This book started out really interesting, but eventually took a turn that was "meh" for me. Even so, the history of Indian tribes and land in Oklahoma was fascinating to read about.

This is a terrific book! The terrible plight of the "orphans" mixes so well with the future young woman ranger and her child. It was hard to tear myself away from each chapter. And, then the surprise conclusion...

Thank you to @netgalley and @RandomHouseBallatine for this ARC. 1909 Oklahoma: Ollie is living in the attic with 2 wards with her step-dad and her drug addicted mother. Hazel disappears one night and the step-dad soon comes for Nessa. Olive "Ollie" knows they must leave. The two wards were Choctaw that her true father was trying to save before he, himself disappeared so Ollie knows if Nessa is to stay alive, they must run. One night they come across the "elf children". Native, orphaned children whose home and land were taken from them by rich landowners and oilmen. After the Dawes act in 1889 when some land was allocated to the Native Americans, the white man saw their opportunity. The parents started disappearing and the white men would become wards of these children often times making them disappeared or wed to a family member at very young ages. One oilman had 100 wards in his "care". 1990 Oklahoma: Ranger Valerie is hired to protect the natural forest around Talihina when three small bodies were found in a cave. This sends her down a rabbit hole of history. The Flowers of the Killer Moon opened my eyes to the violence of Native women but I had no idea about the orphaned children left behind. What a story. #Shelterwood #LisaWingate #RandomHouseBallatine #June2024

Due to health issues I skimmed through this book. What I read was intriguing. I love Lisa Wingate as a Author and was very disappointed I had to read it in this way. I plan to re read it when it comes out. For what I did read, I liked it alot. Looking forward to taking my time to enjoy it.

The writing and research for this book was very strong. I was fully engaged with the 1990 story and wanted to stick with that story but the dual POV didn’t quite work for me. The back and forth was a bit confusing to get back into each story. I really liked the mystery story and wanted to know what was happening and thought it was a great reveal in the end. Overall it was an interesting read and well written book.

I have read many of Lisa’s books and enjoyed every one, all of them were five stars, and was so excited to have the opportunity to read this ARC. This one a bit different. It has a dual timeline, 1909 and 1990. We travel with Olive aka Hazel in 1909 and Valerie in 1990. Was quite coincidental that I had just read another book on the Indian nations where the Guardians were the worst possible solution for overseeing the Indian land, resources, their money, health care decisions of their people, all was a bad decision and completely ignored nor supervised by reliable sources or laws to protect the innocent.

This did not feel like one of her books, it was way to wordy, hundreds of pages could have been cut from the story. I found Olive to be the hero, her situation was dire, and she did the best she could, with her daddy helping her with kind words along the way.

Valerie was also a good character, but she was stepping out of her duties as a Forest Ranger in an investigation she had no authorization to do.

Going to have to give four stars. The Guardian oversight of these people is a blemish on our country.

I thank Random House Publishing Group along with NetGalley for providing this Galley edition for no requirement other than my offer to provide an unbiased review. This one comes in with four stars.

What a powerful, eye opening read. I knew about "The Trail of Tears", but not of the land, Oklahoma!

This is a dual time read, and I loved how the author seamlessly wove this story together.

Be sure to read the author's notes at the end!

This read opens your eyes to the greed that goes through the ages, and those that have never have enough, and don't care about whom they hurt getting it. Unfortunately, in the early 1900's it was children, and we though the eyes of the author meet this children and get to know some of them.

There are surprises, and then wow surprises, and most you won't see coming!

I received this book through Net Galley and the Publisher Ballentine Books, and was not required to give a positive review.

this story is told in dual timelines about eighty years apart. It comes together in the end. very good book.

Sometimes you just want a book that will transport you to another time and occasionally make you cry. Which brings me to this book and review I’m currently writing with balled up tissues in hand.

Lisa Wingate is a master at weaving together stories based on true events many may not know about. Including myself.

“Before We Were Yours” was the first book I read by her and just like that one, children and the past horrors they faced remain at the forefront. Hence my tissues.

I really love and appreciate the concern, love and support Lisa brings to her books and this one is no exception.

Taking place in Oklahoma and set between two timelines. Step into a time and a story Lisa clearly did her research on. I’m already looking forward to the next historical gem she decides to unearth.

Thank you NetGalley and Random House Publishing Group for an arc of this book. All opinions are my own.

Unfortunately, this was a DNF for me. I really tried to focus but it just never held my attention. I think I was more invested in the 1900 story line than the modern day one. I wasn’t interested in any characters. I made it about 41% in and decided this book, no matter the ending, is just not for me. I appreciate the opportunity to read an ARC of it as I really enjoyed Before We Were Yours.

Two stories, two narrators, and two timelines, with origins in United States government policies surrounding the treatment of indigenous people and their lands. While I'm generally a fan of this bestselling author, I was disappointed by this book. Awarded three stars on Goodreads, making me a real outlier since the book currently has an average rating of more than 4 stars.

Up front let me acknowledge that I am not a big fan of novels that move back and forth in time, where a connection is not revealed until the very end of the book. With few exceptions, I too often feel the author is simply employing an over-used literary device that keeps both stories intentionally obscure and harder to follow, because just as I get involved in one storyline, it’s dropped to pick up the second. And then back again.

SHELTERWOOD’s two storylines take place in Oklahoma about 80 years apart:
1909 - the story of two young runaways who meet up with other children living on their own — in a time before there were social service agencies or child labor laws to keep unscrupulous adults from taking advantage of children. This story is narrated by 12-year-old Olive Augusta Radley, the older of the two runaways. 
1990 - Newly widowed Valerie Boren O'dell (narrator) and her very inquisitive seven-year-old son Charlie have just relocated to Oklahoma to make a fresh start. Valerie is one of the first women rangers assigned to a national park and eager to prove herself to her sexist male colleagues. Almost immediately she gets involved in missing persons.

In telling both stories, author Lisa Wingate weaves in a variety of historical and contemporary elements. Skeletal remains, accidental death, and murder. Lucrative oil leases. Wealthy locals wielding power through their connections. Fledgling groups trying to organize women to effect political action. Kate Barnard, the first woman elected to statewide office in Oklahoma (who served before women even had the right to vote), and took an interest in helping the many abandoned children living on their own. And, of course, endlessly fascinating, the inner workings of dysfunctional families.

So, with all this drama, why did I award only three stars? Overall, I simply did not enjoy reading this novel. The pace seemed slow, not picking up until nearly three-quarters in. It felt long (368 pages) and picking it up felt too much like a task. And I admit I did not find this subject matter all that compelling. I think I would have liked it more if it was more focused on indigenous people rather than White ones. There were a lot of characters to track, made more difficult by continuing moving back and forth between stories. And I found that back and forth kept me at a distance, limiting my ability to become emotionally involved.

In my mind, a three star rating is a gift, awarded chiefly because I truly believe readers less annoyed by dual timeline stories and more interested in this subject matter and time period will enjoy the book much more than I did.

I loved Before We Were Yours, so I was thrilled when I received this.
Lisa Wingate is such a talented author and she brings out so much emotion, this story was heartbreaking.
I also love dual timelines, and this one bounces between 1909 and 1999.
History is so important and I feel sometimes we dont always really understand the lasting effect.

Once again, Lisa Wingate tells us of history that I was not aware of. Powerful story told in 2 timelines. A bit slow to get into the story in the beginning possibility due to the two different storylines.. I also found it hard to read about difficulties with children in history. I have no doubt this book will be a success!

Review Shelterwood
Lisa Wingate is a master storyteller. Her latest story is much like “Before We were Yours,” in that it uncovers a forgotten tragic story of the abuse of innocent children and those courageous few who worked to right the wrongs that villainous people tried to inflict on children.
It is a duel story-line that covers 1909 and 1990. And like Lisa’s previous story that uncovered the historical, yet almost forgotten tragedy of Georgia Tann selling innocent children, this story uncovers the complex Oklahoma history of graft and greed. It reveals a sad tale of the struggle to possess oil and lumber-rich land at a price that inflicted evil on Choctaw Indians and what became known as the “elf” children. There were little children who escaped and survived by living in the forest for a time. It also uncovers the true story of a little-known heroine who rescued some of those children.
Be sure to read the Author’s notes at the end of the story that uncovers the basis for telling this emotional tale.
The 1990 aspect of the story deals with a single Mom LEO working for a state Park who struggles to give voice to the story behind the bones of 3 children found in a cave. There is mystery and drama connected with the more recent time period that eventually reveals abuse inflicted on children ignored by the law.
For me this was a sadder story than Before We Were Yours. It is hard to read about the historical abuse of children. But it is a story that needed to be told, and I appreciated the uncovering of the woman who fought to be the advocate and protector for those children.
Thanks to #NetGalley for an advance ARC copy of #Shelterwood. And thanks to #Lisa Wingate for uncovering history and bringing it to light. Thanks to #Ballantine Books for allowing me to read this story before it will be available in June, 2024.

Be prepared to be captivated, enlightened, and moved by @author_lisa_wingate poignant story of 𝕊𝕙𝕖𝕝𝕥𝕖𝕣𝕨𝕠𝕠𝕕. Wingate sheds light on a forgotten chapter of American history revealing the dark underbelly of Oklahoma where Native American lands were stolen, lives lost, and injustices served on the Choctaw Nation and underprivileged. Greed and corruption are unveiled in this gripping novel.

𝑫𝑬𝑺𝑪𝑹𝑰𝑷𝑻𝑰𝑶𝑵
The story unfolds with dual timelines until the stories converge. Eleven-year-old Ollie of 1909 flees her stepfather with Nessa, his 6-year-old Choctaw ward, who has untoward ideas for Nessa and her missing sister. They embark on a dangerous journey through the mountains along with an unexpected alliance of fellow orphaned (“elf”) children.

Fast forward to 1990, where law enforcement ranger Valerie faces local unrest, a missing teenage hiker, and the chilling discovery of long-buried bones in the park’s depths. With the support of the Choctaw Tribal Police, Val’s pursuit of truth unearths a labyrinth of hidden truths and the haunting legacy of the land’s dark past.

𝑺𝑼𝑴𝑴𝑨𝑹𝒀
Wingate skillfully weaves a tapestry of mystery and intrigue that bind past and present in this compelling and meticulously researched novel and brings justice to the forgotten Kate Barnard; a strong advocate for the children.

𝑪𝑶𝑵𝑻𝑬𝑵𝑻
💋 Sex & Nudity - Hint of sexual abuse but nothing described.
🤬 Profanity - None
🥊 Violence & Gore - Physical abuse of children; discussion of children being killed. Some fighting and shooting. Nothing graphically detailed.

𝑹𝑨𝑻𝑰𝑵𝑮 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Another great book from Lisa Wingate. Told in two different time frames, but once again, she brings it all together in the end. So sad what our child went thru before laws were enacted to protect them.

My first Lisa Wingate book and I’m very glad to have been allowed to read an ARC of it. Fantastic storyteller.. I typically don’t love dual timeline books, but this one was so well written that I was never bored with either timelines’ stories. This extremely well researched novel tells the story of Oklahoma’s elf children, land grabs by powerful white men, the painful lives of children who were destined to inherit valuable land, including Natives, and of Kate Barnard, a spunky woman who did so much to try to rectify the situation. “A society is only as good as its women.”

As a huge fan of "Before We Were Yours" I was very excited to receive the ARC from NetGalley of Shelterwood for an honest review. This book had me hooked from the beginning. The dual timelines between Ollie in 1909 and Valerie in 1990 provided a smooth parallel to a mystery to be solved, all while uncovering a deep dark secret held by a town's ancestors for decades. I thoroughly enjoyed the twists and turns and suspenseful journey taken by Ollie and her crew. The ending wrapped up beautifully, which I've come to appreciate in a story that is soaked in so much truth. Well done!

A very well written and researched book! The history is really interesting. I highly recommend this book, even though it is a split time novel, which I think there are far too many of these days. :) The story and characters are captivating. Parts of it are sad, but the main characters are strong, and it ends with victory, which is awesome!!
Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for the advance e-copy of this book! All opinions expressed are entirely my own.

Lisa Wingate writes great books and this one does not disappoint. Though I had trouble following along at times due to it being set in two different time lines, early 1900's and late 1990's, but I enjoyed the historical fiction part of it and the story. This is a great story to learn about the Native Americans and land rites.