Member Reviews

I love jenny colgan, but i just cant get into this series. I finished the first book in the hopes it would capture me, but i gave up halfway through this one. The writing was great, i just dont like the characters or the plot. It seems incredibly dry and boring and i dont care what happens. Its not the escape that most jenny colgan books are, and i hate the mentions of the pandemic. It doesnt make me happy or do anything for me....im so disappointed because i love jenny colgan books

Was this review helpful?

Gertie grew up in a small town in the north of Scotland. She's never left. She lives in a very small cottage with her mother and grandmother. When she's not working at the local grocery store, she spends her time with local Knitting group. She passes the time fantasizing about how her life could be different; one day she gets the opportunity to find out.

Another delightful book by Jenny Kolgan

Was this review helpful?

Many, many thanks to NetGalley, Avon, and Voyager for providing me with the ARC in exchange for my objective review. However, I'm not very objective about Jenny Colgan as she's one of my favorite authors!

What a wonderful story! I really loved it! It had all the elements that I love about Jenny Colgan's writing:
- Great main and supporting characters
- Snarky dialogue
- Heartwarming love story
- Healing family dynamics
- Quirky animals including a chicken and a goat
- HEA

This is a sequel to "The Summer Skies". It can definitely be read as a "stand alone" but reading Book 1 first enhanced the experience as some of the same characters played supporting roles in this story.. Also, as a small bonus, the island of Mure and some of it's characters were mentioned. As this is my favorite series by this author, that was a nice touch.

There was a smattering of f-bombs but, like many of Colgan's more recent books, somewhat appropriate based on the two characters who were swearing. Definitely not as bad as Coltan in the "Mure" books, thank goodness! Also, Colgan has moved away from explicit love scenes which I find to be a big positive as well. She does tend to insert some mildly political beliefs that I'm not in agreement with but I just skim over them as they're not too "in your face" and don't detract from the overall story.

Overall a great read and I will definitely be buying the final version of this in ebook and audiobook format.

Was this review helpful?

I am glad I got to read this novel thanks to NetGalley, the publisher and of course Jenny Colgan. I was pleasantly surprised to be returning to the same location and some of the characters from her previous book Summer Skies. It’s not a sequel but I was glad I had background on those characters. The author does it again and writes a beautiful story in a beautiful location with humor, love and and a scary situation. Looking forward to more in this possible series.

Was this review helpful?

I always look forward to a new Jenny Colgan book but gave up on Close Knit after 15 chapters. While Colgan’s style of separating the main characters into individual chapters is usually seamless it does not work in this book. And the daydream reveries of Gertie make it even more disjointed. What could be conveyed in a short paragraph drags on far too long.

Was this review helpful?