Skip to main content

Member Reviews

3.5.
Negatives: this book had a lot of potential but used unnecessary profanity (IMHO). It is also very brief, which might have been intentional. I would have enjoyed more. More stories, more health information, and resources.

Pros: I love the health information that is included on the risks of binding and the self-reflection prompts for folks who are considering binding/parents, as well as loved ones who care for those who do/might.

I am not looking forward to book challenges on this title. I believe that every reader their book, and every book their reader. As the book says, most injuries and adverse side effects from this approach to dysmorphia come from a lack of education and the feeling of needing to hide from loved ones/others.

To the folks who disagree with this practice, consider an analogy of a binder to high-heeled shoes and back pain that folks deal with regularly for aesthetics and self-confidence. This is similar. I never plan to bind nor encourage it (the same goes for high-heeled shoes). Still, I think that if someone else feels the need, there are resources like this book to help people make good choices and encourage them to talk with health professionals and other professionals to assist them in living the healthiest life possible, inside and out.

I know this book will cause a lot of negative press, but by doing so, it will enhance viewership for people who might not have had this book (or even ANY books, gasp) on their radar when struggling with their identities and self-perceptions. Perhaps if we spent more time listening to and supporting people instead of arguing with them about our ideals, people would find easier ways to affirm themselves and live the best life possible. Until society shifts, we have books like this to start conversations and provide insight into other folks' worlds. Love your neighbor.

Was this review helpful?

It's a great book about binding AND it's a graphic novel!! I learned so much about binding and what people go through to show their true selves. A must-have for all libraries!

Was this review helpful?

Breathe shows people how to bind their chests safely as well as what not to do with binding.

This is a quick guide that could be super useful to anyone that binds their chest.

Was this review helpful?

Maia Kobabe and Sarah Peitzmeier's book Breathe was a thoughtful, informative and insightful examination of a very common transition stage in many transgender people's lives. The book describes both how chest binding gave the real people profiled in the book a great sense of agency in terms of how they present themselves to the world, yet how it also let to discomfort, trouble breathing and even injuries. The advice that can be gained through the stories of the individuals was plentiful and this was continued in the medical information towards the back of the books. The drawings and depictions of the unique people who share their binding journeys was warm and engaging. I am very happy that this book is becoming available in the world. I'm certain it will be a positive guide for many.

Was this review helpful?

I think I couldn't have found a better time for me to find this book. Binding is an intimidating part of the trans experience, and it is vital to share clear and safe methods. The stories in each chapter helped show the different ways and reasons many people bind, and I think this will be a great tool for people interested in binding as well as their loved ones!

Was this review helpful?

I chose this book not because I've ever been interested in binding, but because I read Maia Kobabe's Gender Queer, and wanted more information, to help me understand people who are LGBTQ+. This volume contains information laid out in a clearly understandable, relatable way, both for those who need advice about binding safely, and those who want to support people who are LGBTQ+. The illustrations support and enhance the information provided, making the volume more interactive and informational than the text alone would be. For those interested in the issue, this is a valuable resource. Strongly recommended for anyone who is considering binding, has been binding without consulting a medical professional for how to bind safely, and anyone who cares about someone who is currently binding or considering binding.

I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Part memoir anthology, part medical advice, part workbook, this graphic pocketbook shows us how to chest bind safely for body and mind.

I liked how this book has a little bit of everything. The inclusion of graphic storytelling through interviews with a varied cast of people, was great as an initial intrigue and basis to introducing exercises to alleviate pain and discomfort, to then transition into statistics and a workbook for the reader to reflect on their journey and practices.

It is excellent that a small and concise book like this exists, it can be so helpful and validating if this is a journey you're going through. Not to mention, bringing awareness to health complications that can come with unsafe binding practices. Your physical health is important.

I wish the book mentioned how safe binding practices also increase your chances of top surgery scars and healing going well. I think this is something not many think about and know, and could also be a good motivator to take care of your health. BUT it's a small book and doesn't assume top surgery is something a trans masc person wants, which I really appreciate!

Thank you to NetGalley and Dutton Books for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.

I also want to mention that the format of this ARC was a pain in the ass to read and it affected my reading experience, and stopped me from getting a full impression of what the printed work will look like, and be read as.

Just wanted to mention that the format of this ARC

Was this review helpful?

Very helpful and intuitive book for anyone needing to learn food use or just general knowledge. Easy to understand with a good amount of facts and knowledge

Was this review helpful?

This was a very interesting read and I liked it. I love to read these kinds of things because you.actually learn something. I never knew that binding was a thing. I learned it was and its interesting as to why people do it. It also talks about how to safely bind and how long. At first I could not wrap my head around it because I never knew. everyone should read this book just to see what other people say.about it. This book is a must read

I received a free copy of the book and is voluntarily writing a review

Was this review helpful?

Short and sweet guide to chest binding. I enjoyed the memoir section a lot, though I wish the latter half that was a "guide" went into a bit more detail. The exercises and stuff were great, but I wish there had been some more options in the back half for those who can't just go to the store and buy a binder other than "don't bind" — but I'm not binding myself, so I don't have much of a leg to stand on. Ultimately this is a great resource for teens who may be interested in binding but want a trusted source rather than just scouring the internet.

Was this review helpful?

I found this book informative about trans health and safety. I enjoyed the stories of people finding out how best to care for themselves in their bodies with safety and authenticity. I think this book could help others who may not have good support systems in their lives to help them find safe ways to live authentically as a trans person. I will recommend this book to people who are looking for ways to chest-bind safely or are exploring gender expression.

Was this review helpful?

Great illustrated comic about different types of binding methods. It includes personal stories and health and safety tips.

Was this review helpful?

Loved loved loved this book.

A practical, easy to read guide about binding. The illustrations made it accessible and I loved hearing from other trans and non-binary people about their binding journey.

Was this review helpful?

Breathe is such a breath of fresh air when it comes to providing insightful information for binding. There are four different individuals sharing their experiences with binding, whether it be homemade with Ace bandages or store bought. Each individual brings a unique perspective to the pros of binding. Additionally, there are some great resources at the end of the book, with my favorite being journal prompts and a binding journey timeline. By no means does this book try to convince someone to bind, but rather ensure readers have a comprehensive understanding of what it entails. Phenomenal.

Was this review helpful?

This book is absolutely perfect for anyone who binds, or who is thinking about starting to bind, especially for young people! The first story really stuck with me, since I am also a fat, nonbinary femme who struggled with my identity before discovering that I was genderqueer., and I truly felt that my story was represented here. Had I had this book earlier in life, perhaps it would have made things easier during my transition. The book is very informative, gentle and offers great tips for stretching, resting, and finding a binder that works for you at any age and stage of life. The stories are from both trans and nonbinary perspectives, which is great to see. I would recommend this to anyone who is on their gender identity journey, and really hope that it helps others feel seen and informed.

Was this review helpful?

I received an ARC of this book via Netgalley in April 2024. This book tells a lot of important stories and I really enjoyed reading them. They can ignite my own dysphoria at times, but the stories told her are so incredibly important. I am interested to see a final, completed version of this book.

Was this review helpful?

Such an informative book. I love the artwork, and the stories they told. I hope there are more stories than in the ARC, because 4 does not seem like enough. I love the tips on what pain may accompany binding and even the stretches that can help. This book will help so many people who are searching for answers.

Was this review helpful?

ARC. This graphic guide feels so important. I can only think about every single person that is going to help.
There is a lot of information, but it´s presented in a way that everyone will be able to understand, so they can make their decision based on what´s best for them and for their experience. That´s why it´s really important to introduce personal stories that share how everyones journey is different, but also completely valid.
I really loved the overall message that one can affirm their gender while also being safe, healthy and taking care of themselves.
I also think that some details like the journal prompts, the check in tracker, the reflection questions, and others, are amazing additions.
Every person involved in this book made an incredible job.

Thank you to the publisher and Net Galley for the e-arc. I can´t wait to read the final version of this book.

Was this review helpful?

Breathe is a great resource for teens and young adults struggling with their identity or ways of safely binding. As a cis-woman, it gave me insight into the lives of my trans and nonbinary students and the struggles they may face on a day-to-day basis if they are binding regularly. I would give this book to students looking for information on binding and to parents of trans and nonbinary kids so they can better understand the needs of their child and ways to encourage them to safely bind.

Was this review helpful?

This was such an excellent volume. I would buy a copy for any young trans person just beginning on their journey in chest binding. This was a good mix of personal stories, experiences, and good advice for binding healthily and safely. I was really interested in learning more about trans tape as well since I had really only heard about it briefly from my non-binary trans wife.

We need more books like these, they could literally be saving lives and preventing injury in young queer trans folks.

Was this review helpful?