Skip to main content

Member Reviews

This book was way better than I was expecting, I kind of dilly dallied when it came to reading this and man am I mad at myself for waiting so long!

There are themes of love, loss, friendship, and sweet sweet revenge.

This book starts with our FMC Dania, she has been in prison for a year, and has been accused of a murder she didn’t commit, and has been tortured everyday by the Warden of the Prison. Thing’s look bleak until she gains the help of a new friend, someone who wants out just as much as she does.

They both have a grudge against the men that betrayed them and left them to rot in prison, and they have a plan to get their revenge, and avenge those who perished when they were arrested.

Armed with magic seeds, ornate daggers, and a lot of sass. Our MC’s infiltrate the palace and bide their time gathering intel waiting for the first chance to strike.

This is a story where there is love and loss but mostly just anger. Many families experience the generational curse, whatever it may be, at first we think that what came before us is right and just, but slowly we come to find out there are things we can change, and a cycle we can break. 4 ⭐️’s

Thank you to the Author Emily Varga for writing this story and sharing it with us, and Thank you to the narrator Saniya Ingram for her wonderful work.

Big Thank you as well to Macmillan Audio and NetGalley for my no cost copy of “For She Is Wrath”

I received this advance review copy at no personal cost and I am leaving this review voluntarily.

Was this review helpful?

The Count of Monte Cristo is one of my favorites, so I jumped at the chance to read/listen to this Pakistani retelling. Prison escape, revenge tactics, betrayal – it’s all included, along with dark magic.

I love a good vengeance tale, and Dania, with assistance from clever Noor, creates a strategic plan to get back at those responsible for wrongly imprisoning her for the past year. She disguises herself using a stolen djinn treasure involving magic that could have serious consequences if not used properly.

Both Dania and Noor are strong female characters, and I liked the friendship that develops between them. Noor has no problem calling out Dania when she believes her to be in the wrong and occasionally helps her see reason. The flashbacks to the relationship between Dania and Mazin before he deceives her allowed me to feel the deep level of betrayal Dania experiences. But is everything what it appears? The action sequences are full of tension and well-choreographed. Dania is a highly skilled swordswoman, and someone you don’t want to mess with.

With an overall theme of forgiveness, this is a novel I enjoyed and would recommend it to fans of retellings, magic and swords, and revenge tales.

I received a complimentary copy of this book from NetGalley. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley, St. Martin's Press, and Wednesday Books for this advanced copy! You can pick up For She Is Wrath on October 29, 2024.

This was a really fantastic YA fantasy! I loved the way it played on the classic Monte Cristo story but with a Pakistani twist. Our main character, Dania, is the epitome of female rage, and she'll stop at nothing to get revenge on those who wronged her -- including the tortured and sexy Mazin.

Honestly, the romance was one of my favorite parts of this story. I really enjoyed the flashbacks showing the slow build-up of their relationship, juxtaposed with the current day where she's in disguise making him fall for her again so she can destroy him. The magic in this was interesting, and I loved the plotting Noor and Dania did to take down their enemies!

Honestly, the only parts I struggled with were Dania's single-minded focus on vengeance and the book's ending. It made her feel a bit flat and repetitive at times, when I wish we could've seen a bit more depth and growth. As for the ending, I didn't see it coming, but it almost came too out of left field for my taste.

Def pick this one up if you want a quick, action-packed YA fantasy with cool magic and pretty good romance!

Was this review helpful?

For She Is Wrath by Emily Varga is a thrilling fantasy adventure that captivates readers from the very first page. The story is filled with action, revenge, romance, and friendship, all of which are expertly woven together to create a truly unforgettable tale. The protagonist, a strong and determined heroine, is on a mission to seek vengeance against her enemies, making for a gripping and intense read. Varga's writing is both powerful and engaging, keeping readers on the edge of their seats until the very end.

Was this review helpful?

When reading the description for this book I was excited to read it but the book kind of fell short for me. The book is advertised as lovers to enemies and it was nice to get chapters where we see the character's background and what their relationship was like before he betrayed her I feel like they didn’t stay enemies for very long. All of the issues in the book felt like they were resolved too quickly and the ending felt rushed. I liked the concept of the magic system and how it is based on these seeds and how you combine them but I wish we got more background information on them because it was confusing at first. I did enjoy the adventure aspect of the book and that is what kept me intrigued. Thank you St. Martins Press, Wednesday Books, and Netgalley for sending me an ARC of this book.

Was this review helpful?

I will start by saying that I am not the target audience for this book. The storyline was strong, and the world-building decent, but the writing style held me back from fully immersing myself in the story. The focus on describing the protagonist's same (mostly negative) emotions and inner turmoil in every scene made it feel like I was reading an overly dramatic soap opera as opposed to a fantasy novel. My middle-aged sensibilities wanted to tell Dania to just chill, girl.

Lots of girl power here, though, with a solid ending and a twist I did not see coming once the original betrayer was revealed. If you like lots drama and angst with your bad-ass heroines, this book is for you.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Netgalley for providing me with an ARC of this book.
SPOILERS TO FOLLOW

One of the best books I've read/listened to this year! I was intrigued by the Count of Monte Cristo comparison and I always love girls with swords so this was right up my alley. This book was more than I could have dared to hope. Revenge and love and loyalty and betrayal. It was everything good about a fantasy book wrapped in one amazing package. I loved Dania and Noor and their friendship. They felt more like sisters by the end of the book. I'd been really scared there in the beginning that Dania would leave Noor in the prison but she went back for her and it made all the difference in the world! I really loved Mazin and his sister Anam. I knew in my heart of hearts that Mazin wouldn't betray her (unless this was meant to have a more tragic ending where you kill your first love instead of being with them. I was glad to see I was right. The djinn magic and overall world building was really great too. I didn't see the plot twist with Dania's grandmother at all! I thought the emperor manipulated the whole situation somehow. Either way this was an incredible novel and I truly enjoyed it.

Was this review helpful?

Short Synopsis:
For She is Wrath is supposed to be a Pakistani retelling of the Count of Monte Cristo. Honestly I’ve seen the movies but I think I only read that book once, in high school, back in the 1900s. So for me I wasn’t constantly comparing the two books.
I felt like this book stood well on its own and honestly it is so refreshing to have a fantasy standalone book!! I’ve gotten overwhelmed with the amount of trilogies. So thank you Emily Varga for this debut novel.
Dania has been in prison for a year. All she wants is revenge on the people who are responsible for her prison sentence. She has a list of names (a la Arya Stark from Game of Thrones).
She befriends a fellow prisoner, Noor, (who is digging out of prison) and the two manage to escape together. And her revenge plot takes shape although it doesn’t go quite to plan. Nothing ever really does though when you combine anger, love and powerful magic.

You’ll love this book if you like:
Revenge
Magic
Found Family
Arya Stark-like heroine
Lovers-to enemies-to lovers

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Netgalley and Wednesday Books for sending me an early copy of this book! All opinions are my own!

Where to start with such an enchanting story of feminine rage and revenge? Where to start with such a strong female character who is taken on a journey of family, friendship, and the costs of protecting them both? Where to start with such a vibrant Pakistani fantasy full of culture and mythology alike?

Varga does an amazing job of weaving a world unlike any other full of characters that tug at your heartstrings and make you live through every emotion possible on the winding journey with them. I think my favorite part of the book is the way that it was so character driven and really dove into studying the heart of feminine rage and revenge. There are books about revenge, and then there is For She is Wrath - a dissection of each aspect of revenge and the emotions that come with it.

I loved the romance and getting to know both Dania and Mazin through flashbacks more than the present. It gave a lot of depth to what might have been a flat romance without it and helped me really understand the stakes and the *feelings* behind the situation.

I cannot wait to see what Varga does with her writing career. If this is where she starts, we are only in store for more masterpieces!

Was this review helpful?

Betrayal, greed, the need for power - Dania has imaged all the reasons that the person she trusted the most got her thrown in jail. I loved her drive for revenge and her rage at how she'd been treated. The one she stumbles into in her own cell - she was a great off-set and I liked her caution and her knowledge. Meeting the village and all those in it - this story was such an adventure. I loved the knowledge about swords and learning about Djinn magic. Great story, I was hooked from the start and it was a quick read!

A huge thank you to the author and publisher for providing an e-ARC via Netgalley. This does not affect my opinion regarding the book.

Was this review helpful?

Dania wants to escape and exact her revenge on those who betrayed her. Nothing goes her way until she meets Nor. A plan is coming together. Is now the time to act? Find out in For She is Wrath.

I would like to thank Wednesday Books for this ARC via Netgalley.

Was this review helpful?

Look I loved The Count of Monte Cristo, but tried to read this with an open mind. The characters aren’t bad and it started off promising, but it wasn’t consistent. I wasn’t able to stop myself from making comparisons and the book didn’t meet the expectations. That being said as a debut novel, I’m excited for what the author has to offer. Thank you NetGalley for the arc.

Was this review helpful?

This is a standalone Pakistani fantasy retelling of the count of Monte Cristo with Djinn magic. We follow a single POV throughout of Dania, who is the daughter to the weapon master of her village. She is fierce and has known how to wheeled a sword since she was six. Ultimately, she ends up being betrayed and thrown into prison, losing her life in the process. I honestly was so hooked by the first chapter and I had a hard time putting this book down when I needed to. I love how this book draws you in on such a low point in our FMC’s life. Her revenge is poorly planned until she meets a friend along the way. I really liked that there is a dual timeline going on between different chapters, of before and the present so you’re finding stuff out while important current events are taking place. Yes there is a romance element to this book, but it’s not a super big focus as compared to the revenge plot line. I did also enjoy the magic element to this story as well being as it was kind of more herbology based. This book also doesn’t shy away from the violence and has amazing fight scenes and I really love that we have a strong FMC who knows how to fight. I enjoyed the story overall and was happy with how things ended up turning out. I would look up triggers/warnings before reading.📖

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to Wednesday Books for the #gifted copy!

A Pakistani retelling of THE COUNT OF MONTE CRISTO, this book is all the female rage wrapped up in a pretty cover. Dania has been in prison for a year, tortured and starved, and only wants to break out to get revenge on the boy who broke her heart for his own gain.

Emily’s writing is beautiful. I loved both the rage and romance elements, and there were a lot of great lines that stood out to me. There’s also fantastic friendship, constant action, and dual timelines, making this a really solid fantasy read.

Read for:
🗡️BA female main character
🗡️Rage and revenge
🗡️Djinn magic
🗡️Count of Monte Cristo retelling
🗡️Pakistani influence
🗡️Romance and friendship

Was this review helpful?

For She is Wrath took me on an emotional rollercoaster from page one and had me hooked all the way through. A fast paced story, filled with thrilling action scenes, lovers to enemies to lovers, female rage, and an intense revenge plot, it had all the elements I crave in a fantasy read!

Dania is a fierce swordswoman who was betrayed by the person she loved the most, framed for a crime she didn’t commit, and left to rot in prison. Her journey is brutal, emotional, and full of twists. I adored her complex character – tough yet vulnerable, determined yet conflicted. The emotional depth of her character is evident through her struggles to stay true to herself while grappling with rage and a desire for justice.

The friendship bond between her and Noor—SO GOOD, they are always ready to sacrifice everything for each other, true found family vibes.

The chemistry between Dania and Mazin? 🔥🔥🔥 Their complex relationship carry the heart of the story, with intricate layers of lovers-turned-enemies. Their past connection makes the betrayal hit even harder, and the tension between them had me flipping pages like crazy. That push-and-pull, the sword training scenes, the hidden emotions… chef’s kiss!

Also, can we talk about the world-building? The unique djinn magic, the zoraat vegetation, the touches of Pakistani culture - architecture, food and fashion, and the use of Urdu words, added such a unique layer to the story, it makes this book stands out in the fantasy genre.

Overall, For She is Wrath is a well-executed retelling that balances fantasy, romance, and cultural lore. Varga masterfully reinterprets a classic tale, bringing a fresh perspective to themes of vengeance and redemption, making it a must-read for lovers of high-stakes revenge plots, strong female leads, and magical worlds. Dania’s rage and determination are so satisfying to witness, and the ending delivered with a twist that left me SHOOK. 😱

Was this review helpful?

4.5⭐️s. I really had fun with this one. I love the Count of Monte Cristo, and this story has those elements. So very much sold me on reading it. Within the first five chapters, my attention was fully in. Betrayal on so many levels. Found family, romance, and treasure of sorts. Interesting magic system that gives me Lucy vibes if you’ve seen that movie. Only a part of it though. Definitely more to the magic system than that.

Dani has been framed for murder. For a year, she has been in the worst prison around. It’s not until another girl enters her cell via a hole that things take a turn. A turn that just might mean freedom. Noor even knows where to get stolen djinn treasure. This will help Dani seek her revenge on Mazin. It was his hunger for favor with the emperor. Enough to kill and frame Dani for it. With the help of the djinn magic, she will find the answers she seeks and so much more.

Be sure to check out For She is Wrath coming out October 29th! Thanks so much to @netgalley @emilyvargabooks and @stmartinspress for the advanced reader copy.

#netgalley #forsheiswrath #advancedreaderscopy #arcreader #bookstagram #shoplocal #shopsmallbusiness

Was this review helpful?

Okay to be fair, I am not super familiar with "The Count of Monte Cristo", so I cannot speak to the accuracy of the retelling. I was promised an angry fmc, and a revenge plot and I was there for it. I'm thankful for being provided an arc from the publisher for this book, and I really hate giving lower ratings to debut authors, but this book did not work for me.

This is marketed as a Pakistani romantic fantasy, and the story begins with our fmc Dania wrongfully imprisoned because the man she loved betrayed her. She's angry alright, so that part delivered. There are a lot of creative metaphors for revenge throughout the book, which would have felt more powerful for me if they weren't so repetitive. I didn't do an actual count, but the reader is probably reminded that Dania wants to kill everyone that wronged her and take her revenge at least once every two pages. I did think the magic system was pretty interesting, and I liked the concept of having to mix and ingest these seeds that contain trace amounts of Djinn magic. The seeds are controlled by the Emperor, who is bad as Emperors are in fantasy worlds, and the process of mixing them is tedious and can absolutely kill you if it's done wrong. It is very convenient that the prisoner that accidentally tunnels into her cell (Noor) is both is a professional herbalist (seed mixer), and has access to copious amounts of magic seeds and money.

The characters all felt very one-dimensional. Dania = Angry. That is all. Noor = honestly felt like she had some sass in her when they first met in the prison but it quickly leached out of her as soon as they escaped and she became a tag-along sidekick character that serves as Dania's voice of reason. Bad guys = unrealistically bad for no reason, no nuance or depth, no redeeming qualities. The whole plot felt obvious and unrealistic. Dania messes up a lot, which is fine, but no one ever questions it. Dania essentially uses magic to change her appearance and goes undercover to take down all of the people who betrayed her. I won't lie, I was enjoying the scenes between undercover Dania and the guy who betrayed her. I thought that surely there must have been a misunderstanding, a good reason for the betrayal. There was not. The ending, including the insane twist at the end felt so incredibly random. There was no character development at all, it went from "murder murder murder" to a disney channel resolution? Were we trying to make it YA friendly or?? What in the world happened to those last 20 pages? I think that at it's core this story has potential. I love the concept and I feel like the author could have a lot of fun with this world. But as it is now, it fell really flat for me.

Was this review helpful?

“I’d know you with any face. Any skin. Any hair. A thousand djinn could disguise you from me and I’d still be able to find you just by the sound of your breath.”

Short Synopsis:
For She is Wrath is a Pakistani retelling of the Count of Monte Cristo. Dania has been in prison for a year. All she wants is revenge on the boy who is responsible for her prison sentence but also the boy she loved. She befriends a fellow prisoner, Noor, and the two manage to escape together. And her revenge plot takes shape.

My Thoughts:
This was such a fantastic debut. Bravo Emily Vargo. 👏

This is “female rage” in book form, it’s full of revenge, killer swordswoman, and swoony romance. The revenge plot was captivating. The romance has me melting. The friendships were beautiful. Though I found some of the twists predictable, I loved the journey getting there.

What You’ll Find:
🖤Revenge
🔥 Burn it all down
🌆Corrupt city
⚔️Girl with swords
🗡️Arya Stark-like heroine
❤️‍🔥Lovers-to enemies-to lovers
🫠Swoony romance
2️⃣Dual timelines

Was this review helpful?

“For She Is Wrath” is a stunning reimagining of The Count of Monte Cristo as a young woman in a Pakistani-inspired fantasy world, raging and grieving over the loss of her father from her prison cell, bent on escape. Dania and her father were framed for treason against the usurping emperor by her former lover and training partner Mazin, who is now the emperor’s right hand man. A fellow prisoner Noor, also attempting to escape, tunnels straight into Dania’s cell - prompting a partnership for the ages. They work together to escape and then, both motivated by their hatred for the emperor (and in Dania’s case, a lot of other people), embark on a series of magical buddy heists meant to trap, humiliate, and sometimes kill those who have wronged them.
This story is incredible for many reasons, not least the gorgeous writing, the nuance in grappling with the challenging themes of vengeance, justice, and forgiveness, and the spectacular character development. Dania and Noor’s friendship is the beating heart of the story, with each woman coming to appreciate and rely on the other for her skills and qualities - truly one of my favorite instances of found family that I’ve read. Mazin was a fascinating and mysterious figure, with the juxtaposition of Dania’s memories of training with him and his current work on behalf of the corrupt emperor leaving the reader constantly guessing as to his true motivations and loyalties. Running through the story is the undercurrent of djinn magic in the form of seeds, which are the emperor’s weapon of choice as well as one of Dania’s (her true affinity being with swords). The ability of power to corrupt is another fundamental theme. I also loved how we get to see so many people in this story who are trying to wreak vengeance upon others, and we get to compare the effect this has on each character and also where each of them will draw their lines (or in certain cases, not drawing any). An extremely satisfying read, highly recommend!

Was this review helpful?

Oh my gosh. This book was such a ride and I was just hanging on for life. This takes feminine rage, and women scorned to a whole other level. I was grateful that the story just jumps right in. I read the Count of Monte Cristo in high school and absolutely loved it. So when I saw that this was was a romantic fantasy retelling I was excited to dive in. I will say that a lot of time when things are marketed as one thing they end up falling short but I think that this was spot on. Dania was a great character, I found her to be complex and I enjoyed watching her development throughout the book. The supporting cast of this book are all interesting and lend their own pieces to the story. I was glad to see that there weren't really any characters that were just thrown in as a space filler. The action in this book is fast paced and intense. The scheming and back ally politics are well planned out. I really enjoyed the pieces of Pakistani culture and lore that were included in the book and thought that they made this story so unique. This is a book that I don't regret staying up until 2am reading. And one that I cannot wait to add to my physical library.

Was this review helpful?