Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Thank you Netgalley for allowing me to read and review this book. These opinions are completely my own.

I adore love stories that are not necessarily about the romantic kind( it did however have romance). They Deam in Gold gave me that feeling that you know this couple and feel the ups and or course downs as they chase their musical dreams around the world.

Was this review helpful?

They Dream of Gold was a story of how the changing tides of life pull and push us while we're trying to set our feet firmly in the ground. As a debut, this is one of the best I've ever read, the flow from one point-of-view, timeline, and setting to another was tightly held together by the connections between the characters. This type of story could have so easily got away and fell apart but the author's writing style and tone keeps the traveling sands feel discussed in the author's note. I would consider Bonnie our main character and touchstone as she blows into other characters' lives and as she's with them, readers then get tangents into those character lives.

When we enter into Bonnie's life, it's 1969 Switzerland and she's heavily pregnant. Staying at her mother-in-law's home, the household is tense and stressed that they haven't heard from Mansour, Bonnie's husband. He's a musician who's been out on tour and when a radio report comes on that the women fear could hold the answer, Bonnie knows it's time to figure out what happened to Mansour. The story then branches out, giving us Bonnie's childhood, her mother couldn't take care of her when she was younger, so she left Paris to stay with her grandmother in Brooklyn, and then as each character, Bonnie's mother Claudine, Mama Eva, and the other two women staying in Mama Eva's home, Marie and Sokhna, along with Mansour and friends and colleagues Mansour makes along his way and how Bonnie and Mansour met, we flow into each characters' pov and visit their lives at certain times in their history. From 1969 Switzerland, 1949 Senegal, 1927 Alabama, and other times and places, the story manages to give intimate insights into what happened to these characters and how that has shaped and molded them in the 1969 present.

This structure sounds zig zaggy, but I promise it works, we never info dump stay with one character, it's more of a constant flowing around as the present search for Mansour is the central plot line for bringing in and connecting all these characters. As Mansour is a musician and that is a main part of what brought him and Bonnie together, it's all around in the story and what I'd keep in mind if you're more of a linear reader to help you get into the flow of this. There were moments of quiet devastation, fierce love, hope, and strength that will keep you thinking about these characters for a long time. Historical events were in the background and forefront at times to ground the reader in the time and place of the character pov you're reading at the time, adding more layers to the characters. This was an amazing story on how other's not only affect our lives as they come into and leave it, but how we carry and pass on, whether familial, friendship, or romantic, those little grains of emotional experiences from one generation to another. There was so much to experience and feel in this, that I can't recommend it enough.

Was this review helpful?

A powerful debut, They Dream in Gold is a book about who we are as individuals as well as our familial identity. We learn the story of Bonnie and Mansour, alternating perspectives and timelines, going all the way back to the 1920s, until their paths finally cross in the 60s. Traveling the world, we get to know the background of this family until we come to present day, where we know that Mansour has gone missing and Bonnie is anxiously awaiting his return, pregnant with their first child.

While the blurb made this story more mysterious than it actually was, I knew from prior SJP titles that it would likely be heavy on character development and it certainly was. The story itself is quite meandering but the prose is gorgeous and Sennaar paints such a clear picture of who the characters are, that I was heavily invested in the outcome of their story.

Contemplative and throughful, They Dream in Gold is an excellent piece of historical fiction and would be a great book club pick.

Was this review helpful?

Mai Sennaar's debut THEY DREAM IN GOLD show a young couple Bonnie and Mansour and their origin story, including from the perspectives of their caretakers. This novel takes place in several locations: Senegal, Switzerland, and America. Bonnie and Mansour meet when Bonnie is making the cover art for the band Mansour's in. When he goes missing while Bonnie is in the first trimester of her pregnancy, they all must reckon with their pasts.

A novel of identity and belonging, much of this novel is aching. It does have a slower pace, which some readers might not appreciate. I did, as I tend to gravitate toward character-driven novels.

This debut has very strong writing. At times, the narration is more detached than I wanted. I do favor up close and personal narration, but there is a bit of a mystery here so I understand why the author wrote it that way.

I would not hesitate to read the next novel by this author!

Was this review helpful?

I normally love books with multi generational stories, switching timelines/POVs but sadly this wasn’t working for me. I found myself often getting bored or tired after only a few pages. Some chapters are more engaging than others but overall I’m not enjoying the meandering pace or story enough to continue. DNF at 15% but I’ll be recommending to my friends and fellow readers that I know would enjoy the slower pacing, character driven novel

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC. The cover is what captivated me! I am a judge a book by a cover kind of girl. This was my first time reading work by this author and this was a very engaging read with love and flashbacks, multiple POVs well written. Looking forward to see what else is out there by this author.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Zando – SJP Lit and NetGalley for an advance readers copy of this book.

They Dream in Gold reads like a mosaic made of circles, where individual people, times, locations and plot revolve around each other to finally form a glittering picture.

Set mostly in the late 60’s, but going back to the 1950’s, and even the 1920’s, the story tells of Bonnie and Mansour, two talented young black people from different countries but sharing stories of distance and loss of their mothers, unknown fathers, and struggles to find both love and home. The main people are from Senegal, France, Ireland, Switzerland, the USA. Contemporary events – such as the murder of Martin Luther King, Jr. - are part of the background, and racism is often at the forefront.

The book is challenging: many characters appear by name early in a phrase or a sentence, only to return chapters later in significant roles. The timeline is hazy, and some episodes are based on secrets and incomplete or inaccurate information. Chapter headings foretell events that do not occur until later, and the tension of the story’s initial mystery – Where is Mansour as Bonnie awaits, pregnant with his child? – is introduced early, but hints of a happy conclusion are scattered in sentences through the book that refer to later years.

Reading this book was a struggle for me. I wasn’t comfortable with the non-linear structure, which made it impossible not to repeat events and patterns in troubled and troubling relationships. Still, it had a certain beauty to it, especially when describing the music that grounds Mansour and first connects him to Bonnie.
I am 76 years old, white, educated, middle class, and liberal. A younger audience may greatly enjoy and appreciate this book for its style as well as its story.

Was this review helpful?

“They Dream in Gold” is a book of music, love, friendships and new beginnings, The characters are well developed and thoroughly interesting. While I enjoyed reading about Mama, Bonnie and Mansour, the different locales and their journey’s, I found at times that I couldn’t keep track of all the characters and the timelines. I’m usually pretty good with historical fiction that jumps back and forth but this book was a bit disjointed to me. As I got closer to the end, I found I was really liking it! I can see by the majority of the reviews that I’m in the minority re my view. For a debut novel, it definitely hits a lot of high spots ie romance, family, suspense and the jazz/music aspect.
Do I recommend it? Certainly!

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for my eARC COPY.

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed so many things about this book. I was entertained from beginning to end as the characters became friends of mine. Great book!!!

Thank you to the author and NetGalley for gifting me this book in exchange for my honest review

Was this review helpful?

This is great read. The characters were engaging and I couldn't put the book down. I would recommend this book for a book club or a friend.

Was this review helpful?

This was a great book. I loved the theme. I loved the way it was written and the way the words flowed.

Was this review helpful?

This is a love story, this is a jazz story, this is a story of America and of trying to claw your way out of poverty.
When Bonnie and Mansour meet in New York in 1968 they are tied together forever. Through snippets and flashbacks and multiple POVs, Mai Sennaar creates a love song to those who believe in true romance and of perseverance. I loved all of the voices and the easy way I fell into each person's tale. Mai Sennaar is an amazing talent!

A sprawling story of intercontinental travel, this is an intergenerational tale that should be produced on the big screen!
#zando #sjplit #africandiaspora #maisennaar #theydreamingold #bestdebut

Was this review helpful?

I'd like to say the cover art for this book is absolutely stunning!
I struggled to get through parts of this story. It's a bit like a collection of short stories, woven together. Some stories more compelling than others. The overall theme of the story comes together to tell the resilient stories of women and mothers.

Was this review helpful?

I found myself attracted to this book's cover. Each time I look at it I see something new. The author skillfully turned the words into a powerful story. Thanks to NetGalley for the ARC. Sennaar has crafted characters that are going to stay with me for a long time.

Was this review helpful?

A unique story of one man's journey to success as a musician, told largely through the perspective of the leading women in his life. The novel is absolutely sprawling as we jump between characters, time periods, and continents. As would be expected, certain threads of the story are more captivating than others and I struggled a bit though the less engaging parts. However, with music as the thoroughline, the author gracefully explores motherhood, cross-cultural experience, grief and ambition. An impressive debut.

Was this review helpful?

I struggled with They Dream in Gold. I wanted so badly to love this book. When I saw Sarah Jessica Parker’s glowing review I knew I would love this book. Maybe my hopes were too high. In the beginning I was so confused on what was going on. I couldn’t figure out how the characters were connected and the story was all over the place in time and places around the world. About half way through it started to make more sense and I willed myself to finish the book. The ending was good. I love books about families, love, and happy endings so I reluctantly gave it three stars. Thank you for giving me the opportunity to read this book.

Was this review helpful?

simply a gorgeous work about family with fantastic writing and a really fun style. would recommend this one so much. thanks for the arc.

Was this review helpful?

The story flowed well and the characters were well developed. I recommend this book and look forward to more from this author.


****Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for providing an ARC in exchange for my honest review****

Was this review helpful?

such a beautiful story, I was hung on every single word! Sennaar really captured the familys feelings and belifs and told them in such a heartwarming way I loved ever second of it and cannot wait to get my hands on a physical copy!

Was this review helpful?