Really fun, cozy mystery with an interesting cast of characters and a great lead! I love an older protagonist and Sherry was a nice mix of plucky and smart but not over-the-top. Her backstory was interesting and I enjoyed how she pieced the mystery together. I hope this is the start of a series because I would love to revisit these characters!

Thanks to Netgalley for the e-ARC! All opinions are my own.

Not posting on sites because not rating higher than 3 stars. Just posting on Goodreads instead of social media.

This was a cozy mystery with paranormal aspects. I think I would have enjoyed it more as just a cozy mystery. However, the hint at another book makes the paranormal bit sound fun. I hoped to give this book a higher rating, but the characters were flat. Nothing to grab onto to make me want to be a part of them. I hope they are more fleshed out in the next book because the promise of them sounds fun. I grew to understand the paranormal parts of the story even though it was a bit disconnected and underwhelming in this book. I chalk this all up to world-building in book one. I liked the mystery and had to finish the book to find out who did it, plus, I loved the heroine’s name…Sherry Pinkwhistle. How can you not smile at that?

Audience: Adult
Plot: 3.5 out of 5
Characters: 3 out of 5
Spice: 0 out of 5
Keywords: Mystery, Fantasy, Librarians, Cats, Murder Investigation, Paranormal
Tea Pairing: Reading Nook Tea Blend by Plum Deluxe

I received a copy of this book NetGalley from Ace / Berkeley Publishing Group. Thank you! All opinions are my own.

The Village Library Demon-Hunting Society is a cozy mystery, centered around an older librarian in the fictional town of Winesap, New York. Sherry Pinkwhistle has helped investigate a number of murder mysteries in the past. But when there’s a murder that hits a bit too close to home, she begins to think something strange is going on in Winesap.

This novel reminded me of classic Agatha Christie mysteries, as there were many references to Poirot and Miss. Marple scattered throughout. Which I think added a bit of flair to the book, and sort of gave an alternate reality vibe to the story.

My favorite scene had to be when Sherry’s cat, Lord Thomas Cromwell, began talking and guiding her throughout her latest investigation. I also enjoyed the author’s way of providing insight to Sherry, especially through her inner-monologues, most of which were rather humorous.

Overall, I would recommend this book to anyone who may enjoy a cozy mystery, with paranormal elements, or to fans of Christie. At the conclusion of the novel, it was left open for a sequel. And I can’t wait to see what future adventures Sherry and the Village Library Demon-Hunting Society get into.

A cozy mystery that combines demon-hunting with a librarian running the show when the cops can't solve a case! I did like some of the twists and thought it had good pacing. I wasn't the biggest fan of some of the characterization choices for the MC but I think she could be really likeable to some.

I also enjoy books that have middle aged main characters. I feel like we get stuck the late 20s/early 30s range a lot in these type of series.

Murder She Wrote meets Buffy the Vampire Slayer - this was SUCH a fun take on a cozy mystery. Found myself laughing out loud several times, and Sherry Pinkwhistle was a gem of a character. Not your typical sweet old lady librarian detective...or is she??

There's also a cat named Lord Thomas Cromwell! Who may or may not be inhabited by the spirit of the kingmaker himself! How can you not love it??

I am going to be honest with you. I truly thought that I was going to love this book because I always enjoy reading cozy mystery books. Unfortunately, this book fell flat for me. It had potential with its possessed cat, librarian as a main character, and solving crimes in their hometown. All of these components should add up for a fantastic cozy mystery read. However. I found myself a bit bored or annoyed with the main character. I don't know what it is, but the main character was very annoying throughout the whole book. I understand how important it is to protect your hometown, but it doesn't mean to take everything upon yourself endlessly. It makes no sense.

Thank you so much Wednesday books and Netgalley for this free ARC!!

This book was definitely fun! It was also a bit strange. It’s a supernatural novel crossed with a murder mystery and that is certainly reflected in the writing.
I enjoyed it but I did stop multiple times because I thought it was especially cheesy. Maybe that was the point, idk. But I found myself just wanting to hurry up and get to the end so I could figure out the murder. And honestly I could have done without the supernatural aspect of it completely. It was actually better without it in my opinion. Still a good story.
.
.
ʏᴏᴜʟʟ ʟɪᴋᴇ ᴛʜɪꜱ ɪꜰ ʏᴏᴜ ʟɪᴋᴇ:
•cozy mystery
•supernatural
•Agatha Christie novels
•murder mystery

A fun read that definitely makes you suspect the author spent a lot of pandemic lockdown time watching murder mystery tv shows! I read this at the beach and I enjoyed it and found it light and engaging.

4*

This was a fun romp through a cosy supernatural mystery series, led by a small town librarian who dreams of being a detective.

There were plenty of exciting and unexpected twists and turns, and a lot of lovable characters along the way.

A great cozy mystery with lots of twists I didn't see coming. Highly recommend this book. Would be great for a book group.

"The Village Library Demon-Hunting Society" by C. M. Waggoner is a thrilling and whimsical adventure that cleverly combines literature with the supernatural. The charming characters, each with their unique quirks, create a lively dynamic that keeps the narrative engaging and fun. Waggoner's witty writing style shines through, infusing humor into the action-packed plot while exploring themes of friendship and courage. The imaginative setting of a village library as a hub for demon-hunting adds a delightful twist that fans of fantasy will love. Overall, this novel is a captivating blend of magic and mischief that will leave readers eager for more adventures.

This book is the perfect cozy autumn read that’s super cute. The main character is the sassy older lady, Sherry Pinkwhistle, who is the village librarian who happens to have a knack for solving murders. When an acquaintance comes to the library asking sherry to solve her husband’s murder and doesn’t know why, Sherry begins to realize something is off in their tiny little town. She seems to be stuck in a loop of Library, life and solving crimes… but why are there so many crimes in such a small town? And why are things slipping from people’s memories? When the next murder strikes close to her and things at home begin to get a little strange, Sherry will need all the help she can get to stop whatever is happening in her town. The small-town setting enhances the cozy feeling of the story, and the library sounds so cute, I wish it was my library. The colorful cast of side characters add different levels of humor and insight to help Sherry through it all. The magical elements of the story are swoon worthy, but I’ll save the surprise for you to read for yourself. Fans of cozy mysteries and cozy fantasy can rejoice that both elements can be found in this one magical book. If you are a fan of Murder, She Wrote and Buffy the Vampire Slayer then you should just go and get this book now.

Unfortunately I had to DNF this one at around the 33% mark. The plot wasn’t doing it for me personally but I’m sure lovers of cozy mysteries will enjoy this one!

Sherry Pinkwhistle is a librarian investigates her small town. She is also an amateur sleuth who helps solve murders. When the body count of murders starts to pile up, Sherry questions something else might be happening. She joins forces with a unique group of people to put a stop to demonic forces.

I couldn't connect with this story, but I couldn't place my finger on why. I read some of the reviews on Goodreads, someone mentioned this book felt like a sequel & that felt 100% accurate! We just jumped into the story of Sherry, the town librarian, solving murders on the side. It also felt like so much was thrown into the story that it got a bit overwhelming. There were a couple funny moments & I did enjoy the humor. It just felt like I was missing something.

Small town librarian meets the supernatural in this cozy mystery / paranormal fantasy mash up.

Sherry Pinkwhistle just seems to get involved with murders around town that she gets to solve and this time, it's her cat who encourages her to look into the death of a loved one. It's all very cute and fun as Sherry solves the murder and saves her home town.

I was expecting there to be a "society" but it appears that it's really Sherry who is doing the demon hunting, but if there were a book series, I'm hoping that they would cover the formation of the society, because I thought that was a cool part of the title and something that caught my attention.

Overall this was a fun little mystery that was an easy read. I did find it a little hard to get into right at the start but that resolved as the story proceeded. No huge twisty bits. I do want to give a shout-out to this adorable book cover.

Solving murders when there could be something supernatural to these murders makes a great cozy mystery. Sherry, a librarian, has a knack for solving murders but when it comes to the murder of her boyfriend, she's starting to wonder why there are so many crimes where she lives. As a librarian myself, I appreciate a good librarian-centric story. This one was fun and I enjoyed it just for the fun of it. It seemed like it was setting up for a sequel so I will be looking forward to that.

This book was a bit uneven for me. I enjoyed the cozy more than the supernatural aspects. Also the lead character had a bit too many negative stereotypes of librarians. Guess you might call that old fashioned charm to spin it positively.

Sherry is a librarian with a knack for helping to solve murders. She doesn’t stop to think why there are so many or why it seems to be her who catches all of the suspects. When her boyfriend is killed and she doesn’t want to get involved in the investigate. It soon becomes clear to Sherry and a small group of friends and the town’s new priest that they have some sort of demon problem in their tiny town. This book was full of mystery, fun, and humor. A weird but fun ride.
Many thanks to NetGalley and Ace for providing me with an advance copy of this book to review.

This book was a fun paranormal take on the cozy mystery genre. Sherry is a middle aged librarian in a small town who helps solve mysteries in her spare time. However, when her boyfriend is killed, she is able to take a step back and realizes that the amount of bodies piling up in this small town is not normal, and for some reason nobody seems to notice or care. This leads her to believe that there might be a demonic aspect to these murders that she must get to the bottom of.

I enjoyed the characters, especially Sherry, who was very realistic and relatable. I had fun trying to solve the mystery as the story went along, and I did not have it figured out until it was revealed. This book would’ve been enjoyable without the whole demon thing, but it did add for bit of spookiness and allowed the plot to go in some weird directions and for some really convenient coincidences to occur without coming across as too cheesy or contrived. This wasn’t a horror book by any means, but some of the scenes involving the paranormal entities in this town genuinely gave me the creeps, which was fun.

The plot started slow but really picked up about a third of the way in, and then I was hooked until the end, when it started to slow down a bit again. There were almost two whole chapters where Sherry is just monologue the entire time as she explains who the killer is, which got a bit old. Also, there was an excessive use of italics towards the beginning, but those slowed down later on.

Overall this book was a fun time, and I would recommend to anyone who enjoys light paranormal stories and cozy mysteries! 4/5 stars.

I think this is a classic case of a great idea with just okay execution. The premise was fun, with a nosy librarian solving small town murders. She gets a bit too big for her britches and it isn’t until an investigation becomes personal for her that she starts to question why there are so many crimes in such a small town, or why she has been able to solve all of them better than the police. It felt a bit of a combination of Miss Marple + any small town cozy mystery, with the addition of a talking cat and some light demon possession.

The execution was messier though, and this is where it went downhill for me. For the first half of the book, much of the interesting action happens off page. The pacing was quick, but the story felt like it was all over the place. I had to go back and check more than once to make sure this wasn’t the second or third book in a series, because references kept being made that felt like nods to previous books.

The second half did pick up for me, but overall the book felt like a cozy mystery with an added possession. It did not feel at all like Buffy the Vampire Slayer or have any of the darker vibes of Murder She Wrote, both of which were comparisons in the book’s official blurb. The mystery itself fell flat for me, because it was almost immediately obvious who committed the crime we spend the bulk of the book reading about.

I’ll be the first to admit that cozy mysteries aren’t really my jam, but if they’re yours you’d probably enjoy this one! It definitely doesn’t fit the billing in the blurb though, so if you’re actually looking for Buffy + Murder She Wrote, you may be disappointed.

Thanks to Berkley for the advanced copy!