Skip to main content

Member Reviews

In this fourth novel featuring LA Homicide Detective Margaret (Maggie) Nolan, the author manages to economically introduce a large cast from earlier stories in the series with new characters, and to create a complex and compelling mystery.

The story moves from the wealth of Holmby Hills to the deterioration of Culver City, as Maggie’s team and colleagues from other offices work to solve the murder of a wealthy manufacturer and the kidnapping of his former partner’s wife. Personal animosity and international drug cartels weave together as links between people and places start to coalesce.

While the crimes are horrible, the details are not horrific, and in fact, there is much compassion as well as clear thinking among Maggie and her team. As a bonus, for me, the characters also confront the existential issue of consorting with evil to exterminate greater evil. I now have the first book in the series, and am eager to read it.

Was this review helpful?

This book is a great improvement over the last one. It is fast paced and engaging. I was able to read the whole book on a cross country plane flight. It involves the murder of a company owner whose business was about to be sold and the abduction of his former partner’s wife at the same time. It has interesting twists and turns throughout the book. Overall, a good read.

I received a free Kindle copy of this book courtesy of publisher with the understanding that I would post a review on Goodreads, Net Galley, Amazon, Facebook and my nonfiction book review blog.

Was this review helpful?

City of Secrets by PJ Tracy is fourth in the Margaret Nolan detective series. A murder of the CEO of a pet food company. Mags and her partner Al are assigned to the case. The banter between these two is awesome! The author brings the case bit by bit as if you are solving it along with the detectives. The romance between her and Remy adds another level to the story. Highly recommend this book. I kept the pages turning to see what happens! Thank you NetGalley and Minotaur for letting me read this book in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Addictive, fast-paced with a twist at every turn! Another excellent addition to the police procedural series by P.J. Tracy. Books in the series can be stand alone, which I enjoy. If you like female detectives, crime thrillers, and fantastic characters you'll love City of Secrets.

Was this review helpful?

City of Secrets by P. J. Tracy is the fourth book in the LAPD Detective Margaret Nolan series, and while it didn’t blow me away, it was a solid summer poolside read. ☀️📚

Detective Nolan is called to a scene that appears to be a fatal car-jacking but quickly unfolds into a tangled web involving a multimillion-dollar company, an abduction, and a chilling underworld of sex and violence. As she delves deeper, Nolan encounters whispers of an “Angel of Death,” making this investigation one of her most complex yet.

What I appreciated about this book was its rich portrayal of LA and the multi-layered characters. However, some parts felt predictable, and the pacing was a bit uneven. Still, the intriguing premise and the twists kept me reading.

Overall, City of Secrets is a decent addition to the series and perfect for a leisurely summer read by the pool. 🌊🔍 #BookReview #CityOfSecrets #PJTracy #SummerRead #DetectiveNolan #CrimeThriller

Was this review helpful?

City of Secrets by P.J. Tracy is the fourth in a series however, this is the first for me and it is written in a way you don't have to read the others to enjoy this stand-alone. The story is of a murder and then a related kidnapping, mixed with a romantic interest with the professionals investigating the crimes. The characters are likable and real. The story is entertaining and fairly believable with enough twists to keep you interested. I appreciate this ARC, thank you NetGalley, and the publishers for letting me read and give my review.

Was this review helpful?

Another great book in this series. As always PJ takes the reader for a ride as the story plot deepens and takes on surprising twists. What starts as the murder of a Pet Food company CEO turns into a complicated series of different crimes and suspects that keeps the detectives on their toes.
Excellent character development and an awesome story plot make for a fantastic read. This book will keep you turning pages and guessing until the end.
This book is part of a series, but the reader can still enjoy this novel as a standalone.

Thank you to Netgalley, the publisher and the author for the opportunity to read an advanced copy of this book.

Was this review helpful?

Homicide detective Maggie Nolan and her partner are called in to investigate the murder of Bruce Messane, co-founder of Peppy Pet Foods. Does the pending sale of the company have anything to do with his murder? As Maggie investigates his business and life, secrets emerge. The kidnappings of his former partner/co-founder and wife raises more questions. A quick enjoyable read with twists .
#CityofSecrets #StMartinsPress #MinotaurBooks #NetGalley

Was this review helpful?

This is a twisty thriller filled with mystery and drama to keep you intrigued through the last page. This is part of a series, but this can be enjoyed as a stand-alone read. I enjoyed this one and will look for more from this author.

Thanks to NetGalley and St. Martin's Press for an e-arc in exchange for an unbiased review.

Was this review helpful?

Detective Margaret Nolan is with the Homicide Special Section in LA. She’s in a relationship with Remy, which isn’t allowed since they work in the same unit. It makes work and personal complicated. Nolan and her partner are on a case of the death of a wealthy man found in a seedy area. Nothing is what it seems as the more they uncover the more questions arise. The plot had me jumping to one suspect then another as more clues came to light. There are many people hiding secrets and the truth was unpredictable. It’s an easy read, an edgy Crime/Police Procedural series that I’ve read several of and look forward to more.
An Advance Reader Copy of “City of Secrets” Detective Margaret Nolan #4, by P. J. Tracy, St. Martin’s Publishing, publication 08/20/2024, was provided by NetGalley. These are all my own honest personal thoughts and opinions given voluntarily without any compensation.

Was this review helpful?

I received a free copy of this book from the publisher. The opinions stated in this review are all my own.
This is only the second book in this series that I've read and I really like the development of the characters.
I really enjoy the P.J. Tracy books.
Detective Nolan has her hands full with a rich dude murdered in a very sketchy part of town. So many crazy "coincidences" make this such a great read. Keepanyou on your toes trying to figure out how this all ties together.

Was this review helpful?

I didn't realize when I started reading this that it was Book #4 in a series.. (Detective Margaret Nolan). Just as a heads up.

Was this review helpful?

It's been a long time since I read a PJ Tracy, but it was not hard to fall into the current situation. I enjoyed the characters and plot twists. Nice fast paced read

Was this review helpful?

I found the plot well paced and the story as a whole a page-turner. It managed to be realistic without being unduly violent and there is a fair amount of humor too. There were a couple of plot points I might quibble about - would audits etc really have missed what was going on at the pet food company? what was with that decision taken by one of the police officers at the end? - but overall, recommended.

Was this review helpful?

“City of Secrets” by P.J. Tracy
Puzzle Pieces and How many Puzzles !?!
This story kept me turning the pages for one more chapter, again and again. What a tangle of unrelated events, or, maybe not so unrelated after all. If you like puzzles… I am thinking you too will love your time in this story. Happy Reading ! !

Was this review helpful?

Margaret Nolan #4. When police detective Margaret Nolan and her partner are called to the scene of a man found shot in his car it appears to be a car-jacking gone wrong. However as they interview the victim's colleagues and family they begin to suspect there was a darker motive. When his former partner's wife is abducted the next day they are caught scrambling to uncover the motive and suspects quickly. This was the first narrative I have perused by this author. I found it to be a gritty police procedural with realistic seeming authentic depiction of contemporary LA and its violent underbelly of gangs and crime. Margaret Nolan was a strong female protagonist and the supporting cast of characters were well drawn. The plot was multi layered and kept me guessing with the tension increasing steadily as the story unfolded. If you enjoy a solid police thriller this would be a good choice. An engaging read.

Was this review helpful?

Detective Margaret Nolan fought hard to get her position in the LA SWAT Division. How could she have known over 13 years ago just how much she would grow to hate the job and the idiots assigned to her as her partners? She had hoped to be kicked upstairs into management but instead is dragging inept partners to investigate cases.

When Bruce Messane and his wife are found brutally murdered, Detective Nolan is assigned to bring the killer to justice. She will have to drag one of the rookies with her to teach them the ropes. Just the thought of this task makes her groan and turn even more caustic. What a lucky junior trainee/partner!

With a rather slow start, the action is evenly paced and the results are predictable. I enjoyed the characters and can recommend it as a great distraction. 3.5 stars – CE Williams

Was this review helpful?

This was a highly enjoyable detective procedural with great pacing, some surprising twists and turns, and likable characters. I had absolutely no idea that this is part of a series, but I don't think that took away from my enjoyment of the book. It kept me engaged and guessing until the end, with lots of potential motives and perpetrators. This author really does a nice job making the police work entertaining, which keeps you turning the pages.

Thank you!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley for the early read. I enjoyed this book as I like the character of Margaret Nolan’ as a police detective. The book was action packed from start to finish with many twists and turns to keep the reader on their toes. Margaret and her partner are an act to follow through out the dark world of violence and business.

Was this review helpful?

Detective Maggie Nolan investigates the fatal car-jacking of the owner of a company about to sell for millions. The compelling case also involves the kidnapping of the dead man’s partner’s wife. The evolving relationship between Det. Nolar and her partner Remy add to the level of complications that arise.

P.J. Tracy writes a richly complex mystery that keeps readers turning the pages. Fans will enjoy this visit with Ms. Tracy’s well-developed and growing team of characters.

Was this review helpful?