The Shadowhunter Chronicles meets Chinese diaspora folklore in Darker by Four, the first in an epic contemporary fantasy duology from Jade Fire Gold author June Tan.

I love Ava Reid, but this isn’t my favorite of hers. There was a lot of creative liberty that went into this reimagining of Lady Macbeth, but I’m not sure they were necessarily for the best. Overall the story was well written and well paced, I’m just not sure I liked where Ava ran with it,

For Shakespeare, Lady Macbeth is the driving force behind nearly all of her husband’s ambition. For Reid, she remains the impetus for all the action to come, but rather than longing to be “unsexed,” she schemes to protect herself from the cruelty of the men around her. From the moment she asks her husband for a necklace and he launches his attack on Cawdor, all of their fates are sealed. This version of Lady Macbeth is not innocent, her hands are not clean, and she still has visions of blood dripping from her fingers.

The majority of the main story beats remain intact, however the journey to get there is often quite different. The story will be a surprise, even for those who are intimately familiar with the source material.

Overall, an adaptation that honors the original, while still managing to be distinct.

Ava Reid never disappoints! From the very first page, Reid's poetic writing style made this one of my favorite reads of the year. I liked how Reid explored a background for Lady Macbeth and humanized her. I'm vaguely familiar with Shakespeare's play, enough that I knew how the story was going to go, but Reid added so much detail and worldbuilding that this felt like an original novel. I don't think that knowledge of the play is necessarily needed to read this book.

Ok so I've decided that your enjoyment of this book is going to hinge entirely on how much you remember of Macbeth (if you have read it). I read it in high school, and maybe a second time in college and have semi-recently read a graphic adaptation from the perspective of the witches. And so, I don't like, remember it super well, but I remember it well enough to remember Lady Macbeth being highly entertaining evil badass who talked Macbeth into most of his worst deeds (she's basically like, "you can't be a king without a few murders, shrug" iirc). And that is not what is happening in this book at all. Reading the book's description, I was kind of thinking we'd get like, Lady Macbeth: Homelander Edition where she went around just wholesale murdering folks with laser eyes or something, but I got a simpering 17-year-old instead who spends a lot of the book (justifiably) cowering in fear. And I might have liked it more if I weren't expecting...well, Lady Macbeth. So, I think folks who are unfamiliar with the character might like it, but it wasn't for me. I saw another reviewer mention that it might have been better if it were framed as a Bluebeard re-telling, and that's a great take.

My other issue seems to be a draw for other reviewers, and that's the writing style. It's again a matter of preference, but it somehow read as paradoxically too spare and too wordy. I don't know! It's hard to articulate, but it wasn't doing it for me. My thoughts may have also been colored by my aforementioned disappointment in the character.

It was ok - like I can understand why people would like it, because it wasn't bad, it just was so wildly different from what I was expecting. So, 2 stars.

Thanks to Netgalley and Del Rey for the eARC which I received in exchange for an unbaised review. Lady Macbeth is out in August!

Ava Reid’s writing gets better and better with each book they publish. Macbeth has always been one of my favorite Shakespeare plays, and her take on play feels fresh while staying true to the key elements of the original

I’m going to need 3-5 business days to recover because WOW. I was chilled to the bone the entire time I was reading, which is exactly what a horror novel should do. Reid cultivates such an excellent sense of dread with their authorial voice. The word choice and atmosphere are immaculate, and now I desperately want to visit Inverness.

Note - this retelling is very different from the original Macbeth in characterization and tone. Just be aware.

Thank you Del Rey and NetGalley for the digital ARC. I will be preordering immediately.

Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC!

I have always loved Macbeth, so seeing that this would be a retelling from Lady Macbeth's POV was a slam dunk for me. The choice to make her a 17 year old girl instead of an older adult woman threw me, but it really worked. The plot does differ significantly from that of the play (there's a dragon and Macbeth dies differently). I think the characters we dynamic and the dark and moody atmosphere was great. Pacing is fairly slow, but I still managed to finish it in a few days. The witches in this were so good!

Just a heads up for folks: there was a pretty rough torture scene and one scene of marital rape (not graphic).

As much as I absolutely loved Junior & Thorn, this is the second novel by Ava Reid that I wasn’t a fan of. A Study In Drowning was easily set to be my new favorite book of 2023 — a gothic dark academia story focusing on mythology, misogyny and the way women are treated in exclusive academic spaces. Yet, I didn’t love it. With Lady Macbeth, I feel the same way. A feminist, moody retelling of Shakespeare’s Macbeth, it had all the ingredients to make for a compelling read, but the outcome was quite dull. Reid’s prose, as usual, is exceptional, but I wasn’t keen on the characterization or her interpretation of Macbeth itself. I’m still looking forward to whatever Reid puts out next, but I’m hoping it’s more in the style of Juniper & Thorn.

Ava Reid can do no wrong. This book is all of the things you could want in a Shakespeare retelling. It’s gritty and gothic and unapologetically filled with female rage. The perspective of lady Macbeth is not a perspective I knew I wanted until I had it. Lady Macbeth was reflective, poetic, and brilliant. I highlighted so many of Reid’s beautiful quotes because her prose was blowing my mind.

Our main character, Roscille, was brave and fascinating, flawed and dark. The way that she used her cleverness as a weapon and outsmarted the people around her had me hooting and hollering. The subtle love story was just enough to make me swoon, but wasn’t a main part of the story at all. Still, it was incredibly sweet and spicy in a book full of caution and violence. I cannot wait for this book to be out in the world in August!!

LADY MACBETH was one of my most anticipated reads this year and has turned into one of my most conflicting reads ever. I have a special attachment to the Lady since I was her in a play once, and Macbeth is tied for Twelfth Night as my favorite Shakespeare play, so I have to admit I got up and screamed when I saw Ava Reid was writing a Lady Macbeth reimagining and then did it again when I was accepted for the ARC.

I'll start with the good things first, because to be clear, I do not regret reading this book. The writing style was beyond gorgeous and I was spellbound by the craft put in at the sentence level. Every time I had to put the book down, it only took a line for me to be back into the bleak, gothic setting, and I know I will be returning to study this style. I also loved the linguistic care paid attention to the shifting names and rejection of allowing one language to dominate the landscape. It was naturally done and I was never confused by it, so it remained one of my favorite things about the book once I'd finished.

Character wise, I enjoyed Roscille and Lisander the most as characters who are regularly divorced from humanity, a theme that has always been important to me; I think the characterization was strong and Macbeth loomed larger than life in a way I liked reading about. But I think I enjoyed Roscille more as her own character. Comparing her to the Lady Macbeth many know and love is where my disappointment begins to creep in.

As I've mentioned, Lady Macbeth is an important character to me, but I also love ruthless, cunning, conniving women. When I heard reimagining, I was excited to see what had been crafted of her personality and backstory. For such an iconic character, there is little established about her; there was an endless possibility of directions to choose, and while I liked what was offered, I liked less that it was what was offered for her specifically.

If you're attached to the bloodthirsty middle-aged woman who shamed her husband for weakness, you will not find her here, and I'm not sure you will even find the start of her here. In her place, we are offered Roscille, a 17-year-old French bride sold off to the hulking, violent Macbeth. Her witch-touched nature had created a reputation of inducing madness, and so she arrives veiled and adrift with a plan to keep herself from the marriage bed as long as she is able. She has been trained to be clever and at first succeeds at her ploys easily, but has to work harder to arrange the pieces as she wishes as Macbeth's madness grows and she meets unexpected roadblocks.

I want to stress that I love Roscille as Roscille. But offered as a spin on Lady Macbeth, she and her worldview fall flat. I found myself craving nuance or at least a small challenge to Roscille's intense xenophobia and prejudice against Scottish men (I would absolutely not recommend this one to Scottish readers), but as it was, the gender politics felt flatly crafted and gave an unfortunate one-dimensional view of most of the male characters surrounding Roscille. I think this also lended to the disappointing declawing of one of my favorite ambitious female characters; Roscille is passively reacting to a world that was historically sexist, but even in sexist societies women have their own power and value to wield.

In the end, I think I just don't agree with what seems to be the foundation for this reimagining, which is that women being portrayed as villainous is a fault of men around her finding her mad and uncontrollable. This feels less of a roadmap for a young Lady Macbeth sharpening her teeth and more like a defensive defanging, which I don't think was fully sold to me. If this had been an original story with the names changed, I probably would have been in love with it. But as it stands, I adore evil, ruthless female characters, and though I can admit most of my disappointment is probably self-inflicted for entering this book with too many expectations, this did not end up being the Lady Macbeth I've adored for much of my life but instead a sweeping, enchantingly painted portrait with a disappointing subject.

If you are a fan of beautiful prose and aren't quite as attached to Lady Macbeth as me, I would still recommend this book, even just to hear what you think about it.

I absolutely love Ava Reid’s prose and will read anything she writes. Lady Macbeth fell a little short on the momentum for me, but picked up on the latter half and I breezed through it. I would have loved more depth on certain plot-lines and characters, but nonetheless this was still a great read. For anyone who loves a good, classic, retelling, this is a perfect pick. I look forward to the official release and will be buying a copy.

3.5/5 STARS: Another solid work from Ava Ried. Will post a full review on Instagram post release day! @haileysgoodbooks

I really, really wanted to love this one, but for me it was just an okay book.

I thought the actual writing was beautiful, but I did not connect with how this retelling was done.

I think some other people might enjoy it tho based off other reviews!

Thank you NetGalley and DelRay for the eARC in exchange for an honest review.

I'm a big Shakespeare fan, so I felt pretty confident I would love this book from the get-go. I did not, however, know the writing would be utterly luscious. I floated through this book as though caught in the haze behind Roscille's veil. I don't mean the story didn't feel grounded; it did. I mean the whole book read like a sharp-toothed dream. By showing this story from Roscille's point of view, Ava Reid makes this age-old classic brand new. It is dark and harsh and cold as Glammis castle's stone, but it has a secret soft underbelly for those who follow it to its end...just as Glammis castle has secrets for those bold enough to search for them.

This was ambitious and she easily delivered. This book is like time traveling to a world where women are powerless. This lady Macbeth is different from the original. She’s trying to stay one step ahead of her husband. Masterminding her way through the fragile male ego.

10/10
No notes
This was incredible. I wasn't a HUGE fan of the idea of making Macbeth this Gigachad dude-bro toxic masculine character as I've always kind of read him as less than confident-- but this take on the story really works for me. This will be one that should be read in schools. Thank you, Net Galley, for providing me with an ARC of Lady Macbeth. I savored every sentence.

I absolutely loved this book and consumed it with a ferocity akin to the characters within the book. As the title indicates, this story is a retelling of one of Shakespeare’s darker stories, Macbeth but from the perspective of Lady Macbeth herself. I loved the authenticity Ava Reid brought to the time period and her ability to provide us with an incredibly complex and richly developed Lady Macbeth. Ava Reid’s prose is beautiful and her ability to create these spooky, ethereal and gothic worlds is top notch.

Lady Macbeth takes the reader on a very wild ride. At one point I told my friend that this book was giving me major Game of Thrones red wedding vibes and honestly that vibe never dissipated; it slowly grew and blossomed into a masterpiece in fury and revenge. Lady Macbeth is beautiful and savage, calculated and ruthless, intelligent and empathetic. I could go on and on forever.

If you love a good retelling, fantastical or classic, with a beautiful mix of horror please check this out when it hits shelves on August 13th.

There were parts of this I really loved, parts I didn't fully understand, and parts where the story seemed to drag. I'm not sure I have the necessary affinity for the source material to really appreciate this retelling. That said, the prose was beautiful, something I expect (and love about!) Ava Reid, even if the story itself wasn't always for me.

A novel based upon Shakespeare's play. Some license is taken with the story line. It's an interesting take on the play.