Skip to main content

Member Reviews

⟡ fake dating
⟡ professional athlete x team photographer
⟡ trauma, grief
⟡ one bed trope

Amazing Debut book!

Maggie is a photographer for the Chicago Cougars, her favorite team. After getting a small cheap camera and going to games as a little girl with her dad she fell in love with the sport and pictures. She decided to capture it all.
After not having been in a relationship for the last four years due to a traumatic experience. She thought she would be alone forever and only ever experience love through her favorite romcom movies.
Back at work she finds out that Tommy Mikals was joining the team. His reputation is well known. He is a ladies man, a heartbreaker, and not monogamous. But is this all true?
Tommy is a professional baseball player who got swept up in the fast life of money, women, and parties. His relationship with her father played a huge part of how he fell into this career of baseball.
When Maggie and Tommy are seen in a scandalous picture the Cougars PR team decides having Tommy being seen with a relatable nice girl like Maggie can fix his reputation. The two are set up to fake date but when they aren’t able to fake how they feel what will happen.

I really enjoyed this sweet easy romantic comedy book. I love sport romance books! I’m especially excited to read the rest of this series I know all the other boys on the team will be getting a book. I love interconnected series with teammates, friends, or family. The miscommunication trope at the end really threw me just because that trope is so annoying and hard to get through. Overall it was so amazing and so so cute.

Thank you Ally Wiegand. Thank you Netgalley and thank you 8th Note Press publishing for this arc.

Was this review helpful?

This was such a cute and easy read!
This book had a lot of my favorite tropes and was overall heart warming. This book was beautifully written! Not only was this book about a sports romance, it took a deep dive into the characters lives and backgrounds and the relationship they built. I think this book covers certain topics that I think others can relate too.

Tommy , a bad boy trying to redeem his reputation and past, strikes a deal with Maggie and the ChicagoCougars to keep his career. Maggie, a MLB photographer who gets caught up in the paparazzi with Tommy and suddenly her career is also on the line. To avoid them loosing their jobs, they must pretend to be in a relationship.

Was this review helpful?

Baseball Romance! Yes!!!
This was such a cute book!
It was an easy read and the writing was great! It was my favorite tropes so I might be a little bias, but fake dating and one bed are THE BEST! When Maggie was going into detail about why she loved baseball it stuck home for me because I grew up watching it with my dad too.

Favorite lines: “Just because this isn’t real doesn’t mean I can’t still treat you right.” & “Maggie, will you shut up for one second?”

why I gave it 4 and not 5:
It was close door/not detailed spice, and I know there are people that prefer it that way and I’m not knocking it. But, for me when the tension was building and you knew it was about to happen and there were few details… I was devastated.

Was this review helpful?

A baseball fake dating with sprinkle of only one bed? Yes, please!

A great start for a debut author. The story was character driven and I definitely enjoyed Tommy and Maggie’s development.

Tommy and Maggie felt like real people, they weren’t perfect, but you kept rooting for them.

I enjoyed that while Tommy and Maggie pushed each other to do better, they let each other improve at their own pace.

I really enjoyed the story, it was cozy but with heart.

Overall no major complaints. I would rate it 4.5/5.

Was this review helpful?

An engaging baseball romance. From fake to real with interesting back stories. Family and friend relationships, too. A sweet romance but there is foul language and steamy scenes which I skipped. Thanks to the publisher for providing a copy via NetGalley. My review is voluntary.

Was this review helpful?

Overall I wasn't a fan, and only ready 30% of it. I really did not like how the fake dating relationship happened (your fired or else).

Was this review helpful?

(4.8 ⭐️)
(2.5 🌶️)

This book was so much more than a sports romance. Holy crap! This had me hooked from the opening line. Baseball has always held a place in my heart, and this book really played on my heart strings. Maggie is so relatable and if you’ve experienced loss, reading this book will be therapeutic. I cried throughout because it was just so beautiful. This is not just a sports romance book, it’s a book about two damaged people who heal each other, by simply being there. Sometimes we just need the right person to come along and show us the path back to ourselves. I absolutely loved this!

Was this review helpful?

Oh my, Lanta, was this the cutest little read! Ally knocked this slow burn, cozy romance out of the park! I couldn't put this book down!

Tommy is the perfect reformed playboy. I'm in love with the fact that he started to change his ways BEFORE meeting the girl. Most of the time, it's the girl making the MMC change their ways. But with Tommy, he recognized his downwards spiral and decided to change before meeting Maggie, which ends up making him perfect for her!

Maggie is 3 years into trying to emotionally & mentally recover from a traumatic event. And while her situation with Tommy propels her to have to finally face those emotions, I like how Ally wrote Maggie's journey as a self-discovery after a traumatic event. Maggie grew and overcame because of her desire to want to be with Tommy.

I'm usually the girl who LOVES spicy, steamy scenes. But the way Ally wrote this fade to black scene was so incredible. You could really feel all the emotions both characters had in that moment. Nothing was rushed, and you got the intensity of the moment without going into graphic detail.

I definitely recommend this book for anyone looking for a cozy sports romance!

Was this review helpful?

I liked this romance. I wished there had been some more depth to the characters and the story itself as it felt kind of surface but I thought it was really sweet. Definitely a fun quick read.

Was this review helpful?

I could really relate to Maggie and I was so excited to see how she came out of her shell to figure nd love again. I think it is a great message that sometimes love is out there when we least expect it and I think this book captures that beautifully

Was this review helpful?

3.5🌟
I loved this! It was so cute and the things they would say to each other were so cute and wholesome. This book is fade to black so there are no descriptive scenes but I was okay with it because the story was great! I love this concept it's very unique and I loved our fmc because she had a lot of depth emotions as she discovered how to love someone again. Our mmc was fine but I feel like his "bad boy" reputation was nonexistent and we didn't really see much development from him. Overall I loved this it was a cute, fluffy, and short pallet cleanser!

Was this review helpful?

I received a copy of this for my honest review.

Our FMC is the photographer for Chicago baseball team,, and has kept herself from any kind of romantic entanglement since her fiance died four years ago. The day before opening day she is at the field taking some photos when she sees the teams newest addition. Our MMC was just signed as the newest short stop, but is on a very short leash because of his past life as a bad boy. To celebrate opening day the whole team goes out to a club, but it's really not either of their kind of scene. He can sense she is uncomfortable and offers to take her home, but as they leave the paparazzi snap a photo of them. Because he's trying to reshape his image, and she works for the team, the PR department decides they can work with this and set up a fake dating agreement. He agrees, but he has motives beyond his image - he wants to know her. He recruits his teammates to help him keep the girl, while she is working on taking down the wall she has built up. Is this too good to be true, is the past too much to overcome?

Was this review helpful?

I was really excited to read this sports romance and thought it was a great story for a debut novel. I enjoyed the fake dating, that trope has always been a favorite of mine! I liked that the main characters had interesting backstories that gave them more depth than just the romance. It also made it easier to connect with them throughout the book. I liked seeing Maggie navigate through her grief and Tommy grow out of his wild past.

I’m not a big fan of the instalove and miscommunication tropes, which is why i’m giving this book 3 stars. The conflict could’ve been resolved more quickly if the fmc would’ve just listened to the mmc and i thought the third act breakup was unnecessary but overall it was a solid debut!

Thank you Netgalley and the publisher for providing me this ARC in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Woof. I love a leading man with a player past who ends up falling for the woman he's in a fake relationship. Give him a sleeve of tattoos and you've got me, hook, line, and sinker (book pun not intended). I loved Maggie and Tommy's relationship SO much. Their chemistry was wicked from the get go when she got hurt just because she was so busy checking him out, and he was the first one to see if she was okay. I knew from then on out that things would be heated, and boy was I not let down. I loved the little character arc tommy went on from bad boy player to Maggie's, and Maggie's only. It reminds me a lot of Hook Line and Sinker by Tessa Bailey, but only in the way that I love reformed player MMCs.

I truly loved Olivia and her entire character. she was always up to bat for Maggie, and never let her doubt herself OR Tommy. she was the push Maggie sometimes needed.

And Tommy donating to the boys and girls club has my heart because I didn't even think that authors like, knew that place existed. I work for the boys and girls club organization and it is truly a wonderful place so to see it in a book made me so happy.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley and 8th Note Press for the e-arc in exchange for an honest review.

Tropes:
-Sports romance
-He falls first and harder
-Fake dating
-One bed
-Slow burn

Maggie is content with her life as a photographer for a Chicago MLB team. Tommy Mikals is a professional baseball player who gets traded to the team on his final stings, after years as a playboy partier. Circumstances lead to a contract being presented forcing both their hands into a fake relationship to save both their jobs. Can they keep their true feelings at bay?

Thoughts: I found myself enjoying this debut novel. As a big baseball fan myself I found the expressions of love for the game very profound and endearing.
Tommy definitely fell first and harder. I do wish we had a bit more chapters on his POV as I loved seeing his thoughts and I wish we could’ve had a bit more insight on his past. I loved how genuine he was with Maggie and how he made acts of love seem so effortless.

I loved Maggie and found her character to be relatable. She went through trauma in her past and it affected her views on relationships, which is understandable. I did want to yell at her a few times at how oblivious she was on Luke’s affection towards her.

Overall it was a nice cozy read that I would recommend to those who are delving into the sports romance genre.

I do hope Jamil gets his own book!

Trigger warning: past trauma and mentions of car accident and death of loved one

Was this review helpful?

This is an adorable sports romance set in the world of baseball (if you hadn't already figured that out haha). Baseball is the only sport that I enjoy watching occasionally so this was right up my alley. I loved that the female main character also had a job related to the team. It felt more organic this way instead of just a random person.

This book uses the fake dating trope, but it felt more natural than it normally does for me. If you love a good sports romance with very little spice, this book is for you!

Was this review helpful?

this book had everything I love in a rom com and MORE! I’m always in for a sports romance, but to add in a pro baseball player, team photographer, some fake dating, and 2 complex characters that I felt like I was really able to relate to… perfection. I would 100% recommend this one.

that moment when the fake dating becomes real- YES. LOVE.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley and 8th Note press for the opportunity to review First Base by Ally Wiegand. It is the story of a couple of damaged people find a way to heal through loving each. It was very sweet. The two are caught by paparazzi leaving a club, as he innocently was just trying to give her a lift home. His contract requires him to have no scandals and she is the team photographer. Obviously this calls for a fake relationship. The difference is they both really like each other. So really the are just dating. He is still a mess from a strained relationship with his father and she is still broken from having lost her fiancé in a car accident where she was driving. Their sweet relationship carries them to healing. It is really a sweet book. However, for me I t lack sizzle and there was no real conflict, There is a somewhat manufactured third act breakup, which I don’t think it needed. Overall, it is a nice debut.

Was this review helpful?

Maggie is a good girl with a past trauma and is a photographer for a processional baseball team. Tommy is the new short stop on the team with the bad reputation behind him. When they meet, they are instantly attracted. There is a no fraternization policy so Maggie knows better than to get involved. Tommy needs to leave women alone and change his reputation to keep his career. One picture changes both of their lives in ways they never imagined. Follow Maggie and Tommy as they navigate the baseball season and the complications that come their way. They are forced into a fake relationship but trip into real feelings. Can they overcome the past to make a future together?
There are some sensitive topics in this book. The FMC deals with trauma. Know that before reading. Overall, the book made me laugh, cry, yell, smile, giggle, shout, all of the feelings! Such a great book. It was a sweet and quick read.
Thank you to Net Galley for the eARC of this book.

Was this review helpful?

Read this if you love fake dating and the baseball player x photographer trope. This book was a short and sweet read but I did not enjoy the miscommunication and third-act break up.

Was this review helpful?