Overall, a good book and I'm excited to continue on with the series.
Has some good spice that wasn't overpowering. However pacing is everything to me and there were some spots that were a little slower than I enjoyed.

The Stars Are Dying is a stunning and emotional journey, with rich world-building and lyrical prose that immerses the reader from the start. The characters are deeply relatable, and their growth feels authentic, making it easy to connect with them. The themes of loss, love, and hope are explored with grace, leaving a lasting impact. If you enjoy character-driven stories with a touch of speculative fiction, this book is a must-read. Highly recommended!

This is a dark fantasy set in a world filled with vampires, trials, and deceit. This is a star-crossed lovers story and I like the way it explained how the MMC and FMC are connected. However, it was hard for me to connect with the plot and the world. I wanted so much more of the world, but I didn't get that. I also felt like the plot was never fully

The pacing was the biggest flaw. I felt the storyline had the intention to keep the reader hooked by withholding answers, but that didn't happen for me. Questions kept piling up and the FMC did little to attempt to answer them. I also found it to be extremely slow, and even the action scenes felt lackluster. I quickly started to lose so much interest that I even considered DNFing this. I think the reason for holding on was because of Nyte. I was so excited for this one, especially because I have the exclusive version. However, I became very bored with it and couldn't wait for it to be over. I will continue this series because the second one seems to have higher ratings than the first and to see what happens. Ngl, I'm also continuing because if the first edition is beautiful, I can only imagine the 2nd and 3rd one. Lol!

Wow!! I did not know what to expect with this book, and i had such a good time. This is a character driven story, and i really enjoyed the journey this book took us on. I know a lot of reviews mention the plot changing throughout the book but Astraea has lost her memories- only remembering the last 5 years and as she uncovers new things about her world and herself, her priorities do shift. I can't even break down the story without giving spoilers, but a lot does happen, and it was a little challenging to keep up, but I was still invested to keep going. I immediately need to know what happens after that ending. Also, I liked getting the bonus chapters at the end with the side characters Rose and Zath. I'm hoping book 2 has more found family vibes. And of course, the second bonus chapter was of Nyte's POV and I always love getting the MMC perspective!

Read if you like:

-faes, vampires, celestials
-trials
-"who did this to you?"
-slow burn
-secrets/hidden identities
-shadow daddy

I am updating ny review . Overall 3 ⭐️1.5🌶

(Why I dropped 2 stars)

I'm still a little confused with the world and magic, but I expect we will learn more in book 2, and the ending was a little predictable (it just took Astraea longer to figure it out). There was also a lot of time jumping that jolted me, and I had to re-read many times to make sure I understood what was happening.


*Bonus* The special edition is beautiful, and I am definitely adding it to my shelf!

The Stars Are Dying kicks off the Nytefall series with a cool, imaginative world and an interesting plot. The whole vibe is pretty unique, blending trials, vampires, and plenty of danger. That said, the pacing gets a bit slow at times, and some characters don’t feel fully fleshed out, which makes it harder to connect with them. If you're into rich world-building and can be patient with a slower story, this could be a fun read. It feels like there's a lot of potential for the series to really shine as it continues.

I was hyped about this book. I really enjoyed all of the elements, but I am not sure it was executed completely well. I was living for the romance, but some of the dialogue fell flat for me.

I struggled to get into this story. It had some world-building, but it didn't grab my attention and make me want to read.

Now that's what I call a morally grey male lead! The Stars Are Dying strikes a perfect balance with Nyte. It's so hard to straddle the line between dark enough to truly be morally grey and full-out villain, but Peñaranda definitely manages it. I love that Astraea is still finding her spine, but doesn't hesitate to use it as soon as possible. Wonderful to have a female lead who is, in some senses, childlike and new to the world around her, but not a complete doormat. I can't wait to see more of these two!

A lush, dark fantasy filled with star-crossed love and impossible stakes. The writing is atmospheric, pulling you into a world where every choice feels like destiny. Perfect for fans of poetic, otherworldly tales.

DNF @ 25%

I have taken so long to write this review because I was SO excited about this book, and I didn't really hate it...I just didn't like it? I didn't find myself connecting to the plot or characters, and I found the writing to be very slow. So many people DID love it and I wanted to give it another chance, but it's been four months and I think I need to admit that I'm never going to finish this book.

I think I was really uncomfortable with the initial noncon, and the FMC's starting point was really confusing and bleak, and that made it hard for me to connect to her. I like my FMC's in particular to be strong, and it seemed like this one had reasons to be the way that she was, but it took too long for me to understand them and I just needed a single moment of joy or levity for me to personally connect with the book.

I would recommend it to fantasy readers who have a lot of patience for the plot to start and want to immerse themselves in a really unique world.

I received an eARC of this book from Net Galley in exchange for an honest review.

I was unsure about this book at first. I'm not a huge fan of vampire books mostly due to the inconsistencies that seem to be inherent in them (for example saying that a vampire let out a breath he/she didn't know they were holding but having previously stated that they did not breath!!!!). However, this book was a pleasant surprise. Not only was it not solely focused on vampires a la Twilight but it also had different types of vampires and kept a lot of the vampire details vague enough to be inconsequential. In this book there are at least two different types of vampires: those who suck your blood and those who steal your soul. I believe that both take away time from your life when feeding but the soul suckers (aka Nightcrawlers) seem to be the most vicious and deadly. They also have Fae, humans and Celestials. The fae are not described in too much detail although we know of at least one by the end of the book who is a shapeshifter. Fae and Celestials were on the wrong side of the war and are either hunted, conscripted into the vampire army via mindcontrol/brainwashing, or are forced into hiding. The Celestials also seem to be hidden behind the veil? Which is only vaguely described as well. This book is about two possibly fated beings who are both each others love and doom (as well as the doom of the world's). They are finding their way back to each other (maybe). One of them remembers everything that has come to pass and the other was reborn and remembers next to nothing. The dynamic is crazy and you are left unsure if you as the reader are being manipulated as well as the characters that you are reading about. The relationships between the characters feels real and have dynamics that leave a reader unsure who they empathize with or whose side they should be on. I haven't read a book in a long time that left on such a potent line as this one did: "I know how you got that scar". Excuse me ma'am but I would like to know too! What do you mean I have to wait for book two!? Also I really enjoyed the extra scenes with Zath/Rose and Nyte at the end as bonus chapters. I cannot wait to read book two!

Imagine spending so much time together with someone that you start to love and trust them completely. They then turn around and use you for their gain and it seems like they never truly loved you in the first place.

What it is about:
Astraea finds herself thrown into a trial that her best friend was supposed to be competing in NOT her. With no memory of her past, but trying to escape her present, Astraea struggles to find who she is, survive, and figure out who she can trust since lies are around every corner. In a world full of vampires, fae, and warring kingdoms, politics rule everyone’s lives.

What I think:
This is a generous 3 stars for the story, which I enjoyed. The writing was difficult to follow, especially at the beginning. While I liked the story, I still wanted/needed more explanation of the world. This book had SO much potential. In the beginning I was automatically rooting for the FMC and was excited to learn more about the world. I might read the next book just to see what happens and if the writing gets better!

2.5/5 ⭐️ finally finished omg. i have a lot of mixed feelings about this one. overall i enjoyed it and will be reading the sequel when it comes out but this definitely wasn’t an “i can’t put this book down” read for me.

i think the biggest drawback was how predictable the plot was at times. there were a couple reveals towards the end that i didn’t see coming and were fun, but for the most part everything felt very in your face and some stuff (being a bit vague here to avoid spoilers) felt too similar to some other popular romantasy series (ACOTAR and from blood and ash come to mind specifically).

i do really like the world and i’m an absolute sucker (no pun intended) for vampires so that was a plus for me. the writing itself was very beautiful imo. i enjoyed that astrea didn’t feel like she annoyingly fixated on problems for way longer than she should like some protagonists tend to in romantasy books, but she did feel overly naïve occasionally and sometimes i was like “girl be real HOW CAN YOU NOT SEE THIS COMING”. god help me i love nyte, but this should
come as no surprise to anyone at all who knows me. the secondary characters also have a special place in my heart (shoutout zath and rose) and i think my love for the characters kept me interested most of the time and got me through some of the predictability and lulls.

it was a good read (… lol?) and i’m looking forward to getting more lore and worldbuilding in the second one because dang i need to know everything that happened to these two please

How have I not read this book sooner. I was captivated from page 1. It was very melancholy the whole time but there were parts that were happier. If you were a fan of The Crowns of Nyaxia series, this is totally for you, but it meets hunger games, meets shadow and bone, but is totally original. I ate this up. Also the MMC is very much giving mystery and like morally grey. Lived for it and the spice was top and not overlly done.

The world and the magic are truly five star elements of this book to me. The plot and character motivations lose me a lot. I really wanted to like this more, but the plot felt like it meandered a lot and that Astraea did not exactly know what was happening a lot. I think Peñaranda did an excellent job discussing the issue of domestic abuse and how Astraea recovers from that.

I am likely going to read the sequel but it may take me a minute to do so.

Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for the ARC.

I really tried to like this book.... really tried, but couldn't. I read it because I saw the second one was being released and wanted to read the first one first. Obviously. But after reading the first one, I declined the second one.
The cover is beautiful, the title is awesome, the premise is stellar, but those are the ONLY good things about this book. The story is so slow, no real plot, the fmc is all over the place.... I got about half way through, skipped several chapters and still felt like I missed absolutely nothing. There was no connection with any of the characters. Astraea gave off Paris Hilton vibes every time she encounter a new male character: "He's Hot". Really? Just ugh. Gave it a final rating of 1.75 stars and that was being generous.

The Stars Are Dying by Chloe C. Peñaranda is a dark, seductive fantasy that completely pulled me in from the start. With a unique blend of Greek mythology and pulse-pounding romance, this book is perfect for anyone who loves intense, atmospheric stories full of twists, betrayal, and, of course, irresistible vampires.

The protagonist, Astraea, is a complex and intriguing character who is trapped not only by a tyrannical king but by the elusive fragments of her own memories. Her journey to uncover the truth about her past while competing in the dangerous Libertatem trials is captivating, and I found myself invested in every step of her quest. But what really makes this story stand out is the magnetic, dangerous relationship between Astraea and Nyte, the vampire who promises her protection—yet whose motives remain shrouded in mystery. Their chemistry is electric, and the push-pull of trust and desire kept me on the edge of my seat throughout.

Peñaranda’s world-building is rich and immersive, with the dangerous and enigmatic vampires, the political intrigue of the trials, and the constant threat that looms over Astraea’s life. The tension between the dark magic, hidden truths, and the emotional stakes is incredibly well-executed, creating a story that feels both epic and personal.

The Stars Are Dying is the kind of dark fantasy that leaves you eagerly flipping pages, desperate for more. With its breathtaking romance, high-stakes action, and a heroine whose journey is as thrilling as it is heartbreaking, this book is a must-read for fans of seductive, high-stakes fantasy. Chloe C. Peñaranda has crafted a story that’s impossible to put down, and I can’t wait to see where this journey takes us next.

Thank you! Thank you! Thank you! No spoilers. Beyond amazing I enjoyed this book so very much. The characters and storyline were fantastic. The ending I did not see coming Could not put down nor did I want to. Truly Amazing and appreciated the whole story. This is going to be a must read for many many readers. Maybe even a book club pick.

I think this book has SO much potential. The world-building could be amazing and I think there is a great start for the rest of the series. The pacing (at least for me) was the hardest thing to deal with. I had been almost done with the book for awhile, but forced myself to finally finish it.

It felt like the author wanted the reader to be second-guessing or asking questions, but because of the pace, the questions felt like they weren't ever going to be answered, or too many questions came up that it made me forget what I was reading. The FMC felt like she was lacking a TRUE purpose. Yes, she lost her memories, so logically, you'd think that was what the book would focus around. But the plot felt jumpy, and would focus on side characters, before coming back to the FMC where her 'purpose' changed.

The chemistry/romance was one of the pros for this book. I think she gave them a good chemistry that readers could really fall in love with, which made the characters more relatable.

I think overall, it's possible that book 2 will be better if we have the growth that I think book 1 set up for the FMC.