Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Elle McNicoll created something special with her latest book. It might seem like your run of the mill holiday story, but its elevated by the tenderness of her characters and throwbacks to other small town enemies to lovers plots. Give it a try, it won't be a waste of your time.

Thank you to St. Martin's Press | Wednesday Books, and NetGalley for providing an eARC for a honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Some Like It Cold is the cutest small-town romance to curl up with. I loved that it didn't stray too much into the Hallmark category but instead had a decent plot with a solid cast of characters (some of whom are on the ALS spectrum).

Elle McNicoll puts readers inside the mind of Jasper for a front-seat ride of what it's like living with Autism. For persons with no experience, it makes you rethink all the small things you may take for granted- lights, sensory overload, emotions. Elle really grows as a character, especially when she starts embracing her own identity and not the picture-perfect image everyone wants from her.

The shining star for me in this book is definitely Arthur- a small-town boy who takes over his dad's legacy and hopes to make him proud while stifling his urge to explore. His chemistry with Jasper was a definite slow burn but oh so worth it! The integration of Arthurs's film definitely gave the book more dimension and structure.

There was a Bridezilla on the loose and meddling parents who may or may not mean well. Arthurs's film may do just the opposite of what it intended and may cause secrets to come to light in his innocent movie.

In a town where everything seems perfect- will Arthur's quest for the truth expose his?

Thank you to the author and NEtGalley for providing me with an arc in exchange for an honest review,

Was this review helpful?

This was such a cute book. This is my first by Elle McNicoll and definitely not my last. I loved the small town and romance was delightful. I started and finished it within 24 hours. Overall, the whole thing really worked well for me.

A special thank you to NetGalley and Wednesday Book for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I adored this heartwarming small-town romance! “Some Like It Cold” by Elle McNicoll is the latest novel from the author, and is a delightful journey. As readers, we are taken into the heart of Lake Pristine, which is a small-town where secrets simmer, old rivalries resurface, and love blossoms unexpectedly. With achingly honest prose and a cast of endearing characters, McNicoll weaves a tale that captures the essence of small-town life and the magic of unexpected connections.

Meet Jasper Montgomery. She has returned to Lake Pristine for the holidays, her heart heavy with secrets. She plans to bid farewell to her childhood home before embarking on a new chapter far away. But fate has other plans. When Jasper accidentally disrupts her sister's engagement and crosses paths with her teenage adversary, budding filmmaker Arthur Lancaster, her carefully laid-out exit strategy takes an unexpected turn.

I enjoyed the character depth! McNicoll excels at creating characters who feel like old friends. Jasper's vulnerability and determination resonate, while Arthur's brooding charm adds layers to their dynamic. Their chemistry crackles off the pages, leaving readers rooting for their happily-ever-after.

I loved being enveloped with small-town charm. Lake Pristine comes alive in McNicoll's vivid descriptions. The cozy cafes, snow-dusted streets, and quirky locals evoke a sense of nostalgia. You'll want to sip hot cocoa by the fireplace and join the town's annual snowball fight.

As always, I’m here for the enemies-to-lovers trope. The tension between Jasper and Arthur is palpable. Their witty banter and unresolved history create a delicious slow burn. As they navigate their feelings, McNicoll skillfully balances humour, heartache, and hope.

I really enjoyed the themes of home and belonging. At its core, "Some Like It Cold" explores what it means to belong in all forms: to a place, to family, and to someone special. I feel Jasper's internal struggle mirrors our own longing for connection and acceptance.

I tip my hat to the subtle nods to romance classics. McNicoll pays homage to the romance genre, infusing her story with nods to beloved tropes. As much an ode to romance's history as a modern love story, this book celebrates the genre's timeless appeal.

This story is more than a romance; it's a warm hug on a frosty day. McNicoll's prose wraps around you like a cozy scarf, inviting you to believe in second chances and the magic of unexpected love. Whether you're a seasoned romance reader or a newcomer, this book will leave you with a smile and a longing for your own Lake Pristine.

As Lizzie Huxley-Jones, author of "Make You Mine This Christmas," aptly puts it: "Achingly honest and heartfelt... quite literally my favourite romance novel of all time." Don't miss this enchanting tale because it's the literary equivalent of a steaming cup of cocoa by the fireside.

"Some Like It Cold" is a must-read for anyone who believes in the power of love, even in the chilliest of winters. McNicoll's storytelling prowess shines, and I eagerly await her next masterpiece.

Thank you to NetGalley, Wednesday Books, and St. Martin's Press for a temporary e-ARC in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

The best word I can come up with at the moment for this book is electric! I had so much fun reading this one. It’s a bit of a slow-burn romance, with plenty of humor, angst to keep the reader locked in.

Was this review helpful?