Skip to main content

Member Reviews

This book was amazing! It gives reader the ability to further understand mental illness but also keeping you engaged with a haunting, horror & captivating story. One of the things I loved about it, it really is a haunting story not like others books with ghosts involved. Thank you for this ARC!

Was this review helpful?

Something weird is going on in this house. Or with this family. Or both.
After an event that left her family traumatized and led to her bipolar iii diagnosis, Libby, her mom, and her younger sister seek a fresh start by moving into the home that's been in their family for generations.The home where almost a dozen of their ancestors have gone missing over the years. Are the strange things Libby is experiencing caused by the house or are they just hallucinations? With the help of their cute neighbor who has a vested interest in the house, Libby and her sister try to uncover the secrets behind The House of Masks.
 
This book was so atmospheric. The descriptive writing had me seriously creeped out at points. I could picture it all so clearly, I felt like a ghost in the corner watching everything unfold. It was eerie, dark, and mysterious. But what really stood out to me was the family dynamics and how they all acted after Libbys diagnosis. Vivi's hurt and anger toward Libby, the mom reiterating words from a pamphlet while simultaneously ignoring the most important advice, Libby struggling to hide her real feelings in fear of disappointing her family. It's messy, clumsy, and painful. Just like real life. I can't really speak to the accuracy of the bipolar disorder rep but considering it is a condition the author has, I am going to give the benefit of assuming it was handled with care.

Arc was from Random House and NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. Thank you!!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you Netgalley and Delacorte Press for the ARC!

"A Place for Vanishing" by Ann Fraistat is a haunting and gripping tale that weaves together elements of mental health, family dynamics, and supernatural intrigue. Libby, grappling with a recent bipolar disorder diagnosis and a life-altering scare, finds herself in her mother's childhood home—a sprawling historical marvel with unsettling secrets.

Before I get into this review, I do want to note the concerns I’ve seen from others with the mental health representation and accuracy within the book. As I am not an expert on mental health and the Type III Bipolar Disorder, I am not able to provide an accurate analysis of this representation in the book. I highly recommend looking over reviews from those with this perspective before reading my own. I will mainly just be focusing on the plot/characters of this book within my review.

The atmospheric setting of the House of Masks is a definite strength of this book. The vivid descriptions of stained glass windows, concealed staircases, and locked doors create an immersive experience. The addition of insects adds a layer of creepiness that complements the house's enigmatic history. If you’re like me and you hate insects, especially when thinking about them touching you, then you will definitely think this part of the book is extremely creepy. I think these descriptions worked in favor of the book and the atmosphere it was trying to create as there is quite a focus on insects throughout the book. The author's storytelling prowess shines through as the narrative expertly balances reality and the fantastical.

The writing of the book was very well-done and worked well as a paranormal psychological thriller. The fast-paced progression, intense last 25%, and the inclusion of a small romance subplot with Flynn contribute to a captivating reading experience. The romance, while not really important to the plot’s progression, was developed well and felt realistic, especially with the inner monologue of Libby showing her perspective and thoughts on Flynn. Libby's character growth and her relationships with her family members, particularly her sister Vivi, add depth to the story. I think I preferred the growth and transformation of Libby’s relationship with her sister and her mother over the romance.

I recommend "A Place for Vanishing" for readers who enjoy a blend of haunted houses and intricate character development. The book navigates the fine line between reality and the supernatural, creating a chilling and enthralling atmosphere.

Was this review helpful?

I just don't understand why it is that when there are so many ways to get a particular effect, writers use mental illness as entertainment to get where they want. And with the Internet, there's no excuse for not knowing more about the mental illness you choose to entertain people with.
There were a lot of things to like about the story, with its steady creeping of fear and dread. But it was focused on someone with a specific mental illness who is inaccurately portrayed. That's frustrating.
Thanks to NetGalley for letting me read this

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed this book! I loved the spooky aspect of the house and the way that we got to see how Libby acclimates- learning what's normal and what's not. I also really liked the idea of the masks!

Was this review helpful?

A true horror story in all its perfection! When I went into this book, I had every expectation that it was going to have a haunted house creepy vibe to it. But the author really gave homage to a classic horror story in this one.

While using a phenomenal comparison and contrast between the main characters mental diagnosis and the experiences throughout the story, you really get to immerse yourself in everything that happens.

A family already torn apart by a near tragedy, they continue to experience the calling of death that is on their door step. Some of my favorite lines from the book:

"Clearly, this house was in need of, as Mom put it, 'a lot of love.' But was anything truly wrong with it - or was I only seeing, yet again, my own mental distortions?"

"Just as a caterpillar undergoes dramatic transformation to evolve into a butterfly, Myers believed that only in death could humans achieve their superior form."

More than impressed with the authors ability to write such an immersive story; one that aligns a higher message with the inner workings of the plot. I couldn't put this book down and I was even more terrified of bugs than I already was after getting through the first few chapters. When a book has the ability to bring the pieces of itself to life in this manner, I am also a hooked fan for life!

Was this review helpful?

I tried to start this book and found myself losing interest pretty quickly. The protagonist from what I have heard is not represented correctly with her bipolar condition resembling schizophrenia more. While I'm not super informed on either of these two conditions, I trust those that do know and saw this as a blaring warning sign that left me, as a reader, not interested to read more. I skipped to the last chapter and still felt like I understood what happened in the whole book.

Was this review helpful?

A heavy YA horror/fantasy that deals with family trauma, mental health (depression and Bipolar III rep) as well as suicidal ideation. I really enjoyed the atmospheric quality and creepiness of this story and the excellent therapy rep, however, for me it was WAY too long. I felt it would have benefited from some serious editing but regardless, I still very much enjoyed it and would recommend to fans of authors like Tiffany D. Jackson. Many thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for an early digital copy and @prhaudio for a complimentary ALC in exchange for my honest review!

Was this review helpful?

Many thanks to NetGalley and Random House Children's for providing me with an eARC of A Place for Vanishing in exchange for my honest review!

This viscerally atmospheric and eerie piece of YA gothic horror is just the sort of thing I needed to fill me with dread and disgust. Right from the first few pages, it oozes a powerful mood that wraps me up in the unnerving and rotting state of the house that makes up the book's central setting—a house that boasts bugs and blue roses as significant markers to create distinct images in our heads. Libby stands as a compelling and sympathetic protagonist who's wrestling with a whole cauldron of feelings in regard to her struggling mental health and her fractured family. The twists and turns aren't all that wild if you really want to foresee them, but this doesn't detract from how riveting the journey is as it consistently rolls along, unveils the chilling truth behind Libby's new home, and dishes out many moments that slither the creepy-crawlies through my body.

My only major criticism is something that I hadn't even considered until I checked out reviews from other readers who called out A Place for Vanishing due to its depiction of Libby's bipolar III. As someone who's not bipolar, I can't speak on this from a personal perspective, but I saw others take issue with this aspect coming across as poorly researched and exploitative. Same goes for the portrayal of Libby's past suicide attempt and how it's used to drive the plot forward. These things didn't jump out to me, but I can understand them becoming major problems for other readers.

Overall, I'm officially rating A Place for Vanishing by Ann Fraistat 4.5 out of 5 stars, which I'll round down to 4 stars on Goodreads, and I'm eagerly looking forward to more of her work.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you Netgalley, Ann Fraistat, and Random House Children's, Delacorte Press for the advanced ebook! I loved the creepy but beautiful house vibes! This book gave me Conjuring vibes but the story was also quite beautiful ... a young girl struggling with mental health just trying to maneuver through life and come to terms with oneself learning how to navigate through all that is thrown your way.

Was this review helpful?

Vanishing Secrets Revealed
I arrived a bit tardy to the party, but when life gifted me a snow day with no excuses to avoid reading "A Place for Vanishing" by Ann Fraistat, I couldn't have been more thrilled. For four enchanting hours, I remained almost immobile, immersed in the tale. Following a recent bipolar disorder diagnosis and a life-altering scare, Libby's world is left in turmoil. In pursuit of a fresh start, her mother relocates Libby and her younger sister Vivi to their ancestral home, a sprawling historical marvel concealing unsettling secrets.

The narrative unfolds with an eerie ambiance, fueled by enigmatic masks in every room and a swarm of insects infesting the ancient structure. What truly unsettles Libby, however, is the town's collective knowledge, including the mysterious Flynn, about the ominous history of the house, marked by people mysteriously vanishing from its depths.

It becomes evident that something within the house craves attention, yearning to be unleashed, and Libby, Vivi, and their mother stand dangerously close to its dark desires.

A standout element in this book is the portrayal of mental health. Though the author's sources remain undisclosed in my early copy, the topic is handled with care and honesty. The narrative delves deep into the family's journey with mental illness, vividly depicting both struggles and triumphs. This exploration of mental health is intricately woven with a sinister undertone, creating a narrative tension that is both compelling and unsettling. While not every decision by Libby's mother aligned with my preferences, the eventual explanations satisfied my curiosity. I've already purchased "What We Harvest," another book by this author, anticipating another five-star read.

Overall, the writing is exceptional. I felt a sense of foreboding from the outset, and the suspense continued to build. The inclusion of breaks for family bonding and cutesy romance added a delightful touch. Gratitude to Netgalley and the publisher for providing a complimentary digital copy in advance.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you so much for an advanced copy for the story so you really have to look at the stream from a fresh perspective because otherwise you’re going to think it’s just another bug about a creepy house so I would say please go into it with fresh eyes and tell me what you think because I thought that it was a good book and it has some supernatural elements in it which I’m always down for because I love her and thrillerone thing I don’t like is bugs, so I just wanna give you a heads up about the bugs, but I would definitely recommend the story

Was this review helpful?

A Place for Vanishing is an interesting YA book about a family that moves into a home that is not what it seems to be. The main character, Libby, moves to her mom's childhood home which is anything but normal. Bugs haunt its winding halls, towering stained-glass windows feature strange, insectile designs, and the garden teems with impossibly blue roses. There are also rumors about people vanishing and weird séances. Libby has bipolar disorder and has had a rough go of it including a stay at a mental hospital. The fight scenes went on forever which caused me to start to skim the last quarter of the book. All in all, it was a good read, I think middle school and teens will dig this one.

Was this review helpful?

Nothing like reading a book at night that keeps creeping you out. I had to keep stopping and telling myself I need to continue during the day only. With that being said this was a good horror and suspenseful book. The atmosphere was earie and the world building was phenomenal. I wanted to know more with what was going on with the house and its history. A family home passed down with many secrets and vanishings. This book follows Libby right after a life altering event, whom is then diagnosed with bipolar type three. I truly feel the bipolar representation wasn't very well executed and could have been researched better.

Slow passed that picked up more than halfway.

Thank you NetGalley and Random House for giving me access to this book in exchange of an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

WOW! Thank you you NetGalley and the Publisher for this ARC. I absolutely loved this YA Gothic Horror. After a Bipolar incident and subsequent diagnosis, Libby and her family move to her childhood home for a fresh start. But it's all too obvious that something is lurking in the house, and it is t all the bugs. This had such a real depiction of Bipolar Disorder and an amazing aesthetic of a gothic, complete with haunted house. I adored all of the characters as well as the plot progression. The book had me hooked since Chapter two and the pace was fast all the way through. HIGHLY recommend!

Was this review helpful?

This book was phenomenal! It was such a fresh and new idea; I loved how it was written! Bugs bother me immensely but they definitely bother me after reading this! It was so well-written and the characters just came alive. I especially loved how Libby was so flawed and weak, but ended up being so incredible and strong. I had no issues with the free ARC, it was well edited and put together neatly. Fantastic story, and I can’t wait to read more from this author!

Was this review helpful?

This was a creepy paranormal horror story! The author’s writing style kept me hooked, loved the character development, and also found the plot to be unique. I know this is geared toward younger adults, but I still enjoyed it as an older adult and would recommend for all age groups. I’ll be writing a more in depth review and adding to my Instagram page as a recommended read. Thanks so much for the opportunity to read in advance!

Was this review helpful?

13 ghosts meet the Winchester mystery house in this bug riddled haunted house tale.

The descriptions in this book were so rich and visceral I felt like I could feel the wallpaper in this house and smell the overpowering scents. If you like ghost stories, the age of spiritualism and family coming together against all odds you'll love A Place for Vanishing. I could not put it down.

Trigger warnings for mentions of suicide, suicidal thoughts, attempted suicide, bipolar disorder, entomophobia, death, possession, bodily harm, gaslighting, family trauma, generational loss, missing persons, prescribed substance use, bullying.

Was this review helpful?

This was written so well. I was creeped out from the very beginning and the sense of foreboding kept growing along the way. Small breaks for family bonding and cutesy romance. So lovely.

This is actually what I like Horror to be: black and white. People are redeemable. The Baddies are actually bad. Dabbling in the occult is a no,no.

Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for a complimentary digital copy in advance.

Was this review helpful?

If you are chasing after a real supernatural horror story, pick this up. I will say that I’m not a fan of real supernatural things and situations that were presented here. This is entirely my personal opinion and taste and is not a criticism of the author’s fantastic work. I don’t enjoy monsters in the sense of demons. I also don’t like the ghost hunting tools and ideas of mediums. It’s a little too far for my tastes. I won’t go into more details because, big spoilers. (Trigger warnings for possession and suicide). Though, I will say the concept of the house of masks was captivating and the tension was real and I see why the author chose these topics as the horror element because of how they tie into the struggles of the main character; they’re a mirror of some of the struggle of mental illness. Anne Fraistat built up emotional and climatic events well. It was a roller coaster of ups and downs. My favorite part of this story was processing and experiencing the main character’s mental health and diagnosis. Navigating Libby’s Bipolar 3 inside her mind also felt like living in a haunted house and the horror being your own body and voice. I understand that for her, the Bipolar 3 was “possessing” her like the beetle tried to. I liked the raw aspect of it and the reality and reactions of people and how they respond and the fight she had every moment of every day. I liked that learning about Libby’s diagnosis brought me with her through the uncomfortable encounters she had with her family and how they also processed her. Fraistat made me think and feel about how I should and could respond better to others in my life. Fantastic work! I would recommend this book if you loved A House With Good Bones by T. Kingfisher and are looking for an adult variation of this concept.
Thank you to Anne Fraistat, publishers, and Netgalley for this eARC to review!

Was this review helpful?