Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Imagine being caught in an escape room style game except you don’t quite know that you are. Car mirrors echo words that say “objects in mirror are closer than they appear”, those words ring true for people like Maria and Nina staying at Nina’s father’s house. Although they occur separately and unknown to each other it becomes a terrifying experience.

This story was so good and not reminiscent of anything I’ve read before. The great attention to details allowed the reader – me, to truly get the whole picture and it was a thrilling ride. I enjoyed this read immensely and thought the setting made the plot stand out even more. The characters were understandable and their development was crucial to the plot. Really great read – 4️⃣⭐️❗️

Was this review helpful?

Catherine Steadman is FANTASTIC. She has a unique ability to immerse you into the lives of her characters.

Was this review helpful?

This is a story of two women who dont have a connection. Nina has lived a lonely life and at 34 the life she build with her father and then he passes away and she is forced to go to the British Virgin Islands urgently. Nina becomes enveloped in her fathers house and the secrets it holds. The other character Maria is a medical student working as a nanny for the rick to afford her schooling. Her next job is at a secluded mansion and the house is mysterious full on with a whole level she cant go on and with secrets of its own. Learning the connection between these women and circumstances was fun and interesting. It was pretty fast paced and I found myself really wanting to know the secrets and wanting to skip ahead. Liked the pace and the twists.

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely adored Catherine Steadman's first book but this book fell into the Sophomore slump that I have heard about. I felt as though we were going no where fast the entire book. The twist was predictable and lacked originality. I was frankly bored the entire book and skimmed the last 1/3 of the book as I couldn't wait for it to end. I love the rich people drama that she did include but I feel as though this was a play off a movie I have seen 1,000 times. I wouldn't recommend this book if you are a seasoned thriller reader but I will pick up what she writes next to give her another chance.

Was this review helpful?

This psychological thriller jumps into the dark side of human nature. Atmospheric and suspenseful with interesting characters. Overall fast paced and engaging, a bit predictable but still entertaining. Solid read for lovers of psychological thriller

Was this review helpful?

Nina's father passed away and left her a mysterious house she never heard of in the British Virgin Islands. However, having a house she didn't know about isn't the only mystery, but also what is in the basement and who is leaving threatening notes for her.

This one is different for Steadman. I’m left with a lot of locked room vibes…. Sort of. Multiple points of view, but also a very disjointed and often times feels rushed. Decent read but also a few plot holes that could have been filled to be a better read.

I've heard people say they thought this book is unhinged and crazy, but I didn't think that at all. I actually thought it was a bit flat, with a somewhat predictable storyline that's been done before.

I requested a digital advanced readers copy from NetGalley and Random House Publishing and providing my opinion voluntarily and unbiased.

Was this review helpful?

Nina Hepworth is grieving the recent loss of her father when she receives a letter stating that she has inherited his home in the British Virgin Islands. Nina is shocked, as she had no idea her father had another home, and when she flys out to the island to settle the estate, she is intrigued by the small details that seem to suggest that it was in fact his home. However, as Nina stays in the house, she starts to receive odd notes - and whether they are a threat or a warning remains to be seen. It seems that the house may have a sinister past after all...

This book really drew me in from the first chapter and I didn't want to put it down - I finished it in less than 24 hours! There were so many twists and turns, you didn't know who to trust and who was the good guy. While a lot of the story focused on the action, the psychological aspect was also very real and had my mind spinning. Steadman is a go-to psychological thriller writer for me and I can't wait for her next work!

Was this review helpful?

Thriller of intense dynamics. Nina believes she has inherited a home that her father built without her knowledge. All alone since his passing she suffers doubts that she maybe never truly knew him or was cherished by him. Her mother had died shortly after her birth and she was raised by her father. This inherited home is extreme. But something is off from the start and the terror grows.

Was this review helpful?

This story really sucked me in from the beginning. I was suspicious of everyone in the story. I really liked the two main characters, Nina and Maria. I was so glad when Maria escaped, but sad with how her story ended. She was so strong! I’m also glad Nina got away with her two saviors! It’s scary to think of someone making a real life deadly escape room. It was an interesting concept to read about!

Was this review helpful?

Nina has lost her father, and misses him madly. She discovers that he left her property in the British Virgin Islands, so she goes to see it. What she discovers is a posh house, showing that her father just might have been affluent, and tries to decide what she will do with the house. Quite naturally, she explores the house, but one point is made clear to her. Do not go in the basement.

In a secondary timeline, there is Maria. In medical school currently, she takes a nannying job sight unseen. She settles herself in the fancy house, awaiting the arrival of the parents and her new charges. She also gets a single mandate. Do not go in the basement.

Will these two timelines converge? There is plenty of intrigue to be sure, creating much curiosity. For chess lovers, there is mention of Andersson’s Opening, a famous, but not one considered wise. As I was reading this book, I wondered how this reference would play into the intrigue of the story.

So, for both Nina and Maria - curiosity killed the cat for sure. Question is: would that very curiosity take their lives? Keeping track of each of them was easy, while the drama and danger grew with each page.

Many thanks to and to NetGalley for this ARC for review. This is my honest opinion.

Was this review helpful?

I loved THE FAMILY GAME and I heard if you loved that one, then you would eat up LOOK IN THE MIRROR. Apparently I am the exception because this went from wild to BONKERS and not in a way I enjoyed. Was it entertaining? Sure, I guess. But I could do without the whole plot of what the house was actually used for... and well, that's like the whole book. The beginning really had me though so I'll call this an average read.

Thank you Random House Publishing Group - Ballantine | Ballantine Books and Netgalley for my ARC i exchange for a review.

Was this review helpful?

This is my second read from Catherine Steadman. I felt the same about both. I believe the concept is quite interesting, but the story itself just doesn't go far enough for me. I saw another reviewer call this horror. I disagree, however, I wish it WAS horror. If she would've taken this a little further the book would have been right for me.

Was this review helpful?

I loved the cover of this book! Definitely makes you want to read this just off of the cover.

This had multiple POV which is one of my favorite things to read in a book. As i read through the book it has a very unique writing style and plot. As you read, you have no idea what to expect which keeps you engaged.

Character build was great and i loved the entire book. Will read more from this author.

Thanks NetGalley for letting me read and review.

Was this review helpful?

This was a great read with a unique premise! I liked the multiple POVs, and after a couple of chapters, I had NO idea what to expect. There were so many unexpected twists, right up to the very end. Definitely a suspenseful book with a lot of creative twists and characters.

Was this review helpful?

The Squid Game but centralized in one beautiful British Virgin Island home, hidden away in the vast basement where only the twisted elite have access. Nina finds this gorgeous island home has been left to her in her father’s will. At first, she’s shocked that her father owns a mansion on an island, but as she stays there, it’s just a matter of time before she’s caught in its web. The games are reminiscent of mind games she and her father played when she was a child, but losing a round at this game will cost her a life.
The stakes are high, and the confusion is mind-boggling, but Nina knows the only way she’ll ever live through this cruel and horrible trap is to keep her wits, stay calm, and above all, think.
This is a fun cat-and-mouse game where the mouse is at a huge disadvantage, so you’re pulling for the mouse to win. Fast-paced and full of well-plotted surprises, it kept me enthralled to the end. Thanks so much to Random House Publishing Group, Ballantine for an ARC in exchange for my honest review. The publishing date is July 30, 2024.

Was this review helpful?

*3.5 stars, rounded up*
Majority of the book is told from a dual POV, Nina and Maria. As the story develops, additional POVs are added in, in the form of different chapters (as in, each chapter is a POV). Still mourning her father's death, Nina is stunned to discover she’s inherited a luxurious, modern vacation home in the British Virgin Islands—an extravagant property she never knew existed. Puzzled by how her practical father could afford such a place and why he kept it a secret, Nina begins to question what else he may have been hiding. Meanwhile, Maria, once a driven medical student, now works as a nanny for the wealthy, enjoying the better pay and glamorous locations. On what she hopes will be her final assignment, Maria finds herself alone in the mansion when her wards fail to arrive, spending her days lounging by the pool and in the sauna—until she’s warned to stay out of the basement. But curiosity gets the better of her, and soon, she’ll realize the house holds far darker secrets than she ever imagined.
---
I felt like this book dragged on for the first quarter, but then it TOOK TF OFF. Like... Hey, this plot is actually insane??? I was floored and creeped out. And I LOVE it when a book is able to do that. However, I feel like I was left with questions by the end - that, and the slowness at the beginning, added to the star rating.

Was this review helpful?

I loved the escape room aspect of this book! i felt it naturally connected how technology can be so extremely dangerous when its matched with money. The way the points of views changed actually contributed to the story more because of the mystery behind the rooms in the house. I gave it 3 stars because there was no surprising factors of the book for me. I wish there was a wow moment but I could pretty much guess what was coming next.

Was this review helpful?

I loved The Family Game by Catherine Steadman and had hoped for an equally crazy and twisty story with her latest publication. However, I was a bit disappointed. The beginning was a bit slow with a LOT of Nina's inner monologue about her relationship with her dad. I mean, I got it after one full chapter of "Did I really know him?" Maria's chapters were more interesting to me. I knew right away that we were dealing with an altered time line (which usually annoys me when it isn't labeled on the chapter pages, but since this was obvious, I didn't mind it as much - but seriously, can we put this trend/trope/plot device to bed already??). Then, once we figure out what is actually happening, the plot just got a bit crazy--too crazy. And not that compelling. I honestly didn't care that much about these characters. The pacing was really odd - especially at the end. The end was REALLY rushed. We never really got the motivation for the entire thing from the players involved. I didn't believe the "love story" element at the end. The whole thing just took a little too much suspended disbelief for me to really fathom. Where the Family Game was crazy but could have actually happened, this one was just a bit too bizarre and asked me to overlook too many plot holes and questions to really enjoy fully. It was a quick, fun-ish read, though if you don't mind some super far-fetched moments.
2.5 rounded up to 3

Was this review helpful?

The thing about thrillers is that soo much is reliant upon the ending, a book can keep you at the edge of your seat for the entire book but if the ending is ridiculous and mucked up, it ruins the whole reading experience and unfortunately this was the case for me here.

The first half of the book was great and compelling, it had an early hook which for me is essential when it comes to thrillers, and it kept me reading till about 75% at which point things started to fall apart. The way the storylines played out was unbelievable and there were too many plotholes. 4 stars for the first half, 2 stars for the 2nd, which leaves me to settle on a 3 star rating. The writing at least was not awful, which is likely another thing that kept me reading.

Was this review helpful?

I loved this one! Catherine Steadman does such a great job of pulling you into the story and I couldn’t put this one down but I also didn’t want it to end. I loved all the twists and turns this one took! It was such a wild ride and I loved every second! 5 stars!

Was this review helpful?