Skip to main content

Member Reviews

A charming, if a tad oversweet, story of families given and made that centers around a book-related mystery in a library in rural Washington State.

Chloe Sampson’s situation is dire. She was at University but when her mother, their only parent, walked out on her younger siblings, she was forced to abandon her studies and try to keep her family together. Chloe works at the local library where she finds a copy of The Tropic of Cancer with a conversation written in the margin by two lovers and realizes that one half of the couple is her grumpy elderly next door neighbor, Jasper.

In a second narrative strand, it is 1960 and free-spirited and strong-willed Catherine meets rough but book-loving Jasper and romance ensues as they leave each other notes written in the margins of A Farewell to Arms, The Haunting of Hill House , and, aha!, The Tropic of Cancer . But, Chloe finds out, Catherine died a long time ago.

Though both 1960 Jasper and present day Sampsons live in near-poverty it is of the we-were-poor-but-we-were-happy variety. The characterization of all the cast is pretty heavy-handed; they are each given a distinctive trait which is reiterated every time they appear. The exception is Chloe, who feels authentic in a way that makes you root for her and wish the other characters could have been a little more nuanced.

When things go from bad to worse for the Sampson family, things move towards a crisis and Chloe has to make some tough decisions. There are a few surprises along the way and Chloe and Jasper realize they are similar in many ways and can find their way out from the depths only by opening up to other people.

Not the most original conclusion, for sure, but pleasantly and satisfyingly arrived at.

Thanks to Sourcebooks and Netgalley fpr the digital review copy.

Was this review helpful?

The Library of Borrowed Hearts by Lucy Gilmore was a perfectly fine book, but not one that made too much of an impact. The story occurs in two timelines. In the present, Chloe is raising her three siblings after their mother left the family. She works in a library and is trying to solve the mystery of love notes she found scribbled in the margin of a scandalous, banned book.

In the past, Jasper, a logger, meets Caroline, the daughter of an army officer. The story takes us on their relationship journey in the 1960s.

While the story kept my interest, it dragged on for a bit too long. The characters were fairly forgettable and some just downright unlikeable. My favorite character was actually the curmudgeonly next-door neighbor, but most of the other characters just felt underdeveloped.

Thank you to Sourcebooks Casablanca and NetGalley for an advanced copy of this book in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Sourcebooks Casablanca and Lucy Gilmore for an eARC copy of The Library of Borrowed Hearts via NetGalley.

My gosh this was such a sweet read. I loved everything about each plot line of the story. Lucy finding the different books that were written in by the "mysterious" couple was immediate serotonin boost. I was obsessed with Catherine and her free spirited nature that went against the status quo of the time she was born in. Lucy tenacity and willingness to put herself aside and create a stable environment for her little siblings, and the turmoil that caused for her life as the story progressed was a poignant example of a reality many face when their birth parents are less than stellar caretakers and they decide to change the pattern going forward.

The relationship between Jasper and Lucy, and the parallels of their lives was a beautiful example of a friendship that spans generations, and I wish we would see more examples of a friendship like this in real life. I think the parallels of Jasper/Catherine's relationship against Lucy/Zach's was fascinating however, I am not someone who loves an open-ended result in a book though, so it was hard to accept when it ended with Lucy and Zach's relationship being up in the air, and Jasper and Catherine didn't run away from their respective lives together. I like everything packaged in a neat box with a bow, though that's not reality (unfortunately), so I will acknowledge that ending the book this way caused me to think about how the story progressed after the pages and made a longer-lasting impact. It was also a good example that "happy endings" aren't always what we think they are.

I want to re-emphasize that this was such a good read. I found myself emotionally tied to the characters, and it was such a good illustration of found family and how those we choose to have in our lives often make even more of an impact than those we are born into family with. I would recommend this book to romance-lovers and non-romance readers alike, it's a beautiful story.

Was this review helpful?

This book is all about a book within a book and found family. It was slow placed but it felt like a hug in book form. We get perspectives in multiple timelines and viewpoints that added to the story for me and helped you get know the many characters. I liked that was a small mystery involved as it kept me intrigued to know the answer. I would read more from this author in the future.

Was this review helpful?

This was a nice fast read, but it wasn’t one I’ll remember long. I didn’t really care for any of the characters, but the story was nice. And I love books about book lovers, this one just wasn’t a favorite.

I received an advanced copy from netgalley in exchange for a review and opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Bookish books are my favourite books.

Anything set in a library, or book store?

Gimme.

Is the main character a librarian, or an author?

Add to cart.

Was a flawless work? Nope, but I’M GRADING ON A CURVE.

I loved the tiny town setting, the platonic and not-so-platonic Grumpy-Sunshine tropes, and the diverse set of characters.

I loved the multiple timelines and multiple points-of-view (‘though, I did think some were stronger than others).

I loved the marginalia plot device, and added a few books to my TBR because of it.

My main beef was the ending. If ever a book needed an epilogue, it was this one.

Looking forward to more from Lucy Gilmore.

Thanks to NetGalley, Sourcebooks, and DreamScape Media for this bookish ARC.

Was this review helpful?

I really wanted to love this book but found it a bit slow and tedious.
I found the plot had too many holes and left me feeling underwhelmed by the conclusion of the story.

Was this review helpful?

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ - 3.5 stars!

Thank you to NetGalley and the author for providing me with an eARC in exchange for an honest review.

The definition of a wholesome read. The plot was certainly something that grabbed my attention but I ended up staying for the pure sweetness some of this characters provided.

Chloe is a librarian who, while cleaning up boxes there, finds an old copy of "Tropic of Cancer" with writings on the margins. And those notes seem to be from two people. But who are they? And what happened next?

Throughout this book, the author takes you back in time to learn the story of the two mystery scribblers, while dipping back in the present to tell Chloe's story as well. A cute and heartwarming read 💜

Was this review helpful?

While it took a while for the slow build of character development and setting to take place, I could absolutely see the second half of Lucy Gilmore’s novel play out like a Netflix movie. The Library of Borrowed Hearts showcases the importance of your chosen family when your biological connections are not supportive or healthy, while also working in an atypical romance. This was a quality read!

Was this review helpful?

I really wanted to love this book but it was just a slow read for me. I enjoyed the characters, enough, but it never got me quickly turning pages. Thank you netgalley for this arc in exchange for my honest opinion.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you, Netgalley, for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.

This book has great bones. It has dynamic, enjoyable characters and an interesting plot.

But . . . .I needed more. It felt rushed, and the characters weren’t given the pages necessary to make their behaviors realistic to the reader. I feel if the author would have given an extra 100 or so pages to dive more into the characters, this would have been an easy 4 star read for me.

I liked the references of other books and the love story on the margins of pages. This is such a cute concept. I liked the grumpy neighbor and all the sass that comes with unruly adolescent neighbors.

I believe I will check out other works by this author in the future as she writes cute characters and interesting plots.

Was this review helpful?

Highly recommend this one!! This is my first time reading one of their books but it won't be the last! This book sucks you in from the get-go and you will find yourself thinking about the characters long after you finish it. Do yourself a favor and get this book!!

Was this review helpful?

Lucy Gilmore is now an auto buy author for me!

I loved (LOVED) The Lonely Hearts Book Club and I felt the same about The Library of Borrowed Hearts! I loved the idea of finding hidden notes in books and following a love story...how will it end?
I enjoyed the dual time lines and seeing two sides of Jasper. All the characters were wonderful and Noodle....oh Noodle! Such a sweet character. I don't know if he was intended to be on the spectrum, but as a mom to a son on the spectrum it was a joy to read a character who shared traits with my child!

Such a delightful book, I've already recommended it to several people.

5 stars

Was this review helpful?

Another touching story about book lovers! This was a very creative tale told in two different generations. It is the 2nd Lucy Gilmore book I’ve read.

Was this review helpful?

If you are looking to read about a love story from the 60’s, a potential love in the current day, family unbuilt and built again, then pay attention. This book is an emotional journey with sprinkles and quotes from classic and infamous books made to apply to life then and now.
It could be considered a warm hug of a book to some while to others it may be a bit too mushy. I am somewhere in the middle. I loved the concept but am a bit too cynical to enjoy it to the fullest. I also hate jumping back and forth in time, but that shouldn’t stop others from enjoying it as the book itself is wonderful.

Was this review helpful?

Small-town librarian Chloe spends most of her time caring for her 3 younger siblings. One day she stumbles onto a book annotated with a young couple's love story. With the help of her best friend, a mountain man love interest, and the grumpy neighbor next door she works to unravel the mystery of their story by finding all the books they corresponded in. I enjoyed the blend of genres in this novel: part romance, part mystery, part historical fiction. As the book goes on, we get chapters from a variety of perspectives, and I appreciated the unique narrative voice and heart in each of them. The beginning was a little sad, given Chloe's circumstances, but it picked up fairly quickly, then I couldn't put it down for wanting to see what happens to these characters.

I was able to read this novel as an ARC through Net Galley.

Was this review helpful?

The way this dual plot story came together at the end was sheer perfection. The story of Jasper & Catherine was über engaging as they used messages in book margins to build their relationship. Then, adding Chloe, Zach, Noodle, Theo, Trixie and Gummy Bear brought another element to the story. As Chloe & Zach uncovered the mystery the real story of Catherine & Jasper is revealed. This is a heart warming story with family drama, love story, sacrifice for family and more. What a great book!

Thanks to NetGalley and Sourcebooks for a copy of this book.

Was this review helpful?

📱 The Library of Borrowed Hearts 📱⁣
⁣⁣
⁣Genre- Contemporary. ⁣
⁣⁣
⁣Length- 368 pages. ⁣
⁣⁣
⁣My thoughts- The Library of Borrowed Hearts is a heartwarming tale about the power of books. Librarian Chloe Sampson is struggling with life as the legal guardian to her three younger siblings. When she finds a rare edition of an old book while cleaning the library basement, she decides to sell it- hopefully helping some with her financial woes. She soon notices it is filled with notes between a man and a women. ⁣
⁣⁣
⁣Things I enjoyed about this book:⁣
⁣- lots of talk about books! ⁣
⁣- Chloe’s complicated relationship with her grumpy, elderly neighbor. ⁣
⁣- The focus on found family and Chloe’s sacrifices to be a mother to her siblings. ⁣
⁣⁣
⁣Things I didn’t like about this book: ⁣
⁣- it moved sooooo slowly. It took me ten days to finish! I needed a faster moving plot. ⁣
⁣- A couple of the characters were selfish jerks and didn’t really apologize or have to deal with their actions. ⁣
⁣⁣
⁣I enjoyed! Three and a half stars… rounded up to four! ⁣⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Thank you to @netgalley for an ARC. The Library of Borrowed Hearts is out now!

Was this review helpful?

Absolutely incredible. It broke my heart, repaired it, broke it again, and I think this book will always stay there. I loved this one so much. It has a level of mystery that keeps you guessing. It has romance that I typically don’t love but this was crafted so sweetly that I couldn’t stop reading it. It wasn’t just romantic love but family, friend, community, and self love. It made me laugh, cry, and reflect on my own life. Sometimes what you have and what you need are right in front of you. Perhaps my favorite read of the year.

Was this review helpful?

The Library of Borrowed Hearts had me feeling all of the emotions. Such a heartwarming and touching story, and I would highly recommend.

Was this review helpful?