Skip to main content

Member Reviews

"Love You, Mean It" is a captivating and thoroughly entertaining romantic comedy that serves up a delightful blend of humor, heart, and an enticing touch of amnesia-induced confusion. With a charming premise involving dueling delis, fake relationships, and a lively cast of characters, this novel offers a fresh and engaging take on the genre.

The protagonist, Ellie Greco, is a relatable and endearing character whose struggles with her family's deli and her longing for a more exciting life make her instantly relatable. Her journey from a reluctant deli owner to a participant in an unexpected fake engagement is filled with humor and heartwarming moments. Ellie's witty banter with Theo Taylor, the dashing yet enigmatic love interest, adds a layer of sizzling chemistry and playful tension to the story. The amnesia plot device is used skillfully to create humorous and endearing situations that keep the reader eagerly turning the pages.

The novel excels in portraying the dynamics of family and friendship, making the reader feel deeply connected to the characters. Ellie's dedication to her family's legacy and the choices she must make between her heart's desires and her responsibilities tug at the heartstrings. However, some readers may find certain plot developments, especially those involving the shocking ex-fiancée Sam, to be slightly predictable, which is a minor critique in an otherwise engaging and enjoyable narrative.

In conclusion, "Love You, Mean It" is a delightful romantic comedy that delivers on its promise of laughter, romance, and heart. It's a feel-good read that reminds us of the importance of taking chances, embracing change, and the surprises that love can bring. Fans of the genre will find this book to be a delightful and satisfying escape into a world where love and laughter reign supreme.

Was this review helpful?

This book seemed like a Romeo and Juliet style romance but in a more modern setting which I loved. Also second chance ex is a troupe I love as well as enemy’s to lovers. This was a very cute novel nothing too earth shattering but just a fun popcorn rom com

Was this review helpful?

When Ellie’s family deli is threatened by a big bad mega food company, she’s desperate enough to pair up with Theo Taylor, son of the real estate tycoon whose company will decide if the sale goes through.

At first glance the premise gives off major Hallmark vibes, BUT Gagnon’s latest definitely has a couple of spicy scenes, and the tension between Elli and Theo is pure escapist fun,

If you like fake relationship tropes with a splash of spice, this book is your jam! It’s such a nod to everything I loved about 90s rom coms.

Was this review helpful?

The story was cute, and the idea was nice. The MCs were nicely written. I felt I lacked any sort of attachment to them. It felt like the same thing repeatedly.

But I really did not like Sam; I thought she was pointless to the sorry. I understand they needed someone to create a “wedge” but still not a fan. Also, all those internal monologues had me skimming the text.

Was this review helpful?

I adored the cover and title of Love You Mean It!

This was a fascinating book, a story based on family business and the risk a potentially new threat could have on the existing family business and community. Ellie runs her family meat store business and is threatened when a former schoolmate's father decides to open his family meat store… Tripp, also known as Theo, is not a fan of his father's new business venture. Surprisingly, these two former schoolmates engage in a scheme to ensure Tripp’s Father's business is unsuccessful.

You will love the chemistry between Tripp and Ellie. This was a slow read but eventually romantic in so many other ways. What happens next? Grab the book and find out.

Thank you Kathleen for this arc book.

Was this review helpful?

I’m literally obsessed with Theo and Ellie. I loved the way he was the one that really fell for her first. I mean, Ellie is trying to set him back up with Sam, but all Theo does is become super protective of Ellie. I really loved the whole tennis scene. I thought it really funny how Theo tried to play Ellie with the whole amnesia thing to see if she caught on to the fact that he did remember her. I really enjoyed how Ellie stood up to Theo’s “dad.” We love a confident woman. It really hurt there towards the end and honestly they are both to blame for the way my heart hurt. I was really happy to see the way Theo fought to not let Ted get away with the whole project. I’m glad that Sam really helped Theo help Ellie with in a way. I’m glad that they stayed friends after they realized that Theo was son in love and better off with Ellie. I really enjoyed all of Ellie’s family and how they were all in on the whole fake fiancé situation.

Was this review helpful?

A cute and charming rom com with cute banter, cute boys and fake dating.
Ellie Greco fee up in Milborough. A small town that she fled as quickly as she could. She always felt she was destined for more. Ellie was able to escape her hometown for a few years for her dream career, designing costumes for a theater production. Sadly Ellie is called back home when her father passes away suddenly and she needs to help run her family’s deli. She loves her deli, but she dreams of something more.

When Greco’s deli is threatened by a new business Ellie suddenly feels the tug to stay in her hometown and keep the deli going.

I thought this was a charming and sweet story. Cute for all rom com lovers and one I will recommend to others.

Thank you Netgalley for an early copy in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Ellie runs her family deli and a new business possibly coming to town could jeopardize it. Ellie meets up with Theo to try and sway him to not open up Mangia. Things take a turn and we get the fake engagement but not in the normal way.
Good easy read but a little off for me.

Was this review helpful?

When I read the synopsis for Jilly Gagnon new book I almost had a heart attack. This is like While You Were Sleeping candy for those who are fans of the movie. Ellie and Theo really romcom'd it up and couldn't have been happier.

Thank you to Random House Publishing Group - Ballantine, Dell, and NetGalley for providing an eARC for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Love You, Mean It is a fun romantic comedy. I was skeptical of the fake engagement story line in the beginning, but, my doubts quickly faded. Jilly Gagnon provides well developed characters, great dialogue, and an all around great story. Plenty of steam as well! Thank you to NetGalley, Jilly Gagnon, and Random House Publishing for the ARC!

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to NetGalley for the eARC of this book. All opinions are my own.

I really enjoy booked based on restaurants or with food as a main character. Love You, Mean It hits those plot point. I also really enjoy the fake romance trope and this book nails it on the head. When Ellie must head back to her hometown to run the family deli she does what she can to improve things. But when she finds out about plans to bring Mangia, a mega gourmet food shop to her little town she does what she can to put a stop to it. She ends up in a fake relationship with Theo, the son of the owner of the property management firm looking to bring in Mangia in order to put a stop to the mega shop and save her deli.

Overall I thought this was a cute story with all the makings of a happily ever after. I liked all the characters (especially Sam!) and felt like the character development was there. Of course there are many twists throughout and by the end of the story, you can breathe a sigh of relief. This was a very cute quick read.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you Netgalley and Random House Publishing Group-Ballantine for the arc. The comments and review are my opinion.
Ellie has returned home from NY to work in her family’s deli after the death of her father and after failing in her dream of becoming a costume designer.

I am not much of a reader of romcom’s, but since I have read other books by this author, I looked forward to this change of pace. Although it was okay, I have liked other books by the author more.

To me Ellie was portrayed as being rather pathetic. A “Woe is Me” type of person. No boyfriend, no girlfriends nearby and no social life because all she does is work in the deli, keeping her father’s dream alive while her dream failed.
What finally wakes her up is news that quite possibly the building where the deli is located is going to be demolished with a super store being built in its place. What follows is a fake dating and fake engagement to a principal partner of the developer to try and stop the new store from coming to town.
The book does have a sweet ending, so if you are into cozy romcoms, you very well may enjoy this book.

Was this review helpful?

This was such a cute read! I fell in love with Ellie and Theo and especially the fake dating troupe. I really enjoyed this book because I releated to Ellie in which her father died and she had to take over his deli while essentially putting her dreams on hold. My father has passed and although my father didn't have a business I put my life on hold. This book helped me realize that I'm not the only and that I can he more than a griever. Back to the story it was such a quick read for me. I really enjoyed that the author didn't bombard us with too many characters to make the plot. I loved the handful of characters and how each were important to the story. I really reccomend if you love a meet cute, fake dating troupe.

Was this review helpful?

Ellie the main character is very hard to like. The self deprivation and negative attitude just puts me off. I can’t root for her let alone even like her.

Was this review helpful?

Although I love a good fake dating trope this one didn't check many boxes for me. I liked ellie and I liked Theo but. Meh. One of the biggest things that bugged me is I literally still have no idea where the title comes from. As a reader I very much enjoy being able to say. Aha! That's where that is from.

That being said this was a quick read for me. Just not a favorite

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for sending me this e-ARC in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I thought this was a cute and fun romance store, although it did read more like women's fiction than a standard romcom to me. I really enjoyed the relationship between Ellie and her family, particularly with Bella, more than anything, but the romance between her and Theo was cute as well.

Thank you to the publisher and to Netgalley for letting me read an early copy. Opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Given how much page space the deli dilemma and her desire for friends took up it felt more women’s fiction than romance to me. And half of the book was extremely difficult to follow with random other peoples movements in the middle of dialogue with no tags. If you’re gonna put a name in the middle of dialogue, make it at least be the person who’s talking. I was so confused I almost put the book down so many times. OMG just use “said” already.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Netgalley for the opportunity to read this book for my honest review.
I thoroughly enjoyed this funny, sweet, laugh out loud romantic comedy! The characters were likable and the ending was great. Highly recommend!

Was this review helpful?

This book seemed very promising from the premise (and honestly the cover is what drew me in the most). That being said, I am at a loss for how to rate this book. I think the plot needs a lot of work for it to be more engaging for the reader. Throughout chapter 1 I felt like I was learning more about deli meats than anything and I had to go back to understand what I was supposed to know as a reader. I was lost by chapter 2 and forcing myself to finish the book thereafter. I think the characters are somewhat developed, but I found myself unable to relate, which again made the reader 10x harder.

Overall, a good premise, but definitely needs work! Almost a DNF for me.

**I appreciate the ARC privileges from NetGalley.

Was this review helpful?

I think that with booktok being so relevant, it’s hard to find a book that is unique. I did enjoy this book and you grow to like the characters a lot but it doesn’t stand out to me. It has a lot of similar tropes and plot points from other books I’ve read which makes it feel like something I’ve read before.

Was this review helpful?