Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Thank you to NetGalley for this ARC.

The Kamogawa Food Detectives is a delightful story that is guaranteed to bring a little joy to your day. This sweet tale focuses on a family that tracks down nostalgic dishes for its clients based on their memories and recreates them. It’s a simple story and a quick read that I would definitely recommend.

Was this review helpful?

Kamogawa Food Detectives is such a lovely story. Nagare, a retired detective, and his daughter Koishi work together to recreate food memories. Koishi does the interview gathering past memories and Nagare does the investigating. Together they nourish your soul. Thank you, NetGalley and Penguin Group for the opportunity to read an ARC. My opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

This was a delightful surprise. Having just returned from Japan, I enjoyed the detailed food descriptions...mouthwatering! What an idea...a food detective recreating recipes from someone's past. Each of the short stories was touching and successful!

Was this review helpful?

This lovely book of short stories tells tales of a father-daughter duo who runs a restaurant in Kyoto — and a detective agency that helps clients discover/recover favorite meals. Japanese cuisine features heavily in these stories, with excellent and evocative descriptions of tastes and smells. In one story, for example, a client wants to find out why his deceased wife was able to make a recipe that his current girlfriend (and potential next wife) cannot duplicate — the detectives help unearth the recipe but, more importantly, help the widower move on to the next phase of his life.

This is a quick, yummy read with feel-good vibes.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the digital review copy.

Was this review helpful?

Hello new comfort read! This is a wonderful addition to the cozy mystery genre.

This story follows a father-daughter chef-detective duo who find long lost meals for customers. Don't read this on an empty stomach, because the food descriptions will have you craving every dish! I've never been to Kyoto but the loving details in this book have me wanting to plan a trip now.

There's not much plot to this book, and that's not the point. It instead is a collection of short stories infused with the importance of food, family, and memories. I hope more people will pick this one up when it comes out!

Was this review helpful?

I was lucky enough to win an eARC of THE KAMOGAWA FOOD DETECTIVES by Hisashi Kashiwai through a Shelf Awareness giveaway. Thanks for the early look, and have a safe and happy holiday season!

Was this review helpful?

Just returned from Japan and really enjoyed this book of stories about a Kyoto food detective. The stories were lovely and the food detail was mouth watering!

Was this review helpful?

This is a classic case of a good book, but not for me! I think this book would be great for those who enjoyed 'Before the Coffee Gets Cold' by Toshikazu Kawaguchi. I like the father-daughter dynamic featured in the book, but the book was hard for me to get into.

Was this review helpful?

Calling all fans of nostalgia and comfort food - The Kamogawa Food Detectives delivers a father and daughter pair that work hard to recreate dishes that are connected to precious memories for their clients. The Kumogawa's run a restaurant that intentionally makes itself hard to find, but they also run a side business as food detectives. Their clients describe the food they want recreated with as much detail as possible, including when and where they ate it. These conversations reveal quite a bit about each individual character and paint portraits of people that are very different from what might first be assumed of them.

This work definitely leans into the feel-good vibes. If you are not familiar with Japanese cuisine, I highly recommend having a search engine available as you go through so that you can see visuals of the food listed. It all sounded scrumptious to me - and left me wanting to try and hunt down some of the dishes described. The tone is very similar to that of Kawaguchi's Before the Coffee Gets Cold, so for those of you that enjoyed that work I would be sure to check this one out.

Was this review helpful?

Nagare Kamogawa, former policeman in Kyoto, Japan, runs a diner and food detective agency with his adult daughter Koishi. Nagare does the sourcing of ingredients and the cooking, while Koishi's job is teasing out the details of from the clients. In order to even find the restaurant, the customers have to be very motivated. The building itself is nondescript and has no signage, and the only advertising is done via a very vague mention in Gourmet Monthly magazine. If people are determined and can track down the restaurant, they will be treated to the chef's daily special, and once they are suitably impressed with his skill, Koishi takes the customer back to the office where she can get the details of why they came. The detective agency exists for one reason: to recreate dishes that people have had at some point in their lives and want to experience again. Koishi tries to get as many details as possible: where was this food eaten, who was the person with, how old were they, what sights/smells/sounds can they remember, etc. As the dishes were eaten long ago, most of the details are rather vague. The clients are instructed to return in two weeks, at which time Nagare will present them with the dish that they remember from so long ago. Of course, the dishes all were eaten with people who are no longer alive or are ill, so a big part of the memory is tied up with longing to be back in a time or place that can never be experienced again.

While the stories are all very touching, the book itself is an ordeal to read. There are so many Japanese foods, dishes, ingredients, place names, etc. mentioned in nearly every sentence that it's difficult to get any "flow" when reading. Then there is the excruciating detail about how each ingredient in the various dishes was tracked down and prepared -- and every dish has dozens of ingredients. It's hard to believe how the people in the "memories" and the chef of today spend hours and hours sourcing individual ingredients from various locations and then have to subject each item to meticulous treatment (such as drying mushrooms in the sun, "rehydrating" them, and boiling them down with other things before adding to the main dish). Each recipe had numerous ingredients, and the chef was happy to list them all, where they came from, how they were prepared, and how each individual step was necessary to recreate the exact dish the person remembered. It was exhausting to read. Maybe people who are massive foodies will enjoy reading about such things as mame-mochi, nabeyaki-udon, kamaboko, nikujaga, hirosu, okara, kikuna, ebi-imo, kujo negi, tonkatsu, etc. but after just a few chapters I was craving something with simple ingredients!

Was this review helpful?

This is fun and already has lots of helpful reviews, so I'll just recommend it to cozy readers.

I really appreciate the free copy for review!!

Was this review helpful?

Book: The Kamogawa Food Detectives
Author: Hisashi Kashiwai; Translated by: Jesse Kirkwood
Format: Digital
Genre: Food & Wine, Short Stories
Places Featured: Kyoto, Japan
Review Score: ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️
Review: I was a little surprised at how much I enjoyed this–it doesn’t really have a plot, but it is just a collection of sweet short stories about the power of food, family, and memories. Nagare, a retired police detective, and his daughter, Koishi, run the Kamogawa Diner in Kyoto, Japan–a small hard-to-find place with a very specific clientele. The diner mostly serves guests who are looking for a specific meal–a dish that meant something to them at some point in their lives they want to recreate. Each chapter is the story of a certain guest, the dish they’re looking for, why they’re looking for it, and how Nagare works to recreate it. Although I had to spend some time researching many of the Japanese ingredients and dishes mentioned in the book, the descriptions still made my mouth water. (There are also some great descriptions of Kyoto.) For a short, quick, feel-good read (especially if you’re a Japanophile for a foodie), check out this book.

Was this review helpful?

★★★★☆

The Kamogawa Food Detectives is a heartwarming culinary tale translated from Japanese by Jesse Kirkwood. Centered around a Kyoto restaurant run by Koishi and her father Nagare, this light mystery follows the Kamogawas as they recreate meaningful dishes from customers' pasts. It's a poignant celebration of food, memory, and human connection.

Author Hisashi Kashiwai brings the setting of Kyoto to life through vivid sensory details, particularly the mouthwatering cuisine. Protagonist Koishi is spirited and curious, complemented by her father's wisdom and cooking expertise. The "food detective" premise is original and intriguing. Each chapter focuses on recreating a touching dish for a customer, seamlessly blending miniature mysteries, cooking, and emotion.

The soothing pace, uplifting tone, and focus on food over plot make this perfect for foodies seeking a gentle read. While the mysteries themselves are relatively simple, the stories behind each lost recipe are moving. Food and memory are deeply intertwined here; the Kamogawas' dishes unlock powerful nostalgia and closure.

Readers seeking an in-depth thriller should look elsewhere, but as a heartwarming journey celebrating food, family, and second chances, The Kamogawa Food Detectives delivers. Kashiwai's prose is inviting, with restaurant scenes sure to make your mouth water. A poignant four stars, the only way this could have been improved is if recipes had been included in-depth for all the meals.

Was this review helpful?

This cozy collection of stories set in a Japanese restaurant with a food detective agency was the perfect palette cleanser for me. It’s short and sweet and I appreciated the same structure of each story (person comes in wanting a meal recreated, then when they come back and try it). Some of the stories were more endearing than others, but I overall enjoyed this book and the beautiful descriptions of Japanese food and the relationship between the father and daughter who run the restaurant/detective agency.

Thank you Netgalley and Putnam for an advanced copy in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I was really hoping to like this one because I have read one Japanese novel that I loved (The Traveling Cat Chronicles) but this one was hard to get into. I was pretty bored and didn't feel super connected to the characters. It also felt pretty unrealistic. But I did love all of the food descriptions! That was so well done. I also love Japan and have been to Kyoto so that I also loved that personal connection. It was just hard for me to really get into the story.

Was this review helpful?

This was such an enjoyable little story! The creativity of the plot and the descriptions of food were definitely where this book shined, and I think the atmosphere is one that a lot of readers will enjoy. I did find myself wishing that the chapters were less repetitive (I was able to predict entire sections of dialogue because they were being said in every single chapter) and we spent more time learning who the father and daughter were especially. I enjoyed having some regular customers that would return from chapter to chapter, but I still found myself wanting more characterization from each of the visitors as their stories and personalities really did begin to blur together by the end. In general, though, my complaints can be boiled down to wishing the vignettes were longer and more fleshed out, which is definitely not a deal breaker for me. The story was still very cozy, and a breeze to get through. A great book to curl up with in a warm cafe and read in one or two sittings.

Was this review helpful?

Quite possibly my favorite read since encountering the Thursday Murder Club series. This is the coziest of cozy mysteries, highlighting the restorative powers of food, community, and understanding the past to move forward in the present.

A father and daughter run a small diner tucked away in a quiet part of Kyoto. And if a certain type of diner is fortunate enough to find themselves there, the restaurateurs also are food detectives, helping track down and recreate the diners' favorite meals. Each chapter stands alone but, together, the vignettes draw a picture of the proprietors and their patrons. Even more than the mouthwatering descriptions of the food, the gentleness and care for these characters and their interior lives makes this the most delightful and gentle of reads that is the perfect respite from the chaotic world.

Was this review helpful?

Gentle, sweet, atmospheric, and oh so charming. This book will transport you into your own cherished memories and leave you feeling all of your feelings. Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the chance to read this one early.

Was this review helpful?

Very sweet book about a food detective agency, linking foods to memory and sentiment. What a wonderful idea.

Was this review helpful?

A delectable read filled with wonderful characters and lots of good memories.

A quick cozy read.

Thanks NetGalley for this ARC.

Was this review helpful?