Skip to main content

Member Reviews

I love historical novels that tell true stories in wonderful storytelling ways that grab the reader and teaches them about another time and place. Taylor Brown takes us back to 1921 in the Coal mining towns of West Virginia. The coal miners were treated very badly by the coal mining companies and the miners revolted in the biggest uprising since the Civil War. They fight for unionization and better lives for all the miners. The reader gets introduced o both sides of the issues. This is a book that will have you digging around the internet for more of their stories. The book is not fast read but is a fascinating glimpse into history..

I wish to thank NetGalley and St. Martin’s Press for allowing me to read a copy of this book. I have voluntarily read and reviewed it. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

The atrocities of the true history of the coal miners to unionize in West Virginia unfolds forcefully in this novel. The greed and disregard for life of the coal barons brings hate filled and murderous men paid to enforce unlawful retaliation on the miners. The sins of the bought courts are a blight on the land. The miners take matters into their own hands and begin a brutal and ugly fight with the coal companies. They are hoping for better days for them and their families that unionization would bring.
I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

A fictionalized account of what took place in the 1920's set in i West Virginia. Known as the Matewan Massacre through the Battle of Blair Mountain it was the largest conflict since the Civil War. As the unions moved in to improve the work conditions and salaries of the West Virginia coal miners, mine owners would fight back, striking the miners at the heart of their protest and often sending armed men against anyone who dared to speak. After many years of suffering in the mines and rough treatment outside the mines, these workers would take a stand, fighting for a better life for themselves and their families. A well researched and well written novel, Ms. Taylor gives the readers of HF a book filled with heroism in the face of injustice, and the power of love and community against all odds. Highly recommended.

Was this review helpful?

"Rednecks" by Taylor Brown earns a resounding four stars for its compelling narrative that seamlessly weaves together history and fiction. Set against the backdrop of West Virginia and the Battle of Blair Mountain, the novel plunges readers into the heart of the largest labor uprising in American history. Brown's meticulous research and vivid imagination breathe life into the multi-ethnic army of 10,000 coal miners as they face off against mine owners, state militia, and the United States government.

Through richly drawn characters and gripping storytelling, Brown illuminates the complexities of this tumultuous period in American history. The struggles, sacrifices, and triumphs of the miners are rendered with authenticity and empathy, making their fight for justice and dignity deeply resonate with readers. Against the backdrop of the battle-scarred hills of Appalachia, Brown crafts a riveting historical drama that captures the spirit of resilience and solidarity in the face of overwhelming odds.

"Rednecks" is more than just a retelling of a pivotal moment in labor history—it is a testament to the power of ordinary people banding together to confront injustice and demand change. With its blend of action, emotion, and social commentary, this novel is a must-read for anyone interested in the untold stories of America's past. Prepare to be captivated from the first page to the last by Brown's masterful storytelling and profound insights into the human condition.

Was this review helpful?

If the term Rednecks get your dander up becuase of its modern meaning - - "a working-class white person, especially a politically reactionary one from a rural area" that is not the meaning that we find in this book. Interestingly, it came about when the Union workers tied red bandanas around their necks before entering this war.

If you like your American history real, raw, bloody, and very descriptive, then this might be the book for you. You may also enjoy this bit of history, especially if you come from or live in the rural Blue Ridge Mountains/Appalachia and want to see what it was like for some people over 100 years ago.

This book is about the bloody battle between the miners who wanted to join the union and King Coal, who wouldn't let them. It also shows us how so many ethnicities and people from different countries and cultures managed to band together to try and beat the 'enemy'.

It is a terrifying historical novel that sticks more with history in all of its blood, guts, and glory and a lot less with fiction (yes, a lot of this was fictionalized, but not much, I think).

Long descriptive passages and a compelling look into the life of “Doc Moo" Muhanna, a Lebanese-American doctor (inspired by the author’s own great-grandfather), and what he has to deal with not to take sides.

Well worth reading if you can really handle the horrors of what trying to break into a union really meant to our ancestors.

*ARC was supplied by the publisher St. Martin's Press/Macmillan, the author, and NetGalley.

Was this review helpful?

An interesting look at the dispute between the unions and mining companies in 1920's West Virginia. While the premise, characters, and setting captured my interest, there was something about the writing style that kept me from being truly engaged.

Was this review helpful?

4.5 stars

Rednecks is the fascinating very well written story of the Battle of Blair Mountain in West Virginia in 1920.

Coal miners were trying to form a union and the uprising was bloody and brutal and shocking.

The miners worked under extremely harsh conditions which is an understatement.

The story is told form multiple POV's and this works very well.

The characters are real and unforgettable . I loved the Doctor.

Hardships are plenty but their strength, love of family and determination are admirable.

Taylor Brown has written a powerful story that will stay with me for a very long time.

Rednecks is not to be missed.

Taylor Brown has a new fan and I am off to read a few more by him.

Thanks to NetGalley and St. Martin's Press for a compelling and informative read.

Was this review helpful?

4 stars

This is my first encounter with Taylor Brown's novels, and I anticipate that it won't be the last.

For me, successful historical fiction requires engaging characters and new insights. My wishes were granted. Dr. Moo's story is particularly compelling, and since I did not read a word about this novel ahead of time, I was extra enthused to learn this character is based on one of the author's relatives. There are other fictionalized depictions of historical folks here to match the events, though I did not feel as connected to the rest of the cast.

Folks who enjoy historical fiction and especially stories of rebellion in the name of equitable rights will appreciate this one. Though I'm an enthusiastic reader of the genre, this isn't necessarily the region I'm often clamoring for, but I'm glad I went off script this time and encourage other semi-reluctant/uncertain readers to do the same.

Was this review helpful?

"You ask me, Crock, there's different Americas. America if you got means or don't, if you work in a tie or neckerchief, up in the office or down on the killing floor. White or colored, man or woman, Native or not. I reckon there's Americas they'd drop a bomb on, and ones they wouldn't even think it."

What a great read! Perfect for fans of 'Demon Copperfield,' or those looking for really grounded historical fiction instead of reading the same stories in the same settings over and over.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley and Taylor Brown.

“Rednecks” by Taylor Brown is a gripping historical drama set during the early 1920s in the coal-mining region of Logan, West Virginia. The novel revolves around the Battle of Blair Mountain, the largest labor uprising in U.S. history. It sheds light on the struggles of miners seeking fair treatment and their fight against Big Coal. Through fictional characters, Brown captures the resilience, sacrifice, and hope of those caught in this pivotal moment. A tale both heart-wrenching and hopeful, “Rednecks” brings to life a dark chapter from a century ago, revealing the perils of big business and government collusion.

Was this review helpful?

Enjoyed it, I never knew the backstory. History books don't talk about the Battle of Blair Mountain.

Was this review helpful?

"Rednecks" by Taylor Brown is an enlightening and engaging historical novel about the coal mine wars in West Virginia in the early 1920s. Although I had heard pieces of this story, I was not familiar with details of these large battles that took place between coal companies (and the U.S. military) and thousands of miners. I also wasn't aware of the diversity of the miners who banded together in this large labor uprising. Brown's writing captivates with historical figures such as Sid Hatfield, Mother Jones and journalists Boyden Sparkes (who was shot in one of the battles) and Mildred Morris. The honorable, kind and brave Lebanese doctor Dr. Muhanna was my favorite character; he was inspired by the author's great grandfather. The bibliography at the end gives additional resources as well as the extent of Taylor Brown's research. I do feel that some of the details could have been cut to focus a bit more on characters and make the book a bit shorter. Overall, "Rednecks" is entertaining and very educational. Thanks to Netgalley and St. Martin's Press for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

"An army of men rising from the earth, clad in blue bib overalls. They hail from Italy and Poland, the Deep South and Appalachia. One in five is Black. They wear red bandanas knotted around their necks, as if their throats have already been cut. People will call them primitives and hillbillies, anarchists and insurrectionists. They will call them rednecks."

Rednecks by Taylor Brown is a historical fiction masterpiece, and if I never read another Taylor Brown novel, this is enough to solidify him as one of the most talented writers I've ever read. I realize those are a couple of lofty statements, but I happen also to be reading another highly acclaimed historical fiction novel right now. While I consider the writer of the other novel talented and the work very good, Rednecks held me tightly in its grip through its entirety, It didn't just entertain, it felt significant on so many levels.

It is a story of the Battle of Blair Mountain in 1921, between striking miners and the mine owners, their hired gun-toting thugs, local law enforcement, and the US Army. Miners and their families want to unionize under the United Mine Workers of America, but the mine owner refuse to concede anything, kicking them out of their company housing, refusing company scrip for food, and forcing them into squalid tent encampments, When violence erupts -- "building like methane in the chamber of a mine and any day could come the spark" -- war ensues between the factions. It is incomprehensible that I never learned of this battle before, especially since the mine workers were targets of aerial bombing even before the Army arrived - American bombs dropped on American soil.

"Reinforcements flooded in from out of state. Frank and his comrades met miners from the Ohio, Illinois, and Indiana coalfields. They came riding in on top of boxcars and passenger coaches, sitting on flatcars or hanging from the hoppers of coal trains. Their bodies festooned the cars, hands and boots and rifles hanging in the wind, the engines throbbing beneath their weight. The boldest among them crouched right in the cowcatchers, watching for ambushes."

Brown's research was impeccable. He included known key figures like Mother Jones and Sid Hatfield and real-life events. He uses meticulous details throughout to create characters that are endearing, like Doc Moo, Musa, Miss Beulah, and Big Frank, and to show just how impressively organized the miners fought, breaking into combat battalions, practicing military drills, and teaching infantry principles to "a combined force the size of the 1st Infantry Brigade" in the Great War.

Ironically, many of the fighters on both sides fought in World War I for their country only to use their experience to fight one another - exemplified by Crockett and Bad Tony, both veteran Marines with the same tattoo spanning their chests, who led rival factions. I had a particular soft spot for both Big Frank and Musa, who were so similar and shared such a touching encounter on the mountain away from the bloodshed.

With zero doubts, I can say Rednecks is a must-read, for its history lesson, rich narrative, bold characters, and beautiful writing.

My thanks to St. Martin's Press for the advanced copy of this book through NetGalley, which I received in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

One of the best parts of historical fiction for me is learning about the events of another time that are not widely known. Author Taylor Brown has done a wonderful job with this, mixing real-life and invented characters to convey the explosive events that led to The Battle of Blair Mountain in West Virginia. I can not say enough about the author's ability to bring the characters to life. The struggles the miners endured and their sacrifices to obtain justice were captivating. This story is exceptionally well written and researched. The events of the book are milestones of American History, as the largest labor uprising in US History. I recommend this one for all Historical Fiction lovers.

Thank you, NetGalley and St. Martin's Press for the advanced reader copy, in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This novel takes readers of a journey through the complexities of Southern culture set on the backdrop of rural Georgia. This novel had vivid imagery and rich prose exploring themes of resilience amidst violence, poverty, and the pursuit of dreams. This raw and unfiltered portrayal of southern life immersed me in a world I am not too familiar with and is often misunderstood. Due to my unfamiliarity, I had trouble connecting to the setting. Despite this, I found this novel to be a thought-provoking read that left a lasting impression.

Was this review helpful?

I went into this book not having any knowledge of the events that are fictionally described (though based on real incidents), I'm not sure if that's a good thing, I think if you have some knowledge you may appreciate the book more. That doesn't mean I didn't enjoy it, I did, just that I wish I understood more of what was going on and why. This story is told through multiple points of view, the strongest one for me was Dr Moo (an abbreviation of sorts of his last name Muhanna), who is a immigrant from Lebanon, has three children (2 girls and a boy) and gets called out to take care of those that require it. In this story there are a lot of people that require it, mostly miners, they are trying to join a union and the mine company doesn't want that to happen and makes life very difficult, evicting them from their company owned houses, firing them from their job and eventually employing a local gang of thugs and the American Army(!). This was the largest armed conflict since the Civil War. A large part of the book describes various skirmishes that the miners and hired thugs/Army engage in, there is a LOT of people that are injured/killed and in my humble view it gets a tad repetitious. However there are some good guys, Dr Moo being one of the strongest. I would recommend this if you like historical stories and if you have an interest in armed conflict. Thanks to #Netgalley and #Stmartinspress for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

Wow! This is one powerful book! Based on the true struggles of miners in Virginia, specifically the Battle of Blair mountain, the book brings home the treatment of miners and their families by everyone - wealthy coal mine owners who cared about nothing but money, and essentially owned the miners, the government who acquiesced t the demands of the wealthy and sent in the military against the miners, and even the townspeople in the town. Through the eyes of both miners and residents including the Lebanese Dr. Moo, the story of the courageous resistance against all odds is horrifying, unbelievable and full of inspiring acts of bravery and integrity. (And, you learn about the original of the term Rednecks). I couldn't put it down, read it through in just a couple of days. This is a don't miss read!

Was this review helpful?

This stirring historical tale plunges us into the brutal coal wars of 1920s Appalachia. Coal miners labored under brutal conditions in the region, their lives utterly dependent on the whims of the coal barons and their private security enforcers. Unionization swept through many coalfields, providing better wages and working conditions, but southwestern West Virginia was a holdout, and any attempts to unionize were met with the barrel of a gun. Readers may be familiar with the acclaimed film "Matewan," which depicts a shootout between coal miners, backed by the local sheriff, and the company soldiers. This novel takes off from the events of that film and leads into the two years of struggle that culminated in the Battle of Blair Mountain, the largest uprising since the Civil War. Some 10,000 coal miners clashed with several thousand law enforcers and the hired guns of the Baldwin-Felts detective agency. Machine guns were used, bombs were dropped, bridges were set on fire and the conflict ended only when the U.S. Army intervened on the side of the mine owners.

Brown brings us the multifaceted events of these years through the eyes of several participants, including a local doctor sympathetic to the miners' cause, and a young Black miner whose perseverance and dedication makes him a hero of the fight. The action is nearly non-stop and the tension remains high, though the eventual outcome is easy to guess. Brown has made an admirable contribution in his accurate depiction of these events. Some of the characters seem a bit one-dimensional and the good vs. evil binary tends to erase much of the nuance that must have been present, but fans of novels about historical conflicts and the struggle for union rights will be riveted by this immersion in the coal wars.

Was this review helpful?

I received this from Netgalley.com.

An interesting in-depth look at coal mining and labor issues. The info dumps were a bit dense to ingest, but overall a decent read.

3.5☆

Was this review helpful?

I was given the opportunity to read an ARC copy of this by St. Martins Press, NetGalley and the author. I thoroughly enjoyed this historical recount of the Battle of Blair Mountain as told in a historical fiction novel. This novel looks at many of the injustices surrounding the 1920s and coal mines in general. I could not imagine having lived in times like these and I empathize and sympathize with the workers who did. This was a great novel!

Was this review helpful?