I enjoy reading police procedural novels. I have been reading quite a bit of them, and I am always fascinated by the work and time that goes into solving a case. My fascination grows even more when the book is set in the early days of forensic science. Agony Hill is one of those books.

I was also pleased to see that Agony Hill takes place in Vermont. I can count on one hand the number of books set there in the past year.

Agony Hill is the first book in the Franklin Warren series, but it can also be read as a standalone.

Agony Hill takes place in 1965, and the author mentions the Vietnam War and the draft. The author does explain in her note (at the beginning of the book) that she didn’t use the spelling that most small-town papers used for the war (they separated Vietnam into Viet Nam). She didn’t want to confuse people; I am happy she did that. I am also glad there weren’t too many scenes with anti-war protests (actually, there was a brief scene of a veteran marching against the war in the parade).

The main storyline of Agony Hill is centered on Warren (a recently hired detective from Massachusetts), Sylvie (the wife of the victim), and Alice (an amateur detective who is more than she seems). The book is slow. Usually, I’m not too fond of it when books start and stay slow, but in this case, it worked. It allowed me to digest the clues that Warren uncovers, try to figure out who Alice was and the motive behind Hugh being killed. It took me a long time to read, but I enjoyed it.

I have never read a book in which people were so happy to see someone die. I get that Hugh Weber was unlikable, but to have no one, not even his wife or children, mourn for him was a bit much. Of course, the more Warren uncovered about this unpleasant man, the more I could understand why people felt that way.

I liked the main characters (Warren and Sylvie). Each had a compelling backstory, which added mystery to the main storyline (Warren’s background and everything about Sylvie).

I do want to mention Alice. I loved her. She was the epitome of your busybody, widowed neighbor. However, as the author got into her background, it was surprising to discover that she was so much more. Alice has a lot of layers to her, and I feel that the author isn’t done yet with this character.

The mystery angle was well written. The author kept me on my toes about who killed Hugh and why. I had several suspects on my list but started mentally crossing them off as Warren began talking to people. I was shocked at what happened and even more surprised at what Warren did. But, having thought about it, it was the right call.

The end of Agony Hill was interesting. I liked how the author wrapped everything up, but I also liked how she left a little room for the next book. I have a feeling that Bethany, Vermont, is going to be a hopping place now that Warren is there.

Many thanks to St. Martin’s Press, Minotaur Books, NetGalley, and Sarah Stewart Taylor for allowing me to read and review this ARC of Agony Hill. All opinions stated in this review are mine.

This mystery set in small-town Vermont in 1965 has a general feeling of a simpler time and yet the characters all felt so much more real and multidimensional to me. It's clear from the beginning that everyone is hiding something, and those secrets are slowly uncovered as we follow Detective Franklin Warren as he tries to solve a case involving a death (murder or suicide?) and two mysterious fires. Then there's his next-door neighbor, Alice Bellows, whose late husband worked in the OSS in WWII and who has mystery-solving skills of her own. You can almost feel the summer heat coming off the page as these two work on figuring out the truth, and while there's a satisfying ending, there's also a sense that we have more still to learn about these characters.

Thank you to Minotaur Books and NetGalley for the advanced reader's copy of this book I received in return for an honest review. This book will be published August 6, 2024.

I thought this was really well written and I look forward to reading more from this author in the future. I think it will find readers at our library, so we will definitely be purchasing for the collection.

Agony Hill was my first introduction to Sarah Stewart Taylor. I found the book to be a bit of a slow read, and not quite as much mystery as I was hoping for. It was an all around enjoyable read though, just not quite what I expected.

I enjoyed meeting Warren, the law.. Just gutted in his life and hired in a new post he is immediately called to a fire on Agony Hill.

Set in a small rural town in Vermont in the 1960s, Sarah Stewart Taylor’s AGONY HILL has all the right atmosphere for a mystery. A young detective settling into a small town, a barn fire that leaves a farmer dead, and an elusive widow with plenty of secrets - coupled with small town gossip, it’s perfect. We follow the investigation alongside Detective Warren, meeting a cast of unforgettable characters (including his neighbor, a Miss Marple-ish Alice). The context of the book during the Vietnam War is important, and Taylor manages to create an underlying tension that is noticeable but not a distraction.

It was an enjoyable read, but it leaves the reader with the kinds of unanswered questions that make the book ideal for a series, and it was clear almost immediately that this was intentional. Our glimpse into the characters’ histories is so fleeting that it feels too unresolved and almost half-hearted. I also found myself wanting just one sleuth - either the actual detective *or* the amateur investigator Alice.

Even though it didn’t quite land for me, I would probably read the second book in this series - if only to have some of those questions answered. I also loved the town itself and thought it was perfectly described in a way that made it feel real.

Thank you to NetGalley and Minotaur Books for the advance reader’s copy. All opinions are entirely my own.

This is the first book I’ve read by this author and what stands out most to me is her prose. I loved the way she weaved words together, the world and characters she created.

Set in 1965 this is a slow thriller to get through. There were times when I wanted it to hurry up and get to the juicy part but I also understood that this was a story to be savoured not rushed through.
I loved Alice and the dual life she led and would love to learn more about her.

This is perfect for someone who loves historical fiction with a bit of murder mixed in to it.

Thank you to NetGalley and Minotaur Books for the opportunity to read an advance copy of this book.

I love this author's Maggie D'arcy series so I thought I would give this a try. Unfortunately, this wasn't for me. It's more literary fiction than mystery. It's also VERY SLOW. I was bored for the entire book; it was a real struggle not to DNF it. The writing is lovely, though, and you can definitely picture the Vermont countryside. However, more than one plot line is introduced but not continued. What was the point of Warren's neighbor, Mrs. Bellows? Maybe there will be more to her character in future books? This is book one in a new series but I can't see myself reading more of them.

I really liked the setting of this mystery/thriller - a quaint, little, fictional Vermont farming community. It's the summer of 1965, and some people's lives are in a state of upheaval. The US's involvement in Vietnam is raging, and some of the owners of the picturesque farms in Bethany, Vermont, are being strongarmed into either dividing or selling their farms in order for the interstate to be built. It's a promise to bring more life and commerce to the sleepy haven of Bethany. As can be expected, most townspeople are not happy with this so called "progress."

Our protagonist, Detective Franklin Warren, arrives as a transfer from Boston to Bethany ready for a quieter lifestyle. He has supposedly been placed here as a favor to his father by the police chief whose life was saved by the senior Warren in the war. Franklin has some demons of his own to overcome as we learn he found his wife brutally murdered upon arriving home from work one evening in Boston.

The new detective has really no time to settle in because a local farmer, Hugh Weber, is found deceased in his burning barn on the evening of Detective Warren's arrival to Bethany. Is it suicide (as the door was bolted from the inside), or is it murder (as Weber had many enemies).

What ensues is a long trail uncovering many suspects who could have had motive to end Weber's "back to basics" lifestyle.

The plot will keep you enrapt as you travel through the scenic Vermont hamlet with Detective Warren on his journey to solve the case. The reader will also learn that many things aren't as they originally appear.

Thank you, NetGalley and St. Martin's Press, for the opportunity to preview this mystery with a mix of historical fiction and an array of interesting and some quirky characters.

Murder/suicide TW

I love all the thrillers but they are rarely set in the past, maybe as far back as the 90s unless it’s based on a true story. This was refreshing reading combining my love of historical fiction with a thriller. Set in the 60s along with the Vietnam War,
It also reads a bit old western with the homestead life. A couple characters were extremely unlikeable and could have done without or at least toned down a bit which is the reason for four stars

This is a murder/suicide mystery, the character development was done well. Franklin Warren comes to town due to some unknown reason that we get snippets of, this leads to more mystery. Mrs. Weber had a whole story of her own.
The small town of Bethany is in for a big change with the interstate coming through. Many of the town’s occupants are not happy.
I found this story is be well told, kept my attention and my only complaint was the nosy women living next to Warren. She was just plain nosy. This one comes in with 4 stars.
I thank St. Martin’s Press along with NetGalley for providing this Galley edition for no requirement other than my offer to provide an unbiased review.

State Police Detective Franklin Warren is new to the small Vermont town of Bethany, but a deadly fire in a barn on Agony Hill plunges him into not one but multiple mysteries that deeply impact his life and lingering grief. Featuring neighbor and self-professed sleuth Alice Bellows, the victim's engaging widow Sylvie, and a collection of unforgettable locals, this heartfelt puzzle box mystery set in 1965 is charming, haunting, and utterly immersive. Sarah Stewart Taylor's rendering of this fraught time is flawless, as is her gift for storytelling. I can't wait to return to Bethany with Warren and Alice again.

Detective Franklin Warren arrives in Bethany, Vermont. Immediately he has a case when Hugh Weber dies in a barn fire. Hugh was interested in living off the land and chose Sylvie as his wife because of her knowledge of farm life. There are a lot of suspects in Hugh’s death along with his brother showing up and expecting money from his estate. The gossipy town is full of ideas about the killer and the reader is kept guessing. This is historical fiction from the 1960’s. Feelings about the Vietnam war and changes being made to be more progressive figure into the story. I loved Sylvie’s work ethic and devotion to her children. The boys were so willing to help as best they could. Warren was a good detective, determined to be thorough and fair. His struggles to overcome his own hardships helped form his character. Great book!

Thank you Sarah Stewart Taylor, Minotaur Books and NetGalley for the gifted copy. All opinions are my own.
______

“That was how it was with other human beings. Until you started digging, you only ever saw snapshots of their lives.”

Franklin Warren has recently moved to Bethany, Vermont from Boston for his new job as a detective with the state police. Before he can even unpack, he’s called to a farm in Agony Hill, where it appears a farmer intentionally locked himself in his barn and set fire to it. Though it seems to be a straight forward suicide, Warren has doubts. As he investigates the fire, he gets to know the town and his neighbors while at the same time processing with his own tragedy.

What a beautifully atmospheric, small town, police procedural mystery! Set in 1965, the Vietnam war and subsequent protests are very much a part of the narrative. Warren himself is an enigmatic character and I enjoyed getting to know him, as he got to know the people in the town. The town was so richly and vividly portrayed that I felt as if I was there. Don’t even get me started on the food. From burgers and fries, sliced bacon frying, fresh bread out of the oven, and homemade raspberry jam, I was wishing I could jump inside the story!

Agony Hill is deeply character driven, however the plot, to my surprise and delight, had some lovely additional layers, as not all in the town are who they seem to be. The person who stole the show for me, was Warren’s neighbor, Mrs. Alice Bellows. An unassuming elderly widow, she is kind and caring, observant, intuitive and clever. I found myself looking forward to what she might be getting into. I’m thrilled this is book one of a new series, because I can’t wait to find out what happens next in Bethany.

Potential spoiler content warnings below.























⚠️Content Warnings: death of a family member, stabbing, alcoholism

“Agony Hill” is set in rural Vermont and evokes a sense of small town living. The characters are well developed but the plot unfolds slowly. Thank you NetGalley and St Martin’s Press for sending this ARC for review consideration. All opinions are my own.

I throughly enjoyed this book. I did think it was going to be a darker book then it turned out to be. It had really good world building. I could picture all things well. The characters were memorable in I didn't get confused on trying to remember which person did what. I would read another book by her.

This book is set in a very interesting world- the 1960s in rural Vermont. It's an era I have not read much about. Interesting takes on law enforcement of the times and the influence of the unpopular war in Vietnam.
Franklin Warren is a detective who is needing a change of scenery after some difficult times including losing his wife. He is given a job in Bethany Vermont and immediately encounters a case of a barn burning with a man dead inside, the door barred from the inside. Is it a suicide or something more sinister?
The Weber family (Hugh Weber was the man who died) were very interesting characters. The reader also meets Franklin's neighbor Alice Bellows who is an enigmatic character. It seemed to me that the story was laying the groundwork for subsequent books to go off in lots of different directions - maybe a little bit too much so.
The story is a bit slow paced but with an enjoyable plot. The evolution does seem to fit the setting - bit laid back.
This is definitely a character driven story with a very strong sense of place!
Thanks to NetGalley and Minotaur books for the ARC to enjoy and review. I very much enjoyed it and will look out for next in series!

BOOK REPORT
Received a complimentary copy of Agony Hill by Alex Sarah Stewart Taylor from St. Martin's Press|Minotaur Books/NetGalley, for which I am appreciative, in exchange for a fair and honest review. Scroll past the BOOK REPORT section for a cut-and-paste of the DESCRIPTION of it from them if you want to read my thoughts on the book in the context of that summary.

My only complaint about this book is that it ended.

For real.

So Sarah Stewart Taylor needs to get on the stick and write more in the series!

OK, OK, I know I’m being ridiculous given that this book isn’t even slated for publication until August 6, 20204. But I’m sincere in my sentiments.

PS
Imagine my shock when the description (aka flyleaf copy) turned out to actually be accurate!!

PPS
Guess I will just have to content myself with reading her other two series. Woohoo!

PPS
I think that’s more than enough exclamation marks for one week, let alone one Book Report, don’t you?

DESCRIPTION
Set in rural Vermont in the volatile 1960s, Agony Hill is the first novel in a new historical series full of vivid New England atmosphere and the deeply drawn characters that are Sarah Stewart Taylor's trademark.

In the hot summer of 1965, Bostonian Franklin Warren arrives in Bethany, Vermont, to take a position as a detective with the state police. Warren's new home is on the verge of monumental change; the interstates under construction will bring new people, new opportunities, and new problems to Vermont, and the Cold War and protests against the war in Vietnam have finally reached the dirt roads and rolling pastures of Bethany.

Warren has barely unpacked when he's called up to a remote farm on Agony Hill. Former New Yorker and Back-to-the-Lander Hugh Weber seems to have set fire to his barn and himself, with the door barred from the inside, but things aren’t adding up for Warren. The people of Bethany—from Weber’s enigmatic wife to Warren's neighbor, widow and amateur detective Alice Bellows — clearly have secrets they’d like to keep, but Warren can’t tell if the truth about Weber’s death is one of them. As he gets to know his new home and grapples with the tragedy that brought him there, Warren is drawn to the people and traditions of small town Vermont, even as he finds darkness amidst the beauty.

Thanks to netgalley and the publisher for an ARC in exchange for an honest review!
The book is the first in a new series about a police detective that just moved to Bethany, Vermont from Boston. His name is Franklin Warren (just call him Warren) and he left Boston when his wife died. On his first day on the job in Bethany, there is a suspicious fire on Agony Hill where a man is killed. It appears to be a suicide but Warren must investigate to make sure, and to make a good impression at his new job.
I'm sure there are many who enjoy a slow paced mystery set in picturesque Vermont, but I am not one of them. I was hoping for an edge of your seat kind of thriller and this did not do it for me. The writing is beautiful, The words painted a perfect picture of the rural Vermont town, but honestly I was just bored throughout most of the book. I did enjoy the characters in the story and I really liked how we got different perspectives throughout the book. It just wasn't fast paced enough for me

You can tell from the very beginning that this is the first book in a new series. The way we learn just enough about main character, Detective Franklin Warren and how he ended up in Vermont keeps you intrigued and wanting to know. The same can be said for his new name Mrs Alice Bellows and her mysterious past and her amateur sleuthing skills.

This series is set back in the 1960s so it has that historical significance to it as well as a police procedural at the very beginning of what we think as modern day police work with the emphasis on crime scene investigations.

I’m interested to see where this series is headed because I really enjoy Sarah Taylor Stewart’s Maggie D’arcy series.


Thank you @stmartinspress and @netgalley for this eARC in exchange for my honest feedback.