This cozy debut is okay for me. I think the plotting is strong, and that's what I usually lean into the most. And that works here. But so many of the characters are unlikeable, I just didn't enjoy spending that much time with them. I like the main character, but she's about it! The cussing doesn't bother me at all, but I do agree with others who've said this book might be missing too much of the "cozy" aspect of cozies. I'm not looking for Hallmark Movie stories! But there doesn't seem to be much of a cast of appealing regular characters to get to know. It feels a bit like a book caught between different subgenres of the mystery genre, so that might make it hard for the book to find its people. I hope it does, since the plotting feels strong, but I'm not sure I'd spend more time in Hummingbird Hollow.

Review copy provided by the publisher via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.

I received a free copy of, Murder on Devil's Pond, by Ayla Rose, from the publisher and Netgalley in exchange for an honest review. This book is part of A Hummingbird Hollow B&B Mystery series. Hannah moves back home to help her sister Reggie with the inn they own together. When a senior citizen is murdered Hannah has a mystery to solve. This book had a lot of twists and turns, it kept me guessing until the end. A good mystery.

I liked the idea of a bed and breakfast series. Hannah, the protagonist, is a likeable character, despite all the turmoil going on around her. I didn’t care as much for her sister, Reggie, who has a sterner personality. I never could find much sympathy for the victim’s family—they each had their own agendas. The story is led by the murder mystery, so the characters aren’t that deeply cored out. The mystery is very good; yet, to me it had a darker tone than most cozies. The murderer killed too violently for my taste. Pet lovers will enjoy Moose, the dog, and Turnip, the cat.

I honestly reviewed an unedited digital arc provided by NetGalley and Crooked Lane Books. All opinions are my own.

I received a free copy from the publisher through Netgalley and voluntarily reviewed it.

I like cozy mysteries, so I always keep an eye out for those in Netgalley and the fact the owner runs an inn caught my attention for this one. While I had expected the inn to be one of the things I would enjoy most about this book, I actually ended up enjoying the mystery the most. The rest of the elements fell flat for me, but the mystery was a solid one and was what kept me reading.

Let's talk about the mystery first. I thought this book had a really well written mystery. The focus strongly is on the mystery and way less on the daily life events, and most of those still tie back to the mystery in some way. When Hannah's 80 year old friend Ezra is murdered she gets involved trying to solve his murder. There are three of Ezra's cousins staying at her inn who are all suspects, but the more she digs into the murder and Ezra's life the more she uncovers. The mystery kept me reading and I was curious to find out who had killed Ezra and why.

Hannah keeps uncovering new pieces of information about Ezra's life, his past and those around him. Multiple strange events have happened and I like how Hannah digs deep into everything and slowly uncovers more piece by piece. I thought the mystery ended up being quite sad in a way, not only how Hannah lost a friend, but also some of Ezra's past that comes to light. It did make for an engaging mystery and I was coming up with the weirdest theories about who the murderer was and why they killed Ezra. I thought the actual reveal was a bit of a disappointment as I had expected something different.

Besides the mystery this book fell a bit flat to me. While I liked Hannah's dedication and determination in finding who killed Ezra, I felt like I didn't really get to know her as well as I wanted. There's the work she did with the inn and her passion for gardening, but besides that there isn't much.

The side characters weren't really likeable or interesting, they were mostly there to fulfill a role in the story and a lot of them felt very manipulative and only out for their own gain. It sure gave a lot of them motive for murder, but it didn't make for a very enjoyable read. I liked how Reggie, Hannah's sister, becomes a bit warmer to her toward the end of the book, but for most of the book I didn't really like her either or her relationship with Hannah. There is a hint of romance and even almost a love triangle, but neither gets a lot of attention so it's hard to even call it that. There's a not quite date, one kiss and then at the end Hannah seems to pick one of the guys and agrees on a date with him. So maybe there will be more romance in the next book.

I also thought this book kinda missed the cozy vibe, with so many unlikable or even manipulative side characters and not a lot of focus on the small town vibe, it just didn't have that cozy vibe I look for in a cozy mystery. This didn't feel like a cozy town, but one with lots of secrets and people out for their own interest. I also had hoped for more about the inn Hannah runs, but there really is only the basics and the inn felt more like a plot device for Hannah to talk to the cousins as they were staying at her inn.

To summarize: Murder on Devil's Pond had a well written mystery, but that was the only thing that kept me reading. The book didn't have that cozy vibe I expected and there wasn't as much about Hannah's job at the inn. Most of the side characters weren't really likable or interesting and a bunch of them come across as manipulative and out for their own gain. I liked Hannah's dedication and determination in solving the mystery, but felt I didn't really get to know much about her besides that and her passion for sustainable gardening. The mystery was a good one though, it kept me reading and I was curious to find out what had happened. There is a lot of secrets and facts about Ezra's past that Hannah uncovers during her investigation. I was coming up with the wildest theories about who the murderer was and the actual reveal was a bit disappointing as it wasn't what I had expected at all. This book has an engaging mystery, but fell flat where it came to the characters, theme and cozy vibe.

In this captivating read, the author masterfully weaves a narrative that is both engaging and thought-provoking. Through a blend of richly developed characters and a meticulously crafted plot, the book offers a unique exploration of its central themes, inviting readers to immerse themselves in the story's depth and complexity. The narrative is paced perfectly, balancing moments of intense action with thoughtful reflection, ensuring that readers are hooked from the first page to the last. The author's ability to evoke emotion and create a vivid, immersive world is truly remarkable, making this book a must-read for anyone looking for an exceptional literary experience.

Beyond its compelling storyline, the book stands out for its insightful commentary on the human condition, weaving philosophical questions into the fabric of its narrative. The author's skillful use of language not only enriches the text but also elevates the reader's experience, offering new perspectives on familiar themes. Whether it's the intricate dynamics of relationships, the exploration of identity, or the confrontation with ethical dilemmas, this book tackles complex issues with sensitivity and intelligence. It's a testament to the power of storytelling to illuminate the nuances of life, making it a valuable addition to any book lover's collection. Regardless of genre, this is a work that resonates on multiple levels, affirming the enduring impact of well-crafted literature.

I WILL UPLOAD THIS TO MY INSTAGRAM CLOSER TO PUB. DATE

I gave Murder on Devil's Pond by Ayla Rose 4.5 stars

When 33-year-old Hannah Solace returns to her hometown to renovate and reopen the inn she co-owns with her sister Reggie, her mission is to give the old Victorian hotel an entirely new life. She’s even planting pollinator gardens around the inn–native flowers and fruit trees to lure honeybees and houseguests alike. Hannah’s fresh start is stymied by Reggie’s continual interference, unreliable contractors, a check-the-couch-for-coins budget, and townspeople Hannah left behind fifteen years ago. Her main source of camaraderie is Ezra Grayson, an 80-year-old recluse who lives nearby. After an unsettling conversation with a disgruntled Ezra, Hannah is horrified to discover him dead on her property later that day. Ezra had always had plenty of people to complain about, especially locals trying to force him out of his property for its prime real estate. Hannah starts digging and quickly discovers that secrets lurk beneath the charming surface of the town she once again calls home.

-------- REVIEW --------

Oh, such a great first book in a new series. I really loved the mystery and there were several suspects, so had no clue of whodunit. I wish the person who died would be a mean person and not an old man that I am sure I would have loved to get to know more.

Putting that aside, there were several characters I liked in this book, especially Hanna's niece Peach. They had a lovely bond, and it was fun seeing them together. I also loved reading about Hanna running the B&B and hope we get more of that in the upcoming books.

I really go start to a new series and I highly recommend all cozy mystery lovers out there to pick this up.

Thank you, NetGalley and Crooked Lane Books for the ARC in exchange for my honest review.

Hannah is getting comfortable running a small town Vermont inn and working in her gardens. Then her best friend dies and it looks like murder. A new series with great characters and plotting. Plus, the garden makes me want to get out and improve my gardens too.

Solace is at the heart of a captivating tale, surrounded by a diverse cast of supporting characters that make this story an enthralling read. Hannah, alongside her sister Reggie, embarks on revitalizing Hummingbird Hollow B&B, formerly known as The Jasper Inn. They meet Ezra Grayson and their tranquil town takes a dark turn when Hannah discovers Ezra's lifeless body during a fateful encounter at Devil's Pond.
Noah Booker, a detective, steps into the scene to investigate Ezra's death, intertwining the lives of Hannah and her newfound companion, Moose, Ezra's elderly dog. The plot thickens as Maura Hamilton Saunders, Ezra's niece, and her brothers, Rob Long and Waylen, enter the picture, seeking to claim their inheritance. The valuable property becomes a battleground for potential heirs, including scheming neighbors like Brian Lewis, ambitious developers like Henry Yarrow, and Ezra's estranged family members.
Tensions rise as Hannah, determined to unveil Ezra's killer, navigates a web of family drama and buried secrets. The story offers readers an immersive experience in the charming yet mysterious town. The reader is taken on a thrilling adventure as Hannah delves into the past two decades, unraveling connections between Ezra's contacts and unveiling shocking revelations.
In the midst of the unfolding drama, accusations against Hannah add layers to the suspense, making the investigation a race against time. The book skillfully combines elements of inheritance intrigue, murder mystery, and family dynamics, culminating in an unexpected resolution. The story is a page-turner.
Ayla Rose treats the reader to a murder mystery creating a compelling narrative that keeps readers engaged from start to finish. A must-read for those who appreciate a well-crafted mystery with a blend of familial drama and unexpected twists. The anticipation for future works from this author is palpable, given the delightful experience offered by this engaging and thoroughly enjoyable story.

Murder on Devil's Pond is the first in the new Hummingbird Hollow series. I loved the strong main character, Hannah. She is starting a new life in a small Vermont community. With her sister, Reggie, she begins the renovation of an old home to make it a welcoming bed and breakfast. Hannah is working out her own identity. She has goals and she has beliefs--like her stand for ecology. Hannah befriends her next door neighbor--crochety Ezra. Imagine her horror when she finds Ezra floating in the pond! Who did it and why? Who inherits Ezra's home and land? Every action depends on a prior action is this mystery. Thanks to NetGalley for the arc.

Murder at Devil’s pond is the first book in the Hummingbird Hollow B&B mystery.

The tone of this book reminds of me of Ellery Adams’ Secret, Book, and Scone Society series which I absolutely love.

Hannah Solace is the main character in this book. She moved back to her home town and she now co-owns an inn with her sister. We don’t find out why she moved back till later in the book.

Hannah has befriended the grouchy neighbor, Ezra. Ezra’s house is on desirable property and it recently has a fire. The vultures - his family - has come to convince him to sell and move. A few locals also want to buy his land.

Ezra is found dead in the marsh by Hannah. As Hannah tried to uncover who murdered him she also uncovers many secrets. This book was definitely a page turner and I did not expect the killer.

I enjoyed the different relationships in the book and the descriptions of the characters and even the inn property.

A great first book in the series!

I received a complimentary copy of this book, opinions express in this review are completely my own.

Murder on Devil's Pond I think is the first in the Hummingbird Hollow B&B mysteries. It takes place in the town of Jasper, Vermont. Hannah Solace is the main character with a great supporting characters to make the story a fun read. Hannah has moved back to the town where she grew up to work as a part owner of Hummingbird Hollow B&B, formally The Jasper Inn with her sister, Regina (Reggie) Solace who got the victorian house in her divorce from her ex Chad. Hannah is redoing the back yard into a special natural garden. Ash Kade, a landscaper is helping her. Hannah is a friend of Ezra Grayson an elderly man in his 80's whose property backs up to hers. He lives in a rundown victorian in the middle of town with his elderly dog, Moose. When she is out on Devil's pond she sees Moose on the shore line upset. She goes over and discovers the body of Ezra and calls the police. Noah Booker a detective is working on the case. To avoid sending Moose the a shelter Hannah takes him home with her.

Maura Hamilton Saunders is staying at the B&B. She is Ezra's niece. Her brother, Rob Long and his wife, Simone are staying at the B&B in the airstream on the property, Waylen, his brother is also there. They are Ezra's nephews. They have been trying to get their uncle to sell the house and move into a retirement home. Now that Ezra is dead they think they are his heirs. The property is very valuable and several people have been trying to get Ezra to sell to them. One is his neighbor, Brian Lewis, Henry Yarrow who brought Devil's Mountain abandoned ski resort. His property abuts Ezra's property to expand, Chad is a realtor and property developer.

Reggie and Hannah are estranged from their father, John Solence, who brought a large amount of land from Ezra which he developed. He lives in a large beautiful house which he built and developed land around him. Ezra was not happy that John had developed the land. Thought the property was not going to be developed. John became very wealthy because of the purchase.

Hannah is determined to find out who killed Ezra. This is where the story takes the reader on an adventure with lots of twists and turns. There is so much going on in the story that it would be hard to put all on paper. I will leave it to the reader to enjoy to the exciting end.

I really enjoyed this story and all the characters that make up the town. I look forward to read the next book in the series.

Thank you NetGalley and Crooked Lane Books for this ARC.

"Murder on Devil's Pond (A Hummingbird Hallow B&B Mystery #1)" by Ayla Rose reads both like a first book in a series and a book a bit further into a series. Lots of things make it seem very standalone/first book while at times information is given a bit like it's been an established piece of information. More specifically the coming to run the B&B for Hannah. Hannah has been in town now for a few years and after the standard reasons a cozy mystery main character shows up, rather than it being a fresh event. It's not a bad thing, just a bit different.

The mystery was a bit predictable to start with, I had a bit of feel of who the victim would be since we didn't get out outright annoying/mean person it was really only one other option. A little sad it was them though. It wrapped a smidge differently than I was thinking but not far off. The clues were starting to get me there at the reveal point.

I enjoyed this cozy mystery set in a bed and breakfast. I don't think I've every read one with that setting before.

Thank you NetGalley and Crooked Lane Books for the eARC.
The first in a series, this was a great start and I'm looking forward to reading more.
It's a cozy read with a very likeable protagonist, Hannah, and I love that there's a dog and a cat in it. The setting of Vermont is wonderful and the gardening bits were quite interesting and oh yes, there's a murder! A very enjoyable book and I hope there are many more to come!

Murder on Devils Pond is the first entry in this new bed and breakfast mystery. After fifteen years away, Hannah Solace returns home to renovate and reopen an old victorian inn. She strikes up an unlikely friendship with Ezra Grayson, an 80 year old recluse who lives nearby. His niece and nephews come to town to try and convince him to sell his ramshackle house that is sitting on some valuable land. When Ezra is murdered, Hannah finds his body and becomes one of the prime suspects and has no choice but to do some investigating to clear her own name and find justice for her old friend. This was a fast paced book with likeable characters, lots of red herrings, and a big protective dog. I was surprised by who the murderer turned out to be. I can't wait to read the next book in this promising new series!

Thanks for the ARC from Netgalley! Its a page turner story and i loved it!

Can you imagine, you inherit properties and million dollar from someone you who is pretend like they have nothing in this world and down to earth? Beside, you are non of their family; just a friend. Why would they pass their property to you if there is no reasons? Of course! They have a reasons to do it.

Ezra was killed. The killer must have been among his family members where they knew that Ezra had a lot of property but did not want to discuss passing it on to his family for some reason.

Hannah who is Ezra's friend inherits all his property and at the same time, Hannah has to find out who is Ezra's killer. She was accused of killing Ezra and with this accusation had made Hannah to unravel one thing after another. The events of the last 20 years lead Hannah to research each of Ezra's contacts to unravel this murder case if there is any connection.

Plot after plot goes well. Although the reader wonders 'who' the killer is and seems to be able to guess who he is, the guess is wrong. At the end of the story, an unexpected unraveling.

One of the books that must be read this year. I'm waiting for this author to write more stories in this genre and will definitely read it. Im fell in love with the author's work. Keep going!

Returning home…secrets…red herrings…family and friends…murder…all of this adds up to a page turner. A talented author has written a cannot put down novel. An elderly man found dead…starting over…enjoy trying to discover who did the murder. Thanks Netgalley.

The version of this provided had issues with formatting that made it really hard to read in kindle. It made it hard to follow the story over all in some place because of the line breaks. Other than that I did quite enjoy this book cozy mysteries have been evil moving recently to not have so many not the extreme troupes such as female competition for no reason other than hate main character which greatly improved its like ability to me.

I rated this book 4 stars on good reads but our version 3.

I really enjoyed this mystery. It has a lot of elements of a cozy mystery but has a realism that I think makes it not exactly a typical cozy one. There is a realism to this book in the gruesome nature of murder and life without being graphic. Hannah has a passion for the environment and befriends one of her fathers former friends when returning to town a few years earlier. She works with her sister to dig into his past and finds more than one to work through. There was also a hint of romance for the future. Thank you NetGalley for the copy to read in exchange for my honest opinion.

I've been really getting into cozy mysteries lately. I don't know if it's the weather or the time of year, but they are really speaking to me. I was immediately drawn in by the gorgeous cover and by the time I was done reading the synopsis I couldn't wait to get my hands on a copy. I grew up visiting Vermont every year and the setting was described very accurately and gave me quite a bit of nostalgia. By the end of this book I wanted to move to a small town in Vermont, even though this was a murder mystery. Usually I can guess at least part of the plot, but I had no idea how this book would end until the last 5%. I basically couldn't stop reading once I started, and I was pleasantly surprised by the complex character interactions mixed with rich imagery of the natural beauty surrounding this dark and tragic event. I can't wait to read more from this author!

This was a very cozy and intriguing read and I feel like this book is an amazing start to the new ‘Bed and Breakfast Mysteries’ series. The plot was very interesting and kept me guessing the entire time; I truly didn’t see the end coming, which isn’t always the case with cozy mysteries, so I really liked that. However there were quite a few spelling and/or typing mistakes throughout the book. I can read past those though, so it didn’t bother me too much. I’m looking forward to the rest of the series.