Come Out, Come Out is a queer YA horror novel addressing conversion therapy and coming of age as a young queer person in a family and community that is not supportive. It's about finding your voice, being true to yourself, and discovering found family when your own family isn't an option. It also wraps religion into the mix and is sort of a less intense younger cousin to Camp Damascus by Chuck Tingle.

It follows two characters - Jaq is a lesbian and Fern is non-binary but they are expected to fit inside traditional gender norms as girls. When they were young teens, something strange happened to them in the woods and a friend of theirs disappeared, but they have little memory of what actually happened. It's disturbing at times, particularly for the ways they are pushed to conform and held back from saying and doing what they actually want to do. I did feel it was a bit on the nose at times and the ending was less satisfying than I wanted it to be, but I also think something written for teens can get away with being more direct. I liked it, just be aware there is a lot of depiction of homophobia, transphobia and more. The audio narration is okay but the narrator doesn't do distinct voices for the different perspective characters which made it hard to follow at the beginning. I received a review copy via NetGalley, all opinions are my own.

✨Thank you to Penguin Random House Audio, Netgalley, and Penguin Young Readers Group for the gifted audio and digital copies of this book!✨

🚨SEMI spoilers ahead🚨

This was great YA queer horror. I loved the spooky supernatural elements. There was a good story here with an interesting origin without too much fluff or smoke and mirrors.

This was a very powerful queer coming of age story as well. The teens in this book all had different pressures and struggles with coming to grips with who they were vs who everyone wanted them to be. It was not lost on me that when the kids asked for “safety”, instead of their family and friends just being accepting and open, the only “solution” was for them to conform to the heteronormative values of those around them. This is the devastating reality for many queer people in the real world.

I really enjoyed the characters and their individual stories. I wish we had gotten a bit more closure with Fern’s story in particular. I felt that Jaq’s present and future seemed tied up well but Fern’s was a little more elusive and it left me feeling incomplete.

Overall, I wish that most things got more elaboration and more time. I wanted more of Fern’s sisters. I wanted more of the history of the Patron. I wanted more of Mallory’s story. I know the author really wanted to hit the overarching theme of this book and it was well done, but I think the stories of the individual characters got sacrificed a bit.

The narrator did a great job and she set the tone really well.

Overall, this was an entertaining and powerful queer story and I really enjoyed it! It is very much YA and it is important to know that going in for the expectations of the reader.

Spooky queer horror named Come Out, Come Out? I was very on board! This book starts off with a bang. The classic horror movie scene is happening in the opening chapter, and it grabbed me from page one. A lot of this book was more nuanced than classic horror, but that terror of homophobia is almost more frightening than a monster in the woods.

I found the characters to be well-written with full storylines. Multiple POVs worked well for this one, but I did sometimes have to remind myself who was talking. Overall, a great read and one that made me think. I would say that homophobia and transphobia take center stage on this one, so take care if those are sensitive topics before you read.

Thanks to NetGalley, Natalie Parker, and Penguin for the chance to read and review. My thoughts and opinions are my own.

Come Out, Come Out is a unique blend of speculative and paranormal horror that touches on deeper themes of self-acceptance, identity, and the fear of being different. It follows three queer friends living in a homophobic community, where the real terror isn't supernatural, but the struggle to be yourself when others refuse to accept you. The book is emotional, heartfelt, and thought-provoking, with a strong message about courage and love. The horror elements enhance the story without overshadowing its deeper meaning, making it a great read for horror fans who enjoy stories with substance.

Fern, Jaq, and Mallory never felt safe coming out. There was one place they did feel safe. A hidden abandoned house in the woods where the urban legend of the Patron of Port Promise resides. You make a wish and he keeps you safe. Only the friends find out there is a horrible cost. A cost that is rewoken years later when they start remembering the 'truth' of who they are and they're part of the disappearance of Mallory.

What worked: Perfect twisty thriller with a paranormal presence that erases an individual's truth. It's now senior year and Fern and Jaq are no longer close. But an encounter in the woods has memories resurfacing. Memories that are painful but also have both of them question their true identities.

Think urban legend so-called Patron of Good Deeds meets paranormal conversation therapy. Both girl's parents have a certain vision for their futures. Jaq's parents are conservative Christians. Jaq even has the perfect boyfriend. Fern is on track to follow her older sisters in theater. Only Fern can't push aside the thought she's not a girl, but something else.

Once the girls remember their times with Mal, the pieces of the puzzle come back together. How they found safety with each other in a town that refused to accept who they were. It's then that Jaq and Fern reconnect and try to help not only Mal but themselves.


What I really enjoyed about this thriller had to be Fern and Jaq struggling with emotions resurfacing on who they were. Fern finds that the animosity she had toward Kaitlyn might in fact be something more. Jaq no longer feels that her long-time boyfriend John is the one. Even though she feels an attraction to Devyn, she tries to fight it off.

Together the friends reunite and go back to the place where it all started.

Modern queer horror tale that is timeless with its story of survival but also has a message of hope.

3.5 stars rounded up. This book started out strong, then lost me a bit in the middle before arriving at a bittersweet ending.

I liked the characters in this one. Their relationship/identity issues were timely and interesting to read about. All in all, I'd say this book wasn't the most exciting one I've read, but it was the right level of creepy and atmospheric for me.

I read an ARC of this book from NetGalley. All comments are my own.

Rating: 3.5 stars

Come Out, Come Out is an intriguing blend of queer identity and horror that follows Jaq and Fern as they confront their past and rediscover themselves. The story masterfully weaves together themes of friendship, self-acceptance, and the challenges of coming out in a small town.

The eerie atmosphere and supernatural elements kept me hooked, while the emotional journey of the characters added depth to the narrative. It’s a powerful reflection on embracing your true self and the strength of found family, making this a compelling read for fans of both contemporary and horror.

Ever just… forget you’re queer? No? Me neither.
But that’s exactly what happens to Jaq and Fern in this eerie YA horror novel.
After running into the woods during a high school party, they’re suddenly overwhelmed by memories of a forgotten friendship—one that ended abruptly with the disappearance of their close friend, Mallory, five years ago. Now, Mallory’s back—sort of. The two teens are haunted by visions of decay and blood, and by screams from a night they can’t remember.
This was a quick read for me. I enjoyed it, though there were a few frustrating aspects. I read the digital ARC, and the formatting was a mess, but I assume that’s been fixed in the final release. Aside from that—and the slightly rushed ending—it was a solid queer read with genuine scares! Jaq and Fern are compelling characters, and you can’t help but sympathize with them as they grapple with their forgotten identities and the challenges of being queer in a hostile community.
I would absolutely recommend this for spooky season! And let’s face it - queer plant horror is the best horror.

Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for the ARC of this book. All opinions are my own.

This book. This book has my whole heart. I absolutely adored this! From the incredible characters, to the plot, to falling in love with everything so quickly- I couldn’t put this down. I highly recommend this!

This is a massively important book, and I’m so glad it’s considered Young Adult to be seen by those who are growing up in homes where they may feel alone or trapped. The resources listed in the back pages I can only imagine will be life changing for many in finding their own safe spaces to grow.
I felt so seen by the imagery surrounding the Patron, and I gasped and cried with the weight of betrayal I know Mal, Jaq and Fern felt after placing so much hope in this previously safe haven. I was also overwhelmed by thankfulness for the long history of LGBTQ+ people who have fought for the rights and freedom of the rest of us, and given us a place to work from to continue to create a world where we don’t have to be afraid of who we are. Mal was such a symbol of light and courage and a change-maker in this way, and she was so honored by her friends in every part of life.
I love the community that just grows and grows throughout the story, reminding the characters and the readers that they are never alone in their experiences or questions. And I love the representation of varying identities and responses to coming out and the reality of loss while also relishing in freedom. There is so much fear and pain and clawing to get out that leads to autonomy and queer joy and relief. I’m proud to be a part of this community.
Thank you to the author and NetGalley for allowing me to read an advanced copy of this story. It is one that needed to be written.

I love Natalie C. Parker’s Seafire series so when I saw she came out with a YA horror queer book, I had to get it! I loved the writing, but the book went from horror to highschoolers falling in love and a coming-of-age story. I love those kinds of stories but that’s not what I thought I was getting when reading this book. I really wanted a good YA horror book.

In the same niche as Camp Damascus by Chuck Tingle, the conversion-therapy-as-horror genre. Similarities abound, even down to the senior class quarry jumps, which doesn’t indicate any co-opting of plot points but simply how ubiquitous this experience is, the same script across rural America, where any deviation from the script means there will be Consequences. A key plot point involves a gender-swapped/gender-neutral production of Grease, which is both fun and thematically relevant. Chuck Tingle nails the horror bits more effectively, but Parker nails the family/friends emotional dynamics very well. I’m glad that both exist.

This follows Jaq and Fern five years after their friend Mal “ran away” one night. Jaq has a loving boyfriend, and Fern is part of a theatre dynasty. One night at a party in the woods they remember everything that happened between them and Mal. They’re torn between who they are and what everyone expects of them.

This book is classified as horror but it’s not scary in the way horror movies are scary, it’s scary in the way that there are real people out there who are bigoted and hate anything about the lgbtqia+ spectrum.

Ah, catch me crying on an airplane over the end of this book. A queer awakening with a horror twist that will suck you in with its mix of dread and tenderness.

It made me miss high school friendships and appreciate that true love can also be platonic.

Come Out, Come Out by Natalie C Parker, in the book we meet Jack and fern they go to the same high school but live absolutely different lives and on the surface wouldn’t look like they have much in common but boy oh boy do they have something in common. Fern is part of a dynasty at her high school because all of her sisters have had the lead in their high school musicals and when she’s not doing that she’s hanging out with her two best friends. Jack hangs out with the daughter of preach keech and her boyfriend John but when they both attend a party at a fellow high school students home they experience something that causes them to remember things they forgot. Is this also the reason Fern keeps seeing Mallory and who is the new girl trying to get close to Jack, that looks just like Mallory? Both girls are living with a secret possibly even more than one this book is a strange coming-of-age story about two teenagers who were so accustomed to living the way others expect it takes paranormal intervention to scare them into being who they really are. At least in a way! I finish this book a couple of weeks ago and didn’t know exactly how to do a good review because this book is so good I was shocked the rating was in higher than it is but having said that if you love great horror with mindbending dreams/reality a gender fluid Casting call and an unfortunate impending marriage then you definitely will enjoy this book it is definitely hard drama spine tingling breaches in reality and so much more. #NetGalley, #PenguinGroupPutnamForYoungReaders, #NatalieCParker, #ComeOutComeOut,

Okay, this was a really good read.
First time with this author but I was definitely pulled in.
I don't normally care about pacing but this one dipped a bit and I put it down for a while.

But I'm glad I picked it back up, good solid ending in my opinion and kept me curious.

I dont know ehat it is but ive been loving horror novels with gay or lesbian characters this had me on the edge of my seat because i was trying to figure out what happen to the character that disappeared who they say that ran away. Mosg of this novel was basically a thriller u til the last 80 precent and thats why i gave it 4 stars

Wow. This was such an emotional ride. This was my first book by this author, but it won't be my last!

Teens Jaq, Mallory, and Fern all go into the woods to find "The Patron" - a soul who is said to grant you the deepest wish you have - but only 2 of them come out. 5 years later, Jaq and Fern suddenly receive memories surrounding the events that led them to going to the woods that night, but can't remember the actual night. Both feel trapped in their heterosexual lives under the strict scrutiny of their religious parents. Both are determined to have "The Patron" help them understand the events of the night long ago.


The book starts off with such a bang! There were a couple of lulls in the middle, but overall, I think this is a book that has so much potential! It approaches the topic of homosexuality and issues such as extreme religiousness and homophobia with such tenderness that it definitely makes you stop and think about teenagers today.
The buildup to the ending and the ending were just so emotional and so good! I thoroughly enjoyed myself the whole time reading it!

The biggest thank you to NetGalley and Penguin Group/Penguin Young Readers Group for an eARC of this novel! All opinions are my own!

I was hoping that this book would be something along the lines of Camp Damascus by Chuck Tingle, and while it was similar in some aspects it also didn't quite live up to it. That's not to say that it was bad, because it wasn't, it was an enjoyable read, and I enjoyed all three POVs. I will admit I apparently didn't read the synopsis quite as closely as I thought I did because I thought the timeline was slightly shorter...I guess. Basically I didn't realize that the initial incident happened when the main characters were in middle school. I think this is an important book, and I'm sure it will resonate with a lot of queer teens, I am not queer, nor am I a teen, so obviously I'm not the intended audience for it, but I also don't regret reading it. I will say that I think I was expecting something a little scarier. I also have a few questions about some of the life-threatening ghost activity. I'm not going to bother to get into that though. I think the other thing that stopped this from being a really stand-out read was the ending. Sure, things are tied up for the most part, but one of the main characters makes an insanely odd decision that culminates in the climax occurring, and while I was reading it I just kept scratching my head because it made no sense. Maybe it's because this was an ARC, so things changed between this draft and what went into print, but the foreshadowing was INSANE for the outcome, and thus made the character doing what they did almost stupid? I don't want to spoil anything, but if it hasn't been changed when you get to that point you'll know. My other issue was that I wanted more of a resolution with one of our main characters. The lesbian main character who had a boyfriend because of The Patron did technically end up cheating on him, and then the inevitable confrontation after the climax that should have happened with him was just glossed over. I wanted to see more of that because I think it really should have been bigger, seeing as it was such an important thing. Those were just kind of the issues I had with it. Like I said overall it wasn't a bad book, I just think I was expecting a little more out of it. If a teen is looking for a queer horror story I will certainly point this book out to them, because I think it has some important messages in it, but I'm not sure I would suggest it to adults unless they're really looking for a book to kind of shine a light on the dangers of surprising queer teens (and let's be honest, I'm not sure many would be).

This is a wonderful coming of age novel. I love this author so I was expecting a good book. This is not as scary as I expected but I am old and jaded so it just didn't hit me the same way it probably hits younger people.
I loved it. It is a quick read.