Skip to main content

Member Reviews

This was cute and a bit sexy, with well fleshed out characters and enough of a mystery to it that it kept me reading. I do wish there had been more concrete answers on why Aiden was the only ghost Cara ever encountered or why only Cara could hear him, but it worked.

Was this review helpful?

Typical teen romance of boy’s ghost who is trying to set his sister up and see her happy. Lots of the same old dishonesty leading to a break up because who is going to believe that your dead brother is the matchmaking type. It’s an okay story but there were a lot of stereotypes and not a lot of people stepping out of their comfort zones.

Was this review helpful?

I loved this book at the beginning and end. Cara, the protagonist, has some serious growing pains during the third act, and it was painful to read. The concept of The Ghost of Us is unique and the characters were interesting and diverse. The quippy writing felt very Whedon and it was fun!

Was this review helpful?

This sapphic YA romance was a ride! I thoroughly enjoyed (and laughed) throughout Cara and Aiden's interactions. It felt like real and valid conversations teens of their age would discuss. I could have read a whole book of just them talking! I adored Cara's parents and how they embraced who they are (oddballs who love each other immensely). Cara's best friend Meredith was also well done. While Meredith was religious she still supported Cara and her ghostly YouTube channel and did her best to keep Cara involved. Cara's behavior when it came to Meredith and her beliefs is where I got stuck. Cara's personality could be selfish, and very self-centered, and I know most teens are and can be that way, her actions felt over the top a lot. I honestly cheered for Meredith in the end and how she handled Cara.

The fake dating/romancing of Aidan's sister was awkward and cringe worthy---which was perfect! No one's first dates and interactions are going to be a dream. Embarrassing things happen and are said. I loved this about their budding relationship. The end got me a little teary and I wasn't expecting that but I really got attached to Aidan. He was definitely my favorite character.

Readers looking for a fun YA sapphic romance can enjoy this one while also enjoying moments including rock climbing, promposals, friendship, grief, and self-discovery.

Was this review helpful?

A DNF unfortunately with potential for me to go back and finish the story. I would love to say more but I am withholding my review until St Martins Press meets the demands of the ongoing boycott.

As of August 27th R4A has determined that the demands of the boycott have been met so Im not able to share why this was a DNF for me. Since reading this Ive decided I don't think ill come back and finish it. I liked Meredith a lot and the whole concept for the story but those were the only things I liked about it unfortunately. I hated the writing, it was very out of pocket sometimes and it felt like an adult trying to write how teenagers would talk and it just did not work. Sometimes it was funny and worked well but others it just felt very ick and was kind of jarring to read. And Cara just seems very selfish and for her own gain and upon reading others reviews neither of these issues seem to get better as the story goes on so unfortunately it was a DNF. I think it would have been better had Meredith been given a POV and some of the writing and jokes were edited maybe. Regardless thank you to Netgalley and the publishers for the opportunity to read an ARC of this!

Was this review helpful?

If, like me, you are a sucker for good comedy about grief, I highly recommend* The Ghost of Us. It’s equal parts hilarious, haunting, and heartbreaking. (*if you can handle liberal sprinklings of profanity and scenes of teen sexuality.)

Due to a social media debacle in 8th grade, Cara Weaver is deeply unpopular in her high school and can’t wait to graduate and leave the town of Stossel behind. Rejected by all the colleges she applied to, she’s throwing everything into becoming internet famous as a ghosthunter. When the ghost of Aiden Reyes, a boy who died in a terrible accident the year before, starts talking to her, she thinks she’s on her way. But Aiden will only work with her if she takes his sister to prom. She agrees, but she isn’t prepared for the force of nature that is Meredith.

I loved this book from start to finish. The teens come across as authentic—snarky and confident one minute, unsure and needy the next. They’ve all been hurt, so their guard is up, yet they long for real connection. They take care of each other, let each other down, and try to do better. The book hits a lot of expected rom-com beats, but it’s wacky enough to feel fresh. I really appreciated that being queer for these kids is just an ordinary part of growing up. Their coming-out stories are in the past; now they’re trying to live their lives and get to the next thing. Sweet Christian girl Holly is not the villain, but Cara’s best friend. Ghost Aiden is still the dudebro he was in life, but he’s also a loving brother who has to make sure his sister is okay before he moves on. Overall, a delightful read.

Was this review helpful?

3.5 stars. This was a cute YA story of a girl named Cara who is trying to launch her career as a ghost hunter. She winds up going to a place where a senior has passed way prior. Aiden somehow can connect with Cara from the beyond and she is the only one who can hear him. She is trying to prove he is real and he has one condition to get his sister to prom.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley and Andersen Press for this ARC in exchange for my honest review.

The cover is so so stunning, and I was really exited with the premise but the story fell flat for me. It was super sweet, but overall had the tone of a man writing a book about lesbians, with super out of date slang and terminology.

The romance is also very oversexualized, which is not something that i was expecting and threw me off guard. I

Was this review helpful?

James L. Sutter’s “The Ghost of Us” presents an intriguing blend of supernatural intrigue and teenage romance. The premise is promising, with an engaging mix of ghostly elements and high school drama. The dynamic between Cara and Aiden adds an interesting twist to the usual ghost story. Cara’s journey, guided by Aiden’s ghostly advice, evolves into a heartfelt exploration of self-worth and connection. However, the execution of these themes sometimes falters. Cara’s transformation from a driven ghost hunter to a conflicted romantic feels a bit rushed, and Meredith’s initial characterization as a troubled recluse can come off as clichéd. The resolution presents a satisfying conclusion but may leave readers wanting more in terms of character development and emotional payoff. Overall, “The Ghost of Us” is an enjoyable read with a creative premise, though it occasionally struggles with pacing.

Was this review helpful?

I received a free copy of this book thanks to NetGalley and St. Martin's Press; all opinions expressed are exclusively my own.

I almost entirely enjoyed this story, except the sheer vast looming dread I experienced almost the entire time I was reading it. It's a dramatic high school sapphic fantasy romance, but the drama is HEAVY and there are some very difficult to relate with character choices. That said, I enjoyed the characters and the way they interacted outside of the drama, and I would consider reading more works by this author.

For sensitive readers there are depictions of bullying, death, PTSD, depression, misogyny, sexuality, non-consensual voyeurism, neglect, and betrayal.

Was this review helpful?

I just want to start this by saying that if I knew this was a sapphic novel written by a man, I probably wouldn't have requested this on NetGalley. It was my fault for not looking deeper into this, considering it is in the synopsis, but I don't like to know too much about books before I start them.

The concept of this was super interesting to me; a ghost hunter finds a ghost and he plays matchmaker for her. But that's more or less where my enjoyment of this book ended. The way the characters talked was just so cringe, it felt like the author had never talked to a teenager before and was using lingo that he saw on the internet to make them more "realistic". The "douche nozzle (flirty)" really sent me over the edge. I think I will always have a problem with women written by men, and the queer women written by men is just a given.

I was interested enough to finish the book so I guess that's good but I really did not have a good time. I tried remove myself from the discomfort of someone writing a queer romance in a relationship they've never or ever will be a part of but every time the main character and the love interest flirted, it was hard to not think about it. Every time the main character thought or talked about the love interest, it felt like a teenage boy lusting over the hottest girl in the world. The romance wasn't about how much she liked this girl.... it was about how much she wanted to get with her. And don't get me started on the "I'm a ghost and I think if I get my sister laid I'll move on to the afterlife!"

This author does have a MLM book that seems interesting enough but I probably won't read anything else by this author. But I will give him props for adding "douche nozzle (flirty)" to my vocabulary.

Was this review helpful?

In general, I liked the plot of this one. The main character Cara was flawed (in good ways and bad), I really enjoyed Aiden in her head, and aspects of the romance were pretty sweet. There were several parts, though, that made me not enjoy it so much. The aforementioned bad flaws of Cara's (she was pretty self-pitying and selfish for too long, imo) and the catfishy way the romance happened. Not a fan. Also, I don't know if it was because it was a male author or what, but some of the descriptions were just uncomfortable.

Was this review helpful?

Cara, an 18-year-old ghost hunter, encounters the spirit of Aiden, who died the previous year. Aiden wants to ensure his little sister, Meredith, is okay before he can move on. He strikes a deal with Cara: help him woo Meredith, and he’ll provide proof of the supernatural. As Cara gets closer to Meredith, she faces a dilemma: continue dating her under false pretenses or risk losing her shot at proving ghosts are real. 🌟
This captivating YA novel blends romance, paranormal elements, and LGBTQ+ themes. If you enjoy swoony romance with a supernatural twist, give it a read!

Was this review helpful?

James Sutter is an automatic read for me. His writing is consistently engaging and emotive and his characters are always so real and relatable! I greatly enjoyed the little easter eggs sprinkled in these pages from his other novel, Darkhearts, and I adored the characters in this book. I’ll be thinking about this one a long time!

Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for an advanced copy of this book. Opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

The Ghost of Us feels reminiscent of a chick flick that I read in one sitting. The plot, while familiar, is engaging and filled with emotional highs and lows, with moments of humor that keep the story lively.

The main cast includes an overprotective dead brother, a bullied queer outcast whose life isn’t going as she hoped, a beloved best friend, and the younger sister who serves as the love interest but struggles with social interactions.

The characters are well-developed, each bringing their own quirks and complexities to the narrative as they navigate love, loss, and friendship. The tone was crafted to resonate with the target age group, addressing themes such as bullying, coming out as queer, teen awkwardness, social hierarchy, and various types of relationships, while also incorporating some spicy elements that will engage the audience.

The Ghost of Us is an entertaining read that I would recommend to anyone seeking a contemporary sapphic novel for teens, reminiscent of a chick flick.

I was given a copy of the book through Wednesday Books, and I give my honest review voluntarily. My review is my own thoughts and opinion; my experience in reading this story.

Content Guide: sibling loss, grief, bullying, sex, smoking

Was this review helpful?

I really loved this book!
The book has 3 main characters. Cara likes to investigate places that are supposedly haunted and posts the videos to her podcast. Aiden is the ghost that only Cara and can see and communicate with. Cara had just investigated the place when Aiden died and later that evening Aiden started communicating with her. Meredith is Aiden's sister who has becoming very depressed and totally isolated after blaming herself for Aiden's death. Aiden has a plan to help Meredith. Cara will get his sister to agree to go to Prom with her and Aiden will give Cara all the evidence she needs for her podcast.
Sounds easy, but when feelings start to get involved, things do not go as planned.
I would recommend.
I received an ARC from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review,

Was this review helpful?

As much as I'm not a fan of the "dating bets" trope, this book actually does it well! I was screaming at the main character the entire time LOL! I was invested right away.

Was this review helpful?

"Other people weren't the problem.⠀

Other people were the point."⠀

James L. Sutter, The Ghost of Us⠀


The Ghost of Us by James L. Sutter is a poignant YA story with a supernatural twist. Cara is an outcast who wants to be a famous ghost hunter. When she goes searching for proof of supernatural activities she meets Aiden, the ghost of a popular kid from her highschool. They decide to work together so that Cara can prove ghosts exist and Aiden can help his sister, Meredith, and move on. ⠀

I liked Cara and Aiden well enough, but my favorite characters were Holly and Meredith. Holly is the best kind of person. She has a gentle heart and loves her people fiercely, even when they're acting a fool. Meredith is deep and artistic. She feels her brother's loss intensely but she also seems to have a hope and drive for the future. I like how open she is to new experience and living life despite her depression. ⠀

The witty dialogue is something I've come to love from James P. Sutter and I thought the mention of the band Darkhearts was clever. His accuracy when writing about teenage angst and the modern queer experience is on point and his characters are so easy to root for!⠀

I would recommend this book to anyone who likes YA fiction or Romcoms with a spooky twist.⠀

Was this review helpful?

This was a unique and captivating read that skillfully blends elements of supernatural mystery with relatable character development and queer joy. The premise was intriguing and I adored the supporting characters. Overall, the story was well paced, though at times the character interactions felt slightly contrived.

Sincere thanks to NetGalley, St. Martin's Press, & Wednesday Books for an advanced reader copy in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

The Ghosts of Us is fast and fun. Full of unique plot points like a bisexual highschooler’s ghost-hunting YouTube page, an affirming Uber-religious best friend, a tragic teen death, rock-climbing, prepper-parents, homeschooling… it doesn’t seem like any of this story should fit from chapter to chapter but it flowed so perfectly which made it almost un-put-down-able.
I hate when a quick bit of communication could solve almost every problem, then I remind myself these are teenagers in a paranormal YA romcom and I let their immaturity slide.
The ghost was probably my favorite character- he was hilarious. The overall theses in this book is genuinely kind heartbreaking including grief and bullying, but it’s all balanced with banter-filled dialogue and the buildup to prom. The romance developed naturally and was very sweet as well. Our main girl is kind of a selfish jerk for a lot of the book, but she’s got her demons to battle, so it all makes sense overall.
Definitely recommend this one!

Was this review helpful?