Member Reviews

Thank you, NetGalley, the Author and the Publisher for this ARC.

First let me tell you that I'm incredibly grateful that they decided to transform some of the Greatest Classics into Manga Classics.
It is a very dark read, literally and visually. I haven't read the Original by Mary Shelley, although it is on my TBR.
The Manga is has beautiful yet disturbing illustrations perfect for any horror and graphic novel fan.
For me however, it wasn't fast paced enough and I felt like it could not hold my attention.

I enjoyed it nonetheless as I'm a big fan of the style the artist used and I do enjoy manga and comics in general .

Was this review helpful?

Another entertaining adaptation of a classic that captures the original text's ideas well. The manga emphasis on surprise and melodrama works especially with this story, which has always been as much a period melodrama as a horror/sci-fi story.

Was this review helpful?

An easy reading for the one who wanna read some classics like Frankenstein.
I liked the rough and dark artstyle and the story follow the highlightes of the book of Mary Shelley.

Thank you NetGalley.

Was this review helpful?

I had never read Frankenstein before, but I have heard people refer to the story often. I don't know if I will read the full, regular book. But I wanted to at least become more familiar with the story than I was before. This manga did a very good job of telling the story and portraying each of the characters. I loved reading this Manga.

Was this review helpful?

Enjoyed this manga translation of Frankenstein. Chandler brings in components form Shelly's original version that will likely make this story new for you.

Was this review helpful?

Excellent. I’m not sure how else to describe it. This particular classic in manga form…what more could I ask for? No doubt it’s going to join my usual stack of reading comforts.

Was this review helpful?

This is my introduction to the Frankenstein story. I have never read the book and I am only vaguely familiar with the story in the way that everyone knows of it and the part that a monster was created by scientist Frankenstein. It was cool to finally get myself a taste of what the true original story is kind of like. I don’t imagine this is a 1 to 1 recreation, but the language is in an older style and I feel that the essence of what I imagine the original to read like is kept.

I love the idea of making the classics more approachable to teens and adults alike by turning them into manga. A lot of the classics are intimidating and I feel like the shorter versions with beautiful artwork are a great way to introduce these stories and help with visual comprehension.

I had learned a long time ago that Frankenstein was the Scientist and not the creature that was created, but I didn’t realize how much depth the story actually had. That the monster himself had so much internal questioning and that he’d begged for his master to create a new monster for him as a companion and the scientist destroyed that creation. It’s one of those situations where everyone is in the wrong. Tragedy ultimately was of the scientists own creation and he is as much a monster as his creation becomes.

As a person who loves horror this story is a quintessential example of what good horror looks like. It’s the horrors that man creates on his own that are the most terrifying. I recommend this version of Frankenstein if you enjoy classic literature or horror movies and books.

Was this review helpful?

I’ve read quite a few volumes of Manga Classics and I can only give praise, its a really good way to introduce new and old fans of the original work, to Mary Shelley famous book Frankenstein, in here we learn the story of doctor Frankenstein and what brought to his life the object of his life work, the Frankenstein monster… I enjoyed the artwork, got really interested in reading the source material, and really I can’t recommend it enough.

I say from young teens to everyone else, this is a great way to introduce people to the original story, and the drawing actually looks good.

Thank you Netgalley and Udon Entertainment | Manga Classics, for the free ARC, and this is my honest opinion.

Was this review helpful?

Not a groundbreaking adaptation. I enjoyed the art style, but it doesn't feel like a manga per se, even by old school standards. There is so much text, so much telling, when comics/mangas are the perfect medium to show not tell.. It didn't suck me in. That being said, the agony is well translated all through the manga.

Was this review helpful?

The original Frankenstein by Mary Shelley is one of my all-time favourite books, so when I saw this come up, I had to check it out, although I must admit being a Manga version I was a bit worried that it would be a toned down version, or a strange adaptation.

But this version was outstanding.

This book has the same essence as the original 1818 story, which is a great achievement, especially considering almost every movie adaption have been unable to do it.

The artwork complemented the story perfectly, and despite not being familiar with Manga format, I found it very easy to follow.

I commend M Chandler and everyone who worked on this, the result is nothing short of exceptional, and has inspired me to check out other books in the Manga Classics series, books that I’ve heard off but have been hesitant to pick up due to their older writing style.

I Highly Recommend this book to anyone, who, like me, loves Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein, or anyone who is not a strong reader or someone who finds the thought of reading such an old book daunting, this book is a easy and ideal way to experience this classic story.

Was this review helpful?

The Manga Classics version of Frankenstein by Mary Shelley, was a wonderful graphic adaptation of the original book and followed the original storyline and was written in the same literary style. It was an enjoyable read, and a great way to get into classic literature if you have issues reading that style of book!

Was this review helpful?

This is a manga adaptation of the original novel from 1818 - and it shows. M. Chandler Linus Liu, the authors of this one, used the old fashioned dialogue, which made the whole thing extremely clunky to read. I guess if you’re a fan of it, you like this one, but I prefer a less “staged” way of talking.
The story is pretty much what we know nowadays: Victor thinks himself above God and sets out to create life all by himself. He robs some graves, takes a sewing class or two, does a Benjamin Franklin and BOOM! Life. Just that he thinks it’s ugly and runs away. The “monster” then haunts him until he agrees to make him a girlfriend. But Victor being Victor he changes his mind right before the finish line, which enraged the monster. The Monster goes on a killing spree focused on the people closest to Victor until the good ol’ doctor decides to hunt the monster down. Eventually, they get lost in a cold place, Vic tells his tale to a good samaritan and then dies. The Monster says his goodbyes and disappears into the cold night.
The art style is what sold me on this one. I like that we get an actual monster and not just a guy covered in some scars. The proportions of the monster are all over the place, he runs like a gorilla, really cool. There were a couple of really cool panels in there, when Vic says something completely out there, even though he thinks it’s totally normal. True horror stuff right there. But I also have to critique one thing here: there were also points in the story where Vic screams for no reason? Like, he randomly screams part of his tale, completely unprompted, and then goes on as if nothing happened. That struck me as odd.
Overall a good and true adaptation in my opinion. Mind you: this is NOT a retelling!

Was this review helpful?

I have read a condensed version of this classic and reading a manga version was quite entertaining. I had to first figure out how to read this for it to start making sense (yes, there’s a way to do it) and from then on, I was hooked to the story. The illustrations were visually satisfying and I loved the gothic feel.

Was this review helpful?

Frankenstein

Author:- M.Chandler

Review...

I have always loved the classical monsters since I was a child & anything with them involved I am interested to read, I loved the art work and also really enjoyed the story 😊 & I will be buying this to add to my collection.

Frankensteins story has always been one about so many factors that is a issue with society.

We fear what we don't understand.
Loniness and isolation
Abandonment

Was this review helpful?

A accurate retelling in a classical style. I quite enjoy how well they managed to capture frankenstein with a few exceptions that honestly don’t matter in the end. I was delighted I over the style being very 80/90s dramatic manga and it fit the story well. I think this is a perfect read for people wanting to get in to the classics but don’t wana start with the books

Was this review helpful?

The single most faithful adaptation of Frankenstein I have ever seen. Don’t let the cover fool you, the art in this book is beautifully and thoughtfully done. I would highly recommend this book to fans of the classic novel or those who are trying to read it and running into some difficulty.

My thanks to NetGalley and Udon Entertainment for giving me access to a digital copy of the book to review.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you for NetGallery. I absolutely loved this. It's crazy seeing how this followed Frankenstein closer to how it was originally written and the graphics, oh man! I enjoyed it. I can't wait to read more in the series.

Was this review helpful?

I honestly don’t know if I’ve read the original Frankenstein by Mary Shelly. I’m sure I’ve seen some TV episodes and movies that have focused on this classic tale, but that’s about it. So, obviously, I jumped at the chance to take in a manga adaptation.

I’ve read a number of classics in my life. From novels to novellas to short stories and even poetry, when you have a degree in Literature, it’s pretty standard to have delved into a number of literary classics. Since graduating with my degrees though, I’ve definitely strayed away from classics for the most part, only doing the occasional re-read.

That is why I enjoy this line of Manga Classics. It allows me to indulge the part of me that misses those college days where I did more regularly read classics, while also not getting bogged down in some of the writing style indicative of the time periods these stories were originally drafted and released.

I read manga quickly, and aside from combat/battle/fighting scenes, I find them very easy to follow. So a classic novel that might take me at minimum a few hours can be read in about 45 minutes in a manga format. It’s the same information, but easier to digest and comprehend thanks to actually being able to see the setting or character appearance, etc, instead of reading lots of flowery sentences describing such things.

This manga adaptation of Frankenstein is definitely the most foreboding, terrifying, and dark of the Manga Classics that I’ve read so far, which is keeping with the vibes of the story. And okay, aside from Frankenstein’s monster, the rest of the characters are in that kind of cute manga style. Although, I’d say the monster doesn’t look too terrible or horrifying, but he is different enough from everyone else that he definitely stands out.

The eerie feeling and slowly creeping horror and tension just build through these pages, and you can feel this panic and terror just grow the deeper you get into the story. It was absolutely compelling, and I just wanted to keep reading. I’m not typically a horror or suspense type of reader, but I found myself needing to keep going with this one. I wanted to know what was going to happen next, even when I suspected it was going to be terrible.

I’m glad I read this, and hopefully I have some more Manga Classics reviews coming to the blog soon.

Was this review helpful?

Although Frankenstein is a classic, I find it hard to become interested in it. I read the original in college as a requirement and struggled then. I did enjoy the illustrations in the manga version; however, I was slightly disappointed that it was more Americanized art vs. other manga classics that have skewed more towards Japanese style Mangas. I give this book 3 stars simply because the story was still hard for me to stay interested and the art wasn't as good as other manga classics.

Was this review helpful?

I have been a huge fan of the Manga Classics series since the author and publisher started releasing them many years ago. As a junior high teacher of English Learners, it has helped me bring more and more classics into the classroom.

I appreciate that M. Chandler chose the original 1818 version of Frankenstein, I actually had no idea there were various versions and I've read the latest one, which means that this manga does slightly differ from the one I teach. But I'll still use this book.

The pictures are stunning and match the text but are far from being surface -level drawings. You can see the emotion on Victor or the monster's faces!

Huge shout-out to the author, Manga Classics, and the publisher for this early release copy. I can't wait to order some books for my students!

Was this review helpful?