Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Title: Perfect Fit
Author: Clare Gilmore
Length: 344 pages
Format: ebook arc
Pub Date: October 29, 2024
Genre: Romance
Rating Out of 5: ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️
Spice Level: open door
Summary:
Perfect Fit is a romantic comedy novel that follows Josephine Davis, a fashion brand CEO in Austin, who unexpectedly reunites with Will Grant, the twin brother of her former best friend. Their professional collaboration rekindles past tensions and sparks a new romance.

Thoughts:
I loved this book! It had such well developed characters including our side characters as well. This book did such a great job of exploring love, friendship, personal growth, and the challenges of balancing a career and personal life. Rest assured there is no third act breakup, and the spice is very hot and tasteful! I highly recommend this book especially if you love a second chance romance, a girl boss, and a guy who falls first.

Side note: this is the 4th book I’ve read this year with a MMC chef. Is this a thing now??

Special thanks to the @netgalley and @stmartinspress for the arc in exchange for my honest review!

Was this review helpful?

My goodness gracious, I LOVED this book! Will has rocketed himself up to one of my favorite book boyfriends - he is so understanding, kind, and really just down so bad. He often knew what Josie needed but also listened to her when she needed to set boundaries.

The relationship between Will and Josephine just felt so realistic to me - this is a book that isn't trope heavy and is all the better for it. There's no fake dating or other unrealistic start to their relationship - they just used to know each other, reconnect through work and a traffic accident (lol) and slowly start to get to know each other again. It's a really normal progression that I appreciated so much. This is a book that's light on the drama and heavy on the banter and swoon. The third act conflict made sense for the characters and there was no miscommunication which is also a huge plus in my book!

Read this for:
- Workplace Romance
- Woman CEO on the brink of burnout
- Slow Burn
- Sick Comfort

I just simply cannot recommend this book enough - I loved Clare Gilmore's other book as well so this has solidified her as an auto buy/read author for me!

Thank you to St. Martin's Press for the eARC. All thoughts and opinions are my own and I am leaving this review voluntarily.

Was this review helpful?

Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ | Spice: 🌶️.5


A heartfelt rom-com.
A second chance at love.
A second chance at
forgiveness.
A chance at finding and accepting your true self.


Josephine Davis (Josie): Girl boss, Founder and CEO of Revenant. Josie is a work-a-holic who does mot want to let her personal life interfere with what she has built. Josie is reluctant to date amongst other things. It isn’t until date brings her and Will together, that she allows her walls to come down, that she allows others to help her.


Will Grant: Is just perfection. He is the perfect book boyfriend. He is patient, he is understanding, he gives Josie her space when she needs it. He isn’t pushy, and everything he does, he does for Josie.


Quotes:

💗: “I want my existence to be meaningful” (J)

✨: “Everyone needs help sometimes” (W)

💗: “I wanted you months ago too” I gasp. “You reminded me what it was like.” “To want?”. he mumbles against my skin. “To feel greedy for something I shouldn’t have”. (J)

✨: “Will you please, please be my girlfriend?” (W)

💗: “I have felt like an imposter my whole life. I never believed about myself what other people made of me. My high school classmates thought I was inspirational, but really, I was an insecure wreck who found validation in the wrong places.” (J)


💗The Perfect Fit💗

✨(Ex) Best Friends Brother
✨ Second Chance Romance
✨ Workplace Romance
✨ Hate To Love You
✨ Childhood Friend Reunion
✨ New Old Flame
✨Single POV
✨ Slow Burn

My thoughts: I really enjoyed this book. The FMC and MMC were enjoyable. The themes were relatable. As I stated previously, a second chance at love, a second chance at forgiveness and a chance at finding and accepting your true self.


Thank you NetGalley, St Martins Press and lastly, Clare Gilmore for a chance at a eARC in exchange for an honest review, all thoughts here are my own.

Was this review helpful?

I have discovered Clare Girlmore and I'm not disappointed.

This was a lovely story about Josephine, the CEO of her own clothing company, who runs into her ex-best friend's twin brother, Will, with whom she shared a kiss when they were both eighteen and which marked the end of her friendship with her friend and his sister, Zoe.

Watching Will and Josie fall in love, even though they tried not to, was beautiful. They've been through a lot and have grown in the nine years since they saw last, and every little thing that happened to them, made them ready to start a relationship together. One of the more ready than the other, but still.

One of the many positive aspects of this book is that there's no third act break up, and Will's support to Josie, giving her time and everything she needed from behind the scenes is honestly refreshing to read in a book and I have loved it very much.

The only thing I can say I would have changed, was maybe having Will's povs since it would have been nice to sread what was going on in his mind in a couple of situations.

Thank NetGalley and publisher, I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own

#arc #arcreader #arcreview #arcreviewer #perfectfit #claregilmore #netgalley #fashion #secondchance #spicy #slowburn #romance #contemporaryromance #officeromancenovel #romcom

Was this review helpful?

Rating: 4.25/5

Thank you Clare Gilmore and St. Martin's Press for an ARC of this book via Netgalley!

Josie has racked up a list of accomplishments many of us could only dream of (or not, to each our own 😉) and despite it all, she read so relatable. Josie is all of us who hustles and pour ourselves into our work and passion and, at a deeper level, who push ourselves for fear of disappointing other people, esp the ones we care about. *minor spoiler alert* It's no surprise that she eventually hits burnout. I really appreciated seeing her journey bc we felt her determination, anxiety, exhaustion, and at the end of it all, finally relief. It served as a reminder that it's good to pause and reevaluate what we want *now.* Not yesterday, that's come and gone, but today, the present. Bc priorities change and our needs may no longer be what they used to be. And in any pursuit, accept help. Bc that burnout? That hits so much faster when we go at it alone.

And Will. While we don't get his POV, I soooo loved his role in Josie's journey. He reminded her that the present is not the sometimes painful past. He supported and loved her without condition. And beyond everything else, he was a safe place for her to fall apart. He respected her boundaries, didn't push, but still made sure she had what she needed to heal. Ugh, our soft boy truly made me melt so many times. And gah, when he revealed his own insecurity, it broke my heart. In those moments, I loved that Will *and* Josie could remind each other that acknowledging responsibility was one thing, but unnecessarily shouldering fault was another.

CN: open-door romance, bullying, infidelity (side characters)

Was this review helpful?

There's nothing I love more than a romance novel that blows away my expectations. By the cover and description, I figured this would be a light, not-that-deep rom-com that would be entertaining while it lasted, but likely wouldn't leave much of an impression. I probably should have known better with a cover blurb from Tarah Dewitt, but I'm happy to report I was wrong. This book has pressed itself into my memory, and will not soon be forgotten.

Josephine is the CEO of her own fashion brand, Revenant, based in Austin, TX. For a side-gig she started as a hobby in college, it has grown into something she never expected: an online phenomenon with dozens of employees. In an effort to keep aligned with her values, she's after a new certification which will tell customers how dedicated the brand is to quality and sustainability. To that end, Revenant is hiring a consultant to help, and the man who wants the job happens to be a ghost from her past she's been afraid to run into in town. They did not part in high school on the best of terms, and she's not sure she wants to open the door back up on all the hurtful feelings from the past. But he's a skilled professional and has taken an interest in her business. A few months of working together should be tolerable, right? Especially if it pushes her company, which is everything to her, in the right direction.

So what do I love about this book? The romance felt realistic. These two didn't fall in love over the course of a hot weekend, or a single business trip, or basically just a big firework of an event that 'changed everything'. They build a genuine friendship. Yes, it might be colored by burning crushes on both sides, but over time and many interactions, the two of them form a genuine connection that is strong and true and flush with meaning. Not to mention Will Grant is a walking, talking green flag. Oh my gosh, the romance in this book is everything you could want. It reminded me of all my favorite summer romances that came out this year.

There were also deep themes of friendship woven into the fabric of the story. Josephine was best friends with Will's sister Zoey in high school, and they had a falling out way back when. It happens. It's happened to me. But it's about recognizing your mistakes, realizing there are sometimes greater things playing into things that happen that can exaggerate or cause hurtful things to happen, and that it's okay to forgive, and grow, and repair. The author balances these themes through several characters and really created a big impact for me.

This was my first Clare Gilmore book, but gosh dang it, she's going on my watch list cause this book was something special. I was provided an arc copy from netgalley and the publisher, and what do you know, I hit pre-order as soon as I was finished! I will be reading it again, and I think you should too!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and St. Martin's Press for providing the ARC.

This book was absolutely one of the most amazing stories I've read this year. You will not find another book that so thoroughly makes you fall in love with the characters and showcases how deeply they love and care for each other. Josie and Will are absolute perfection - the way that Josie just wants what's best for him, even when she feels selfish for not wanting to give him up, and the way that Will steps up continuously to demonstrate to her that he is not going anywhere, that she's stuck with him, even when they're faced with some of the toughest decisions they need to make about their own lives and career trajectories. This book has it all; a best friend's brother turned into an adult romance, the beautiful and torturous pining that only comes with the slowest of slow burns, an explosive relationship, but in the best way possible, and healing for both of the main characters in a way that makes sense and makes the reader love them even more.

This book is not to be missed. I loved everything about it.

Was this review helpful?

In this book we explore themes of anxiety and burn out. Anxiety is invisible to most but very obvious to those who know us the best and I felt that she emulated this beautifully. She has a way of placing you in the characters thoughts and pulling you out of it along with her. I was fully immersed in this book and found myself laughing out loud multiple times throughout. I really loved the romance aspect as well, I found the characters endearing and was rooting for them the whole time.

The character growth really stood out to me as well, she has a very unique way of writing their development that felt extremely real to me. A lot of times I find that authors will write their characters to be very abstinent to change and that they don’t generally grow until the very end when they have some sort of realization and suddenly flip their entire life around. I really felt that these characters changed slowly throughout starting with their mindset and then it blossomed from there to transform their life. I felt that it really shows that you can change the outcome of your life at any stage.

I honestly really enjoyed reading this and thought this was going to be a six star book for me until about seventy percent of the way through. It was about this time when I felt that the chemistry slipped a little and a few scenes gave me the ick unfortunately. However this didn’t drop my rating drastically, it just didn’t meet my expectations towards the end. Overall, I gave it five stars and I look forward to reading more books from her!

Was this review helpful?

DNF @40%

I’m shocked because I thought I would love this. The author’s previous novel was a smash for me. This missed on soooo many levels. The fmc was a pick me girl, the mmc had as much personality as a piece of white bread, their attraction was too much too fast, and then the author makes you wait foreverrrr (I skipped ahead some) & then it is cringe… yeah I can’t finish this. Sadness.

Was this review helpful?

A sophomore novel from Clare Gilmore and I am still a fan of her writing style. Her characters are well thought out. The transparency in conversations makes you wish more people could express themselves so articulately in real life. The romance = frothy. Very cute book to cozy up with. A lot of tasty meals throughout the book so you may not want to read while hungry! Thanks to St. Martin’s for the arc.

Was this review helpful?

Gilmore is back with another melt-your-heart, feel good rom com. It’s a sweet story about two people who literally collide into each other at the right moment in their lives. Where Josie is kind to a fault and wants the best for those in her life. It’s a story that shows the growth of an individual who needs to take a moment to figure out what’s best for her and Will is the perfect person to assist in that growth.

Another hit rom-com from author Clare Gilmore that you should absolutely add to your upcoming reading list this fall.

Was this review helpful?

I thoroughly enjoyed this book. It was heavy in dialog, and I don’t think I’ve read to many like this, but actually thought it was enjoyable to get to know the characters through their words vs their thoughts. And with that it brought two things. 1. Lots of banter! The banter between Josie and Will was so good and there was so much of it. 2. No miscommunication trope! They spoke about everything and anything, where there was no chance to flee in the third act when things got tough. No chance to wallow in their thoughts as their feelings were spoken aloud.

Things you can find in this book that makes it perfect is a late twenties CEO who built her fashion company from the ground up that doesn’t have time for anything but her company, a consultant who wants to do everything for his woman CEO and make her and her company the best they could be, and two people fighting an attraction from long ago through trying to deliberately make themselves undesirable by sharing unattractive facts about themselves is just too funny.

I was so giddy towards the end and loved how these two fit with eachother. Both characters were lovable as well as Josie's best friend. I sat on the ending for awhile (iykyk) and realized it was perfect, as I knew both MCs were right together, everything else didn't matter.

Overall it was a lovely book, many heartfelt moments, healthy relationships and friendships, and had me smiling and feeling good. I definitely recommend!

Thank you NetGalley and St. Martin's Press for an opportunity to read an eARC of this book in exchange for my opinion!

Was this review helpful?

What a fun read! Josie and Will's relationship started long ago but didn't go well. Fast forward to now when they unexpectedly meet again and their story takes a turn for the better. Josie is CEO of a successful fashion business and Will is a consultant that ends up working with her business. As they spend more time together the sparks begin to fly and the chemistry heats up. But, the best part of this story is that it feels very real. We learn about Josie's insecurities and we see Will set up to support her as all good partners should do...and, get ready for it...they actually communicate with each other, like really talk to one another about situations and feelings. Such a breath of fresh air in a romcom! I really enjoyed this story and the way the author was able to show not only the romance but Josie's actual life...her work, her friends, her passions, and her fears and insecurities. This was my first book by Clare Gilmore but I look forward to reading more in the future!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to St. Martins Press and NetGalley for the advance E-ARC of this title.

This book is so lighthearted and swoonworthy. This a slow burn, second change, and workplace romance. The relationship between Josephine and Will was so mature. The author builds a solid foundation for their reunion and budding relationship. I loved the meet cute as they find themselves face to face after several years. Will was an exceptional MMC who always seemed to know exactly what Josie needed.
Both balance their dreams with their budding relationship. Will gives Josie room to shine and breathe and installs a new confidence in her to find a new type of balance in her life. Both characters are strong willed, confident in themselves, and their chemistry leaps from the page.

Absolutely adored this!

Was this review helpful?

I am screaming from the rooftops about this book! Josie is a powerhouse CEO struggling with burnout, and her passion for her work felt so real. Watching her navigate those challenges while slowly falling for Will, the last person she expected to connect with, was heartwarming. The history between them added so much depth to their relationship, and the tension from their shared past had me glued to the pages. Will? Total acts-of-service king! His charm and support for Josie, both professionally and romantically, had me swooning. Perfect Fit is a beautiful, realistic love story about finding balance, and I know Clare Gilmore’s continues to cement herself as an auto-buy author for me.

Thank you to NetGalley and St. Martin's Griffin for an ARC in exchange for an honest review

Was this review helpful?

Sometimes you just want a book where you cheer on the main characters, wait for the HEA, and sit back and enjoy the sweet story as it unfolds. Perfect Fit from Clare Gilmore is that kind of read, a warm cozy blanket, a soft hoodie, a perfect cup of coffee, the warm chocolate chip cookie.... You get it, sweet, just right, and just what you want on a cool Fall evening. Thank you SMP for the review copy and the fun I had escaping into this book.

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed this book a lot. It was an easy read, good character communication, a sweet ending. It had it all.

Was this review helpful?

This was a great story! I love second chance romances and this one checked all the boxes! Josie and Will find the happy endings seperately, but also together. The ending leaves us hanging on a bit in regards to Josie's future, but I like that I can fill in that blank myself!

I received a complimentary ecopy of this book in exchange for an honest reveiw. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own. Thank you St. Martin's Press, Netgalley and Clare Gilmore.

Was this review helpful?

This was another book by Clare Gilmore that I adored. Will and Josie are the perfect book couple. Their story development was written well and I enjoyed it. Will was sweet and cared about Josie. Josie was fun and i loved her as an FMC.

thank you to St. Martin's Press and Netgalley for this ARC in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Perfect Fit is…✨[insert dreamy sigh here]✨

I love Josie as an FMC. That she is a go getter without needing to bring others down. Will as a romantic interest is chef’s kiss 😏 and all the other side characters really add to the fun of this novel. Clare’s first novel was one of my first reviews and I am so happy to have been considered this time around. There are so many quote-able moments that read like poetry. I loved it and couldn't put it down!

Basically, read this book! Out on 10/29!

Thank you @netgalley and @stmartinspress for the advanced copy in exchange for my review!

Was this review helpful?