Cover Image: Clay and Bones

Clay and Bones

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

Thank you to Netgalley for a copy for an honest review

I really enjoyed it and would highly recommend and I can’t wait to buy a copy for myself 🙂

Rating 4 stars ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Was this review helpful?

A lover of Bones and the Kathy Reichs novels I was excited to find this book written by an bona fide forensic scientist!

I really enjoyed the chapter where she goes to study with an artist she's admired from childhood and would've loved to learn more about what she had learned there rather than just that they got along well and both enjoy chocolate and wine. I loved the chapter where they visit The Body Farm, where she goes into quite a lot of detail about some of the bodies that they saw as well as photographed and studied, and I was hoping for more gruesome details of cases or other interesting details about different forensic practices.

Instead this turned out to largely be about the sexual harassment and discrimination that Bailey suffered at the FBI and the steps she took to fight back against management who protected the abusers. It's quite disheartening to learn about the horrendous behaviour that goes on in such a well known and respected agency.

All in all an interesting read, though not quite what I was expecting.

**Thanks to Netgalley and the publishers for an ARC of this novel. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

I found this memoir very insightful as told by an FBI forensic artist. The story follows Lisa G. Bailey as she gives the reader a glimpse into the fascinating world of forensic artistry and the intricate process of reconstructing faces from skeletal remains. Bailey shares her experiences working with law enforcement agencies by assisting in solving cold cases and identifying unknown individuals through facial reconstructions. She describes the painstaking process of reconstructing faces from clay, Bailey delves into the human stories behind the remains. Her passion and dedication are obvious as she works the painstaking process of reconstructing faces from clay, Bailey delves into the human stories behind the remains, so she can bring closure to families and seek justice for victims. This is a gripping true-crime memoir, and I suggest you pick up a copy for yourself.

Was this review helpful?

I really liked this book! the way it was written was amazing and super interesting! there was some rage and some parts that made me angry because of the things that happened to her! I would really recommend it especially if you like the temperance Brennan series and know my name by Chanel miller!

Was this review helpful?

Lisa has got the be the baddest woman around. Her retelling of her life and career struggles will sadly remind you of your own struggles.It's sad to read that a woman in such a monument position in the FBI was treated the way she was by men who had authority over her, and by men who just were assholes. Goes to show that where ever you may work, there will always be issues because of our gender. Lisa tells her story though by showing how she kept her poise, her dignity and never stooped to the level of those arrogant men. Reading how she basically created the training of how to correctly map and build a face on a skull, and how her knowledge and growth have helped so many unidentified remains be identified, just proves that a woman can do anything a man believes she cant, and better. Thank you Lisa for paving the way for the next generation and thank you for sharing your triumphs!

Was this review helpful?

The books about forensic investigation always fascinates me and this is a good one as there's humour but it's also informative and entertaining.
Well done
Recommended.
Many thanks to the publisher for this ARC, all opinions are mine

Was this review helpful?

this was a really interesting concept, I enjoyed that Lisa G. Bailey shared their life with the reader. I thought it was a unique concept for the true crime element and had that nonfiction element perfectly. I was engaged with the memoir and thought it worked overall. Its amazing what a forensic artist can do and glad I got to read this.

Was this review helpful?

I found Lisa Bailey’s account of working as a forensic sculptor for the FBI to be fearless and fascinating. Fearless, in that she tells of her disillusionment about the realities of the job she’d always dreamed of, including harassment, outdated computers, and a generally dismal, frought work environment, filled with clashing egos and discrimination. This was not the job she idealized while working hard to hone her skills in college. A fascinating read, in that her capabilities and drive to succeed are remarkable. It is an honest and sometimes painful and relatable recounting of realities intruding on dreams.

Was this review helpful?

This was a really interesting memoir to read. Forensics has always been incredibly interesting to me, so I always try to grab books about it when I can. Facial reconstruction is a topic that I hadn't read much about before picking up this book.

While it was really interesting, by the time I was halfway through the book I was confused about what the point was. The beginning about Bailey's research at the body farm was insanely fascinating. Her story of discrimination and harassment while working at the FBI was captivating. And her explanations of the process of facial reconstruction was easy to follow and incredibly interesting. I would have loved to see either this book structured much better, or three different books about all of those things.

Was this review helpful?

I had a different expectation of what this book would be about. I find anything in forensics to be fascinating, and thought this book would be filled with stories of cases Lisa Bailey worked on while employed with the FBI. While the book does have some of this, it focuses more on her sexual discrimination at the FBI. Her story is important and should be told, however, the book feels misleading with the cover and title. Overall, I found her job and techniques to be fascinating, but I was left underwhelmed.

Was this review helpful?

Lisa does an amazing job of talking about her work as a forensic artist and as a high school forensic science teacher those parts of the story were really educational. The personal part of her life in the FBI and the the abuse, while important to shed light on the injustice, felt like it was two different books. I would have like to have just the forensic work in the book so I could have possibly used in my classroom.

Was this review helpful?

Bones is one of my all time favorite TV shows, and although Lisa is a forensic artist rather than a forensic anthropologist, I was so excited for this book! I'm sure for all Bones fans, we wondered about Angela just as much as Temperance. So going into this, I expected more of Lisa's story to pertain to her journey in her work and cases, but rather it was a lot more about her terrible time dealing with the men of the Agency. At one point after a turn at work, she writes that at night, when she couldn't sleep, she was furious and started to write down "a free flow of words as it all spilled from [her] brain." At times, that's what this book feels like, so it becomes a repetitive stream of consciousness and while I understand the therapeutic benefits of that and truly hope Lisa is in a wonderful, peaceful place now, it didn't make for an engaging read for me. Even still, it was informative and thought provoking to gain insight into working in this field and in the government and the struggles it takes to try and be a successful woman, uninterrupted by spiteful men and apathetic bystanders who don't speak up for those who need it.

*Kindly received an ARC from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

*Thank you so much to the author, publisher, and NetGalley for the chance to review an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.*

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and Independent Publishers Group, Chicago Review Press for an ARC of this memoir.

Wow. I LOVED this memoir. All caps loved. What a fascinating subject to learn about and a fascinating badass lady to learn from. This book followed two different story lines in Lisa Bailey’s life: forensic anatomy and sculpture and the mistreatment of women in the FBI (and probably other government agencies historically run by only men).

I wanted to read this book from a weird art kid who finds true crime horrible, yet fascinating perspective. This was a memoir where I felt like I learned so much about what goes on behind the scenes in helping identify both victims and perpetrators (this book was definite brain candy in the learning category). Although I left as though I learned a lot, I was very invested in Bailey’s life and her cases. It was fascinating learning about how one may make age progressions as well as all the little details (and layers of clay) which go into the finished product of a facial approximation sculpture which the public might see.

I never knew that a skull could tell you so much about what a person might look like. Between nasal passages showing the size and slope of a nose, brow lines, and even fullness of cheeks, I was shocked at how individual each skull is to the individual.

Reading from a perspective of a woman in the FBI, also definitely gave some Clarice Starling vibes (for any Silence of the Lambs fans) throughout the book both with the unfair treatment as well as the protocols going into cases. Unfortunately for Bailey, her career in the FBI was riddled with misogyny and abuse of power by the men overseeing her departments. At times the level of abuse and the FBI’s inability to take action against the abusers was so frustrating that I almost had to stop reading. I mean even an idiot would be able to spot where the problem lies from miles away…but unfortunately the boy’s club still persists. Fingers crossed that this memoir is able to shed some light on the discrimination suffered by women in government agencies traditionally staffed by men.

10/10 you should 100% read this fascinating story.

Was this review helpful?

What a fascinating chance to peek into the life of the first female forensic sculptor in the FBI, and the book's author. I was intrigued by the blurb, and when I started reading the amount of forensic science information in this book, I was so captivated by it, that I couldn’t put it down. Intertwined with that information, I had a chance to read about the workplace environment and the way she was treated throughout her career.
I love to read crime stories and watch crime movies, and this book was so engaging and interesting to read, even more interesting for me because I had a chance to read about real work.
I recommend this book to everyone who likes to watch Bones and similar series.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley for the ARC of this book.

I enjoyed this book as a whole, there were lots of tidbits of really interesting information (who knew that about Sprite?) and both the author's talent and dedication to her work and the victims, was inspiring. Thank you Lisa.

That said, it was different than what I expected. The overarching theme of bullying within the workplace and the toxic-male dominance of the suit-toting dumbasses are important conversations worth having, but it felt like two different stories trying to mesh. For someone outside of the US, the very specific detailing about how the FBI works on a bureaucratic level was a taxing read for me personally.

Was this review helpful?

An interesting reflection on how the artist mind can be utilized to solve the most gruesome mysteries. Highly recommend and it felt reminiscent of Angela's character in Bones.

Was this review helpful?

Clay and Bones, written by Lisa Bailey, tells the story of her experiences as a forensic artist for the FBI. The title refers to the methods used to create a recognizable visage for identification. Lisa is an expert in the field and has been featured in interviews and on television. I thought her fascinating cases would be the subject of this memoir. They are not.

Working conditions for Lisa, one of the few women in the FBI, are horrendous. The harassment by her superiors is difficult to read. Her boss yells at her, coopts her work, gives her assignments that are nearly impossible to in a certain time frame and, in one case, sends her to a foreign country without allowing her time to have the necessary shots for protection. When she fights back, making complaints to HR sources as directed, she is disciplined. She believes that women in management positions will help her. They do not. Clay and Bones presents the FBI as a nest of interoffice intrigue, of discrimination and harassment. Lisa Bailey is to be admired for shining a light on this. I only hope her experiences, described so well in this searing novel, will bring necessary changes. 5 star.

Thank you to NetGalley, Independent Publishers Group and Lisa G. Bailey for this ARC.

Was this review helpful?

This title and the 'invitation' to read it intrigued me. I think that having a law enforcement officer for a father for part of my life has kept me interested in the things related to it. I received an advanced reader's copy of this book from the author, Independant Publishers Group and Chicago Review Press through NetGalley. This is my own unsolicited opinion about it.
The book was not what I expected. It tells of a young woman's journey to find and fight for a successful career in the early days of forensic artistry and investigation. It shows a bravery and will that kept her going when she was literally ignored, belittled and (my opinion) tormented by supervisors and the big boys (my sarcasm) who had 'earned' positions at the FBI. Her job should have been fascinating for me because I am interested in it. Her frank recollection of her days working with some good people, and some others that have honestly left me angry and disappointed for her and others who have worked in a terrible environment. She earned an amazing opportunity and huge challenges.
But, you need to read her story if interested. It's hers to tell.

Was this review helpful?

Clay And Bones is a hugely fascinating look at author's life as a first female forensic sculptor in the FBI.
Lisa Bailey tells her story with unflinching honesty and humility. We see the love and passion for her profession, ability and willingness to help solve crimes and to provide closure to families of victims of crime. But we also get to see the ugly and frankly sad side of the institution that is FBI.
I really enjoyed that frank memoir and would recommend it to anyone with interest in the art of forensic science.

Was this review helpful?