Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Thank you to @netgalley and @Stmartinspress for a free copy of this book in exchange for my honest review.

The Pairing by Casey McQuiston is a captivating book that brings the story of Theo and Kit to life with vibrant narration and immersive storytelling. This summer romance, set against the backdrop of a European food and wine tour, is both heartwarming and humorous, making it a delightful listen.

What I Loved:
Character Chemistry: The chemistry between Theo and Kit is palpable, and the narrators do an excellent job of conveying their complex relationship. The playful banter and emotional moments are brought to life in a way that feels authentic and engaging.
Setting and Atmosphere: The audiobook vividly describes the European locales, making you feel as if you’re part of the tour. The sensory details of food, wine, and scenery are beautifully narrated, adding richness to the story.

What Could Be Improved:
Pacing: Similar to the book, the focus on their physical competition can sometimes overshadow the emotional development of their relationship. While it adds to the fun, it occasionally feels repetitive.
Believability: The number of romantic interests they encounter can stretch believability, though it does contribute to the escapist nature of the story.

Overall, The Pairing book is a delightful and immersive experience that will make you laugh, swoon, and crave a European adventure. It’s a perfect pick for fans of queer romance and anyone looking for a story that feels both timeless and modern.

Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐ (4/5)

#books #bookishlife #booklover #readingisfun #iowabookstagrammers #iowabookstagram #netgalley #stmartinspress #ltbreaderteam #thepairing #caseymcquiston #smpinfluencers

Was this review helpful?

One of the most lush, wondrous, and, yes, spicy reads of the summer, THE PAIRING is everything a Casey McQuiston fan could wish for (and more). Kit and Theo had me blushing, swooning, and biting my lip as I toured Europe alongside their magnetic will-they-won't-they, friends-to-lovers-to-enemies-to-lovers pairing. The food-and-wine descriptions were truly scrumptious; foodies everywhere will adore the extensive depictions of Europe's best culinary escapades. Once again, McQuiston proves themselves a true master of their craft, producing yet another romance masterclass that's sure to end up upon many readers' 'best books of the year' list... I sure know it's climbed to the top spot on mine .:)

Was this review helpful?

Theo and Kit were on the way to the vacation of their dreams--a weeks-long European food and wine adventure--when they break up, having to cancel the trip and each receiving a voucher to use for the tour in the future, good for three years. When the exes unknowingly decide to both book the last possible tour before the vouchers expire, they are thrown together for the first time in three years after having not spoken. Once each other's everything--childhood best friends to soulmates--it's almost impossible for them to be in the same room with each other without emotions bubbling to the surface. To keep things light and most definitely platonic between them, Theo suggests a friendly wager on who can sleep with their hot Italian tour guide, and eventually the most Europeans, given the smorgasbord of options for these hot bisexual exes. But through everything, they continue to be drawn back to each other.

This, this felt like classic McQuiston to me. It doesn't have the camp of RW&RB, but it has its wit, banter, historical references, and depth. I'm not sure what kind of research McQuiston did for this book--presumably, extensive--but their descriptions of the food and scenery are absolutely mind-blowing. Every page had me drooling over the pasta, craving the wine, and dying to visit the gorgeous sites. I was lucky enough to actually be reading this on a European cruise, so I did end up seeing some of these fabulous locations (Pisa, Florence, etc.) shortly after reading, which probably made it more impactful. But even setting aside those extras that really gave the book depth, I also just loved Kit and Theo. They felt like soulmates, two ends of one string, who were destined to come back together. Their story was hot and emotional and spicy and beautiful and this was the book I've been waiting for from them.

Thanks to St. Martin's for my eARC! All thoughts and opinions are my own.

5 stars - 10/10

Was this review helpful?

I loved Red, White and Royal Blue, so I was very excited to get an ARC for this one back in the summer. However, I just didn’t love it as much as I thought I would. There were some things that I loved like the travelling aspects and all of the beautiful food and wine descriptions. Plus there were lots of fun side characters, though I did wish they played more of a part through the book. As for Theo and Kit, while I did like them generally, there was just so much miscommunication, and they seemed to be having repetitive conversations throughout. Overall, I struggled to get through this one, but it was an okay read!

Was this review helpful?

The Pairing was a great book to read right as I was leaving on a trip to Europe; it flows through France, Spain, and Italy on a food and wine tour that had me reminiscing about featured places I’ve been to and stoking excitement about places still on my travel goals list. It’s a very sweet second chance romance between two people who are very deeply in love with and obsessed with one another, and I thought the audio was performed very well with the many accents and frequent dialogue in other languages.

I received an eARC of The Pairing from the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review; however, I also purchased a physical copy from myself via Book of the Month and listened to some of it on audiobook from my library.

Was this review helpful?

I will not be giving feedback on this title at this time. Unfortunately, I did not finish this book.

Was this review helpful?

While there was more spice than I was expecting, I really enjoyed this European romance romp. I loved our two main characters and they realize how they've each grown and learned since their breakup. The supporting characters were entertaining as well.
The way the chapters were broken up by city with a drink and food for each was a nice touch. The descriptions of food tour were mouthwatering too!
Love some good bisexual rep and really enjoy Casey's writing once again.

Was this review helpful?

Many thanks to NetGalley and St. Martin's Press for providing me with an eARC of The Pairing in exchange for my honest review!

I've had great times with Red, White & Royal Blue and One Last Stop, so Casey McQuiston's work is definitely the sort of rom-com storytelling that clicks with me. I wouldn't really say The Pairing stands out to me as strongly, but it remains a charismatic and hedonistic ride whose incredible horniness is an element that I enthusiastically support. I have some fun times with Theo and Kit here as they embark on this second-chance romance path—a path that runs through the gorgeous settings of France, Spain, and Italy, all of which are places that I have yet to visit. However, it does feel odd for so much of the emotional growth in the central relationship to take place off-page. Seriously, what's up with that choice? It makes it a challenge for this tale to move me all that deeply. I'm also not wild about how much the plot simply meanders along. We keep hitting all these vacation spots, we keep watching Kit and Theo have a decadent and raunchy blast while working out the issues between them, but these things require a more coherent and well-paced plot structure for me to grab onto.

Overall, I'm officially rating The Pairing 3.25 out of 5 stars, which I'm rounding down to 3 stars. It may not be an outright winner in McQuiston's bibliography, but I still get some enjoyment out of it. I'll continue to await more of their work.

Was this review helpful?

Parts of this book I loved. And then other parts I really did not. Hard to review in this instance. So I will just say, it had potential to be an excellent read and I don't regret reading. Just felt like I wanted something more.

Thanks to NetGalley, St. Martin's Press for an eARC and MacMillan Audio for an ALC in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

The Pairing was perfection.... I was laughing non-stop, felt the chemistry and longing of Theo and Kit, and absolutely loved the travel imagery! Casey McQuinston has done it again and created characters so human and relatable but also fun and outrageous! I am literally already dreaming of this getting made it to a fun rom com romp movie and I NEED it to happen!

Was this review helpful?

The setting, the food and the wine in this book were fabulous. Kit and Theo unexpectedly reunite on a three week tour through Europe four years after they broke up. I really enjoyed the people on the tour with them and who they met in each city.
Not sure what it was, but although I liked Kit and Theo and the ups and downs of their relationship, there was something missing for me.
Thank you to NetGalley and St. Martin’s Griffin for an advanced reader copy in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This book was so intense for me. I was so worried going in realizing how much I have a history of disliking reading spice between a main character with side characters aka not the assigned love interest. And yes I did cry after one of those scenes 😂 this was a weirdly very teary book for me even though it wasn’t coming from a place of relatability, and I’m saying that with respect and neutrality like I’m just simply not similar to these characters in personality or life experiences and honestly I think that made it even more emotional and at times fun for me to read.

This book is true escapism. I loved their travels. There’s a lot of foodie lingo that some went over my head but I got the gist and I was happy for all involved. The scenery and situations were so vivid.

I actually was a fan of the POV switch and when it happened. It was a bold writing choice and it paid off. All in all I just really ended up loving this book! Thank you to SMP for the eARC, I also purchased my own Afterlight version and it’s so gorgeous.

Was this review helpful?

The Pairing not only offers great LGBTQ+ representation, but it's also an engaging read for the senses. The descriptions of the places Kit and Theo visits, the the food they got to try, made me want to take a similar trip. A thing to note though is this is sex / sexy time heavy as well.

Was this review helpful?

I think that it's possible that this is the sexiest book I have ever read. This includes the setting/locations, the characters, the story, and of course the FOOD, OMG. This romance has everything and you won't stop being aroused until the last pages. I haven't stopped thinking about this book since I finished it. I wanted to have sex with everyone in this book, everyone was unbearably hot, especially when they were drinking wine or eating food. This book is a feast for all of your senses and it will satisfy you, I guarantee it.

Was this review helpful?

Reading this felt like going on my own food and drink tour of Europe from my couch. The way Casey wrote this one was just SO atmospheric and immersive. I loved reading the slowly unfolding story of Theo and Kit's past - how they ended up estranged and where that left them. Theo and Kit were SO hot together - even when they were figuring out the emotional side, their physical chemistry was insane. They both had a ton of baggage to work through - but I really enjoyed their journey back to each other. Also, I am crossing my fingers that this one gets an adaptation!

Was this review helpful?

I did not end up finishing this one because I could not get into the story or characters. I have loved McQuiston's other books but this one was not it for me.

Was this review helpful?

Bisexual exes run into each other in Europe four years after breaking up. Amidst the insanely romantic landscapes and delicious food around them, they challenge each other to a little competition to see who can sleep with the most people in Europe. But, ya know, they don’t seem totally over each other either. I had the pleasure of reading an ARC, and oh my god it was so good. It’s a steamy, sexy, delicious romp through Europe with two bisexuals as the main characters. I absolutely devoured it.

Was this review helpful?

Theo and Kit were best friends in childhood, roommates in early adulthood, and romantic partners for two years. They haven’t spoken since they were blown apart by one terrible argument en route to Paris for a trip of a lifetime. Now, almost four years later, they each decide to redeem their re-scheduled trip voucher before the expiration date, not knowing that the other person had the same idea. First, they decide to stick it out and peacefully coexist as they travel together. Later, they set up a “friendly” wager for who can accumulate the most hookups along the way. As they get caught up in the romance of the tour - the food, the wine, the beautiful scenery, and the people - Kit and Theo begin to realize that this trip will bring more than either of them had bargained for.

I had fun with this story. Vacation romance tropes, if handled poorly, can come across as shallow to the reader. The Pairing sidesteps this issue by giving the main characters a robust shared backstory. Theo and Kit’s experiences in the present are deftly interwoven with memories spanning decades of friendship. I wanted to be sitting alongside Theo and Kit, not just for the escapist aspect of a three-week European food and wine tour, but because they were interesting yet flawed characters, each with a chance to tell their side of the story. I’ve written before about how dual-perspective romance novels can struggle with “hiding the mystery”. McQuiston handles this by giving each character 50% of the novel; Theo takes the first half, Kit covers the second. I liked how McQuiston handled the transition from Theo to Kit, but selfishly, I found myself missing Theo in the later chapters; I identified with them more, and it felt like they had more space for growth over the course of the novel.

What kept this from being a 5-star book for me was that I felt it took the escapist aspect a bit too far at times. This international trip likely cost thousands of dollars, given all the high-end food and wine the characters were drinking and the 15 separate stops across four countries. I needed to “turn off my brain” in order to believe Theo and Kit were able to afford such a tour in their early twenties, at the start of their careers. Also, I felt that it was unnecessary for every non-coupled side character to have a conquest of sorts during the novel. While these ancillary characters didn’t *need* to have their own arcs, I would have liked McQuiston to include more room for non-romantic growth in these side characters, for variety’s sake.

I read this book through both ebook and audiobook formats. Since the story takes place during an international tour, there were a lot of accents the narrators had to contend with, basically from the beginning: American English, London English, Scandinavian, Irish, Italian, French, and Australian, all within the first few chapters. The narrators seem to take it in stride. Emma Galvin’s tomboyish, gruff voice makes Theo instantly endearing. I rooted for them from the start. As a result, Max Meyers had big boots to fill, and he did reasonably well. His lighter, more musical timbre lends credibility to the sensitivity of Kit’s character. I think the book would be equally enjoyable in print or in audio.

This novel was advertised as “hot bisexual summer”, and I figured I was in for some surface-level, spicy fun. I’m pleased to say this book goes beyond that. In The Pairing, the connection between the two main characters felt more genuine than many of the hetero romance novels I’ve read recently, and that’s no bad thing. I think any fan of contemporary fiction wanting to dip a toe into queer romance will find The Pairing a great entry point to the genre. This was my first foray into Casey McQuiston’s work, but it won’t be my last.

**Many thanks to NetGalley, Casey McQuiston, St. Martin’s Press, and Macmillan Audio for the e-ARCs in exchange for an honest review.**

Was this review helpful?

This was a great summer read. It made me want to travel. I thought the characters and I were besties. That’s how good Casey McQuiston writes character's. As always super diverse writing!

Was this review helpful?

I just… want to believe mcquiston is more than a one hit wonder but haven’t seen any evidence of it yet, I loved her first book SO much and the rest have been meh, at best. This one included, perhaps I won’t bother with the next one,

Was this review helpful?