This was a fun mystery that while enjoyable did not leave a huge impact on me or particularly impress me. For starters, it was incredibly slow paced. While the treasure hunt is quickly introduced, it takes a while for all the characters to decide to look into it and an even longer while to give the hunt a sense of urgency or significance. I spent most the book waiting for something major to happen. And when there was new information, it was most often handed to the reader in the form of a diary entry than actually discovered by a character. I was able to stay with the story even if I struggled with the plot because I enjoyed the characters and setting. My favorite character by far was Dandy, with her spunk and determination. And I thought the author did a great job of giving each character their own voice, and making Dandy seem mature to herself but a kid to the Cass and Peter. Lastly, Maple Bay was a fantastic setting, with amazing small town vibes and so much lore. So overall I enjoyed this book but it didn’t wow me.

This book was so good! From the synopsis, I was expecting more Goonies treasure hunting, but I got more mystery that felt like Knives Out, which did not disappoint me at all. It actually made me enjoy the book even more. I loved how the author setup each chapter, telling the story from a different character's POV and in journal entries. It the made the story feel more well-rounded and more exciting for the reader. Each MC was very well developed and strong. I enjoyed reading from their perspectives. The treasure story and lore felt real to me. The author did an amazing job of providing specific details about how the treasure came to be.

Not only do we get a mystery story filled with murder and Nancy Drew style investigation, but also we get a treasure hunting story filled with intrigue and excitement. I had such a great time reading it! Also, I normally guess twists in books, but I was completely blindsided by the big twist toward the end of the book. I did not see it coming, and it made perfect sense, which I think just shows the high caliber writing abilities of the author.

All-in-all, I think Tom Ryan is a master at creating a fun mystery that all readers can enjoy. I highly recommend!

Thank you to NetGalley and Grove Atlantic for the advanced copy in exchange for an honest review!

Thank you to the publisher for an early copy in exchange for an honest review.

I think this book is going to get a lot of mixed reviews. On one hand, I enjoyed the characters and the setting and on the other hand I never really felt connected to the story or felt any high stakes. I think cozy mystery fans may enjoy this but the comparison to "Everyone in my Family has Killed Someone," doesn't feel like it is setting readers up for the correct expectations. It's hard to really pinpoint what didn't work for me, I keep trying to think of the words but the only thing I can conjure is flat development of characters (started off strong, fell off after time), and the mystery just wasn't all that interesting or high stakes. The author really put a lot into this, you can feel that and I do believe it has an audience.

There were a lot of characters in this book, and while I don't mind multiple mains and interconnected story lines, The Treasure Hunters Club felt lacking in depth of the characters as well as how their stories were meant to collide. It felt as though I could see the outline of a fantastic story, but was only given the major plot points. In fact, the most well fleshed out characters in the story were all deceased, with us only visiting them through memories. And as far as the treasure hunting goes.. well... There was a treasure, but where was the adventure? The thrill of the chase? As someone who is a huge fan of real life treasure hunting I was very disappointed in that respect. The twist was... Random. It was certainly surprising, but not in the feel-good "picked up on the clues" type of way, because there were no clues. It had tense moments and tender moments.. neither of which gripped me because I felt like I didn't actually know anything about the characters, or at least not enough to care. The one thing I did love about this book was the authors ability to bring Bellwoods and the town to life.

Unpopular opinion

This was just MEH! I struggled with the different POVs of the story. They weren't signposted and I often had to re-read the beginning of the third-person POV chapters to find out whose POV I was reading, the first-person POV was, obviously, easier to follow.

I struggled to finish this book and in the end the twist wasn't as surprising as I had anticipated.

This book has everything! Murder, pirate treasure, romance, a quaint seaside town, a secret society, I could really keep going. THE TREASURE HUNTERS CLUB is a treasure-trove of a book, and I couldn't put it down. It had me pointing my finger at literally every character and the twist still surprised me!

I had such high hopes for this with the two comparable however it just didn’t do it for me. It felt quite slow paced, there wasn’t the same level of humour compared to everyone in my family and I loved that. It was not a bad book at all, I just expected something different.

a murder mystery set in Nova Scotia, Canada with family secrets, hunting for pirate treasure, and triple POV.

"I was worried about what he knew. I couldn't take a risk of him getting to the treasure ahead of me."

it is unique to find a book with a triple POV and i was loving it! and nothing would prepare me for the plot twist - VERY twisty. chapters are mostly short which makes it fun to read.
we've got three main characters - a GEN Z Nancy Drew - Dandy, an heir to a very wealthy family (which he previously didn't even know) - Peter and a writer who is housesitting for family friends - Cass. all of them are looking for the hidden treasure from a pirate ship but each of them has a different reason why - Dandy wants to continue what her Grandpa did, Peter is trying to learn his family story and Cass wants to write a book.

without further ado, I recommend the book as an evening read in the early autumn as the setting is perfect.

Big thank you to Grove Atlantic, Atlantic Monthly Press, and NetGalley for providing me with an e-arc. This review is voluntary and contains my honest opinion about the book.

The Treasure Hunter's Club is a fun mash-up of adventure and mystery. This book is a cozy whodunnit set in a small beach town full of pirate lore. I loved the quirky cast of characters and was pleasantly surprised when I was taken completely off-guard by the twist at the end! It is a fast-paced, well-written story that keeps you engaged until the last page.

I recommend The Treasure Hunter's Club to fans of Benjamin Stevenson, Nita Prose, and Elle Cosimano. Tuck this gem into your beach bag and join the search for the Obelisk Treasure!

I received an ARC from NetGalley and the publisher in exchange for my honest review.

My expectations going into this were pretty high. Everyone in my family has killed someone and the Goonies are favorites of mine. For me, it lacked the wit and humor of Everyone in my family. The first 30 percent I was really enjoying it, then it started to slow in pace. It picks back up and ends with a bang. I think it is worth the read but don't go in with any expectations. That's my fault, lesson learned. Thank you, Netgalley! I had fun reading this!

The Treasure Hunters Club by Tom Ryan is for all of those people that wanted to go on a great adventure that involes a tale of pirates, stolen treasure, and mystery of what happen to the treasure. I can honsetly say that once I started this book I couldn't put it down and was up until the wee hours of the morning finishing it. The story is made up of 5 boys that by chance found the treasure and then make an agreement to wait until everyone is 18 years old to dig it up and then divide it up between them. The next gerneration takes up the challenge of looking for the treasur, after they each recieve a typed letter about that year that their father's went looking for the treasure. . They start the Treasure Hunters Club and meets the third Thursday of every month to discuss the their findings. Now the great great grandchildren Dandy and Peter are left to solve the mystery. Along with a failed YA writer that is now wanting to write a non fiction book about all the people that lived on the island and are a part of the Treasure Hunters Club. Now all of a sudden the second generation is now are being picked off one at a time. Will Dandy, Peter, and Cass find out what is really happening before time runs out? I would like to thank both NetGalley and Atlantic Monthly Press for letting me have an advanced copy of this title.

Beyond being captivated by the theme of this book (who doesn’t love a good story about a lost pirate treasure?), I was drawn in by the characters and their stories. I wanted to follow their paths to the very end to finally find out exactly where it would all take them, and I enjoyed every moment of the journey. Despite the difficult moments, I find that the ending is a comforting and emotional moment, full of hope for all these characters who have experienced a unique adventure. AND I loved the moment of the revelation that... never seems to end! But that’s what happens when you put a secret within a secret within a secret within...

This book was so much fun! When I read the first line of the description, "Everyone in My Family Has Killed Someone meets The Goonies," I couldn't wait to read this one! Sometimes blurbs are misleading, but I thought this was actually pretty accurate. This story is a cozy-ish mystery with a great cast of interesting characters and a hunt for treasure! I just thought the whole book was an absolute delight. It is the kind of book I can put on the staff picks shelf and recommend to so many different kinds of readers!

The Treasure Hunter's Club features three strangers brought together by letters, notebooks, and a long-buried mystery. The seaside town of Maple Bay, Nova Scotia is a perfect backdrop for this adventure and I feel that Ryan nailed the small-town vibe. I enjoyed the time I spent with these likable characters - even that meddling busy body! The core of this story is a cozy mystery, but I must admit that I did NOT guess the final outcome, which is always a treat.

Thank you to Grove Atlantic, NetGalley, and Tom Ryan for bringing me along on your adventure in exchange for my honest review. I sure hope I get to spend more time in Maple Bay in the future!

Thank you Grove Atlantic and Netgalley for this eARC, these opinions are my own. In the small town of Maple Bay a treasure hunt has begun. Cass, Dandy, and Peter all join the treasure hunt and are unexpectedly drawn together by past ties. Together they’ll search for the treasure but the search becomes more dangerous as people start dying. They need to solve the mystery all while staying alive in the process. I really enjoyed this one! Engaging, fast paced, and will keep you reading! Plus the twist you won’t see coming that will leave you shook! Genuine characters that will have you rooting for them! Highly recommend!

The Treasure Hunters Club by Tom Ryan absolutely blew me away with its unexpected twists and turns! At one point I actually had to stop reading and just take in what had just happened, it was that surprising.
Ryan skillfully uses the varied points of view of the three protagonists that converge on Maple Bay, Nova Scotia - and I love that it is set in Canada - and flashbacks to the original Treasure Hunters Club members story, to weave a complex tale that steadily reveals itself and builds suspense as it does so. The characters are multi-faceted and relatable, and the story touches on the complexities and tragedies that surround families; it is a common theme for all of the main characters.
I stayed up far too late to finish this book, and expect that I will pay for it today. But I have no regrets!
I expected something akin to the movie Goonies, and I got so much more! I am so happy to have received an ARC of #TheTreasureHuntersClub from #NetGalley!

The story appears to be an engaging and suspenseful mystery set in the picturesque coastal town of Maple Bay, rich with pirate lore and hidden secrets. The convergence of three distinct characters—Peter, Dandy, and Cass—suggests a multi-layered narrative that weaves together their individual quests for answers and self-discovery.

Peter's journey seems to involve reconciling with his family’s legacy, while Dandy is likely driven by her grandfather’s influence and the need to find closure after his passing. Cass's storyline hints at a blend of personal ambition and romantic tension, especially with the introduction of a handsome sailor. The mention of bodies piling up adds an element of thriller and urgency, suggesting that the pursuit of the treasure—and the truth behind it—will lead to dangerous and unexpected revelations.

Overall, the story seems to promise a mix of adventure, mystery, and character growth, with themes of connection, family, and the search for purpose. It could be a thrilling ride as the characters uncover not just the treasure, but also the deeper truths about themselves and their intertwined fates.

I personally liked reading this book at my pace just because of the plot twist which was just brilliant and made me enjoy it. However the shift in povs were a bit confusing but one can get used to it.

3.5 | This was an enjoyable murder mystery with a fun buried treasure theme. I have to admit that I was a bit underwhelmed overall with the atmosphere. This book was compared to "The Goonies" and I don't feel like it hit the mark exactly. I was expecting more of an adventure based on that comparison and it let me down a bit. But it was a solid mystery and one I would recommend if the premise sounds interesting!

Thanks to Netgalley and Grove Atlantic for providing me with the e-ARC/DRC in exchange for an honest review.

The Treasure Hunters Club by Tom Ryan is basically a Goonies murder mystery and I had no idea how much I needed it in my life. The characters, the plot twists, the atmosphere...it's all impeccable. Loved it!

Okay. I loved this. Picture a kind of cozy mystery with buried treasure and a lot of bodies! The characters were great and I definitely got surprised and bamboozled by something I DID NOT expect. All in all a great book, and I highly recommend it.

Thanks to NetGalley for the ARC of this book. This will be out in October! Make sure to add it to your TBR.