I loved it! Rebecca does an amazing job. I loved that while reading, I can clearly picture everything. Highly recommend

What an incredible take on the Gatsby story. In all honesty, I was the kid that sparknoted the book in high school because I was never a fan of the classics, give me the fantasy and romance! I loved this book! It took a boring classic from high school and turned it into a fun and imaginative modern take.
I loved the paranormal aspects in this book, and how it was woven in. She had a great family, honesty, and a supportive partner willing to listen and take time despite waiting years for her (swoooon)! My favorite part? I live in Upstate, SC and never thought I’d say the Gaffney Mall mentioned in a book, how fun is that. I can’t wait to share with my book club upon release! I love Rebecca Kenney’s work, and this one does not disappoint!

I thought this was a good book originally and I really got into it until Gratsys paranormal secret came out. I just thought the original story wasn’t the best. That part kind of ruined the rest of the book for me.

So I like the beginning of the book, but I didn’t read most of the plot of the book to know that it was a vampire book. It really caught me off guard just because I’m not really a fan of vampire books, but knowing that Jay Gatsby the guy that the girl was wondering if he was the same guy in the beginning of the book ended up being the same guy he ended up being a vampire. I wish that the plot wasn’t about him being a vampire and that’s how he got so wealthy I wish it was a different turn to the story. I didn’t like some of the stuff that was going on and how he had these vampire parties so that the vampires won’t go and hurt people . It kind of dragged on the story for me so I didn’t find it really interesting I read the whole book though the ending was pretty good, but is it a story for me? No.

There is a lot of spice in this book so if you are looking for a romance book with spice, this is it.

This was an okay read for me and it didn't really capture my attention until about halfway through the book. After the halfway point and everything was on the table for both Daisy and Jay, the story moves nicely along with the fight scene between gen 1 and gen 2 vampires being the highlight of the book for me. For the most part, I like Daisy and her gift, although I find her to be somewhat annoying but maybe it's because she reminds me of a micro-manager or a helicopter mom. Personally, that type of personality is a turn off both in the real world and fictional world, I supposed. Just leave the people be, Daisy and mind your own business, is what I would like to tell her. Again, it's mostly a personality clash between hers and mine (I'm not the most motherly or inquisitive of creature who worry about other people). I do love Jay's personality in the book though.

The spice scenes were enjoyable to read, starting with the VR room scene. I thought that was a really cool concept and the chemistry between Daisy and Jay is undeniable. Overall, a decent read but not a memorable one for me.

Thank you NetGalley and Sourcebooks Casablanca for providing me with this ARC in exchange for my review.

Thank you SourceBooks & Rebecca Kenney for the eARC of Beautiful Villain in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.

Let me start by saying that I did not think this book was bad. I should disclose that I had forgotten how much I loathe the characters from The Great Gatsby (I know that’s part of the point of the original novel). However, I felt there should have been a bit more character building off of the originals. The love story between Gatsby & Daisy felt a little rushed in my opinion. I did think that the paranormal aspects of Beautiful Villain translated well from the original themes from TGG.

Some highlights

⭐️Fast moving plot, easy to read

⭐️Paranormal contemporary romance: sirens, vampires

⭐️Childhood friends to lovers trope

However, if you are a diehard TGG fan and looking for something fun, I do recommend this spicy paranormal contemporary retelling.

And yes…since you asked, there’s spice. And it comes out of nowhere so beware!🤗

3.25 ⭐️

Thank you to Source Books Casablanca, Netgalley, and the author for allowing me access to this book as an ARC in exchange for an honest review.

« You know I’m straight. And you also know I’m yours. Helplessly, devotedly yours. » « You sound like a book again. »


Rating: 3 ⭐️
Genre: Paranormal romance
Format: ARC Ebook
Pages: -
Spice: 1 🌶️
POV: Double first POV
S/S: Gilded Monsters #1
Check trigger warnings for any book

I was extremely hyped when I heard about this book! I think I might have hyped it up a bit too much unfortunately.

I enjoyed the story overall. I liked that the Gatsby aspect wasn’t overwhelming, just in our face « See this is a Gatsby-inspired romance ». It was nicely dosed throughout the novel.

Both characters when enjoyable, although I would have loved a bit more depth overall. Especially from the side characters.

Would have loved a bit more lore in general. I do get that we’re discovering the paranormal world in this book, but there wasn’t much research or wonder on why things were the way they are.

The enemies were nicely done, they made sense in the story. I loved Daisy’s healing journey and her accepting her past choices in a way.

Favorite quotes (MIGHT CONTAIN SPOILERS):

« No one warns you how much it hurts when the people you studied with, ate with, and partied with for four years are just - gone. »

« Nick, my long-legged, blue-eyed cousin, lounges at the foot of my bed, sporting a pale-pink BTS shirt and vintage acid-wash jeans. » BTS YOU SAY?? SLAYYY

« I’m Daisy Finnegan, and I can get my own freaking drink. »

« Great… just when I need a clear head, my freaking libido has get involved. »

« I’m Daisy Finnegan, and I’m a fucking delight. »

« I haven’t forgotten that I’m frustrated with him, that I need answers. But my pussy doesn’t care about any of that, traitorous little fucked that it is. »

« Speaking of creepy, is there a noncreepy way to be obsessed with someone? »

« I’m trying to be the romance novel hero, remember? Everything a girl wants. »

« What is he, a vampire? » « Somebody’s been watching too many teen TV shows. »

« Did he just fucking growl? And did my pussy just quiver at the sound? »

« You have my permission, Gatsby. You may ravish my cousin. »

« Jay Gatsby - my Gatsby - is a vampire. Holy freaking hell. »

« A vampire, but not a murderer. A monster, but not cruel. »

« Misbehave, babies. Make me proud. »

Leena - Leena.reader review - @leena.reader on tiktok and instagram

I normally really like this author’s work, but right off the bat this one fell flat for me. Normally I’m immediately drawn into Kenney’s works from the first page. The pop culture references were too frequent and unnecessary. The characters didn’t really interest me.

Overall, I found the concept of a supernatural Great Gatsby retelling interesting. And I definitely see how this could be appealing for others, but unfortunately, it is not for me.

Unofficial Synopsis:

Years after his disappearance, Jay Gatsby returns, but with a darker aura. Daisy Finnegan looks forward to carefree summer days until her cousin vanishes at a lavish party hosted by none other than Gatsby himself. As Daisy delves into the world of wealth and deception, she uncovers Gatsby's sinister secret: immortality. With danger looming and her powers untested, Daisy faces a crucial decision: stand by Gatsby or fight against the darkness threatening them all. This spicy New Adult retelling of The Great Gatsby adds a magical twist to the classic tale.

Review:

Books without likable characters can be some of my favorites because usually I start to look for nuances within the characters that I am drawn to, anything that I like really, but I struggled with these characters. I really didn’t like them at all. As a result of not liking them, I had no vested interest in what they did or didn’t do, or how things worked out for them. I also felt that this book tried too hard to push social norms such as TikTok and YouTube, it got annoying fast. I do think that there were elements that worked such as the undeniable allure and tension that is strung throughout the story, but that can only carry a reader so far.

I think that after reading the synopsis and what this book was supposed to be about, my expectations created one reality, and this book was the other, and they weren’t the same, so it was a case of mismatched realities. That’s not to say this is a bad book, it’s a perfectly enjoyable read, and I think that for the right reader they will really enjoy it.

Wow. This is a wonderful book. It just grabbed me right in. I loved the great gapsy and I love vampires and this was the chef’s kiss

What a ride! Readers of the original Great Gatsby will be riveted as they turn the pages of this twisty novel.

What if Jay Gatsby and Daisy met in modern times? And what if Gatsby was a vampire…? That’s this book. And it was so much fun!

Short Synopsis:
Jay Gatsby and Daisy were childhood best friends. But after Daisy’s family moved away, she didn’t hear from him until 8 years later. Now, Daisy is getting over a broken heart from her cheating ex, Tom. And she goes to lavish party with her cousin Nick. And finds Gatsby is the host. Sound familiar? But it’s modern day and Gatsby is a vampire. And so much fun.

My Thoughts:
The Great Gatsby is my all-time favorite classic. As you can see, my copy is well loved. The author nailed the characters and their personalities so, so well. Gatsby is still the desperately in love jealous rich man. Daisy isn’t as selfish in this book, but still the aloof party girl. Add in some vampires and it’s just an all around a good time.

Read if You Like:
💎 The Great Gatsby
💎 Vampires
💎 Retellings
💎 Villain romances
💎 Friends to lovers

"Beautiful Villains" takes readers on a tantalizing journey through a paranormal twist on "The Great Gatsby." As a fan of steamy romance with a hint of the supernatural, I found myself intrigued by the premise and the reimagining of familiar characters.

However, while the novel provided an enjoyable escape into fantasy, it fell short of capturing my full attention. Despite its promising elements, I couldn't shake the feeling that something was missing. The plot felt somewhat predictable, and I wished for more depth in both the characters and their relationships.

That said, Rebecca Kenney's writing style is engaging, and there were moments of undeniable allure and tension throughout the story. For me, "Beautiful Villains" earns a three-star rating—it's a decent read that offers entertainment but lacks the spark to truly ignite my enthusiasm.

Overall, if you're in the mood for a paranormal romance with a nod to a classic tale, "Beautiful Villains" might just fit the bill.

I had high expectations for this book and thought the combination of the paranormal and the great Gatsby would be a great read. The references to certain ideologies in the first 50 pages was a little odd, it felt like it was just thrown into the book and it wasn’t really needed. Usually I can overlook this if the storyline is effective in moving the plot forward, but after page 80 it failed to capture my attention. I was hoping for a little bit more, the story and characters felt disconnected with two ideas just thrown together. Personally, I like when the authors torture the characters, give them a little bit of struggle, this just seemed too easy. The mystery and excitement just wasn’t there for me. Great potential just fell short.

So I have some mixed feelings about this one. So let’s start with the things I didn’t necessarily love.
Right off the bat the amount of pop culture references weren’t the vibe for me. I can handle some here and there but there was so much thrown in regarding famous musicians, social media etc. Then our main character Daisy… I found her a little frustrating. I hate when characters think one thing but then constantly do the complete opposite. Like how she wanted to get the truth about Jay then next thing you know she’s grinding up on him.

Some things I liked
I really enjoyed the writing style and how immersive everything was. Scenes were so vivid and descriptive. Then what is shows about Daisy and Tom’s relationship, I obviously don’t love an abusive relationship but I like how she didn’t shy away from the ugly parts of a relationship that some people sadly go through.

I feel like “Great Gatsby” retelling was executed well I just didn’t necessarily love how other aspects tied in.

When I heard that Rebecca Kenney had written a paranormal retelling of The Great Gatsby, it felt like time had stopped and I heard somebody screaming 'Hallelujah'—later, I realized I was the one screaming, and my writing partner responded with a quick 'shut up,' as usual.

The idea left me exhilarated, but upon finishing the book, I found myself making noises like 'hmm,' 'I don’t know,' and 'well, really.' My expectations had been sky-high, given how much I adored the author's previous works, but unfortunately, this one didn't quite hit the mark for me. Perhaps the vampire concept applied to this classic novel was a bit over the top, and I couldn't help but notice some flaws in the dialogues and rushed steamy scenes, lacking sufficient emotional development between the characters. While I could engage with Daisy, Jay Gatsby left me feeling irritated. Despite my usual enjoyment of alpha males and vampires, I found him too possessive, power-hungry, immature, manipulative, and insincere about his motivations concerning Daisy, which made it difficult for me to truly believe in their love story.

The plot centers around Daisy Finnegan, who recently broke up with her cheating boyfriend Tom and is embracing her newfound freedom, encouraged by her parents to break free from her secluded life and seek joy. This leads her to attend a party at a mansion with her friends, where she discovers that the fabulous mansion’s owner and charismatic host is none other than her childhood lover, the one who got away—Jay Gatsby.

Upon facing him, she realizes the attraction still lingers, and she finds herself drawn into his dangerous world, entangled in a web of enormous wealth, lies, secrets, and escalating violence. When she learns his secret identity and the source of his power and wealth, she realizes that not only her own life but also the lives of her loved ones are in more danger than they could have imagined. She must decide whether to surrender to a man who demands more than her heart or lose him forever.

Overall, it was a steamy and riveting paranormal romance, though not quite superior in my opinion. Still, it provided an enjoyable escape into fantasy, earning a three-star rating from me. While it didn't quite live up to the author's previous works for me, it remains an interesting and enjoyable read, particularly for fans of the genre.

Many thanks to NetGalley and Sourcebooks Casablanca for providing me with this digital review copy in exchange for my honest opinions.

Beautiful Villain by Rebecca Kenney is a Great Gatsby retelling with vampires that grabbed my attention as a traditionally published book by an author I had already been adoring the independently published books by so I sort of already knew I was going to love it , but never could I have predicted just how much I would love it.

What I loved
1. Writing style: Rebecca Kenny writes in a lovely and descriptive tone while keeping the work approachable and not overly verbose.
2. Daisy as a character is so much better fleshed out in this retelling.
3. University age characters allow for an almost coming of age feel for Daisy while also allowing her to be an adult that has the freedom and agency to navigate the story as she does.
4.Second chance romance trope is my cup of tea and is excellently handled
What didn't work as well for me
1. intimate scenes near the end of the work were a little too close together and would have benefited from either one of them being relocated in the story or a bit of breathing space being put between them.
2. There a few toxic relationship traits and discussions portrayed in the book that just hit a little close to some personal experiences.
Who I would recommend this title for
Beautiful Villain will be an excellent read for existing fans of the author as well as a wonderful entry point for those seeking fantastical retellings with more than just a dash of spice.

Thanks to Sourcebooks Casablanca for the ARC!

It's actually kind of crazy how seamlessly The Great Gatsby and vampires go together - or maybe it's just Rebecca Kenney's expert writing?! I am always a fan of a retelling, and really enjoyed how this book flowed. Daisy and Gatsby were easy to cheer for, the side characters were amazing, and there was a lot of action throughout the book. This is perfect if you've liked A Court of Thorns and Roses, The Cruel Prince, or Beautiful Little Fools, but you also like magic.

Also - this is being marketed for "fans of Katee Robert" and honestly, her spice level is too high for me, but I think the comparison is more for the retelling similarities than the high spice. Just wanted to mention in case you are also like me :)

Another terrific story by Rebecca! Love her writing style, and she is the queen of a Retelling. Gatsby meets vampires. I love a good fang story and I was hooked! Definitely give this Retelling a whirl for spice and plot that will have you flipping pages until the end!

There were some typos I caught but that's to be expected with any ARC and I'm sure they'll be fixed by launch. That wasn't why I took off a star, it was the feel of the story that felt dissatisfying for me which was the villain for the last 30% of the book. I won't spoil it for people, but I'm just not the right reader for easy villains, I like complications and the story felt too young, despite the spice scenes, and part of that was the parties and part of it was Daisy being a character I just didn't vibe with. Daisy was great in terms of self awareness, and caring about those around her, but I feel like a part of me was a bit bored with this book. Not a knock on the author, I think I might have just not been the right reader for this particular retelling. I Love Rebecca's writing and she has definitely created a fan in me. I will always get excited to read a new book from her! Definitely give her books a try, her creativity is off the charts.

There is on-page death, controlling/abusive ex, blood play in sex (duh vampires)

In a modern retelling of The Great Gatsby, we see Daisy excited for summer and living with her parents again. She gets invited to a party, a beginning to a love she’d thought she’d lost, a web of darkness and secrets she could’ve never imagined. Can her love shared with Gatsby prevail through these secrets and the danger that comes alongside them?

I want to start of by saying the cover is stunning! I love the green and gold touches, it’s perfect. I really enjoyed this retelling. I found the way that the author tied in scenes and themes from the original to be quite clever. I found myself smirking at a few parts knowingly too.

I enjoyed how Daisy was able to grow through all the trauma of her past and allow herself to trust and see past the flaws of the man she loves. Their story kept me up all night reading! Plus, Gatsby as a vampire was perfect.

I felt Nick’s portrayal was exactly as I’d imagined him to actually be in the original too, it gave me closure somehow to his character!

If you enjoy a fantastic retelling, childhood friends to lovers, mysterious abilities and a good spicy vampire romance with some stakes, I highly recommend this book!

Thank you NetGalley and Sourcebooks Casablanca for the chance to read this incredible book!