Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Lucy Foley does it again with a fantastic multi-character perspective that ties up beautifully in the end. Bella arrives at The Manor for the grand opening with less than pure motives. For Francesca, the opening of The Manor is everything she’s worked toward her entire life. Flashbacks intertwine Bella and Francesca’s stories and by the end, you can’t put it down because you’re desperate to know how it ends. Thanks so much to NetGalley and William Morrow for the ARC - all opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

3.5/5 Stars
*ARC Review*

I've always heard great things about Lucy Foley's writing, but I had yet to jump into her thriller world. Reading Midnight Feast was a fun and exciting journey, and I can see why people enjoy her novels so much. I had some issues with the pacing and twist heavy aspects of the novel, but it was overall a positive experience.

It did take me quite a while to get into the book as I was reading. Foley is known for writing about unlikable characters, but I found most of them either too annoying or too boring to really grasp onto. I enjoy books where I can feel like I'm rooting for people I like to win, but I just wasn't getting that sense when the story started. As time went on and the plot got more involved, I found myself enjoying it more and more, and by the end, I was invested in the characters' arcs. Foley's writing was strong throughout, it was just the plot I had a hard time getting into. In particular, I never really got into the cult aspects of the book, and felt like they only added confusion into an otherwise fascinating story. The book felt like an upward climb for the first 150 pages, but like any good hike, I was glad when I reached the top and felt much lighter on the way down.

My only drawback from the second half of the novel was the endless barrage of twists happening in seemingly every other chapter. I found myself excited and surprised in the best way by the first few, then slightly confused by the next, and finally feeling like it was all too convenient in the end. No spoilers until the book is released, but there's just a lot of coincidences that make all the revelations work. Still, overall I found myself in awe of Foley's ability to lay the foundation for these interesting twists, and the drama of the third act was so perfectly tense and action filled, I could forgive a few convenient connections for the sake of the plot.

This book isn't going to the top of my favorites list, but I think it's an enjoyable journey that I will definitely be recommending to people for a exciting summer read. It made me excited to dive into some of Foley's other novels and see how they compare to her latest. This story might not have entirely worked for me, but Foley's gripping writing style will make anyone who ventures in glad for the overall experience.

Was this review helpful?

The midnight feast is decadent with setting, with mood and detail, and is a summer treat that makes me want to stay out late lounging under twinkle lights with a mojito and a good book.

A treat, a feast if you will, for mystery lovers and new and old fans of Lucy Foley! Thank you to Willam Morrow for the early review copy.
Foley succeeds in creating a tension filled story that pulls the reader into mystery and intrigue, a locked room delight filled with well paced reveals while keeping the reader guessing.
Foley always captures a sense of unraveling/unease so well and the best part of her books is seeing how she weaves the story together, laying out a puzzle and letting the reader enjoy the way the pieces fall into place. T

Was this review helpful?

The Midnight Feast is a masterfully crafted locked room murder mystery that keeps readers on the edge of their seats. Known for her gripping narratives in The Guest List and The Paris Apartment, the author delivers once again with a tantalizing blend of suspense and intrigue. The story is set against the lavish backdrop of The Manor's opening night, where opulence and tension mix dangerously under the midsummer sun.
As guests indulge in luxurious amenities and signature cocktails, dark secrets and old grudges simmer beneath the surface. When a body is discovered following a fire, the narrative takes a thrilling turn. The author skillfully weaves together the perspectives of the founder, the husband, the mystery guest, and the kitchen help, unraveling a fifteen-year-old secret that leads to a shocking murder.
With its richly atmospheric setting and well-drawn characters, The Midnight Feast is a delectable treat for mystery lovers. While the multitude of perspectives can occasionally feel overwhelming, the twisty plot and clever revelations ensure this book is a satisfying read. The author's knack for building suspense and delivering unexpected twists earns this novel a well-deserved four stars.
Thank you to NetGalley, the author and the publisher for providing me with a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review!

Was this review helpful?

Lucy Foley is an auto-buy author for me, so I was excited to pick up her new release, The Midnight Feast. I'm a sucker for locked room mysteries and rich people behaving badly, so the blurb for this one grabbed me right away. This will not rate as my favorite Lucy Foley book (The Guest List holds that honor) but it was a solid thriller and I'm so glad I had the opportunity to immerse myself inside of Foley's twisty brain.

The setting for this book is beautiful and Foley sets the scenes so vividly that I could feel the damp night air on my skin and smell the sea. It's also easy to feel the tension ramping up as you read further into this story. These pages flew by for me because I was invested in the characters and kept wanting "just one more chapter" before I put the book down for the night.

However, there were a lot of characters to get to know (5 mains and many sides), many of whom are categorically unlikable. Once you settle into the story it gets easier to remember who is who, but the beginning was a bit confusing until I spent more time in this world. The folklore element was very intriguing to me and I wish we got even more of that in this story. Lastly, there's a bit of teen angst in journal entries throughout the book. Reader know thyself if angsty teenage thoughts are not for you.

Thank you to NetGalley, William Morrow, and Lucy Foley for the opportunity to read an advanced review copy of The Midnight Feast in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

The summaries of Lucy Foley's books always intrigue me. I just can't seem to get along with her writing. I wish this wasn't the case but again, it was. I could not get into the story, the characters were lackluster to me. I did not care for the weird hotel atmosphere or the clients of the hotel. This was not for me and I don't think I will be picking up another Lucy Foley book.

Was this review helpful?

I initially thought The Midnight Feast was going to be a slow burn, but after a few chapters I realized how wrong I was. The Midnight Feast became a book that was hard to put down, switching between present day and multiple time-points, but all focused on the Manor: an estate nestled in the Woodlands. The Woodlands is a luxurious estate owned by Francesca's family, but the rest of the community is struggling to make ends meet. In childhood, Francesca becomes friends with some of the locals, one in particular, who then comes back fifteen years later when Francesca opens up the Manor as a luxury getaway. In present day, a dead body washes up on shore and the book takes us through a story as we try to uncover who the dead body is... and what other secrets The Manor holds. Excellent book and highly recommend for fans of Lucy Foley!

Was this review helpful?

The midnight feast

The guest list was my first DNF ever so I was slightly worried about this book. But over all, I’d give this book a 5-star review!
It makes me want to give the guest list a second chance.

This book was a one-session read for me! I couldn’t put it down. I was worried I would get confused with how many perspectives there were but it was easy to keep everyone straight!

There were some intense moments sprinkled throughout that made you want to keep reading! I felt there was a healthy amount of twists and a great plot! Hope to read more from this author soon.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you Netgalley for the chance to read this!
I would give this a solid 3.5 stars. I'm not a diehard fan of Lucy Foley, but I really enjoyed the twisty, multi POV multi timeline arc of this story. I liked knowing right from the get go there was a murder, but having to pull together the pieces to see which of our main leads was actually dead and who could have been in the right place at the right time. I also really loved the epistolary flashback chapters from Bella's journal, where we learned and really solidified how creepy the woods could be. There was so much going on here but the timeline structure really came together well to leave you really invested in each storyline. The visualizations of the manor turned swanky hotel were really great, and I connected with the idea of a wellness hotel built overtop of a struggling but supportive poor society, and what that meant for each character.
I did have to suspend my disbelief in a few sections, particularly around everyone's 'fake' identities and who they truly were in each time period. That got a bit difficult to follow, and a bit farfetched that none of them would recognize each other. I thought the twists, around a) who was dead b) what happened in the woods years ago c) what happened with Jake were all really good, but also left a bit to be desired? I so wanted more.
The reveal of "The Birds" was excellent though. No way to discuss without spoilers, but thought this was just a brilliant move.

Was this review helpful?

This is my first Lucy Foley book and I am so excited to get more into her thrilling stories. For me, it took a little bit to get into this one but I knew if I stuck with it I wouldn't regret it.

The Manor hotel is hosting a luxurious wellness weekend by the owner Francesca Meadows. She inherited this property and wants to bring it back to life despite all the drama surrounding it. She sees this as a new start as she's spent years trying to reinvent herself. Unfortunately for her, there's only so much she can do to keep the secrets and lies at bay. There are still many people who know the truths of the on goings of this property back in the day and they are coming out of the woodwork to make sure things are corrected. Especially the birds, and you don't want to upset them.

I loved how Lucy Foley was able to provide so many different point of views and not make it confusing. I was able to follow along with each one and be able to keep the story straight. I had so many different feelings towards all of the characters throughout the whole story it was hard to decide who was good or not. I loved the journal entries taking us back in time to provide context to this story and it really kept me guessing the whole time. Just when you think you are catching on to what is going to come she throws you for another loop and the process starts all over which is something I love in a good thriller book. I don't want to be able to figure it out but I love trying the whole time it really keeps me intrigued. I liked the folklore concerning the birds and how that played into things that happened.

Even though this took me a short bit to get perfectly hooked, once I was in I couldn't put this down. I HAD to know what happened! Thank you Netgalley for the opportunity to read this in advance in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I've been eager to read the guest list and the Paris apartment since they came out. So o was excited to catch up on her newest book of the year to explore Lucy Foley's writing.

The story follows multiple POVs and provides diary entries written in a past timeline. A manor sits on the edge of a forest. This manor was newly renovated to a luxury hotel. The locals in town are not happy and neither are the birds from the woods. A lot if strange events begin to take place.

The beginning gripped me, the middle served various plot twists and the ending tied everything together.

This books offers scenery, Secrets, superstitious folklore. Murder and a creepy manor.
I will be picking more up from Lucy Foley.

Was this review helpful?

4.5 stars

A summer full of teenage shenanigans comes back to haunt its cast 15 years later…

Francesca Meadows is opening an uber-posh resort at her family’s seaside manor, perfect for London execs who want to get away from the city. But on opening weekend, there are more than just a few loose ends. Multiple people who were there years before arrive with different agendas and not everyone is keen to see Francesca succeed, and you don’t want to mess with the locals in Tome.

Told in Foley’s classic multiple-POV style, the drama unfolds with a lot of connections, delicious revenge, and a few surprises. A quick read that will keep you guessing and turning the pages.

Was this review helpful?

An interesting premise of a luxury resort opening night gone wrong. A lot of buildup with some unexpected twists and reveals. An easy but captivating enough read where you'll want to know what happens next.

I'm not sure I loved the writing though. It incorporated a lot of modern references (TikTok, Instagram, memes, etc) which isn't necessarily bad per se, but there was a lot of it. The novel does take place in 2025, so the references are very time-accurate, but I still feel like it really dates the book.

I also feel like the imagery also could've been richer. It takes place in a woodsy, small town, and I wanted more of that atmosphere. There was a lot of description of how the characters felt (scared, spooked, etc), but I would've preferred if more time was spent setting up the scene and a little less repetition of how the characters felt.

I thought it was interesting how the story interwove the story from before and after the solstice, and the way this setup was used to throw in some red herrings. I was still left with some unanswered questions but overall enjoyed the ending.

Thank you to Netgalley and William Morrow for the ARC!

Was this review helpful?

So so good! Probably my favorite Lucy Foley book to date which is saying a lot. Completely unpredictable with plot twist, after plot twist. Kept me guessing until the very end.

Was this review helpful?

This book was super creepy and fun to read. It kept me guessing and had me nervous. I really enjoyed the multiple POV and the storytelling style. I wish there had been a bit more shock and twist to it.

Thank you NetGalley for the ARC!

Was this review helpful?

What an odd, but interesting book. First, it took me awhile to get into this book - there was a lot of set up for the climax and, at times, it felt like a bit of a slog to get through. However, when it picked up it quickly becomes fast-paced and WILD. Additionally, there are a lot of characters and voices - and different timelines, so if you are not completely focused, it can be difficult to keep track of all that has happened.

Once it does pick up, I felt like it was one twist after another and, visually, it felt like this novel was made to be a movie. And I think that speaks to Foley's ability to create such details in her atmosphere.

At the end of the day, I definitely enjoyed the ride this book took me on; I was not expecting many of the twists and grew to really hate most of the characters. It's one of those books where you feel you are rooting for the demise of everyone involved because they are just terrible people. (But terribly people are usually the most fun to watch/read about, right?)

Was this review helpful?

Thank you, NetGalley and William Morrow for the opportunity to review this ARC 🥹

3.5/5 ⭐️⭐️⭐️✨️

Overall, the storyline kept me engaged! Loved the multiple viewpoints

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to NetGalley and William Morrow for this ARC! The Manor is a new resort set in the Dorset Coast surrounded by down on their luck locals. The owner, Francesca, plans a grand opening weekend but things keep going wrong and the rumor is “the birds,” a local legend, is to blame. The story is told from 5 different point of views and jumps back in time via old diary entries. Everyone has secrets and the connections slowly unfold as the book goes on. In true Lucy Foley fashion, there were twists and reveals I did not see coming but the excessive POVs, and timeline jumping made the plot hard to follow. The ending was satisfying though, and I liked the added element of a local folklore and history.

Was this review helpful?

Many thanks to NetGalley for giving me the opportunity to read this ARC!

This is my first book from Lucy Foley and in all honesty...this was quite difficult to read. While there were moments I found enjoyable, there were also a lot of multiple identities, strange sequences that seemed unrelated to anything else, and a constant assumption that people wouldn't know others from the past.

The premise sounded interesting and I liked the setting but there were too many characters some of them have even changed their names and identities. Between the staff and the police, it was hard keeping up with all the characters. I did enjoy reading pasts of a journal that ties into the story and there were some twists and turns that raised my eyebrows!

even though this book was not my favorite, I will definitely be reading other books from her like The Paris Apartment!

Was this review helpful?

💕read if you…💕
-binge watched white lotus
-love locked-room mysteries with multiple povs
-enjoy books that keep you second guessing up until the very end

👍🏻what i enjoyed…👍🏻
-the setting was perfect and really anchored the story between the past and the present
-each character was deceptive and morally grey in their own way which created this extra layer of complexity to the story
-the plot twist literally had me gasping! i was totally caught off guard and i loved that!

💬thoughts💬
wow! just wow! the midnight feast is one of my most anticipated releases of 2024 and i’m so grateful that i received an ARC! lucy foley one of my auto buy authors and the midnight feast did not disappoint. told in multiple povs and following a non-linear timeline, i found the characters to be deceiving and the plot utterly addictive. i mean, who doesn’t love a “whodunit” plot set on a luxury manor resort where people’s lies, deceptions, and secrets will all be revealed?
overall, if you have the chance to buy the midnight feast when it’s released in June 2024… DO. IT. you won’t be disappointed!

Was this review helpful?