Skip to main content

Member Reviews

I started this book over a year ago and just haven't found the desire to pick it back up, unfortunately. I typically adore retellings so I may try again at some point. It is marketed as Crazy Rich Asians meets P&P and I didn't get those vibes. It lacks the expected dramatics and comes across much softer.
Thank you to Third State Books and NetGalley for the advanced copy. All thoughts are my own.

Was this review helpful?

As Pride and Prejudice retellings go, this one was perfectly fine. I didn't love how Lissie's writing her thesis on Pride and Prejudice (but maybe it's just me? I always find it unnecessary when characters are reading the books their book is based on). I really did like how the younger Chengs are handled, though, and the Chengs' family dynamics. Preston was definitely at his best (and most likable) when dealing with families and swimming, in my opinion. I did find myself hoping Lissie and Preston would make things work, and smiling at some of the sweeter moments as I read it.

Was this review helpful?

Such a fun and modern retelling of Pride and Prejudice! This story is set within the Asian Community and it really grabs you into the story without feeling repetitive given that its a retelling. There is such great banter in this story and was a fun and easy read.

Was this review helpful?

This was a first time read for me by this author. I am always up for a good modern Austen retelling, and this one certainly hit the spot. It is a delightful modern twist on Jane Austen's Pride and Prejudice, set against the backdrop of a family-run restaurant and a complex, simmering romance. Lissie Cheng, the quick-witted middle sister of an orphaned trio, works hard in the family business while navigating the challenges of building a future for herself and her siblings. Her life takes a dramatic turn when she accidentally serves a shellfish dish to a customer with a severe allergy, setting off a chain of events that draws her into conflict with the wealthy and seemingly perfect Lin family.

Preston Lin, a golden-boy Stanford Ph.D. student and accomplished swimmer, is everything Lissie despises. He’s arrogant, dismissive, and comes from a family that oozes privilege. But as fate keeps pushing them together, a genuine connection filled with humor and tension begin to form, creating a sparkling dynamic between them.

Lissie, with her sharp tongue and fierce independence, encompasses the spirit of Elizabeth Bennet. Her internal struggles, from dealing with her family's expectations to confronting her own prejudices, make her journey of growth and self-discovery deeply satisfying. Meanwhile, Preston, though initially appearing self-righteous and entitled, is gradually revealed to have layers of vulnerability beneath his polished exterior. The slow-burn romance between the two, built on mutual disdain that slowly transforms into understanding and affection, is a compelling draw.

A delightfully fresh and engaging story with the perfect balance of humor and heartfelt moments. The story’s themes of family loyalty, class differences, and the transformative power of love are weaved together masterfully throughout.

For Jane Austen fans, this is a charming, witty retelling of a beloved classic that will leave you swooning and laughing in equal measure.

I received a complimentary copy from NetGalley and am voluntarily leaving my review.

Was this review helpful?

I am a sucker for any adaptation of Pride and Prejudice, and I think Christina Hwang Dudley made Austen proud with this take in Pride and Preston Lin!

Lissie and Preston have great chemistry, and even if readers of the classic have a sense of where it is going, it's a fun ride getting there.

Many thanks to the author, publisher, and NetGalley for sharing this book with me.

Was this review helpful?

Something about this book just felt forced. It tried too much to be Austen's Pride & Prejudice while also being modern and snappy and witty, but it failed at this for me. For starters, Lissie, the main protagonist, wasn't a sympathetic character. I was reserving judgement given how the blurb itself says she makes a mistake giving an allergic client the thing they're allergic to - mistakes happen, I get it. But this one didn't feel or read like a mistake, Lissie is so flippant about it, and then she keeps taking it out on Preston Lin who, frankly, is entirely in his right to be calling her out for what she did. Preston wasn't the villain he was supposed to be; it was Lissie who was, for me, and this tanked the whole thing from the get-go. Jane and Charles also felt like they came from an alternate universe so sweet they were - again, forcing onto what the original Jane and Charles from P&P are supposed to be, and the originals had way more scope and dimensions.
All in all, this one just tried too hard...and missed the mark for me, sadly

Was this review helpful?

As someone who likes Pride and Prejudice and have read several retold versions, I looked forward to reading this one- especially because it has Asian representation. Lissie and Preston's version is unique and fun to read. I enjoyed the Chinese American twist to the story.

Was this review helpful?

This was a fairly cute modern Pride and Prejudice retelling. I always knew where we were in comparison to the original.
I still have mixed feelings about how cavalier certain characters seemed to be regarding food allergies... thus my mid-level rating. It also read a little younger than I anticipated which wasnt bad, but wasn't what I was expecting. Still a cute easy read (especially compared to the original.... haha!)

Was this review helpful?

This book was so cute! It was exactly what I had expected, a modern take on Pride and Prejudice with a new perspective on Chinese culture. Unfortunately, this also made the book a little predictable, and in the end it didn't stand out amongst the many retakes on the classic story. Still, it was a fun read, and I enjoyed it!

Was this review helpful?

This was a fun read, even if it felt younger than I’d thought it would be.

Would still recommend for a YA/New Adult read.

Was this review helpful?

Pride and Preston Lin by Christina Hwang Dudley

Pride and Preston Lin is a fun romcom, with an enemies to lovers trope. If you’re looking for a clean sweet romance than this is it. I enjoyed the character and the different interactions they had with each other. What is a better meet cute than not paying attention to someone’s allergy and causing an allergic reaction? Having been to a restaurant recently that didn’t pay attention to my own allergy, I definitely felt the situation in a different light. And where as I didn’t post about the lack of precaution, I liked the way it was in the story.

Overall this was interesting. Definitely not my favorite Pride and Prejudice retelling, but still very enjoyable. The author wove light jokes, into tense situations.

If your looking for a fun clean romance, than I recommend this story.

Was this review helpful?

Pride and Prejudice is my fav Austen so I had to read this Asian retelling - so fun! Really enjoyed this contemporary twist on an old fav, it’s so well done!

Was this review helpful?

This was an amazing Pride and Prejudice retelling - I loved it. You definitely need to check this out if you're an Austen fan. The characters are so well developed, and Christina did a great job updating the story while keeping the essence of the original. Lissie was so fun and so fresh - she is going to be on my list of favourite heroines for the year.

Was this review helpful?

I really wanted to like this, but maybe I have just been reading too many romance books so far. I definitely want to read Christina Hwang Dudley's books in the future, however, Pride and Preston Lin was just not for me.

Was this review helpful?

I am a sucker for all Pride and Prejudice retellings. This was no exception to that.

I adored the AAPI heritage and culture that was within this book. I found myself laughing out loud, and also rooting on the characters.

I didn’t dislike Preston, but that’s probably because I don’t dislike any “Darcy” character. Especially if it’s nailed correctly as this author did.

I was worried about the JoJo storyline and thankfully it ended better than I expected. I love the Crazy Rich Asians vibe too.

Was this review helpful?

A fun rom com read of misunderstandings and slow developing relationships involving much family, friends, past relationships and complications. Really liked this one.

Was this review helpful?

This is a Pride & Prejudice retelling in the Asian community. It was a decent read but not great. But I always enjoy seeing how authors do a P&P retelling. I'm always up to read them. It's interesting how they connect the stories, how they portray the characters. Overall I enjoyed it.

Was this review helpful?

In this amazing Chinese American retelling of Pride and Prejudice, readers meet San Jose State English major Lissie who works at her aunt and uncle’s restaurant with her older sister and future medical student Jenny. Working on her senior thesis, a Chinese American retelling of Pride and Prejudice (with characters inspired by real people she knows), Lissie doesn’t have time to accidentally induce a seafood allergy in Hazel Bing at her aunt and uncle’s restaurant. This incident turns wealthy Stanford Ph.D. student Preston Lin and his family against Lissie -- and the dislike is mutual. Circumstances, however, keep forcing Lissie and Preston to work together, making Lissie reconsider her pride and immediate dislike of Preston. With a fantastic cast of characters and an excellent setting in the Bay Area of California, Christina Hwang Dudley’s writing prowess really shows in this novel. Her characters are all charmingly realistic, honest, and clever, while the elements of Pride and Prejudice clearly show through in this novel. The characters and their relationships are the star of this novel, and the highs and lows of the plot keep readers glued to the page. A fantastic piece of modern Asian American romance and a great Jane Austen retelling, readers of several genres will love this book.

Was this review helpful?

I haven't read the original Pride & Prejudice, YET! So I'm not sure how this compares, but I couldn't put this down and finished it in a day.

Thanks Netgalley.

Was this review helpful?

I love Pride and Prejudice and was looking forward to reading this book, but it just fell short of what I wanted from it. The characters felt underwhelming and underdeveloped. Lissie is annoying, her actions don’t really make sense, and her writing a play just felt out of place. She spends the majority of the book disliking Preston because he calls out her mistake on a public forum (fair, but she also didn’t really want to take accountability and kept minimizing her mistake), he maybe caused a swim club to fall apart (when he was a literal child), and that’s it? I understand that she already disliked Preston so she was more susceptible to eating up anything negative anyone else had to say about him, but to hold something that happened when he was a child against him was just weird. Especially when she was set on protecting her sister, she should have been able to see that there was more to the story than what she was being told. The swim coach was already acting sketchy before that and she should have been able to see that. I just couldn’t root for her and found myself cringing several times because she was so oblivious to red flags. The gay roommate just felt like a stereotypical character added to check off a list. The ending was rushed and had no closure. Preston’s mom made it clear she will be an obstacle. How are they going to handle that? Are Jenny and Charles actually going to give it another go? What is Lissie doing now that she’s graduating? Lissie and Preston didn’t so much as hold hands prior to their truce and now they’re all over each other? Inconsistent with their previous development. Overall the story felt unfinished and could have used more character development and much less of Lissie’s play (because that also led to nowhere). I give this 2 out of 5 stars.

Was this review helpful?