Skip to main content

Member Reviews

This book tells a complete, fulfilling, well-rounded story, which is particularly impressive because it consists entirely of dialogue (which is mostly, but not always, one-sided). Luciana's voice is engaging and makes her story feel immersive and compelling. Her journey was a satisfying one to follow. Having dates or timestamps at the beginning of each chapter would have made the timeline clearer regarding how much time is passing. Although this is Luciana's story, I did want to know more about what was happening with one other character specifically--I was hoping for an in-person conversation between the two at the end of the book, but I understand limiting the chapters to phone calls only. I would recommend this book to anyone wanting a story about someone learning to stand up for themselves when everything in their life is in upheaval.

Was this review helpful?

DNF. I really wanted to like this and it seemed right up my reading alley when I was invited to review it by Random House. However, the format was a great idea but the interjections of other conversations made it hard to concentrate.

Was this review helpful?

It took me a while to get used to the non-traditional format and style, but I thoroughly enjoyed this story. I love generational stories about strong women, their struggles, growth and triumphs, and this one fits the bill.

High school senior Luciana shares drama, fears and concerns about family members in one-sided phone conversations with her sister Mari who is away at college. Luciana misses Mari terribly and accuses her of being self-centered without seeing that she is centering herself throughout the first part of the story, in exactly the same way as her sister.

Everyone is nuts - in a nice way. Loud, opinionated, sometimes angry, goofy…and hilarious. They are all lovable characters, doing their best to survive and thrive despite generational trauma. Dark family secrets are starting to leak out, bit by bit, and Luciana is trying to figure out how she fits into her family’s story and how she fits into her own life.

Abue…the girl’s grandmother, is the central figure in Luciana’s life. While Luciana and Abue are very, very close, Luciana has a love/hate relationship with her controlling mother, and while she misses her sister, she resents her for leaving and feels abandoned by her.

Through all the drama, trials and tribulations she is experiencing, Luciana learns to love herself. She finds her voice and strengths and grows into herself.

In the end, this story is about love.

*The four star rating is because I'm not a fan of the one-sided phone conversation format. The story was great, though!

Thank you to Melissa Mogollon for a great story. Keep telling your stories and sharing them. Thank you to Penguin RandomHouse, and NetGalley for letting me read the ARC and share my first NetGalley review also shared on Goodreads and Facebook

Was this review helpful?

I found the structure of this book very difficult to navigate. The promise of a good story is there but the delivery makes it very difficult to,find.

Was this review helpful?

Hey! Oye! Oh, that’s Melissa Mogollon’s debut novel. Oye. It is unlike any novel I’ve ever read. Yes, I’m talking about its structure, which is without a doubt, unorthodox. It’s basically a series of one-sided phone conversations between teenage Luciana and her older sister Mari. There are other voices, too, which are set apart by italics. I found this quite confusing much of the time, as it was often difficult to discern who was speaking.

Oye is described as “a coming-of-age comedy.” Initially, as Luciana and her mom prepare to evacuate because of the hurricane that is bearing down on Florida and Abue (from abuela: grandmother) refusing to leave her home, I found little humor. The first time I laughed out loud was when Luciana is on the phone to Mari from the road and refers to the governor, Rick Scott, as Voldemort, the uber-villain from the Harry Potter series! “Dude! “Luciana says that a lot.

Her mother wants her to make something of her life, to have adventures. Luciana just wants to go back home once the danger has passed. Mom wants to go sightseeing. Eventually, they do return, and what they find is not good. Abue is facing a major health crisis.

As the story evolves, we learn much about Abue’s past. She endured much as a young girl and as a wife and mother. Now, as she faces a life-threatening illness, her daughter and granddaughter struggle to understand why she focuses only on her hair and makeup. When her daughter arranges to have Abue’s sister, Luisa, come to help care for her, Abue raises Santo infierno – holy hell. In time, Luciana learns the entire story from Luisa and from Abue herself. It’s almost unbelievable, but it explains much about why Abue is the way she is, how she feels about her family, and how she is dealing with her impending death.

Luciana, too, has family issues. She has come out as a lesbian, and her mother avoids the issue. She doesn’t tell her grandmother, thinking she has enough on her plate. She and her sister have been close, but now that Mari is busy with college, she feels that Mari does not have time for her. She’s busy dating frat guys, going to parties, and traveling with her friends. Luciana lashes out. She pouts. She gives her the silent treatment, avoiding her phone calls for days and weeks at a time. She misses her sister and doesn't understand why she won't come see her and Abue. To her credit, however, the younger girl becomes even closer to her grandmother and spends a good deal of time getting to know her better and advocating for her.

Initially, I didn’t think I would like this story as well as I did. The format was cumbersome – it would do well as an audiobook with a good reader or multiple readers or as a stage production. The conversations ramble at times. However, there is a good deal of substance as well with universal themes and conflicts. The family issues go back to the time of Abue’s ancestors. Personal identity, health-wellness-death and dying. Religion. I loved the Spanish titles for each chapter. I’m glad I gave this book a chance.

Muy bien. 3-1/2 estrellas redondeadas. 3-1/2 stars rounded up.

I received a digital copy of Oye in exchange for my honest review. My thoughts and opinions are my own. Thanks to NetGalley, Random House Publishing, and Melissa Mogollon.

Was this review helpful?

So real, funny, and heart wrenching.

It took me a couple chapters to get used to the one-sided conversation confessional former but it actually really helped me understand Luciana, the family relationships, and what kinds of gals creep up from not knowing the whole picture by being told from one perspective.

It can be difficult to make fiction and tragedies like these carry the appropriate weight and mundanity and reality while still
maintaining the gravity and sometimes off-the-wall dramatic coincidences, but Mogollon does it. I felt attached to this dysfunctional
family. I also felt that despite things like cancer or abusive childhoods being able to happen to anyone, this story tells a uniquely Hispanic, Colombian, if at times purposefully and skillfully exaggerated version.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for an ARC in exchange for my honest opinion.

Was this review helpful?

Oye is a "coming-of-age comedy" staring Luciana, the youngest sibling in a large Colombian family. Luciana has never had to take a leading role in her family, until now she has been able to get away with anything. She never had to take responsibility for anything or anyone but herself. With her older sister away, the responsibility of the family falls on her. She's now having to step up into a role that she was never prepared to take in the family mostly trying to take on the role of caretaker to Abue, the family matriarch.

Oye was a good book, but for me the reason why this doesn't get a higher rating is because of the way it is written. I think the idea is that you feel like you are sitting in the room with Luciana and can hear everything that she is saying on her side of the phone but it is all kind of mixed together at times can be difficult to follow. I did love the descriptions of the characters, especially Abue. I think everyone's personality really comes through in the writing. Overall, a good book if you can get used to the style of storytelling.

Was this review helpful?

4 stars

This is a tried-and-true motif but in a completely original feeling format, and any incoming qualms I had about that format - a series of phone calls - were instantly eliminated by remarkable character development and unwavering investment. I was engaged with this read throughout.

Luciana, the m.c., is the one whose calls readers observe throughout the novel. These calls are consistently placed to Luciana's older sister, Mari, who has somewhat recently gone off to college. At home, Luciana is finding her way. She's trying to grapple with household life minus her older sister, navigate her queer identity in a household that is not entirely enthusiastic about this fact, and manage family-related challenges, including but not limited to Abue's health and a variety of wild family secrets.

Luciana has such a clear voice, and this is obviously especially important for a character readers access in only this unusual way. Her life circumstances are extremely relatable, and her sense of isolation in that space will also be an easy point of connection for many readers. The relationship between the sisters comes through in such a powerful way. Because the conversations are one-sided, the spaces, the specific listener's interpretation, and the educated guesses on the readers' parts are all fundamental to understanding how much the characters struggle but also fundamentally love each other.

As much as I love Luciana, it's Abue who becomes the scene stealer in many ways. Interestingly, that's still a testament to Mogollon's characterization of Luciana since Luciana's recounting of Abue's reactions, stories, and beliefs are the way readers access this character, too.

I enjoyed so much about this book, and I wanted more of it. I can't wait to see what this author does next, and I will absolutely recommend this one to folks who enjoy a good coming of age tale (and maybe would like to see that outside of YA), readers who enjoy engaging with family dynamics (particularly but not exclusively between sisters), and those who are interested in some great play with form.

Was this review helpful?

This is a very unconventional novel that grows on you. I received an invitation from Hogarth publishers and Netgalley to check out the DRC. And so I began reading it and initially I was like, “what is this, what’s going on?”

But I started falling into the groove and became very invested, involved, and interested. Basically this story unfolds over the phone. Luciana is calling her sister Mari, who is away at school, and keeping her informed on what’s going on with her, their mother and grandmother.

The calls are interpreted from Luciana’s perspective, so you don’t get dialogue, just Luciana’s voice that keeps her sister updated on all that is going on. The way the novel progresses in this way is quite comedic and increasingly engaging. I couldn’t stop reading, especially after the Grandmother took sick, and her back story began to fill in, the tone of the novel takes a turn towards sadness but ends on a somewhat satisfying note. Thanks to Netgalley and Hogarth/Random House for an advanced DRC.

Was this review helpful?

A decent book but not for me. The plot lacked a few key elements to keep me fully immersed in this book.

Was this review helpful?

The style of how the story is told in this book is quite unique...a series of phone conversations. If you liked hiding and eavesdropping on families phone calls then this book may be right up your alley.

I enjoyed it and can't wait to recommend it to my bookclub!

It touches on A LOT of topics and I found it to be a great story!

Was this review helpful?

I really liked the storyline, but the style of the entire book being a one sided phone conversation didn't work for me. I found it harder to follow and the flow was really clunky.

Was this review helpful?

Oye was a book that I could not get into. I had trouble following the conversation as to exactly who was who and what was going on. Very hard to follow a one sided conversation. This was just not my type of book to read.

Was this review helpful?

As hurricane Irma was ready to hit Florida everyone was told yo evacuate As this family leaving phone messages and texting the youngest daughter and mother were leaving for safer places keeping others up on their progress . They find that the grandmother would not leave her apartment. All worried about her. Luciana kept the calls and texts going. Lots of alls and texts sent and received till the danger was over and they found the grandmother very ill. Luciana stayed with Abur tending to her and still keeping the others updated by phone and texts. Abue ,the grandmother never recovered as the story goes, she decided how she wanted the end to be . Lots of repeat messages and phone calls!

Was this review helpful?

Oye!

This was fun. A bit challenging at first when it comes to the narrative style. But, once I got the hang of it, it was immersive. Even familiar.

Stylistically this was a riot, and story line overall was a winner. Not my go to genre but as a Latina, and fellow chismosa, this was escándalo!

Was this review helpful?

This book was a beautifully written story following Luciana (Nana) during her senior year of high school as she navigates family dynamics and balancing all the secrets (whether hers or those of her family).

The entire story is told as phone conversations with her sister (Mari) but we only get Nana’s side of the convos. It took a second to find my footing but once I did, we were off!

Luciana is written so beautifully. I found myself emotional at times and laughing out loud (literally) during others. Mogollon perfectly navigates the emotions that come with all that Nana is going through.

I couldn’t put this book down and I was so sad to have it end.

Looking forward to more from this author!!

Was this review helpful?

An interesting coming-of-age story, Oye is unusual in that it consists solely of a phone conversation between two sisters, Luciana and Mari. We only “hear” the voice of Luciana, but both characters come clear.

Luciana is the younger sister, and Mari is away at college while everything from a hurricane to their grandmother’s cancer conspire to drive Luciana mad. Since Mari can’t or won’t come home, Luciana must face all the drama by herself. It is pretty humorous learning how she does this.

However, a whole novel of conversation makes for hard reading. One voice, even if it’s a spirited teenager’s, with all the highs and lows of that age, can become wearisome over twenty or so chapters. It is especially difficult in the beginning because there are a lot of characters to meet, and they may just come up briefly in the conversation and then disappear for pages before being mentioned again.

I have to say, though, that I admire the author for trying to tell the story this way. It’s definitely not easy to reveal through a one-sided conversation the necessary details for readers to understand what is happening in the family. I look forward to learning how the author challenges herself next.

Was this review helpful?

Luciana's senior year, is nothing like she expected, there are many things happening, and her grandmother has lived the life she has had and become the person she is. When a hurricane is heading to Florida, her grandmother decides she isn't leaving, her mother leaves and decides to keep going to see the country, and Luciana is going to have to step into a role she isn't prepared for.
Luciana uses the phone and her sister's answering machine, to make it through all that is going on. At first, I thought this was strange but then as I read, I began to see things a different way. I begin to see the changes in Luciana, and she was beginning to see the person she was now, and she discovered she is moving into adulthood. I enjoyed this story because I think most of us finds their own way of coping and making it through the things that are happening, I had my way and this is what worked for Luciana.
This is a story, that is different, but it how Luciana can make it through all that is going on with herself, her family and the world around her. I received an ARC from Hogarth through NetGalley.

Was this review helpful?

Oye is unique in that it is a series of phone calls that tell a story. I'll be honest that it was a little confusing at times. Most of the story is told by Luciana as she calls her sister who is away at college. In the phone calls you learn all about her grandmother who at first was left alone during a hurricane and then later is going through a health crisis. There is a lot that goes on and there are some really interesting back stories about the grandmother. However this book just wasn't for me. I didn't like the phone call format. I just wasn't as invested as I would have liked to be. Plus there were italics that showed when other people were talking but I had a hard time following who was speaking. I would recommend this book to people looking for a unique type of book about family relationships.

Thank you to Random House/Hogarth for this ARC>

Was this review helpful?

OMG THIS WAS AMAZING.

this is told entirely through the main character (luciana)’s side of phone conversations with her older sister who’s at college. their grandmother is sick and luciana feels like the only person who cares and understands her.

The formatting was everything, the characters were everything, the plot was amazing. I can not recommend this enough Omggggg. Also this was a debut and I’m so impressed Melissa Mogollon you’re gonna do amazing things.

Thank you to Netgalley and Random house for the ARC! I loved reading this I am so excited for everyone else to!

Was this review helpful?