Cover Image: A History of the World in Twelve Shipwrecks

A History of the World in Twelve Shipwrecks

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

While most of it was interesting, I did feel like it focused a lot on the author, lots of references to themselves in here. I also found a bit of the writing dull. I feel like with nonfiction books like this, a bit more of a dramatic and engaging writing style would have been helpful.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to NetGalley and St Martin's Press for an ARC copy of this book.

This was an interesting premise to this book- world history using the lens of 12 shipwrecks to tell the tale. It really stretches the timeline of world history- starting prehistoric, moving into Greek and then Roman wrecks, and then getting into European focused wrecks that involved kings, pirates, polar exploration, and war.
Overall really enjoyed this book- giving it four stars. Some of the wrecks I had some knowledge about, others were completely new to me. I found myself pausing in my reading to go look up photos of the ships, wrecks, and people who lived on them. In some of the chapters he really gets into the cultural and socioeconomic conditions of the world at that time.
The one criticism I have for the book is the wrecks chosen; I caught on pretty early that the author was only going to focus on wrecks he has dived on, which makes sense from a research perspective. But that left out to me some of the most influential wrecks in history, including the Lusitania, Titanic, Shackleton, and Captain Cooke's fleet. Still worth reading in my opinion, just keep in mind that the perspective narrows the scope of what's covered in the book.

Was this review helpful?

With a title that positions it to be the Dad book of '24, A History of the World in Twelve Shipwrecks is careful to position itself as a total world history, but "a history of the world, in which the wrecks provide a springboard for looking at the wider historical context," (emphasis in original), a sight which the text lives up to, mostly. It gives the author the permission to go far outside of the wrecks themselves and discuss the underlying history of the time when they happened.

The weakness of this approach is that sometimes the text goes way out to the point of distraction, but the cool thing is that Gibbins has chosen shipwrecks where there is historical information about them, most chillingly in the story of the HMS Terror where the wreck amounts to providing answers in a mystery story, though a few get particularly tenuous in an unprovable, wouldn't it be cool way for the wrecks from antiquity.

Although, I have trouble calling it a world history, due to its eurocentric focus, though it should be said (in a way that I'm sure is going to irritate some of the conservative twitterati) it is conscious of that and tries to provide more scope when it can. But it is more a history of the idea of the world itself rather than a world history.

Twelve Shipwrecks is a history of globalization, from its earliest passages about the importance of British tin in ancient Europe as part of the possibly ritually buried channel-crossing boat of to the multi-national crew and cargo of the final doomed ship in the Second World War. More, it is the history of the culture of globalization, the persons doing the work of moving goods and making war. It reflects how local culture has always had international characteristics, where the movement of goods and people in surprising ways is the rule, not the exception, but also how that activity, primarily in shipping, has its own sort of character. While that character is not consistent over the ages, it certainly rhymes, and is a worthy topic of consideration.

The weakness of the book is the chronology. There are in effect three competing narratives here. The first is the timeline of history itself, which the book is organized around. The second is Gibbins' work as an underwater archaeologist. It is pointedly cool to get a book on the history of a shipwreck where the author can write experimentally about diving the wreck, or being involved in some aspect of the research. The third is the history of underwater archeology itself, in general and in specific for each one of these shipwrecks, their discovery and what has happened with them over the years.

This adds a layer of unintended complexity to the work, and references to events that will be discussed or have been discussed. Each one of the individual chapters is structured to stand on its own, so it does not negatively affect the core, but much like when the history goes way out into the suburbs it feels disorienting. Also, the writing can be on the dry side (rimshot), but as a stylistic choice between that and the breathless hype of some popular histories, I will always choose the dryer read, as I like being treated like an adult who can add the color if necessary.

Gibbins provides a great framework for a way to think about world history, and one that is centered on the human and the individual. It leaves me wanting more of that, but it could not do that without sacrificing the author describing his unique connections to the history.

Was this review helpful?

Five stars if you are REALLY interested in history, marine archeology and/or the history of ships.

David Gibbins is one of the most famous marine archeologists in the world and so it is logical that he should have written a book detailing twelve famous shipwreck discoveries.

Each chapter is devoted to one of these shipwrecks, in chronological order. By doing so, Gibbins can expand upon the information about the shipwrecks and connect them to to the history of the world at the time, compare them to each other, and to similar discoveries in other locations. This is a clever (and new to me) way to look at history, by focusing on the history of traveling by ship. Gibbins was personally involved in many of the shipwreck discoveries and relates his experiences as a marine archeologist in a captivating and personal style.

Highly recommended if you are a history buff, love archeology and find shipping history fascinating. If you are just slightly interested in these subjects, you might find the pure amount of information to be overwhelming, and that it reads more like a textbook. However, you also might be inspired to go down many rabbit holes (I was!) and find out more.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you so much to NetGalley, St. Martin’s Press, and David Gibbbins for allowing me to review this interesting book. I enjoyed learning about the various shipwrecks and the history of the time periods surrounding each shipwreck. I appreciated that the author included shipwrecks that were not as widely known. I also enjoyed reading about widely different timelines. I am excited to get a physical copy of this book for my history and maritime loving friends. I recommend this to anyone who enjoys history and maritime events. Thank you again for allowing me to review this book.

Was this review helpful?

On the face of it, this book is right up my alley. Shipwrecks! History! Unfortunately, David Gibbins just misses the mark a bit too much in A History of the World in Twelve Shipwrecks.

The premise is good enough. Take a list of wrecks and then explain the history around them. More than half of them Gibbins has personally dived on. Gibbins then gives a wider historical context around these ships and there you go. Easy peasy.

I had to think quite a while about why this one wasn't a home run for me. One of the issues which jumped out at me is that the wrecks can often feel tacked onto a very quick (relatively speaking) rundown of the history in the time period. I wanted more on the sunken treasures. The chapters where Gibbins was actually diving on the wrecks were usually the better chapters. Gibbins also writes well so even when I didn't love a chapter, it was still good, just not great.

The other problem is that since this is effectively 12 vignettes, each chapter must stand on its own. Gibbins accomplishes this, but he does it too well. It felt like you could completely skip a ship and it wouldn't matter. The book was not cohesive enough because sometimes Gibbins talks about how the ship sank, or the people on it, but other times he approaches it completely differently.

My criticisms make it seem like the book is something you should definitely skip, but it very well may be a matter of taste in the storytelling. You won't throw the book away in frustration, but you may not like it as much as you hoped, like me.

(This book was provided as an advance copy by Netgalley and St. Martin's Press.)

Was this review helpful?

This book was incredibly interesting. I enjoyed learning things that I didn't know about these ships and the events surrounding them. The way that the author connected them was so unique!

Was this review helpful?

"A History of the World in Twelve Shipwrecks" by David Gibbins is a captivating exploration of human history through the lens of significant maritime disasters. With meticulous detail and a wealth of archaeological knowledge, Gibbins weaves together the stories of twelve shipwrecks, ranging from the Viking warship of King Cnut the Great to the SS Gairsoppa sunk during World War II. This ambitious undertaking results in a compelling narrative that spans the ages and illuminates not only the maritime tragedies but also the broader historical tapestry.

Gibbins' expertise as a maritime archaeologist is evident throughout the book, as he takes readers on a journey beneath the waves to uncover the treasures and remnants of past civilizations preserved within shipwrecks. The choice of twelve diverse wrecks allows for a comprehensive exploration of different historical periods, including the Bronze Age, Caesar's Rome, the Viking era, and Arctic exploration.

What sets this book apart is its ability to transcend the mere retelling of shipwreck stories. Gibbins skillfully connects these events to larger historical themes, such as the spread of people, religion, and ideas around the world. The narrative unfolds as a tapestry of colonialism, migration, and the enduring human spirit that persists to this day. It's not just a chronicle of ships lost at sea; it's a rich portrayal of the complexities of human history.

The author's writing is accessible and engaging, making complex archaeological concepts and historical periods understandable to a wide audience. Gibbins seamlessly integrates archaeological findings with historical context, offering readers a deeper understanding of the significance of each shipwreck in the broader context of world history.

The inclusion of personal stories, such as those of the people who sailed on these ships, adds a human touch to the narrative, allowing readers to connect emotionally with the historical events. The book succeeds in not only educating but also captivating the reader with the allure of underwater secrets and the untold stories waiting to be discovered beneath the waves.

In conclusion, "A History of the World in Twelve Shipwrecks" is a four-star journey through time and across the seas, skillfully crafted by David Gibbins. It is a testament to the author's expertise, offering readers a comprehensive and enthralling exploration of maritime history. Whether you are interested in archaeology, history, or simply enjoy a well-told tale, this book provides a fascinating and immersive experience that brings the past to life through the secrets hidden beneath the ocean's surface.

Was this review helpful?

OH wow so I’ve been on an under the sea kick and this filled that for sure. I loved reading about the history of our world and seeing it from shipwrecks. I’m slightly obsessed with swimming and water so it was a perfect read for me. At times it came off a little like a textbook but that’s ok I still enjoyed it.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for this ARC!

Really neat read. I learned a lot and appreciated the authors sharing of his experiences and engaging writing style.

Was this review helpful?

I have always been interested in shipwrecks so I had to request this book. I was not disappointed reading this book. Thank you also, for not including the Titanic as there's enough books out there about it.

The author definitely researched. He also is a good writer as this book was well written. This is a definite recommend if your interested into shipwrecks.

Thanks Netgalley and publisher

All thoughts and opinions are my own and aren't influenced by anyone else

Was this review helpful?

A fascinating look at maritime history. Gibbins makes these disasters accessible and gripping for the modern reader. Sure to be on the best nonfiction lists of 2024.

Was this review helpful?

For a history book, there were way too many "I"s in this. Other readers might be interested in the author's education & experiences diving, but I was reading it for the historical context. I think there was too much padding to make this into a book.

Was this review helpful?

This is definitely good and I liked the premise. But ultimately, there just wasn't enough information for my taste. I appreciated some of the early entries more than later ones. There is less information about these, but I enjoyed the author's use of the artifacts present in the archeological evidence to speculate about the people present at the shipwreck as well as the broader time period. The later chapters almost have less information included, probably due to having more information about the time so less need for speculation.

I do feel inspired to read more about the Franklin expedition. Lead poisoning + cannibalism! How is that not interesting? This is not the only time I read about it this month, as it is also included in an essay collection by Margaret Atwood.

The author actually gets extra points for not including the Titanic. My unpopular opinion is that one is overdone and it bores me.

Was this review helpful?

I love shipwrecks: their mystery, their abruptly-destroyed journeys, and what they say about the culture that sent them, and the culture that would receive them. "A History of the World in Twelve Shipwrecks" attempts to distill the history of human communication and transportation into a smattering of maritime disasters, and on the whole it's an engaging, successful and interesting book. From ancient Turkey to the frigid waters of the Arctic, Gibbons not only discusses the specificities of the ships, but how they were discovered, how archeologists studied them (some were by far more readily accessible than others) and how, if applicable, they were brought to the surface. But Gibbons also concentrates on the historical context in which these ships sailed: what they carried, where they were going, and what their goods indicated about human culture and civilization.

Gibbons writes for an audience that's more learned than most - I found myself looking up things he offhandedly referenced, and terms I wasn't familiar with. It's not really written for a general audience, and the vibe leans a little dry and dense here; however the writing itself was detailed, fascinating, and passionate on the subject. I very much enjoyed the structure of the book (a chapter on each wreck) as it sailed closer to modern day. Very much recommended for fans of maritime history, and history in general.

Was this review helpful?

A shipwreck captures the history of a single moment in time. As an archeology major (even if I don't use my degree in my daily life lol) I love learning about history from the artifacts left behing so shipwrecks have always fascinated me. Gibbins has spent practically his whole life entranced by shipwrecks and has explored many. The twelve shipwrecks highlighted in this book are quite the variety.

I enjoyed getting to learn about the process for making sure an underwater excavation doesn't destroy the items they are trying to excavate. As an archeology nerd, this book was a really fun look into underwater archeology and 12 distinct times in the history of the world. It is dense but I def recommend if you are interested in learning about our world through what we leave for those after us to find.

Was this review helpful?

Such a cool book, a very cool way to organize information. It's about a lot more than just shipwrecks. In a way, it almost reads as a history of the world, funneled through these shipwrecks as a way to get at the most important facts. Interesting things covered beyond sea-going vessels: where much of the tin came from that helped make the bronze of the Bronze Age (my personal favorite tidbit), the early languages of the Mediterranean and Middle East, who the Sea Peoples likely were and their impact on the end of the Bronze Age, the battles of the Greco-Persian wars in the fifth century bce, the founding and general history of the Roman Republic, the military successes of Justinian's general Belisarius, the origins of Sinbad the Sailor, the history of tea drinking, the ins and outs of the medieval ivory trade, the reach off the Dutch East India Company, and the dangers of the water just off the coast of the most southerly point of the British mainland.

My favorites of the shipwrecks included were "Early sea traders of prehistory in the 2nd millennium BC” "11th century AD Viking seafaring and voyages of discovery," "The Santo Christo (1667): lost masterpieces of the Dutch Golden Age," and "HMS Terror (1848): to the limit of endurance at the ends of the earth."

There were a few times when I was somewhat bored, usually because the time period and place or subject covered was not one in which I'm particularly interested, but usually I had no trouble staying engaged. It took me longer than usual to read this though, because some of the chapter ignited an interest in me that I couldn't ignore. After the early chapters, I had to read a book about the Trojan War. After the Vikings chapter, I had to read a book about William the Conquerer. The mention of Ahmad ibn Fadlan made me want to find a biography of him. After the 1667 chapter, I had to read a book about the Dutch Masters. And then I couldn't start the next chapter until I'd finished these sister reads, as I was worried a new topic would ignite in me. The best type of nonfiction is the kind that makes you want to read other things because what's within is so stimulating.

I received this book through NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and St. Martin's Press for this ARC of A History of the World in Twelve Shipwrecks in exchange for an honest review! Reading this book you can't help but appreciate how much effort and research David Gibbins put into this. I love the insights he's gained from his diving experiences and he's done a great job taking that and other research he's done to write a very interesting history book! I was learning something new with every turn of the page. I think I was fascinated the whole time because Gibbins was so clearly fascinated by what he was telling me. That made me find this book incredibly engaging, especially for a history book!

I think if you wanted to have a very informative evening this book can be read in one sitting. I also think it could be enjoyable to read a chapter or two at a time if you want to pace yourself. I think the length is good for reading it either way.

If you're a fan of history, shipwrecks, or both I would recommend this book! If you look at this book's description and think you might be interested, I'd say you definitely should give it a try!

Was this review helpful?

Lots of interesting information, but a really slow read. I put it down between chapters, but kept going back for more history.

Was this review helpful?

Very well researched. An interesting and informative read for anyone interested in archeology, shipwrecks and ancient history. Meticulous descriptions with loads of background information.

Was this review helpful?