So I didn't realize this was book 3 in a series, and had to go back and read books 1 and 2 because I am not unhinged and go blindly into the middle of a series. But overall this is adorable. I am adding this series to every single one of my fall witchy spooky season book recommendation lists. I've said before how I don't enjoy a second chance romance trope, but I guess when we are dealing with witches it completely captivates me. I love how a big theme within this series is about women "finding themselves" and coming into their own. Is this the most fantasy forward/well developed story? No. But it absolutely is perfect if you want a warm and cozy, hallmark feeling during witchy season. I emphasize the time of year because I don't think this book hit has strongly reading it spring or summertime. Will definitely be picking up book 4.

I love a fall witchy book and I liked that this explored some things not typically in romance - like pregnancy - but it was pretty repetitive at times, tighter editing would have made this a lot better! Otherwise I enjoyed and it was a fun read for the season!

Great end to the series! One of the best small town witchy series I’ve read. Love these and highly recommend all the books especially this one

Thanks Netgally for the ARC!

I didn't realize that this story was part of a series, though it could be read as a standalone. With that being said, I think I would have enjoyed this better had I read the first two in the series first. I really loved the witchy vibes that this cozy book brought, and will read the other two books soon!

When I read the first book in this series (which I also loved, by the way), these were the characters I was really looking forward to reading about. Ellowyn and Zander are clearly meant to be, and between their romance and the ever-growing drama of St. Cyprian, I had a great time with Truly Madly Magically.

This book had such a cozy, magical vibe—I really enjoyed the whimsical elements and how they blended with the romance. It felt like reading a warm hug.

Great addition to the series from Hazel Beck. Very clearly sets up the fourth and final book with a third point of view.

This was by far my favorite book of the series so far! I 1) love a pregnancy trope and 2) felt the most connected to these characters. I think it helped that the world was more developed and even the character's backstories were already pretty well hashed out. It allowed the book to be more plot focused while still developing the characters. I'm really hoping for more about Ellowyn and Zander's new family but I'm realizing it would be after the events of the last book take place :(
The only criticism I have is that element of the fairytale story that is going to come into play with the final book. Obviously this is a fantasy series with witches and ghosts but so far there hasn't been any indication that fantastical creatures like dragons exist in this universe so its odd that the authors are all of a sudden introducing that for the final book of the series.

This was a cozy book. I enjoyed the plot and the characters. I want to read more from this author and series.

I am Truly, Madly, Magically in love with Hazel Beck and the world they both (yes, the author is a pair of women) have created. This book builds beautifully upon the first few and I so enjoyed continuing in this world. Ellowyn steps into her own and maybe we learn, grown and heal alongside her as she learns to trust again.

Thank you to Netgalley and the Publishing Company for this Advanced Readers Copy of Truly Madly Magically by Hazel Beck!

This book wraps up a lot of things in the series in a really nice way. I loved the prickly Ellowyn's perspective and story, and this was entertaining, sweeping, and interesting.

If you’re looking for something light, sweet, easy, entertaining, and thoughtful… read this book and the rest of the Witchlore series! This series is a cozy fun read packed with emotion. Ellowyn was such a fun FMC to follow, and her story felt incredibly emotional and tender. I really enjoyed her journey with Zander. So far, all of the Hazel Beck books in the Witchlore series have a great focus of women finding themselves and coming into their own. This story just makes you all warm and fuzzy by the end.

This book is such a cute, fall, magical realism read! The growth of the FMC was amazing the follow throughout, just like the rest of the Witchlore books. This book with hook. you in and make you emotionally invested in all the characters!

Book Review: Truly Madly Magically by Hazel Beck
⭐️⭐️⭐️ (3/5)

In Truly Madly Magically, the third installment of the Witchlore series, Hazel Beck centers the narrative on Ellowyn Good, a half-witch cursed to always tell the truth. Ellowyn grapples with her place in the Riverwood coven and confronts past emotions involving her first love, Zander. As the malevolent Joywood coven targets her, Ellowyn must collaborate with her coven and navigate her complex relationship with Zander to survive.

Beck's portrayal of Ellowyn and Zander's rekindled relationship offers a heartfelt exploration of second chances. The narrative delves into their past misunderstandings and personal growth, providing depth to their renewed connection.

However, the inclusion of certain tropes, such as the surprise pregnancy, may not resonate with all readers and can detract from the overall enjoyment. Additionally, while the book can be read as a standalone, familiarity with the previous installments enhances the understanding of character dynamics and overarching plotlines.

The novel's blend of witchcraft, romance, and action provides an engaging experience, though some plot developments may feel predictable. Despite these shortcomings, Truly Madly Magically remains a cozy, witchy read suitable for fans of the genre.

In summary, while the book has its strengths in character development and atmospheric setting, certain narrative choices may not appeal to all readers. Even though it wasn't for me, Truly Madly Magically is a pleasant addition to the Witchlore series, particularly for those invested in Ellowyn and Zander's journey.

This book falls into a genre that I don’t usually read but this book may have changed that. I thoroughly enjoyed this book even though I hadn’t first realized this was part of a series. I have since read them all. I love Ellowyn and Zander. I cannot wait for the next book.

In Truly, Madly, Magically, readers are swept away to the magical town of St Cyprian. While I came into this series without the benefit of the first two books, I was instantly charmed by the atmosphere and tone of this whimsical, cozy mystery.
The story starts with a bang and the mystery only continues to grow. It’s never without a sense of suspense, and the ultimate resolution feels satisfying. It’s a cozy mystery in the truest sense — a clever puzzle and a delightful group of friends that you can’t help but want to stick around for. Even without prior knowledge of the series, the plot is accessible, and the characters’ relationships grow naturally, leaving me curious about their histories and eager to read more.
St Cyprian itself feels like a character, with its picturesque streets, friendly (if occasionally eccentric) residents, and the small town atmosphere is warm, inviting, and full of little details that keep you turning pages.
In short, Truly, Madly, Magically is an enjoyable, lighthearted read with the perfect blend of mystery, magic, and community. Whether you’re already a fan of St Cyprian or just discovering it, this book will leave you wishing you could visit the town yourself—maybe even for a bit of magic and a chat with its inhabitants. The perfect choice for a cozy weekend read!

The third in the series, Truly Madly Magically continues the story of the Riverwood Coven through the eyes of Ellowyn Good.

Ellowyn is cursed to tell the truth. Always. Can you imagine? No white lies, no lies of omission, no turns of phrase...only truth all the time. Ellowyn is also cursed (not actually but in her mind) with a lack of belief in herself. She doesn't believe that she truly belongs or contributes to the coven's power. She is only half a witch after all.

As the coven continues to battle the evil Joywood coven, she starts to realize, with the help of her friends and her sort of ex, Zander, that perhaps there's a reason the Joywood is targeting her and maybe she's more powerful than she ever thought.

Read if you like:

cozy witch stories
second chance at love
found family
good vs evil
a true growing into one's own self story.

** spoiler alert ** I had a hard time finishing this book because of the FMC's personality. Also, spoiler, but accidental pregnancy is kind of a surprising move for the plot. Not my favorite in this series.

Perhaps it may be because this book in the series was dedicated to mothers and I am expecting my first child as I read it, but this has been my favorite part of the series thus far.

I personally enjoy a grumpy romance and, if you’ve been following the series thus far, you know that Ellowyn and Zander are just that. So I was excited to see that this next book explored their disdain for each other and the suggested romance they had before all of that.

Without spoiling one of the main “complications”, this storyline hit home for me in some ways, and I loved seeing Ellowyn find her strength and a new meaning of herself in the midst of it all.

I can’t wait to read the next installment about Georgie.

Thank you NetGalley for an ARC of the book!