Skip to main content

Member Reviews

This story follows two friends who everyone thought would end up together except them. I read one of Rainbow Rowell’s book, Fangirl, and really enjoyed it so I was excited to hear she wrote an adult romance book. I really enjoyed the storyline of this book. The writing style was still the Rowell style and I loved the past writing style feeling. The setting is in a small town of north Omaha which was well told. I enjoyed the conflicts that the author incorporated into the story which kept me entertained until the ending of the book. This book is told from the past and current perspective of Shiloh and Cary’s life.

Shiloh is divorced with kids but doesn’t know where she’s heading in her life. I loved reading about a woman finding love even after having young children. As a person, I didn’t truly like her because I was getting munipulative but bland vibes that threw me off but I liked how strong she was. Then we have Cary who poor man was so into Shiloh but was getting so many mixed signals from her. There are many side characters in this book and I believe my favorite were Shiloh’s kids. The romance was well done with the friends to lovers and slow burn trope. It’s a messy type or romance and not the cutesy stuff but the real stuff.

The ending was well done and overall I really enjoyed this book. This was a great read and I can see how it’s a book club pick because it can hold an amazing conversation.I recommend checking this book out especially if you love The Perks of Being a Wallflower.

*this arc was sent to me by the publisher to give an honest review in return*

Was this review helpful?

I received a copy of this book from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

Like many, I have loved Rainbow Rowell’s past books and was excited to see another one from her. I will admit that this book was a little slow at the beginning and took me awhile to get in to, I really loved how well developed the characters were. It felt much more like a “real” story than the many trope filled romances that are popular lately (that I also like, to be fair). Recommend for those who like complicated love stories, just be wary of the pacing.

Was this review helpful?

Best friends since before high school everyone thought it would be Shiloh and Cary forever. Except, neither Shiloh nor Cary knew how to bridge that gap in their relationship. What happens is many missed opportunities.

Now, they're reunited at a friend's wedding for the first time in nearly fifteen years. They have both lived full lives in the intervening years. Can they pick up what they put down so long ago, or has too much time passed between them?

I love Rainbow Rowell's simplistic approach to writing about life and love. I say simple when in reality it's anything but simple. I should more appropriately say she truly captures the nuances and complications of everyday life in the most relatable way.

I absolutely adored Cary and Shiloh and I was so pulled into their story. The book is laid out in that we get chapters in the present and chapters in the past. I liked that there's such a dichotomy between Shiloh and Cary past and present that I didn't need the "before" sub-headers to indicate when we were getting a glimpse of them in the past. I think this perfectly highlights how different they are, how much they've grown, as individuals in the intervening years, but also the subtle ways in which they've remained the same.

I will say that I had the most difficult time reconciling the past Shiloh from the present Shiloh. I just think this is because she's had a much more substantial change with everything she's gone through. Instead of becoming the actress she wanted to be Shiloh was married, now divorced, and is mother to two young children and back, again, living with her mother in the house she grew up in, and teaching children's theater. Shiloh doesn't want to be living with her mother, and I think she wishes some things had turned out differently with her life, but she cannot see a way to change any of that.

On the other side is Cary who, after graduation, joined the Navy and has been enlisted ever since only coming back to Omaha occasionally to look after his mother. I think it shows a sense of steadfastness. He had one trajectory for his life and he has stuck with it for the long haul. The only thing, or someone, who could have moved him from his course would be Shiloh.

They've each carefully circled around one another, not wanting to rock the boat, not wanting to risk losing their friendship. The will they/won't they is pretty spot on as is their undeniable connection to one another.

I really liked how all the other characters surrounding Shiloh and Carey are rooting for them, it's just Shiloh and Carey themselves that are the biggest obstacles.

I'm happy that Rainbow Rowell decided to return to an adult title this time around after having spent the last few years in the YA and YA Fantasy realm. I was first introduced to her writing through her first book Attachments and these types of books of hers have always held a special place for me. I can now honestly say that Slow Dance fits perfectly in there as well.

Was this review helpful?

I had wanted to try Rainbow Rowell's writing and I did end up enjoying this book. This was a story about Cary and Shiloh and how their deep friendship from the time they were kids grew into a much different but still much the same relationship years later. The story was different and the characters were different than your usual romance novel, but they grew on me. The characters had more depth than some other novels, and more tragic history, which also made the story a bit slow at parts. There were constant flashbacks which, at times, interrupted the flow, but we're also relevant to the story being told. Overall, it was a good book, although not a favorite. I will try more of Rowell's work though. Thank you NetGalley and William Morrow for this ARC! #slowdance #williammorrow #netgalley

Was this review helpful?

I have been waiting years and years for Rainbow Rowell to write another adult novel. Her book "Attachments" is one of my all time favorite reads. So when I was offered an early copy of her latest "Slow Dance," my excitement level was sky high.

"Slow Dance" did not hit for me the same way her previous novel did, but I did enjoy this cute second chance romance. I appreciated that the present day time line was set in the not so long ago past instead of the technology fueled world of today. I connected with these characters because they were experiencing the events at a time where I would have been the same age. I found myself routing for these characters even with their flaws. The kids were written adorably.

This book is light and sweet and can be read in a day. I definitely recommend it.

Thank you to William Morrow and Netgalley for an advanced readers copy for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

More than a decade has passed since Shiloh and Cary even saw each other. But when the third from their high school trio invites them to his wedding, they both show up and reconnect.

They've each followed their expected adult path, to an extent. Cary is a Navy man, and Shiloh has a career in the arts. But maybe there's enough of the people they were back when they were the closest of friends that they still recognize in each other.

Of course, if they'd actually dated in high school, as everyone had expected, it would have undoubtedly been easier. Now they've got plenty of adult problems in the mix as well. Shiloh is divorced and a single mother who lives with her mother in the house where she grew up. Cary is the most responsible member of his childhood family, and now continues to try to manage everything for his mother from a distance.

Overall, the story went pretty much as expected. High school relationships can never end up as simple as they appear in the beginning, and adult live makes everything harder. The book earned 3 out of 5 stars and was a nice cozy friends-to-lovers romance for a pretty quirky girl and they guy she never thought she'd be with forever.

Was this review helpful?

I have loved Rowell's other novels and had high hopes for this one. Unfortunately it was just okay. Not bad but not great.

Second chance romance and friends to lovers are my favorite tropes but this is a mash up of those and I was frustrated with the characters for making the same decisions/mistakes over and over.

It had some sweet moments and ultimately was satisfying but the middle was just meh.

Was this review helpful?

This book really turns the tables on a trope I normally hate: miscommunication. Shiloh and Cary were best friends in high school who haven't spoken in 15 years. Sparks fly when they are reunited at a friends wedding. Unfortunately Shiloh doesn't think anyone would want to make an effort to be with her and Cary is still hurt from their last encounter. There wasn't one misunderstanding keeping them a part, it's decades of history. They can't seem to have that big conversation and get together.

The book goes back and forth between their high school selves and the present. After the wedding they slowly come back to each other. Supporting characters and the realities of daily life provide wonderful color to the story. As always I enjoyed the Omaha setting.

Was this review helpful?

Rainbow Rowell is back! This was a fun book, and I really appreciated the opportunity to read it! I will recommend this book.

Was this review helpful?

Love, love, love this book. I loved the timeline changes and the character growth. The two main characters were relatable and likable. Their story is one that is relatable for so many and the authors writing is so realistic. One of my favorite reads from this summer.

Was this review helpful?

I am a big fan of Rainbow Rowell's young adult books so I was very excited to try an adult novel from her. I'm going to be honest I struggled a bit wit this one. I found that the younger characters were written really well and realistically but the adults didn't work. I especially found Shiloh to be immature and honestly didn't really want Cary to be with her. I loved Cary and wanted so much more for him. I loved the setting. We need more books that take place truly in middle-America and feel that way. I look forward to what Rainbow writes next.

Was this review helpful?

I have been WAITING for a new Rainbow Rowell adult romance, and I was absolutely not disappointed.

This was a second chance romance between two best friends who couldn't speak their feelings for each other in high school/college and then reconnect fifteen years later at their third best friend's wedding. Complicated family dynamics, plus Cary's Navy life and Shiloh's divorce and kids, made this really really interesting to see how everything would be navigated. SO MANY FEELS!!!! I loved it. 4.5 stars!

Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for an ARC in exchange for my thoughts.

Was this review helpful?

I’ve been patiently awaiting a new romance by Rainbow Rowell for years and she most definitely did not disappoint. This story line was especially intriguing to me because I am also a recentlu divorced single mom of two kids. Shiloh was so well developed and I loved watching her grow and find herself (and Cary, again) after so much hardship and trauma. Couldn’t recommend this one more. For fans of Emily Henry and Annabel Monaghan.

Was this review helpful?

I love Rainbow Rowell. All of her books seem to strike a chord with me weather or not its something I've actually experienced. As for this gem? Thank you, Rainbow, for giving me characters that I was able to so immediately and so deeply fall in love with. And to all the best friends secretly in love with each other out there? I'm rooting for you to figure it out. However long it takes, I'm sure it will be well worth the journey.

Was this review helpful?

I am so sad I didn't love this book. I have adored Rainbow Rowells past books. Fan Girl, Eleanor & Park, Attachments love them! So I was super excited for Slow Dance. I honestly got tot he 85% and just didn't want to finish it but knew I'd be upset with myself if I didn't finish it.

This landed at a 3.5 for me

I still love her writing style but the story felt like the end was 80% on and that needed flushed out for me more and a lot felt rushed and I was missing that something. I don't want to get into a lot here for spoilers.

Shiloh and Cary are the main characters and I loved the kids more than them. Cary felt like he was quick to getting mad but he NEVER fully expressed how he felt and Shiloh I didn't like her the flash back scenes mad me like her less. She also couldn't express how she felt and both of them wasted so much time and then it was all or nothing really out of left field.

I am very sad I didn't connect to the story more and that the end felt rushed.

Thank you to NetGalley for this Arc in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

The sweetest second chance book ever! Relationships never last from high school, but Shiloh, Cary and Mikey gave it a go. After fourteen years of not seeing each other a wedding brings the band together. Mikey is the third wheel, sort of, and is secretly supportive of his friends. Cary is a career Navy man with some familial issues he’s working out. Shiloh has two kids, a manipulating ex, and lives with her mom. Every person has changed and evolved since high school, except how Cary and Shiloh feel for each other. Their path is slow going, bless Cary for being an understanding and patient man. Their story was a joy to read, easily losing my thoughts to their world, and wanting to witness their relationship in person. I was thrilled to get an early copy from NetGalley and have left my review voluntarily.

Was this review helpful?

Sometimes you really just need a light read. I was captivated right away but lost interest in the last part of the book. The characters became less likable and story kind of dragged on and the outcome was always a given. 3.5 stars rounded up.

Was this review helpful?

By Gail Pennington
Special to the Post-Dispatch

Free spirit Shiloh and upright Cary were best friends in high school. But she headed off to college, he joined the Navy, and their lives went in different directions.

Now, though, 14 years after they last spoke, their friend Mikey is getting married, and that will bring Cary back home to Omaha. What will Shiloh say to him? Will he even want to see her?

Rowell, author of the first-love classic “Eleanor & Park” (2012) and the delightful “Fangirl” (2013), which spawned a fantasy trilogy based on its protagonist’s fan fiction, may be best known for her Young Adult novels. But her newest, “Slow Dance,” is for adults, albeit ones for whom high school still resonates.

Shiloh, free spirit no more, is a divorced mother of two, living with her own mother and helping to run a children’s theater. Cary, a career Navy officer, spends months at sea. Can they find common ground to restore their friendship? Do they even want to?

If this were just any author, we might expect a will-they-or-won’t-they scenario to follow. Rowell, though, gives us a leisurely back and forth of “why did they never” and “might they still,” told in 84 chapters bouncing from the present (it’s 2006) to “before,” high school in the 1990s.

“Slow Dance” is a slow dance indeed, but a charming one. Over 400 pages in which nothing really happens, we learn about Shiloh and Cary and their intense young friendship, with Mikey as the third Musketeer.

Shiloh, then, was pointedly quirky, a girl who “would shave her head not to look like anybody else.” A teacher once commented that “a little of her goes a long way,” and that’s true — teenage Shiloh is sometimes so annoying, we might not want to spend time with her if we didn’t know her adult self.

Even the grown-up Shiloh has a crippling fear of exposing herself, of being seen, whether on the dance floor or in bed.

All she had to do, she tells herself in one happy moment after reconnecting with Cary, “was keep her self-consciousness at bay. (Her self-consciousness. And her bone-deep desolation. She could be desolate tomorrow. And the next day. She could table her ennui.)”

We learn little, initially, about Cary. His family life is messy. He believes in duty to his country. He lets Shiloh and Mikey supply the crazy for their friend trio.

Rowell cleverly delays bringing adult Cary’s (eventful) story into the picture until we’re wondering whether this yarn is ever going somewhere. Hang on; it will and it does.

Throughout, “Slow Dance” really triumphs with its supporting cast, each one richly detailed. (My favorites: Shiloh’s 6-year-old daughter, Junie, and Cary’s ailing mother, Lois.) This could make a fun TV miniseries with very little adaptation, just some good casting.

What I’m trying to say here is that “Slow Dance” won’t be for everyone. You can probably tell already whether you’ll take to the floor or sit it out. But if you already are a Rainbow Rowell fan or are ready to become one, she’s playing your song.

(Reviewed in print and online for the St. Louis Post-Dispstch.)

Was this review helpful?

Mikey, Cary, and Shiloh were a closed-knit trio at their Omaha, Nebraska high school. Fourteen years later the three meet are together again in Omaha at Mikey's wedding. Cary is in the U.S. Navy; Mikey is an artist; Shiloh is a divorced mother with joint custody of her two children. The novel is constructed of "before" chapters that tell of the trio's high school friendship and messy family lives; alternating chapters detail the trio's current lives with taking care of their mothers and managing daily life. What unfolds is the romance between Cary and Shiloh--it was the spark that was never lit in high school. Readers will enjoy discussing finding a love from years ago and acting on a crush or curiosity. Recommended for escape weekend or long plane ride reading.

Was this review helpful?

Adult! Romance! From the queen herself!! Gosh I loved diving back into a Rainbow Rowell world - I have loved her YA books for what seems like my entire life and I was not left disappointed by her foray into the world of adult romance. This was genuine and authentic and awkward and everything I expected from someone who took me through the awkward and difficult stories of my teenage years.

Was this review helpful?