me want to read it and I definitely not disappointed. It was a thrilling adventure with twist and turns and kept me guessing the whole way.

I’m glad I branched out of my comfort zone of romance to give this one a read. It was 100% worth the hype it has received.

Darling Girls
By Sally Hepworth
Published by St. Martins Press
4/23
3.5*

Sally Hepworth always has a good story to tell and her newest is no different. The story focuses on Mrs. Fairchild and her relationships with her foster daughters. Over the years she fostered many, but the story centers around the eldest three and another younger child that cannot be accounted for.

I feel I must disclose my state of mind in reading this book. I was post surgery and on pain pills, so each chapter featuring a foster child had me guessing at who and what happened. I also had a bit of trouble keeping track of the girls.

By the time I got near the end of the book, I had my theories, which were close but not on target. I loved the surprise, twisty ending.

Many thanks to Net Galley and St. Martin’s Press for allowing me to read an advance copy. I am happy to recommend this to readers and give my honest review.

This was my first Sally Hepworth book, and when I say I was blown away, that is exactly what I mean. Hepworth caught my attention from the first page, and I couldn't stop. I had a love-hate relationship with some of the characters, and couldn't stop thinking about the goings-on as I was reading them. The story follows the troubled lives of multiple women who were foster children and who suffered from mental, emotional, and even physical abuse from their foster mother as children. When a body is discovered in the ground where the home they shared once stood, they were all thrown back into the memories of what they had endured. As the investigation carried on, we learn so much about each character, and grow to either love or hate them, depending on who we are hearing from at that moment.

I truly loved this book, from beginning to end, and highly recommend it to anyone who loves a good thriller, or who loves Sally Hepworth in general. I'm going down the rabbit hole with her books after reading this, and cannot wait to read more of her work!

Thank you so much to NetGalley for providing this arc in exchange for an honest review. 5+ stars!

Sally Hepworth has done it again. If you are seeking a thriller that you can be immersed in this is the book for you. Three young preteens in foster care were placed in the home of Miss Fairchild. Reading this made me want to sign up to take foster children so they would not be treated the way these poor girls were. Truly heartbreaking. Their descriptions and actions seemed so very realistic and many times I forgot they were characters in a book. So happy they had each other and formed the lifetime bonds they did. Twenty five years later bones are discovered. Who do they belong to? What caused the death? This read will make you cringe as you judge the foster care system while you inwardly cheer for the poor children placed within its confines.
The additions of the sections of meetings with Dr. Warren kept me wondering and ultimately resulted in me figuring it all out…until the chilling ending.
Many many thanks to Sally Hepworth for another chilling read, St. Martin’s Press, and NetGalley for affording me the pleasurable opportunity to read an arc of this psychological thriller, published on 4-23.

I am shocked at home much I enjoyed this book! I couldn't put it down! The plot twist I didn't see coming but at the same time i kind of did if that makes sense. The writing was fantastic and completely drew me in and kept me excited about the book and where it was going to go

Not for the faint of heart. I should have known better than to read this book. As a former foster parent, this book was extremely hard for me to read. Unfortunately, the horrible experiences these poor girls go through are sometimes the cruel and unfair things that children in the system go through. It felt too real to me at times, reminding me of stories some of my kids had told of the things they experienced in other homes. Despite the heavy feelings this book brought on; the book was well written. The characters were well developed, and the story flowed well. This book was quite good and enjoyable but extremely sad. ⅘ stars. Thank you, netgalley, for sharing this book with me in exchange for my honest review.

Darling Girls is another blockbuster pyschological thriller from the master, Sally Hepworth. Young foster sisters Jessica, Alicia and Norah are raised by Miss Fairchild, who portrays herself as the benevolent dream-mother when really a monster lurks below the surface. Jessica found herself at Miss Fairchild's first and initially is living a fairytale but soon realizes she can never do enough to win Miss Fairchild's attention and affection. When angry Norah and sweet Alicia join the fold, they bond together and form a united front against the abuse. Decades later, still close as sisters but each facing their own demons following their upbringing, Miss Fairchild is back in the news. A body has been found on the property and the investigators ask the sisters to travel to the farmhouse as former residents to help shed light on the potential victim and cause of death. This novel, told in alternating timelines and perspectives, is as fast-paced as it is chilling. Is one of the sisters a cold-blooded killer? Or, is the truth far worse than what is imagined? Hepworth is at her best in this engrossing novel.

Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for this ARC in exchange for my honest feedback.

Jessica, Norah and Alicia aren’t related by blood, but they are sisters through and through. The three spent several years together at a lovely farmhouse as foster children. The woman taking care of them, Miss Fairchild, seemed to be a loving and kind woman.

But the time they spent there was horrific, and they endured emotional abuse and lived in fear. One day, they spoke out and were freed from Miss Fairchild’s care. But years later, each still carries wounds.

When police notify the women that human remains were discovered buried beneath where the house used to stand, they are asked to return to that place of nightmares, both physically and metaphorically. The headlines “practically write themselves” since they’re former foster children. People are fascinated by them and the lurid news. The police, well, they’re gathering information, but who knows when the women may be arrested?

I automatically picked up this book as an ARC because I’ve enjoyed Sally Hepworth’s other thrillers. And they’ve all been rated moderate. I was disappointed because this one has more strong content. I probably should have paid closer attention to the summary of the story; I have found I don’t do well with stories of abuse. That said, though, I also didn’t find the ending to be at all a surprise. It made complete sense to me, so it wasn’t a shocking twist. Not sure if that’s what it was meant to be, but it felt like a bit of a letdown.

So, all in all, Darling Girls is my least favorite of Hepworth’s books. My favorites would probably be The Mother-in-Law and The Good Sister.

Thank you to NetGalley, Sally Hepworth and St Martin’s Press for the free ebook in exchange for an honest review.

This might be one of my favourites from Hepworth; it was twisty, fast paced and very very tense. I was engrossed in this model right away and I wanted to just sit and read the entire thing. I enjoyed the pacing and the ending so much - I definitely recommend.