📚 BOOK REVIEW 📚

But How Are You, Really By Ella Dawson
Publication Date: June 4, 2024
Publisher: Penguin Group Dutton | Dutton

📚MY RATING: ⭐⭐⭐⭐✨
(Rounded Up To 5⭐)

📚MY REVIEW:

But How Are You, Really was a heart-warming story about the ups-and-downs of post-college life, the mistakes we make along the way, and the realization that the love and support of our chosen family can help us become the person we've always known we wanted to be.

This book centers around a lovably quirky, bisexual female main character, Charlotte, who returns to her alma mater, Hein University, during her graduating class's five-year reunion at spring commencement. It just so happens her miserable narcissist boss is giving the commencement speech at graduation, so Charlotte has to balance the nostalgia of reconnecting with old friends and old flames with the incessant needs of her boss.

At first, I wasn't sure this book was for me, as it seemed it might be better geared toward younger adults still struggling with figuring out how to 'adult' in those first few years after college. But the more I read, the more endearing ALL of the characters in this book became...And I found myself really invested in each of their stories and how things were going to turn out for them at the end of this reunion weekend.

Dawson's writing style was so authentically relatable, she created characters who felt so real you wanted to give them hugs throughout the book. The setting of the characters' story, back together at their college campus for the first time in five years, evoked such strong feelings of nostalgia for my own college days and sparked memories of things I didn't even know I remembered until I read about them in the pages.

But How Are You, Really is a beautiful story about acceptance. About the vulnerability of being our authentic selves, letting down our walls, getting rid of our negative self-talk, and learning that we're all worthy of being loved... Just as we are. It reminds us to connect with one another in a deeper way and ask the title's very question, "But how are you, really?" every chance we get, because we're all fighting our own inside battles nobody else can see.

I have to thank NetGalley, Penguin Group | Dutton and Ella Dawson for providing me an e-copy of this book in exchange for my honest review.

#ButHowAreYouReally #EllaDawson #PenguinGroupDutton #NetGalley #NetGalleyReviews #ARC #womensfiction #lgbtqiafiction #romance #bookreviews #bookrecommendations #bookrecs

Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for allowing me to read and review an advanced copy of this novel. I highly enjoyed it and will be recommending it to others.

This book was sooooooo gooood!! And it was not at all what I expected. Yes, technically, it is a romance. But it’s also so much more than that!

There are definitely a lot of triggers in this book, so be warned before you get into it.

I got very upset with Charlotte during SEVERAL different parts, LIKE REALLY MAD, but looking back I can see how that is intentional due to its ending. I honestly wish that this book was longer because by the end I was honestly so invested and needed to know more!! Her character growth by the end was perfect and I just wish that I could’ve gotten to see more of that side to her.

But How Are You Really by Ella Dawson centers on Charlotte, who happens to be bi-sexual and is going back to her college reunion. (is it just me or are there a flood of reunion books of late?). I enjoyed this story and it's a quick read and likely will be enjoyed by a lot of people in that age group.

Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the advacne copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. But How Are You Really is available now.

I love an LGBTQ+ positive book, it's definitely a highlight for me that there was a tight-knit queer community. Definitely an enjoyable read as someone who is nostalgic for their college days but is also unsure of how they would navigate uncomfortable memories that are brought up during a reunion.

As someone who graduated the same year as the protagonist, this book was very nostalgic for me. While the details may have been different from my college experience, the feelings -- of sometimes wanting to go back to when things were in undergrad -- are the same. This book is for any millennials who are still finding their place in the world, and what we can do to learn from the past while still moving forward. It is a wonderful debut novel and I can't wait to see what the author does next.

Honestly, this book wasn't what I expected it to be but was still a fun ride & an overall quick read! I definitely felt the general nostalgia vibes [associated with my own uni years], though I do think the plot (while interesting & engaging) could have been executed a bit better. This book reminded me of Buzzfeed in a way haha, but perhaps that's because, again, it also had me reminiscing on my own past experiences in which Buzzfeed also happened to be more relevant. One thing I didn't like though (and I've said this before in many a review haha) is the excessive use of slang— regardless of whether it comes from a Millennial or Gen-Z lens, I just feel like it instantly dates a book. Otherwise, this was a solid & witty book about finding your place in the world during a time of extreme uncertainty from all fronts.

Thank you Dutton and NetGalley for the eARC of But How Are You, Really. All opinions in this review are my own.

I feel like I have been reading a lot of books centered around a reunion lately. This one reminded me of The Devil Wears Prada but set a college reunion.

But How Are You, Really explores the unease at seeing people you may not have had the best endings with and how going back to a place can take you back in time. While I did enjoy it, I definitely felt the anxiety of the main character through some of her experiences. Overall, this ended up being a sweet story about how you can rely on your friends to help you when you are down.

This review has been posted to Goodreads and Storygraph on September 22th, 2024. Links provided.

Charlotte Thorne is not looking forward to returning to her alma mater, Hein University. Her life after college has not gone as planned and the idea of spending a weekend with her successful former classmates seems unbearable. However, when her demanding boss, a successful tech journalist, is invited to give the commencement speech during her five year reunion weekend, Charlotte is forced to go along. The moment she sets foot on campus, old memories resurface, specifically her relationship with her ex-boyfriend Ben and her unresolved chemistry with Reece Krueger, the hockey player she rebounded with. While dodging her best friend’s questions about her life, ignoring her boss’s incessant messages, and confronting her true feelings about Reece, Charlotte wonders if she can truly resolve her past and create the life she actually wants in just one long weekend.

Sadly, this book did not live up to the excitement I had before reading it. I was really looking forward to this book based off the description (who doesn’t love a book about life post-college not going as planned and yet the opportunity to make things right and have a second change is at your fingertips?), but sadly I really struggled to get into it. I found almost all of the characters to be very annoying, and I could not stand Charlotte’s constant self pity party. I have difficulty reading books with main characters who are so negative and who complain all the time, and unfortunately I felt like that was Charlotte's constant state of being. I loved the idea of the story, but I just could not grow to love the characters or execution of the story. It is still a 2 star read for me because I appreciated how things ended with her boss and her ex-boyfriend, but by then I really just wanted the book to be over unfortunately.

Thank you to Penguin Group Dutton and NetGalley for the opportunity to read to an ARC of But How Are You, Really? in return for my honest review.

The book went by so quickly and loved every minute of it! I loved how honest and raw this book was especially as a young women reading this!

Charlotte Thorne returns to her university five years after graduation for a reunion and to help her nightmare of a boss give the commencement speech for the graduating class. She's depressed and stuck in a life she cannot bear, so a weekend hearing all about everyone's successful lives does not sound like a great time, but her boss has promised her a promotion if he nails the speech and Charlotte sees a glimmer of hope for the future. And once she's back with her friends and ready for a weekend of fun, it might just be the change in perspective her life needs.

I wanted to like this one more because the ending is phenomenally empowering and it has a great message about confidence, found family, and accepting help when you need it. There was just something about Charlotte that never meshed with me. I get her depression and understand the massive toll the emotional abuse by those she loved left on her, but the way she handles and instantly reacts to things annoyed me. That said, reading about a group of friends being so close after graduating and heading their separate ways and the way they celebrate each other's wins gave me all the positive feels. There's a very delicate balance in the plot between super positive interactions and some very negative ones. The scale leans more towards the negative simply because we're in Charlotte's mind and she needs some very intense therapy, but the resolution Dawson came up with really is downright empowering.

Overall, I had to really think about how I felt here. It's a good story that's told from a POV that I couldn't connect with.

Thank you to Netgalley and Dutton for the read!

I requested this for consideration for Book Riot's All the Books podcast for its release date. After sampling several books out this week, I decided to go with a different book for my review.

I enjoyed my time with this book, I flew right through it and it was an easy and fast read. I appreciated the writing but it’s not my favorite, and I probably won’t be purchasing a physical copy. I definitely would pick up another book from Ella Dawson though and I look forward to more books from her.

I wish Charlotte did not go back to the college where she buried many many demons to find herself and happiness. I wish she could have done that before she started to question her value and identity. I wish she could not care so much about what others think about her, her job, and her artistic drive.

Charlotte went to homecoming hoping that people she should not see wouldn't show up. Also she went there because her mansplanier boss was going to give the commencement speech. This was less than an ideal situation, but here she was walking through the same streets, entering the same dorm, going into same hideouts. What started to be the worst time of her life could actually be the best thing ever happened to her.

I woohooed out loud when Charlotte sent that one tweet. It was a slap to all misogynistic and ageist men out there. Most of the male bosses need this kinda slap delivered to them on a "golden platter" because they wouldn't accept it any other way.

Summer 🤝 Fall in this ideal September book, a perfect blend of beach read and campus novel. But How Are You, Really is a sleeper hit of the summer, toeing the line between romance and lit fic and perfectly capturing the "lost or left behind" vibes many experience in their 20s. I am lucky to share an alma mater with the author, and I uniquely appreciated the love letter to college life she crafted. I pictured my own campus, laughed and cried at all the (not-so) subtle references, ( @brosandprose I caught them all), and sort of felt like I was time traveling.

Alongside its hilarious one-liners and heartwarming friend/found family themes, this book also has its heavy moments. As both a romance reader and also a psychologist, I think the mental health and trauma representation in this book outdoes most of the genre. BHAYR showcases the messy, bumpy reality of healing, that it's rarely linear, and that most people don't have sudden epiphanies that lead to quick resolutions (something that bothers me in many romances). Overall, this is a really wonderful debut with a ton of heart, definitely deserving a read as you craft your fall TBRs.

Thanks to @duttonbooks and @netgalley for sending this one to me early, and to @brosandprose for the literal time capsule you created.

Thank you NetGalley and the publishers for the opportunity to review this title. A fairly easy read, a bit of self reflection tossed in. Three stars.

Full of heartbreak and angst, it's easy to forge a deep connection with the characters in this book, which makes it all the more satisfying to root for their happily ever after.

4 stars

I did not expect to enjoy this one as much as I did! I almost thought it was going to be a YA book because it takes place at a college campus but thankfully it turned out to be an amazing story of growing up, true friendship, and old friends.

Charlotte comes back 5 years later to her old college during commencement weekend as an assistant to the graduating class commencement speaker. Rather than living out her dreams post graduate, she’s miserable in NYC, overworked, barely able to pay her bills, and has a boss that is more like a child than a mentor. Hoping that working this graduation weekend will be the key to her promotion and leaving her POS boss behind, she sets forth for a weekend reunited with her college friends and old haunts.

Her best friend lives across the country, the friends close by are all moving forward in life and work, and her abusive ex-boyfriend is also attending the reunion putting her on edge and reliving an awful part of her past. The last few years she’s let her self esteem be eroded and allowed her life to get crushed by the grind of entry level position expectations. Even years later the sight of her ex and the sound of his voice physically assaulted her with the memories of all she endured to try and be the perfect girlfriend. The boy she rebounded with post the awful ex is also there and while they had such amazing chemistry the first time around, the damage from her ex was too much for her to take him seriously. Rather than try to move forward, she runs away from him at graduation never to be seen again until she gets a second chance at reunion. They have an amazing few days and her guard finally drops around him but she is still stuck in her own head about needing this awful job and pushes away everyone who truly loves her.

I connected so hard to Charolette. She’s a bisexual who truly opened up in college and was finally able to be her true self without small town judgement or her parents expectations. She found her family in her college friends and after an intensive blast from the past being back on campus together she finally realizes people care about her, people love her, and people want her to put herself first. And that’s exactly what she does by the end of the book! I was so proud!

While at times I felt Charolette was too stubborn for her own good, and there were moments that went on for far too long and others went too quickly, it was a nostalgic read. I really loved how much this story dived into trauma, grief, disappointing family members, and true friendship transcending all obstacles. For anyone playing the comparison game, newly graduated, or looking for a tender second chance romance, this one is for you!

This book was a lot. It explored the way someone revisiting their past can improve their livelihood, they just had to go through the trauma of it. Charlie and Reece were undeniably soul mates, just took a bit longer than anticipated.

The real talk about how financial independence is tough growing up without stability was so incredibly real and I had to take a step back because it’s unfortunately a flaw that happens in life.

Truly happy to be able to have been able to read this.

“But How Are You, Really” by Ella Dawson is an engaging exploration of the challenges and complexities of life after college, especially when you’re still finding your way. Charlotte Thorne, our burnt-out bisexual protagonist, is relatable and real, capturing the uncertainty many of us face in our late twenties. Returning to Hein University for her five-year reunion, Charlotte is forced to confront not only her past but also the future she’s been avoiding.

Dawson does a commendable job weaving together themes of identity, mental health, and the messy, beautiful reality of chosen family. The nostalgia of revisiting old college memories, mixed with the stark contrast of present-day struggles, gives this book its emotional depth. The character development, especially Charlotte’s journey, is well-executed and satisfying, making her transformation feel earned by the novel’s end.

While the pacing occasionally drags, and some plot points feel predictable, Dawson’s ability to blend humor with heartfelt moments keeps the story grounded. The reunion setting, filled with both cringe-worthy and heartwarming moments, adds a layer of relatability that will resonate with anyone who’s ever questioned their life choices.

Overall, “But How Are You, Really” is a thoughtful and entertaining read, perfect for those navigating the ups and downs of early adulthood. Dawson’s debut novel is one to check out, especially if you enjoy character-driven stories that delve into the complexities of life, love, and the pursuit of happiness.

Thank you to NetGalley and Penguin Group Dutton for providing this ARC in exchange for an honest review.