
Member Reviews

I found this a very strange story. Lots of storylines and characters and a crazy folklore about The Birds. It took a long time to get into this story, there was so much going on and I know it was all needed to make the story fleshed out - but it just took to long for me to get into the real storyline.
Thank you to NetGalley, the author and publisher for a temporary, digital ARC in return for my review.

Thank you to the publisher and to NetGalley for an advanced copy of this book in exchange for a review. I enjoyed Lucy Foley’s The Guest List a few years back and was looking forward to this release. Overall I found it… fine? I enjoyed the exposition at the beginning and the setup explaining the resort and the small English town it grew out of. But I think there were one too many “big reveals” especially involving characters who were someone else than who they were pretending to be. I just didn’t buy the believability of the plot line much. It also wrapped up a little too neatly at the end as well. I gave it 3.5 stars as I found it enjoyable but wouldn’t necessarily rush out to recommend it.

Similar to a few of her other books, Lucy Foley’s latest book is a claustrophobic story as tension mounts and the reader recognizes how isolated the characters are at the retreat. Again, this isolation has been done before, so it was hard not to compare Ms. Foley’s books, but she is an entertaining writer.

Thank you to NetGalley for an eARC in exchange for an honest review.
3 stars for this one. It wasn't terrible, but I wasn't very impressed with it.

Lucy Foley's "The Midnight Feast" is a captivating read that delivers on atmosphere and intrigue but falls short in a few key areas. The novel's strength lies in its richly described settings and the palpable tension that Foley masterfully builds. The story revolves around a group of friends who gather for a weekend getaway, only for secrets and past grievances to surface, leading to unexpected and dramatic outcomes.
Foley excels at creating complex characters, each with their own motives and hidden depths. However, at times, the large cast can be overwhelming, making it difficult to keep track of everyone's backstories and relationships. Some characters feel underdeveloped, leaving readers wanting more depth and insight into their actions and decisions.
The plot is engaging and keeps you turning the pages, but it occasionally relies too heavily on clichés and predictable twists. While the suspense is well-maintained, some of the reveals feel a bit forced and less impactful than expected.
Overall, "The Midnight Feast" is an enjoyable book with a compelling premise and a gripping atmosphere. It's perfect for readers who love a good mystery with a touch of drama. However, the underdeveloped characters and predictable plot points prevent it from reaching its full potential.

I was surprised with the content of this book. I couldn’t quite keep up with the characters while reading but closer to the end, it all came together. It did have a surprising ending A good book doesn’t always need the foul language to draw people in.

I will always pick up a Lucy Foley book so was excited when I heard she was coming out with a new book. The premise of this book sounded interesting however overall it was alright.

Another great read from Lucy Foley. I enjoyed the twists and turns, the revelations about each character. As with her other books, I'll probably go back for a second read to see what little clues I missed that point to the big reveals.

3.5 stars - This was a fun, interesting, twisty thriller. Some of the twists were predictable and some weren’t, but it kept me wondering the whole what was going on. The ending was very satisfying, which I prefer with this genre. I think I preferred The Guest List a bit more, but I liked this enough to read more from this author in the future. The villain was interesting and pretty unredeemable. There are a couple good characters you feel like you can root for. Overall, I think people who are big fans of this genre are likely to not be blown away, but to have a pretty good time.
Thank you to NetGalley and William Morrow for providing me access to this eARC for my honest opinion!

This is my first Foley read, the storyline was good and I like a story where most things get tidied up nicely in the end with the story.
Not a huge fan of the amount of characters/ names that get flung at you all at once but it does tie in at the end, I'm definitely looking forward to the next one.
You just tend to get the right amount of feels from each character as you should with how the story progresses. You are meant to see right and wrong as you go and it's got it's "oooohhhh, that's from this" moments thrown in a decent bit.

In yet another murder mystery set on a charming island off southern England, we find ourselves at The Manor, an all-inclusive retreat where wealthy city dwellers come to escape and immerse themselves in nature. However, local resentment brews as the townspeople disapprove of the affluent guests encroaching on what they consider their land.
The mystery unfolds in a manner reminiscent of a Scooby-Doo adventure. While the locals seem menacing, they don't present any real danger to the guests at the hotel. Francesca's incessant, over-the-top talk about the "healing" aspects of the retreat grew increasingly irritating. Despite these elements, the book is an enjoyable read—perfect for a beach getaway.

Never have I ever felt such a profound feeling of love, community, and hope from a thriller. The final paragraph of Lucy Foley's The Midnight Feast saw my server at a City Taphouse asking if I was alright, because I started sobbing openly. The Midnight Feast solidified its place as one of my favorite books ever—an honor a thriller has never held before. I cannot express how much this absolutely mystical and haunting book meant to me without veering into spoilers. Thank you so much to William Morrow for the opportunity to be shaken to my core with this advanced review copy.

I enjoyed most of this book. My biggest problem came from the cult vibes of it. I’m not a huge fan of that trope, but otherwise it was a very atmospheric read.

Kind of a slow burn that definitely had more focus on the characters than the overall plot, needed to trudge through the first 100 pages or so.

Unfortunately, "The Midnight Feast" by Lucy Foley didn't quite live up to my expectations. It was not a bad book, just not for me. While I've loved other books by this author, I found this one to be a slow burn that failed to keep me engaged. I wasn't able to finish it, but I appreciate Foley's writing style and will definitely give her future works a try.

This thriller was top notch! The pacing was just right and kept the reader just wanting more. The use of different character perspectives and movement between past and present was weaved together with perfection answering questions just in time to have you asking new ones.
I loved the creepy vibes that the author wove throughout the book. The small town setting and local lore even gave this book a supernatural feeling at times.
This book will make your jaw drop by the last page, breaking down events that you didn't think could have more angles to reveal. This book is must for thriller readers!!!

Another Foley classic twist and turn mystery!
You don't ever leave your past behind.
Lucy Foley’s The Midnight Feast is a suspenseful mystery that will keep readers on the edge of their seats. Set in an opulent estate, the novel brings together a diverse group of characters for a weekend gathering that quickly spirals into chaos. Foley excels at creating a gripping atmosphere, drawing readers into a world of secrets, revenge and local lore.
Told through multiple POV's, each voice distinct and engaging, adding depth to the story as hidden motives and personal grievances come to light. The pacing is brisk, and the tension builds masterfully, culminating in a climax that’s both surprising and satisfying. THE LAST LINE WAS A MASTERPIECE.
Fans of psychological thrillers and character-driven mysteries will find much to enjoy in this well-crafted novel.

The atmospheric setting of this book was absolutely perfect, and I'm still thinking about it a month later. However, the book just had too many points of view for me to be too interested in any one character, so it would often lose me at times. I did enjoy the twists and definitely did not see them coming! Overall a fun read.

So grateful to have received this as an ARC! This is my first read from this author, and it will not be the last. I went in knowing nothing about the plot and was blown away!
The hottest new luxury hotel, The Manor, is having its opening night—a big fish in a small town. Hear from multiple viewpoints, each carrying a secret, culminating with a murder by the end of the night.
Think White Lotus.

Pretty good book. I loved the resort setting. Kinda predictable but not so much that I won’t seek out the author again.