This was an engaging read that kept me on my feet from start to finish. I'm glad that I heard about this book from Instagram, and as someone who is a queer and disabled Asian-American woman in STEM, I can painfully relate to some of her experiences. I never did a PhD, but some of the things she wrote in her book hit home for me.

I really wanted to like this book more than I did. And while I did really enjoy Pangu’s Shadow and the drama of it all, I feel as if the actual premise was oversold to me. To be short for now, and perhaps longer later, this book is not an adult novel, it’s YA, and it often shows in painful ways.

I DNF'd this book at ~ 32%, which is about where both girls had only just had even a thought about being attracted to other girls. Up until then, one was pining after their male boss and the other only cared about dancing. It was weird, suddenly having each make note of their same-sex attraction only at this point, especially in reference to characters they'd already interacted with and not had any thoughts about other than platonic ones at best.

One of the POV character's chapters was weirdly formulaic in a way that pulled me out of it. She'd think about some scientific thing in a simplistic way in the first paragraph, compare it to the current problem at hand, then never mention anything science again in the chapter. Next POV, same deal.

Thank you to Net Galley and the publisher for the ARC. Pangu's Shadow was a thrilling read, I loved it. Academic Rivals who must work together and end up falling in love and its sapphic - of course its beautiful. I really enjoyed reading from both Aryl and Ver's perspective and following along as they solved the murder of their boss. The science was fascinating and I loved the world building. I really felt for both characters and could empathize with them being others, and Ver being disabled. I loved how through solving this murder, we got a close look at the problems plaguing society in Pangu's moons and the inequality between One, Two and Three. The tension and suspicion between Ver and Aryl was really enjoyable to read, as well as watching them slowly trust each other and fall in love. I knew I really enjoyed when the genres fantasy and mystery are combined, but Pangu's Shadow made me realize that sci-fi blended with mystery is also really fun. This book was really fast paced and fun to read!

I wasnt too sure what I was getting into with this book, but I was suprised how much I enjoyed it.

The plot of the book flowed freely and I barely wanted to put it down. This was actually one of the rare books I didnt check how many pages I had left with. I think I read about 80% of it in one sitting.

Far as characters- I wish we saw a bit more development. Sometimes they felt very flat to me, even with all the background we got on them.

After reading the synopsis and early reviews I was very intrigued about this book! Sci-fi + a murder mystery seemed like it would be right up my alley. But unfortunately I don’t think the author’s writing style is for me as I am 10% into the book and have not been able to get invested in Aryl and Ver’s story.

Thank you for the ARC and the opportunity to read and review this book.

In the Pangu Star System, where second chances are scarce, Ver and Aryl are thrust into a harrowing mystery in 'Pangu's Shadow' by Karen Bao. Apprentices in a prestigious biology lab, they are suddenly implicated in the murder of their brilliant boss, Cal. With obvious motives, they must join forces to uncover the truth and clear their names. As they delve deeper into the secrets of Pangu's moons, they grapple with their pasts and the futures they desire. Bao weaves a gripping tale of suspense and intrigue, keeping readers on the edge of their seats until the very end.

Pangu's Shadow is a very well written and engaging YA mystery SF standalone novel by Karen Bao. Released 6th Feb 2024 by Lerner, it's 288 pages and is available in hardcover and ebook formats. It's worth noting that the ebook format has a handy interactive table of contents as well as interactive links and references throughout.

The advice for writers has always been "write what you know". This is an *intelligent* story, written with the surety of experience in STEM science and labwork. She clearly gets it (including the minor day to day irritations of working in close proximity to other brilliant and driven colleagues.

At its heart, it's a murder mystery with two frenemy lab assistants who need to cooperate if they're going to prove their innocence of a murder of which they're suspected. The setting and world building are wonderfully detailed and believable, despite being set in deep space. The characterization is nuanced and intricately rendered.

Despite being marketed as a YA novel, this is going to be a highlight in SF/speculative fiction releases for the year for YA & adult audiences. Watch for it on the awards lists.

Four and a half stars. Very satisfying, and a real insider's look at life as a "lab rat" (except for the bionic body parts and manned deepspace research facility, those are still fiction currently).

Disclosure: I received an ARC at no cost from the author/publisher for review purposes.

This book was unexpected. I went into Pangu’s Shadow thinking it would be a fun YA sci-fi murder mystery. Pangu’s Shadow delivered so much more than that. I was hooked by the story immediately and could hardly put the book down. The world is unique and has characters with incredible depth to them. I had a harder time connecting with certain characters but they all felt so realistic. The themes explored in this book were done so thoughtfully and were well executed. The pacing was a bit off at times but was mostly fast paced. Karen Bao is an exceptional writer and I would love to read more of her works in the future! I recommend this to anyone looking for a unique YA sci-fi world with mystery elements and relatable characters.

Thank you to Lerner Publishing Group for providing this eARC via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

Thank you Netgalley for the ARC!

"Pangu's Shadow" by Karen Bao is a captivating YA sci-fi murder mystery that weaves together science, social commentary, and an engrossing mystery. The book immerses you in a beautifully written world that explores themes of inequality, queerness, and immigration through a sci-fi lens. While there are some slow parts to the plot (mainly in the middle of the book), I found "Pangu's Shadow" to be highly enjoyable and thought-provoking.

The positive aspects include the well-developed characters and their relationships, the expert blending of mystery and science fiction, and the exploration of relevant social issues. The storytelling prowess of Karen Bao is evident as she delves into topics like disability, queerness, and xenophobia in academia, adding depth to the narrative without feeling forced or preachy. The social critique in the novel works well, exploring classism, immigration, and illness against the backdrop of a murder mystery. Even though the book was set on different planets with the sci-fi element, readers could definitely make connections to their own lives right now. The commentary was fresh and realistic, especially when considering the academic side, like prejudice against women and immigrants in the academic world.

I thought the author did an excellent job at delivering on multiple fronts, including being a sci-fi mystery, layered with nuanced world-building, relationship development, and a well-developed mystery. The mystery had me guessing throughout, though I would say I was more invested in the characters over the mystery itself.

The characters in "Pangu's Shadow" are lauded for feeling real and complete, making the plot even more engaging. I think the character writing is the strongest part of this book. Bao took care to create two distinct characters, two distinct perspectives in the first person POV, which can be quite difficult to achieve. But I really felt like I was in the minds of two separate characters when I was reading about Aryl and Ver. For example, I really like how the start of every Ver chapter involved some sort of scientific information, which aligned perfectly with her character. I did feel a little detached to Ver’s voice, but I think that is mainly just because of her character and who she is as a person. Aryl’s perspective was very emotional and engaging.

Overall, I would recommend "Pangu's Shadow" for fans of thoughtful space mysteries, YA sci-fi, and anyone looking for a compelling story that balances entertainment with thought-provoking themes. Karen Bao's ability to craft relatable characters and explore meaningful issues makes this book a must-read for those who appreciate the intersection of science fiction, mystery, and social commentary.

Ver and Aryl have overcome many obstacles to become apprentices in a great biology lab. They know they have a long way to go, but everything changes when an explosion happens, and their boss is found dead. The authorities believe there was foul play involved and one or both girls are behind it. They are bailed out by Cal’s wife and have less than a week to figure out what exactly happened. Was it an accident? Was it suicide? Or was it murder?

Pangu’s Shadow is a stand-alone sci-fi mystery that wasn’t very long, which made the events appear that much more intense. I was swept into the story immediately and thoroughly enjoyed the science-fiction aspects and the mystery that needed to be solved. I have never read anything by Bao before, but I will be looking for more books by this talented author. A great escape whether you like science fiction or mysteries.

This was a fun and interesting story about two very different girls falsely accused of killing their mentor. I enjoyed the futuristic sci-fi world Bao built, complete with robotic limbs programmed with host DNA. The alternation between each girl's perspective made their initial dislike of each other and eventual romance that much more layered. It was interesting how Bao embedded deeper cultural themes in the novel, which mirror some of the prejudices and struggles we see here on Earth-everything from disabilities, skin color, heritage, class, and LGBT+ issues. I really liked this book and would recommend it to anyone who enjoys YA fiction, science fiction, and murder mysteries.

I appreciate the opportunity to read and review this ARC through NetGalley!

This was basically a one sitting read for me. I only paused to grab a snack and ensure my kids were surviving without me. From page one, I was taken into this world. I think it's brilliant and engrossing. The sci-fi murder mystery blends well with the social discrepancies we see between the three moons. The bias everyone throws upon those not of their world, it was done very well.
There was so much frustration on the first pages when the police nabbed their two suspects and decided to look no where else. Then while they try to find the murderer to save themselves how they find more than they were looking for.
I think this was a beautifully done book about social injustices and those who can walk away because of money, power and perceived importance by a supposed un-biased system.

This book really surprised me! A really interesting science fiction mystery focused on two women from disadvantaged backgrounds who are apprentices at a prestigious lab and are accused of murdering their boss when he is suddenly killed. It is an action-packed adventure as they are forced to work together to try to clear their names while knowing they shouldn't trust anyone, not even each other.

This novel tackles a lot of important themes (sexism, queerness, capitalism, immigration, inequality, wealth inequality, etc.), and I thought it approached each of them carefully and impactfully. Learning at the end that the author faced similar experiences made sense; this is a great own-voice story.

As someone who has read some sci-fi but not a ton, I thought the world was built in such an interesting way as well, and I'm glad we got to explore a lot of aspects of it. The best part of the story is the characters, especially the way the two main characters grow after having to work together to try to clear their names. I wasn't sure how I felt about them at first, but by the end, I loved them and would love to continue to read about their lives if the author ever wanted to write a sequel, even though this made a great standalone novel.

I don't think I ever would have picked this up if not for the Netgalley review copy, so thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for the e-arc copy in exchange for an honest review. I'm so glad I picked this up.

I love this book! It has the perfect balance of science and feelings, and I especially appreciate its analysis of class politics.

This had a great sci-fi element to it during the plot of the book, I enjoyed getting to go through this story and the characters felt like they were supposed to. Karen Bao has a great writing style and creates a unique world and the characters within it. I’m glad I got to read this.

Wow.
I've never read any of Bao's books before, but after this, I'm definitely going to. This was not just a story, it was an experience. The characters felt real. You didn't just know what they liked and didn't like. You knew who they were; what they cared about. They were complete people, which made the plot even better.
To me, the worldbuilding and the characters are the two most important pieces of a story. If Aryl and Ver just went about their everyday lives doing absolutely nothing, I still would have read and enjoyed every single page of this.
Of course, they didn't just sit around twiddling their thumbs. Pangu's Shadow is an innovative story that takes you to the moons of a foreign star to solve the murder of Cal. Aryl and Ver, two academic rivals, both accused of murder, must work together to clear their name.
That's where things got good. Having such incredible characters put to such extremes makes for a gripping story that I enjoyed every page of.

There are no second chances in the Pangu Star System. Ver and Aryl, apprentices at the most prestigious biology lab among the system’s moons, know this better than anyone. They’ve left behind difficult pasts and pinned their hopes for the future on Cal, their brilliant but difficult boss. But one night while working late in the lab, they find Cal sprawled on the floor, dead.

This was a great Y.A. sci-fi mystery. The characters and world-building were really well done and I really enjoyed the prose.

Pangu's Shadow by Karen Bao is a YA sci-fi murder
mystery that immerses readers in a beautifully written
world brimming with science and intriguing social
commentary. From start to finish, this book captivates with
its engrossing plot, well-developed characters, and
exploration of themes related to capitalism, inequality,
queerness, and immigration.
Bao's storytelling prowess shines brightly as she expertly
weaves a tale that seamlessly blends elements of
mystery, science fiction, and social critique. The author's
ability to create relatable characters and meaningful
relationships within a futuristic setting is commendable.
Furthermore, Bao's exploration of topics such as
disability, queerness, and xenophobia in academia adds
depth and relevance to the story without feeling forced or
preachy.
While a minor drawback is noted in terms of pacing during
the middle section, the overall experience of reading
Pang's Shadow is highly enjoyable. The intricate world-
building and the race to uncover evidence of innocence
keep readers engaged and invested in the outcome. The
science explanations are both informative and accessible,
making the book appealing to a wide range of readers.
Pang's Shadow is a must-read for fans of thoughtful
space mysteries and YA sci-fi. Karen Bao masterfully
combines elements of mystery, science, and social issues
to create a compelling story that balances entertainment
and thought-provocation. This book showcases the
author's talent for crafting relatable characters and
exploring meaningful themes, making it a highly
recommended addition to any reader's collection.

This review was made possible via an ARC through NetGalley.

Pangu’s Shadow by Karen Bao is a Sapphic science fiction mystery YA featuring chronic illness, Asian, and immigrant representation. Ver has a degenerative illness that leaves her needing a cane and aware that she could die before the age of thirty. She and Aryl are both students working in a medical research lab and both are immigrants from Moon Three and Moon Two, respectively. The pair do not get along but are brought together when Cal, their mentor, dies in the lab in front of them.

The novel explores the intersections of classism, immigration, and illness against this backdrop of a murder mystery. The mystery elements themselves did not personally work for me, but the social critique did as did the use of scientific terms and explanations. It’s very easy to veer into sounding condescending or to use terminology that is hard to parse when discussing concepts that are often learned in the science classroom, but Bao made these explanations feel more like a reinforcement than a lesson. It felt organic and true to the characters.

Ver and Aryl’s character arcs are linked to their identities as immigrants and to each other. Aryl is a dancer who is attracted to her teammate, Rhea, and frustrated by the way her family is treated on Moon One. Aryl herself is often treated as less than and an outsider despite being born on Moon One; what matters is where her parents came from, even if they are intelligent and hardworking. Ver’s mother suffers from addiction while Ver’s main goal is to find a way to slow down her illness.

I recommend this to fans of YA sci-fi, shorter chapters, and those looking for stories about immigrants with a bit of an SFF twist. I do not recommend this to readers looking for more mystery or thriller elements in their books.