Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Thank you to NetGalley for this ARC! This is my honest review.

Plot: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️.5
Spice: 🌶️🌶️
Character Development: ♥️♥️♥️♥️


This was a very beautiful love story. I really enjoyed the musical element to it all and how the music was used to tell the story too. This was wasn’t as funny as I was hoping though. Much much more serious of a story. I wished we had more time with some of the side characters. I loved Jake and Declan!

It was hard at first to figure out how these two feel I love outside of just the music. Months and months go by in this story but we don’t see very many conversations between the two characters.

The spice was spicy but also just a little boring. Like each science was kind of the same and it was a lot of describing but the characters need to talk more during that spice.

I absolutely loved the ending. The resolutions to many of the conflicts were great. I felt really happy for all of the characters by the end.

Over all I did truly love this story. Beautifully written and the musical element was gorgeous.

Was this review helpful?

The way this book consumed me is unbelievable I literally finished it in one day. I was BLUSHING SO HARD I SAW RED. Who knew that music can be both secy and romantic. I’m at a point in my life where I want to become a musical prodigy just to have that tension the mmc and fmc had. It was so ANGSTY, TENSION FILLED, PHENOMENAL story. I cannot recommend this enough, this was a complete step up to Julie Sotos other work “forget me not” which was another amazing work by her. But this book? I want to see it on TV.

Was this review helpful?

I'm really not sure what to say about Julie Soto's sophomore novel. It got to me on such an emotional - yearning level. I started it at 9 pm the date I received the ARC, thinking I would read a few chapters before falling asleep. I ended up finishing the book at a little past 1 am. I have a 4:30 am alarm.

You see the illustration on the cover? yeah, it's an actual scene in the book. and oh boy, was that a good scene.

Bonus - little nods to the Forget Me Not gang.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed Julie Soto's debut but i LOVED Not Another Love Song. I can not believe how much I enjoyed this book! I did not think that a romance in am orchestra would pull me in as much as it did. The charcters were so interesting and felt very fleshed out. I figured out pretty quickly that this was going to be a book written for me. The dynamic between Gwyn and Alex was so good to watch evolve and see flourish by the ending. I loved every second of it and can not wait to tell everyone about how great it is.

Was this review helpful?

5/5 ⭐️

Wow holy cow Julie really did the damn thing with this one. Not Another Love Song is a story of two people yearning to find their places, and they end up finding eachother. In this story you have our fmc Gwen, the orphaned violinist who was taught by sweet grouchy Mabel, grow from being this timid people pleaser to someone with a newly grown backbone. Did she frustrate me from times? yes, but i can understand her running away from goodbyes trauma issues so it was an easy to get over being annoyed.
Alex/Xander is that type A music prodigy all band kids wished they could have been growing up. He dealt with his struggles of feeling "enough" throughout his teen years until he had enough and became 'Xander Thorne' to let go and know he was the best at what he did. This man had me giggling with his words and how he expresses his love to Gwen, even though i wanted to throw hands in the beginning of the book not understanding his feelings for her until they were explained 😅😂

These two come together so beautifully, and the music they create with one another had me teary eyed multiple times. I absolutely adored this couple and the ending made me so fulfilled.

Thank you again NetGalley and Forever books for this ARC in exchange for my honest opinion ♡

Was this review helpful?

An enemies-to-lovers romance set in an orchestra?!! I think Julie Soto wrote this SPECIFICALLY for me!!! Started this on a plane ride and COULD NOT PUT IT DOWN. Loved everything about this book!

Was this review helpful?

I really liked Forget Me Not by Julie Soto so I was so excited to read her new book, Not Another Love Song. I loved this one even more. I connected more with the characters and felt like they had great chemistry. I think it was such an interesting take for the characters to communicate romance better through music instead of words. There were some really beautiful moments described that I think will stick long after. I’m looking forward to more from this author. Thank you so much to NetGalley and Forever (Grand Central Publishing for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for an advanced copy of this book.

I really enjoyed Julie Soto’s previous work and I was very excited to read Not Another Love Song and it did not disappoint. This was such a unique love story that was just so well done. The chemistry between Gwen and Alex jumped off the page. Highly recommend.

Was this review helpful?

Forget Me Not was a favorite of 2023 but this one still managed to surpass it and cement Julie Soto as one of my favorite authors. I had little to no interest in orchestra going into this book and now I’m obsessed. Amazing story, very well researched and completely swoon worthy.

Was this review helpful?

Julie Soto has done it again! As a big fan of her fan fics, I came in with big expectations for a great read and was not disappointed. She really knows how to build a world around the characters she creates. In this case, I found myself fully engrossed in the NY orchestra scene, almost like pulling the curtain was pulled back on their real lives. You feel invested in their story and are of course rooting for them! I enjoyed the bits of mystery about some characters pasts, and of course the ROMANCE! Always respectful, always so sexy! All this book needs is a companion soundtrack (suggestion: play the songs as they are mentioned to set your reading mood!) and a snuggly corner to read in. Hope you check out this book and enjoy it as much as I did. I am already waiting for Julie's next book!

Was this review helpful?

It's hard to talk about how much I loved this book without talking about myself, but I'm going to try. I loved this. I loved how obviously gone Alex was for Gwen from the very beginning. I loved the found family element. And that cello scene
But man, I loved watching them fall in love. Sharing a love of something like music brings people together in a way that Giuliesotowrites was able to articulate so well. It changes you, that love, and you're never the same. So grateful l was able to pick up this ARC. Can't wait for others to read it when it comes out in July!

Was this review helpful?

Not Another Love Song by Julie Soto was such a refreshing romance. It was really well written and story that had a unique voice.
I think this will be enjoyed by most!

Was this review helpful?

"Not Another Love Song" by Julie Soto offers a delightful blend of romance and music, making it a captivating read for fans of both genres. With its innovative characters and unique premise, the novel provides an engaging storyline that keeps readers hooked from beginning to end. Soto skillfully weaves together themes of love and passion against a backdrop of musical inspiration, creating a truly enjoyable reading experience. Overall, "Not Another Love Song" is a perfect choice for romance enthusiasts looking for a fun and refreshing tale!

Was this review helpful?

Gwen Jackson is content with her music career. As a violinist in the Manhattan Pops orchestra, she feels at home. She is surprised when she is offered the First Chair position but happily accepts. Cellist and fellow Pops musician Xander Thorne has been wanting that position and he doesn't hide the fact that he doesn't think she deserves it. As Gwen and Xander get to know each other, it's clear that they have an undeniable chemistry, on and off the stage.

I am utterly amazed by this book! Julie Soto's writing is flawless and she tells a story that will suck you into the music world. I am not a musician and I have not had the pleasure of going to professional orchestra performances. This book has made me an orchestra fan, without ever having seen one. Soto's research for this book must have been painstaking, but it was worth it because the attention to detail in this book is astounding.

What I loved most about this book was that Soto weaved music with emotions seamlessly. The passion that Xander and Gwen had for creating moved me. I had never thought violins and cellos could be sexy, but HOT DAMN!!! There was a sensuality to their playing that had me thrumming with excitement.

I was intrigued by Xander's story. There were so many layers to his history and who he was as a person and I enjoyed how Soto peeled back those layers, little by little. I couldn't have been more happy for him to have found happiness with Gwen after all those years of being lost in other people's expectations.

This is a remarkable book that is a 2024 MUST READ!!!

Steam level: 🔥🔥🔥

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC!
3.5 ⭐️

I'm going to start by talking about what I enjoyed the most— I really liked how the author put care in their careers and it was not just a background in the story. I don't personally know much about music or the instruments they play but you can feel that it wasn't just there for the sake of being there, it was either something the author already lived or put a lot of care in researching (in this case we know its the former because of the notes). I admire it even more because I know a lot of romance readers wouldn't care if it was there just for the background, and for this reason I think it might not please some. But it did please me.
However, as much as I enjoyed this part of the story, I felt like the first part of the book focused too much on it at left the romance a little behind for later to focus more on the romance and I feel like that shoud have been more balanced out. I felt like they deserved more development before things started happening between them, they needed to have interacted more.
Overall it was an enjoyable experience, I like Julie's writing, I liked the characters and the couple had chemistry (something I'm finding hard to find in romances lately). I feel like if the next books does not have the issues I had with this, she could become one of my favorite romance authors!

Was this review helpful?

I just finished Not Another Love Song by Julie Soto maybe 20 minutes ago, and I can’t quite tell if I’m crying happy tears or not - I am very much still recovering from that ending!

I’ll start off with: this is NOT your typical romance novel, it is a gosh darn masterpiece. How Julie manages to make orchestral music sound sexy is beyond me? I am not a classical music person, I don’t listen to strings, and, quite honestly, know next to nothing about music. Yet, Julie manages to make music flow so smoothly with the plot - when she says Allegro, the pace of the words match that!

Music aside, I am so in love with both Gwen and Xander. I appreciate that both of them are individuals, with their own hopes and dreams and that Gwen doesn’t just bend herself for this hot-sexy mans she’s been dreaming about. Their love story was real, it was believable, and it makes me want to convince me boyfriend to start learning an instrument with me!

All in all, this is the perfect romance to read for the summer - for me, it’s a 4.5⭐️ and 3🌶️! Not Another Love Song publishes July 16, 2024 - thank you to Julie Soto and NetGalley for giving me the opportunity to read this one💗

Was this review helpful?

Julie Soto knows how to deliver the perfect romance, and Not Another Love Song just might by my favorite romance to date! Gwen and Xander are so  perfect together! I loved watching them go from what seemed an incompatible couple, with Xander being a bit of a grump to him being vulnerable with her and showing her his true self. They fit perfectly together... "..a cello who fell in love with a violin." xo

Thank you NetGalley, Forever (Grand Central Publishing), and Julie Soto for this read!

Was this review helpful?

I knew within 40 pages that this would be a 5 star read. This story was so amazing, Gwen and Alex’s romance is hot, and passionate and beautiful. This book made me laugh, cry and everything in between. There were several times while I was reading where I would literally have to restrain myself from reading further as this book should be SAVORED. When I made it to 50% through I was devastated. I could read about these characters forever.
The YEARNING!!!!!!!!!!!!! Alex is my new favorite book boyfriend by far. Men should take a note from Alex and start yearning again.
I loved all the side characters as well, every time Mei was on page I knew I would be laughing. I also loved bringing Ama and Elliot back!!!
I live in New York and this book really felt like a real love letter to the city and the music scene here.
I cannot say enough about how much I loved this book.

Was this review helpful?

Rating: ★★★★½ (4.5 very enthusiastic stars)

Julie Soto's upcoming book, "Not Another Love Song," is a captivating addition to her universe, where our favorite wedding planning duo Ama and Elliot find themselves expanding their wedding gigs to the East Coast. Enter Gwen Jackson, a Manhattan Pops violin prodigy with talent, charm, and magnetism in spades.

Little did Ama know Gwen plays the violin, NOT the cello, as the bride wanted. So, with a little help from the handsome, musical royalty, and rockstar cellist (and fellow Manhattan Pops musician) Xander Thorne, Gwen decides to improvise and play the cello, catching Xander’s attention for the first time.

The palpable chemistry between Gwen and Xander leaps off the page, as they make music together that jumps off the page and makes you feel it and hear it, even when you are just reading it. Their magnetic relationship is a joy to read, as they challenge and inspire each other to new heights, playing music outside their comfort zones and creating art together. One of my favorite things about Julie Soto is how she engages you, keeping you invested in the characters' journey from start to finish. I, for one, was shipping them from the first chapter.

Gwen and Xander quickly became one of my favorite book couples, and I truly loved experiencing their musical journey together. "Not Another Love Song" is a testament to Julie Soto's talent for crafting compelling stories and characters that readers can't help but root for.

Thanks to Netgalley for an advanced copy of this book!

Was this review helpful?

“I need to be in your orbit”

Contrary to its title Not Another Love Song is in fact an intense and poetic love story! Filled with angst and music this book is one that I flew through because it was such an effortless read.

Gwen Jackson has not had things easy. She lost her mom at an early age and befriends the owner of a music shop who teaches her to play the violin. Xander Thorne is a gifted musician who is born into music royalty and struggles to find fame on his own terms. When Gwen is offered First Chair of the Manhattan Orchestra, a position Xander has secretly coveted, they immediately butt heads but their hostility soon fades to deep attraction.

The chemistry between Gwen and Xander is intense! There is a definite soulmate vibe between the two throughout the entire novel that is undeniable. I, myself have never played an instrument and am not musically inclined however I can appreciate the care and attention to detail that Julie used as she crafted this beautiful story. Lots of spice in this one too so if that is something you enjoy in a romance book then this is a fantastic pick!

Overall, I really enjoyed this one and it reminded me a lot of her first book, Forget Me Not, which I loved so if you were a fan of that one, I would definitely recommend giving this one a try!

Was this review helpful?