Cover Image: Lies My Teacher Told Me

Lies My Teacher Told Me

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

I ended up reading this at the library when it came out, and I really enjoyed it! Love the art style. I have already recommended it a couple times to patrons! Thank you to the publisher, author and Net Galley for an advanced copy of this book!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Netgalley for a copy for an honest review

I really enjoyed it and would highly recommend and I can’t wait to buy a copy for myself 🙂

Rating 4 stars ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Was this review helpful?

This is INCREDIBLY dense from a graphic novel perspective. I think it does a fabulous job at conveying the material in each section but for me and my preference it is too wordy. To like the traditional book with text on text on text on every page. Because of that I skimmed the book after I made it to page 100. I will be seeking the source material out to read audibly since that is a preferred method of reading especially non fiction. Thank you to net galley for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

This graphic non-fiction work seems meant to provide an introduction to many stories in the history of the United States that have been elided, ignored, or mistold by American high school history textbooks. Since it's only pointing out omissions and giving a very light gloss on what students could be taught, it's really only enough to start one's interest in these historical events and people—it would have benefited from the bibliographies and "further readings" that are apparently present in the original book by James W. Loewen, which this adapts (and which I haven't read). Without having read the original, I really appreciated the visual element of the storytelling here.

Was this review helpful?

This should be required reading! I know I'm going to be giving it to as many readers (teen and adult!) as possible.

The range of topics covered is amazing. I really appreciate that we dig into the WHY we leave things out of textbooks and WHY we present not-quite-true-facts. There's some big concepts in here that I'm excited for folks to delve into.

This book does an excellent job integrating image and words. Both work well to draw your eye across the page and keep you engaged. I can't imagine reading this book any other way!

Was this review helpful?

What you don’t know about American history could fill a book. In fact, the book is here and entitled Lies My Teacher Told Me.

This graphic true story tells the rest of the tales not told in traditional history books. It also corrects some frequently repeated outright falsehoods. Some are widely known, like there were natives already in America when it was founded and we viciously fought them for total control of their land. To lesser known facts, such as what is commonly labeled as fighting to end communism was really done to help multinational companies make money by installing puppet regimes amendable to their plans.

While this book laments boring and overly long textbooks, it unfortunately falls into the same trap. Instead of being a true graphic novel, Lies My Teacher Told Me is more like a lightly illustrated history textbook. The quantity of words on each page truly overwhelm any art found there. So while the concepts are thought provoking and need to see the light of day, I would recommend reading the original book rather than this graphic version. This book would have been much better if only a few select stories were shown graphically rather than the plethora of subjects tackled here. 3 stars.

Thanks to The New Press and NetGalley for a digital review copy of the book.

Was this review helpful?

I was unaware of this book originally being released in the 90’s until after reading this graphic novel version. That being said I had no prior expectations of this book. Having the subject of American history being turned into content that is informative in a digestible manner is no easy feat. Lies My Teacher Told Me tries to do just that. I think this graphic novel would be a cool supplementary format in high school classrooms that would make learning American history interesting. There are many details in school books that are outdated and missing important information that are still used in classrooms today. That being said this book is heavy on text for a graphic novel and to be honest I think it still needs to include more information on each topic. It’s a cool concept but I did find that very important part lacking. It’s not something I would depend on for all my history information but I think it was good as a better peak in what many of us were never taught in school. The illustrations were great and helped in driving the book forward. I think it would have better off in a series with focusing on each decade per book to really get more info in.

Thanks to The New Press and NetGalley for the Arc and opportunity to review it.

Was this review helpful?

I was interested in this book mostly because I had read the original book and wanted to see how it was adapted into a graphic novel format. Overall it was good, although there were sections of pretty lengthy text in somewhat small font. It was moments like this that made me question the effectiveness of the medium for this text. I just wonder how many people who wouldn't have read the original version would pick up (and complete) this adaption. Having read and enjoyed the original, I enjoyed this as well.

Was this review helpful?

As a history teacher I read a lot of "This is what really happened" books. I love them and love including them in my curriculum. But this one is different. It actually goes into the why we have incorrect history and why it is so important to include different histories. Most of the stories included were ones that I have heard before, but this book should be required reading for all history teachers.

4 stars

Was this review helpful?

This work is perfect for students, educators and history buff. Add this title to high school library collections. Parents may also enjoy this title, but I don't see it being enjoyed as widely by the general teen and adult audience outside of a school setting. Great illustrations and content.

Was this review helpful?

I wanted to look at this book before purchasing it for the library—when looking through other reviews, some said that the ratio of text to images was weighted pretty heavily towards text. It does have a lot of text, and I think if they'd given the book a higher page count maybe they could have space things out a bit better. But for its size and the amount of information conveyed, I get the ratio. Overall I like it—the illustrations were well done, and the text is inline with the original so it's pretty much what I expected. Maybe some will read it that wouldn't read the book, with the lower word count, but I'm not completely sure with how much text is included on each page. It should be interesting to see-I did go ahead and decide to give it a shot in our collection. Thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for letting me check out the advance copy!

Was this review helpful?

5/5 Stars for the intended audience (students, educators, and as supplemental history reading). Personal rating of 4/5 stars.

In a classroom, library, or homeschool setting, Lies My Teacher Told Me would probably be devoured over and over. It has excellent art, thorough topics, and fascinating stories. For me personally, I probably wouldn't reread it outside of an educational setting.

Thanks to the publisher for an advanced review copy!

Was this review helpful?

Nate Powell is an amazing and talented visual storyteller and he has a vision for society and a better world. A wonderful read and smart adaptation.

Was this review helpful?

"American history is longer, larger, more various, more beautiful, and more terrible than anything anyone has ever said about it." This opening quote from James Baldwin sets the tone for the rest of this essential and eye opening book, now in powerful and skilfully drawn graphic adaptation. This edition effectively summarizes the original text, and the graphic format and evocative illustrations add depth and connection to the material, in a way that is accessible and engaging, especially for young adult readers.

The whitewashed narrative of U.S. History which has been traditionally taught to students has prioritized nationalistic pride over factual information; spinning, lionizing, sanitizing, or even outright lying, leaving generations misinformed and unable to connect the past to the present in accurate or meaningful ways, to understand marginalized perspectives, or to apply the lessons of the past to decisions which impact our future.

The author analyses multiple U.S. History textbooks and the ways in which they often fail to accurately present historical truths, and asks essential questions about why this has been, and continues to be, the case. Who decides how history is interpreted - whose perspective matters, whose story matters, and what is emphasized (or even invented) and what is left out? Who benefits from this interpretation, and who is harmed by it? What is the purpose of the text - to encourage critical thought or to support the status quo? History textbooks are often written and taught with an eye to avoid offending school boards, parents, or the public, or making students (specifically white students) "uncomfortable". But History isn't supposed to make us feel good, just as Algebra or Chemistry are not meant to make us feel good, and any History curriculum with a focus on justifying, appeasing, or comforting, does so at the expense of the truth.

Without teaching students the causes that led to events, the different options that were available but not taken, and the ways those actions influenced later events, we deprive them of the tools to understand and contextualize history or to connect it to their present lives. When we teach students that events of history are divorced from each other and occur in isolation, they appear random and illogical instead of connected and consequential. People are entitled to their own opinions, but not to their own facts. Truth is still truth even if it reflects poorly on individuals or groups, or causes cognitive dissonance for those invested in a narrative that absolves their complicity or harm. Presenting a sanitized, heroic Columbus to students is both an easily disprovable lie and a cruel invalidation of the tremendous harm he caused. Promoting the fiction that the U.S. Civil War was about state's rights instead of slavery and white supremacy contradicts what Confederate states clearly (and verifiably) expressed about their objectives and motivations. Pretending that the 9-11 terrorist attacks were rooted in "jealousy of our freedom" completely ignores the contribution of U.S. actions to the circumstances that caused it, or the warnings that were ignored.

The myth of American Exceptionalism, and the view of its domestic and foreign actions through the "Global Good Guy" lens, prevents a full and factual reckoning of U.S. history, comprehension of its impact, or of perceptions of its impact outside of its own white hegemonic narrative. In teaching history this way, we discourage critical thought, we discourage empathy, and we discourage activism and change. But we have the ability, and the responsibility, to do better.

This book is exceptionally well-researched, well-written, informative, and insightful, and an essential companion to standard education materials. This graphic adaptation makes a more accurate and nuanced historical understanding accessible and approachable, especially for students or people who are turned off and disconnected from the way History is usually presented. I will be purchasing a copy of the graphic adaptation as well as the latest edition of the full text version for my family.

I'm thankful to the publisher and to Netgalley for providing me with a free advance reader copy of the book in exchange for my honest review. All opinions expressed are my own.

Was this review helpful?

As I’ve gotten older, I’ve gotten more and more curious about all the small bits of history that were altered or left out of my learning experience. Bit by bit, I have been trying to fill in the gaps, so when I saw this on NetGalley, I was quick to jump on it. I was glad I did.

With it being in a graphic novel format, I figured there would be a lot of information here, but condensed. I was partly right, there was a lot of information here. Each page is filled with not only illustrations to help sell the point, but information galore. This is something that you need to give your time too. You are going to want to take your time with this one.

There was a lot of information in here that I didn’t know while other bits were something I have learned on my journey to learn more, so were only reinforced here. Throughout the nearly 300 pages, there are a lot of topics covered, each one vastly important. It brings up things I’ve never thought about like why the textbook authors are writing to pacify instead of the truth. How the teaching of history needs to change, etc. It really leads to an eye-opening experience overall.

The illustrations were nice and managed to relate some of the text to more current events, which I think was important (if not a little discouraging as things haven’t changed) to help remind readers of how current events can still relate to the past, which was a nice theme this had throughout the novel.

Absolutely, this is a book I would recommend. At the beginning of some chapters there is a page to take notes or write down questions that you have as you read. I loved this idea and would absolutely take advantage of this so I can dive deeper into some of these topics.

For anyone who wants to learn more about American history, and even if you aren’t but live in the United States, I highly recommend picking this up and taking your time as you read through this.

Was this review helpful?

Lies My Teach Told Me is what I needed when I didn't know I needed it. I'm glad to do the work to learn for myself. Teaching of history should definitely be overhauled. This book would make a great supplement to American school teaching (if only administrators/politicians would care for you to know it). I'd advocate for something like this to be added to maybe mandatory optional summer reading lists. Many parents need to read this too. Knowledge is power; however, many people in the majority don't want the minority to have that power, but that is a whole other lesson. Hence, what this book talks about.

I love it covered a huge variety of topics from colonialism, racism, class structure, sexism, teaching style, who writes text books, politics, private corporations influence on politics and foreign affairs, and the environment. I took more notes reading this book than any other book I have read. I'd suggest people buy this book physically and annotate in it. I will say this book has a strong point of view which leads toward biasness. It also leaves out certain details to show the complete story, which I wouldn't mind knowing. Like how did Republications who were first on the side of minorities, then flip to be against them. Overall, great book that sparks a conversation. I'm glad to have read it.

Was this review helpful?

I received a complimentary copy of this book via Netgalley. Opinions expressed in this review are my own

Once again I love an educational graffic novel.. For myself, I lt helps retain the information.

I did find some pages hard to read (white writing on black), other then that great book.

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed reading this book in graphic novel form, and I think in a lot of ways it makes the content of this book even more accessible to a young audience.

Was this review helpful?

I had always meant to read the original 'Lies My Teacher Told Me' so when I saw the graphic adaption, I figured I would give it a try. I think it was a good adaptation, and of course, the original intention behind the work is perhaps even more meaningful today. The only hesitation I have is that I would think that the main reason to do a graphic novel adaptation would be to make it more appealing to middle school/high schoolers, but the way the text was still written, I'm not sure that it would be effective. The reading level of this graphic adaptation appears to still be quite high, and it seems like there would still be a lot that would need further explanation. As such, I think this would be better to accompany additional lessons from a teacher, rather than be read independently.

Was this review helpful?

I loved this book. The graphics are well done and the content is so much fun. You are reviewing the bits of history that were missed or just wrong. This book is good for several different age levels.

Was this review helpful?