Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Okay. I have thoughts...

I'm just going to flat out say - I was not a fan of this book.

I hate rating this so low because I found myself seeing that the writing itself was not bad but I really struggled to get through this. I’ll say this again later but to those who lived this book, I’m glad that you had a better experience with this! Not every book is for every person and that’s totally okay.

For me, the plot could have been cute but this is a hard concept to make cute and not cheesy or weird. Like, this story could have easily ended if she came clean in one email. Everything else just felt so unnecessary and extra.

I feel like there was just A LOT going on in this. We had so many little stories or add on moments that just had me feeling like this was all over the place.

When the camera crew came over, I just felt like we tried fitting 10lbs of story into a 5lb bag. Too much. The bear and the swimming and the canoe and the brownies and the girl coming onto Chris and the neighbor and the tree and I could keep going. And that was just 10% of the book.

The characters were not my favorite. I couldn't feel any chemistry between Chris and Daphne. I felt like he was hired and then they're suddenly texting but there was no relationship growth or development. Texting to "we're in a fling" in a matter of like two chapters. I was genuinely confused as to when they suddenly got super close and BFF material.

I don't want to repeat myself a lot but throughout this whole thing I just felt like there was too much being thrown in. Chris is an accountant but now actor and author and boyfriend? Like...it's doing too much. The two of them go back and forth this whole book and I just kept getting annoyed. There was just a lot of talk and no action.

The end was all over the place. The letter and him leaving and then chasing her was just so overly dramatic and ridiculous.

I don't think I could even pinpoint their personality traits at this point. So I couldn't even tell if Chris would act this way and even which Chris it was. Why were there two Chris personalities?

I had to skim majority of this because it was soooo much "inner dialogue" in third person.

This is sounding really harsh and just mean and I'm so sorry for that because I don't like to be negative with books. But isn't that what your personal opinionated reviews are? Speaking how you truly feel?

Because listen, there are some people on here who LOVED this and that's amazing. I'm glad they were able to see this book differently.

For me, I just couldn't get into it and didn't like a lot of aspects of it.

Thank you so much to NetGalley for an ARC copy!

Was this review helpful?

I regretfully say I had a really hard time with this. at times I found myself laughing, but in others I was downright annoyed with both main characters. The MMC was hard to like, and I could not stand him the moment he appeared, the FMC had me liking her about halfway through the book, but still fell short. I also did not enjoy the mid chapter POV switches, in my opinion it would've read better had it been separate chapters. As a whole, the story just felt odd and off, and the chemistry between the two just felt flat.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley for providing me with an ARC to Finding Mr. Write, here’s my honest review :

This is the first rom-com by one of my favorite authors, Kelley Armstrong, and I was delighted when I learned that she would be writing out of her usual genres. I liked the book at first but the more I kept reading, the more I loved it. While the romance in this book was top notch (Chris is swoon-worthy), I couldn’t help but be intrigued by the behind the scenes of being an author - especially a woman frightened by the idea of having her book not sold because she’s a woman and because she is, well - herself. Being an introvert, I understand that speaking to an audience - even your own fans - is a terrifying thought at first. Of course, there were all the regular Amrstrong tropes in the book, like the Yukon, the dog, ect, and that felt like coming home to me. I can only recommend this book for everyone since it had a good balance of romance and comedy shown through the eyes of a debut author, and a guy who plays the role of said debut author. I can’t wait to read Kelley Armstrong’s next rom-com!

Was this review helpful?

4.25 stars
I love books about books and this one had some interesting takes about being a female author. I enjoyed how quickly we would switch back and forth between the POVs so sometimes we saw the same scene from both MCs. Their flirting was cute and at times awkward but never cringey or uncomfortable. The miscommunication in the third act was actually a little funny because men can truly be that dumb sometimes. I enjoyed it! I'm surprised this is the author's first contemporary romance.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for this ARC!

Was this review helpful?

When YA author Daphne was trying to get her zombie book out into the world, she assumed using a pen name could help to her advantage. Her pen name? Zane Remington. A male persona that was strong, outdoorsy and photogenic — everything Daphne was but in male form. She wanted to show just how unfair the system was for women when publishing a book.

When the book sold for half a million dollars, Daphne needed to think quick. She hired a (very unqualified) actor, Chris Stanton, to act the part. Daphne never expected just how far the charade would go on or how fast she’d start catching feelings. Chris could only act as Zane for so long before people would find out their big secret.

I wanted to love this book because it started off so STRONG. I loved the banter in the beginning but then it got boring quickly. I also don’t love the plot — I don’t think the author is sending the right message here whatsoever. All of my favorite authors are extremely successful women and to think that this book was all about how Daphne was too scared or lacked the confidence to publish her book as herself was just disappointing to me.

Was this review helpful?

A sweet and sensual romcom from one of my favorite writers! Armstrong somehow manages to capture the nail biting essence of being a new author while developing a slow-burn romance that readers will cheer for.

Was this review helpful?

Daphne has written a book but she wrote it under a male pseudonym so now doing a book tour. She has to have an actor to play the real Zane. She hires. Chris, who is an accountant to play Zane well she is in the background.

They at first appear to be very polar opposites but the more they get to know each other the more they see each other for who they really are and not what they put out to the world.

This was a very interesting book to read because it was not exclusively a light-hearted rom-com. It definitely had some very serious moments but that really just helped add to the story.

I've pretty much loved every book by this author I've read and this is no exception. So if this at all sounds interesting to you, I highly recommend you pick it up.

Was this review helpful?

Finding Mr. Write is a dual-POV romance based on a false identity. After receiving a frustrating rejection, and a little wine, author Daphne resubmits her manuscript with a new cover letter, and a new name: Zane Remington. In the excitement of having her book picked up Daphne didn’t expect so many people to want to see and meet Zane- so she hires Chris to play the part in interviews and at signings. Chris falls for Daphne and slowly convinces her to open her heart as well.

This book was a lot of fun, although a bit messy with the false identity and how everything was handled once it became obvious that Daphne couldn’t keep up the charade. I was so caught up in Daphne’s dilemma that at times I’d find myself annoyed that there was a romance happening too (this is admittedly a WEIRD reaction for a romance lover to have to a romance book). I just wanted to see how she’d balance her career with her need for privacy but there was a hot guy (and they make sure to tell you he’s hot. A lot.) making everything more complicated! Still, I thoroughly enjoyed the book and I’m glad I got a chance to read it!


Read dates: 05/13/2024 - 05/15/2024
Goodreads review: 05/15/2024
Instagram review: 05/15/2024
Blog review: 06/25/2024

Was this review helpful?

As a female author, Daphne is having no success getting her zombie apocalypse novel published. She hatches a plan to submit her work under a male pseudonym, and she hires a gorgeous brawny male to portray the author of her book. Obviously there are sparks, romance, and an ultimate happily ever after.

This book was cute. I didn’t think there was enough of a romantic struggle for my personal taste - I’m a slow burn girl, all the way. But all in all, I thought the story was fun and had some originality to it.

Thank you NetGalley and Forever (Grand Central Publishing) for early access to this ebook!

Was this review helpful?

I am so excited that Kelley Armstrong wrote a rom com! Finding Mr. Write was a joy to read and I hope that she writes more books in this genre. It is entirely possible that this story will be a one off for her, so make sure you pick this one up!

One of my favorite tropes that the books centers around is also the reality that sometimes if you change your name, success follows in the book world for seemingly little to no reason. Daphne McFadden discovers how true this can be when she decides to change the author name of her book from female to male. Of course, she then needs this fictional man to appeal to a variety of people, so he becomes a rugged, outdoorsy hunk. When a publisher picks her book up, suddenly she needs someone to play the author.

Chris Stanton is an accountant who made a poor decision for his business and needs some help. His lawyer makes a deal, help for his business if he will pretend to be Daphne's author. He completely fits the bill, except he's not an actor. He's willing to make a go of it and become Zane Remmington, author.

Suddenly Daphne and Chris have to have a bunch more contact in order to take care of the publisher's requests for book publicity, and hilarity and romance ensue.

I enjoy the way Kelley Armstrong structures her stories and uses subplots to support her story while bring surprising elements to her books. Like bears.


Thank you Forever (Grand Central Publishing) and NetGalley for the opportunity to review this wonderful book!

Was this review helpful?

3.25 stars. Something about this book didn’t quite connect with me (I’m probably the problem). The plot setup is great, and I really loved the beginning of the book, especially when they were in the Yukon together. The book started to lose me while the MCs were on the book tour. The tour made me care less about the couple instead of more. I also didn’t think either MCs response to the third act conflict really made sense. Also, the FMC’s best friend just kind of disappeared in second half of the book? I feel like she could have helped the plot if she had been included more, especially since she was acting as the FMC’s lawyer.

Was this review helpful?

People who love to “pretend” - read this book!

Daphne hires a man to be the “face” of her novel - and of course it does SO much better than her previous times of where she was rejected.

This book was so fun! There was so much pretending - Chris pretending to be outdoorsy and an author of Daphnes book, when in reality he was an accountant who isn’t outdoorsy at all.

I always love a good fake romance, and you could FEEL their chemistry and attraction grow.

I read “Finding Mr. Write” so fast because I didn’t want to put it down! If you’re looking for an easy and enjoyable read - mark your calendars for this book!

Thank you NetGalley and Forever (Grand Publishing) for this ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

this woman has been writing for as long as i've been alive and reading and she can do no wrong. utterly astounded by her range. this was a fun time. was it the most incredible romance i've ever read? no but it did the damn job. it had an interesting concept being about a writer who hires a man to be the face of her book and of course, it all goes to shit. and books about writing and writers are always enjoyable. i also liked that while it did have moments of spice, it was mostly a closed door romance. i think this market is so oversaturated with smut right now and this was a nice refreshing balance of dirty and sweet.

also picturing the male mc as justin hartley made this so perfect

Was this review helpful?

Daphne (FMC) ends up submitting her manuscript with a male name after she has been rejected multiple times and to her surprise it gets picked up and sells for big money at an auction. But there's a problem...she needs a man to play her alter ego, Zane Remington. In comes Chris Stanton, he looks perfect for the role, but Chris has some secrets of his own. He is really an accountant who has no idea how to do these manly, outdoorsy things. When Daphne becomes a bestselling sensation, she and Chris are forced to go on tour together and she starts to find herself wondering if this geeky but hot guy is what she needs to push her out of her comfort zone and claim her dreams.

I loved this so much! The book had all the things I love...dual POV, fake relationship (romantic and professionally), forced proximity, he falls first, and there was so much witty humor!! I found myself laughing out loud a handful of times. The characters were relatable and I loved the feminism spin this novel took and how hard it can be for women to get recognition for their work...but if they slap a male name on it, bam!! The dynamic between Daphne and Chris is just perfect and so adorable. So so good!! I gave this 4.5 stars.

Was this review helpful?

I need Kelley Armstrong to write more romcoms because Finding Mr. Write is 💯 a five star read! Daphne is a smart and capable woman who takes a chance by publishing her book under a man’s name when she keeps getting rejected. Then the addition of Chris who gets hired to play the part of the male author and essentially switches between 3 different roles led to some very funny scenarios. When Daphne and Chris are together it is constantly switching between sweet moments and funny/ridiculous situations that just make it very hard to put this book down. I highly recommend you add this book to your tbr now so you don’t forget to buy it when it comes out in July. Trust me you will want to read this one!

Thank you Forever and NetGalley for providing me with an ARC of this book!

Was this review helpful?

This debut rom-com by Kelly had me laughing from the beginning! I loved the witty banter and dynamic chemistry between Daphne and Chris. Chris was a refreshing MMC. I loved his authenticity and the loyalty he showed to Daphne, thought the book. Daphne was a strong and fierce FMC, and I appreciated her vulnerability when it came to expressing her fears. Sooooo is her house, in the Yukon, listened on Airbnb? I want to spend my summer there! The house by the lake and the picturesque landscape sounded breathtaking.

There were a few moments on the book when I felt like the story didn’t flow and the dialogue was kinda chaotic. These parts of the story were still easy to get through and I think this book is the perfect summer read! It’s such a fun and lighthearted rom-com that will keep you wanting more.

Was this review helpful?

An utterly fun and hard to put down romcom debut from bestselling fantasy/mystery writer, Kelley Armstrong. I've long been a fan of this Canadian author and I was excited to see her trying her hand at contemporary romance.

The premise for this book hooked me from the start and I was laughing out loud from page one. When Daphne can't sell her YA zombie surival book under her own name she tries submitting it with as Zane Remmington. When it sells at auction and gets a HUGE marketing push Daphne finds herself hiring an actor to play the role of Zane only to later discover Chris is just a down on his luck accountant who needed the money.

Full of banter and great chemistry, this was such an enjoyable dual POV, forced proximity romance with a Canadian lead and a swoony, hot, baking love interest. HIGHLY recommended especially for fans of movies like The lost city with Sandra Bullock. Many thanks to NetGalley and Forever for an early digital copy in exchange for my honest review!

Steam level: fade to black/closed door

CW: death of a parent from cancer

Was this review helpful?

This was one of my favourite reads of 2024! It was easy to get into and instantly entertaining and engaging. I loved the main characters Daphne and Chris, their banter was perfect. Great setting, the house in the yukon by the lake sounded so picturesque. I also liked that the book gave a look into the world of publishing, book tours and PR. Kelly Armstrong has a great writing style. It was interesting reading her authors note at the end of the book with her inspiration behind the idea and how the book came to be. I never would have guessed that she was a mystery/fantasy writer and not a romance writer as her writing in this book is so perfect for the genre. Can't wait to read her other books! Would highly recomend to romance readers! 5/5.

Was this review helpful?

Daphne McFadden is beyond fed up with rejection. Despite tirelessly sending out her manuscript to agents, she's faced disappointment every single time. But she refuses to let that squash her dreams! So, she takes a bold step—she submits her work again, but this time under a male pseudonym. And guess what? It's picked up and becomes a sensational hit! Now, Daphne needs a man to portray her macho alter ego, Zane Remington. Enter Chris Stanton, who appears to be the perfect fit for the role. There's just one hitch—Daphne didn't anticipate that Chris is actually an accountant with no clue about rugged adventures.

Armstrong sweeps us away on an exhilarating journey to the Yukon, painting such vivid scenery that you'll practically feel the brisk air against your skin and smell the pine trees. It's like embarking on a nature retreat without budging from your couch!

The characters in this book are simply phenomenal! Daphne is a fierce go-getter unafraid to shake things up, while Chris Stanton is a delightful mix of rugged charm and unexpected vulnerability. Their chemistry is electric, and I found myself chuckling endlessly at their witty exchanges. And the slow-burn romance? Absolutely sublime. You'll be championing for them right from the first page.

But "Finding Mr. Write" isn't merely a lighthearted romp. Armstrong fearlessly delves into weighty topics like gender roles, sexism, and racism within the publishing world. Yet, she navigates these themes with grace, enriching an already fantastic story with layers of depth.

So, if you're seeking a read that seamlessly blends swoon-worthy romance, uproarious humor, and thought-provoking insights, "Finding Mr. Write" is the book for you! Seriously, snag a copy pronto and thank me later!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you so much to the author, the publisher, and NetGalley for an early copy in exchange for an honest review!

Finding Mr. Write follows Daphne, an author who feels scorned by the publishing industry as she tries to sell her novel until one night, she drunkenly comes up with a pen name, poses as a man, and submits her query letter. And, just like that, Zade, not Daphne, is picked up as the book world's newest hot author. In order to keep her ruse alive, she enlists the help of Chris, an accountant/mediocre actor with motives of his own that create the perfect opportunity for them to work together.

With some forced proximity, annoyances to lovers, bookish vibes throughout, this had all the components to be a book that is right up my alley. And, in many ways, it was. However, I found that there were some aspects and moments that distracted me enough to make this a 3 star read.

While the premise to this sounds really exciting, I felt like there were important moments that were rushed, and other times that felt redundant and distracting. Like, how many times can someone be interrupted by a text or phone call before they put their phone on DND? The will they/won't they, constant back-and-forth between Daphne and Chris was effective at first, but after a while, the feelings of tension started to be replaced by annoyance. Another part that had me pausing was the sudden switch between Daphne feeling mistreated by the publishing industry, which is a very real thing that happens (especially to marginalized communities), to feeling like she had overreacted/the faults she thought existed within the industry weren't actually that bad. There is a moment where Daphne is contemplating whether she made a mistake using a pen name, since the issues she had convinced herself of were not that serious/nonexistent. And while I do not want to downplay anyone's story or experience, I do think there was a missed opportunity here to touch upon the more serious themes of the book. It felt like there could have been more commentary around that experience.

I also found that while I really, really wanted to root for Daphne and Chris, many of their moments felt lacking in chemistry. Too much of it felt forced for any of it to feel natural, and I just didn't find my heart truly invested in their happily ever after.

One thing I will say, though, is that I really appreciated how bad ass Daphne was. A lady in the wilderness who can more than hold her own is admirable, and I thought that aspect of her character was really interesting.

Overall, I thought that this book was, for the most part, a quick and slightly steamy read, but I found myself wanting more out of most aspects- relationships, social commentary around premise, chemistry... I do think that if you are in the mood for a low stakes romance set in the wilderness with a Chris Hemsworth-esque MMC and bookish vibes throughout, this one may be for you!

Was this review helpful?