Skip to main content

Member Reviews

While I love Katherine Center's writing, this was unfortunately not a smash hit for me.

Emma was a very sad main character. I had a hard time liking her and didn't find her quirky and charming... But more cringy and lame.

Charlie was pretty boring and I didn't understand the infatuation she had with him.

I thought the sister relationship was way too intense and strained, they didn't seem as close as they were conveyed.

The biggest issue I had with the book was the consent. Charlie kept telling her no and Emma just kept pushing. As a reader it began to feel awkward that she was trying so hard when he kept saying no. Even if he was obviously protecting himself and protecting her cause the vibes were there, he explicitly says no and she should have listened to him.

The writing itself was wonderful. The jokes landed. The pacing was great. The tone is always perfect from Katherine but this one just wasn't for me.

Was this review helpful?

Coming next week to a bookstore near you The Rom-Commers is Katherine Centers’s latest. An auto read author for me, I was fortunate enough to get both the digital and audio arc. I highly recommend both formats.

The Rom-Commers is the story of Emma Wheeler, whom I connected to her right away, I think mostly because I have been a caretaker myself so I was able to feel what she was going through, how she put her life on hold. Then there is Charlie Yates, the cranky screen writer who is idolized by Emma, but has no desire to have her help. He is having issues with the rom/com he is writing (though he doesn't really know it...yet).

This was a great read, there was great banter, laugh out loud moments along with a serious side - as I have come to expect with this author. It was well written with real characters in real life situations. Definitely a book and author I recommend. Be sure to read the blurb, it gives more details into the story - if you want, I actually went in blind.

My thanks to St. Martin’s Press for a digital arc and McMillan Audio for the audio arc.

Was this review helpful?

As someone who makes a rom com movie bracket a yearly sport, I appreciate someone having the same fervor and passion for them as I do. And I feel as though Katherine Center was making a point of it, and I agree.

This was cute. The single POV didn't deter me from liking it as much as some single POV romances do. I think my only issue is that the character had some immature responses to things that kind of threw me. Not that folks aren't allowed to have immature responses to very valid feelings, just that they felt a little outlandish in comparison to what she had went through and dealt with. But that is a me thing.

I am always amazed at how Katherine Center somehow jedi mind tricks you into thinking sexy things have happened in her books and it still remains clean. This is no exception.

Thank you to Macmillan Audio and Netgalley for an early copy.

Was this review helpful?

I love this author and have read every book she has written. I enjoyed listening and reading this one as well..mostly. Emma is a wonderful person who is gives up every dream she has to take care of her father and allow her sister to live her best life. A little overboard, yes, but guilt is a powerful motivator. When Logan, her old boyfriend offers her an incredible opportunity comes to work with her favorite writer she is over the moon with excitement for the experience and the financial gain. Her sister offers to help for the period while she is away and off she goes. Well, turns out Logans offer wasn’t what it seemed to be, Charlie Yates, the author she loved was a horrible human being and her sister disappointed her beyond belief. Yes, she does finally grow a backbone and self worth and get a truly wonderful happily ever after and I was thrilled for her, but the road there was at times really cringy for me. That said, I look forward to whatever comes next from this wonderful author.

Was this review helpful?

Emma is a screenwriter who has yet to make it big, because she has been focusing on taking care of her dad for 10 years. Charlie Yates is ,THE Charlie Yates, big famous screenwriter and only Emma's idol. Emma is given the chance of a lifetime to work with THE Charlie Yates on screenplay. The only problems are; Charlie Yates is bad at writing RomComs and an asshole.

I thought this book was so so cute!

Emma is chaotic and all over the place and talks before she thinks often. I thought this fitting. As someone who spent the last 10 years of her life care taking for her father, this all makes complete sense to me. Care taking is hard and it is easy to lose yourself in making sure someone else stays alive. Her obsession over his numbers and health just screams; "I actually care!" (I work in the medical field and the amount of family members that take this good care of family is rare. This made me automatically drawn to her.)

I was on fence about Charlie for a good portion of the book. His actions said he cares while his mouth told a different story. I was glad to see self sacrifice on his part even if it was misplaced. The ending made up for his mixed signals.

This was a 4.5/5 star book for me!

Patti Murin was fabulous and had a great performance.

Thanks to NetGalley and MacMillan Audio for the ALC!

Was this review helpful?

Cute, funny, quirky, and heartfelt.

Emma Wheeler is an aspiring screenwriter, but her career was derailed after her father had a rock climbing accident and suffered a traumatic brain injury. She’s been his sole caretaker for 10 years and looked after her sister during that time too.

Her friend and agent, Logan, reaches out to her one day with an offer she can’t refuse: write a rom-com with legendary screenwriter Charlie Yates! She rearranges her life to go to California to work with him. But he’s not what she expected.

Katherine Center is an excellent storyteller, I can’t get enough of her rom-coms! This book made me laugh out loud, made me teary, and every emotion in between. I honestly did not want it to end.

I enjoyed the audiobook narrator too, she really acted the heck out of Emma’s character.

Thank you to NetGalley and MacMillan Audio for the ARC in exchange for an honest review!

Was this review helpful?

The perfect companion for a summer road trip and a great beach read, the audio-book version of THE ROM-COMMERS is engagingly narrated by Patti Murin, who brings to life the witty dialogue and banter that make this book shine. This is that summer novel that leaves you bereft when you finish, like you've just said goodbye to a good friend. THE ROM-COMMERS features characters who each have a strong sense of self that isn't dependent upon a romantic relationship (unlike too many other contemporary romances).

Both Charlie and Emma are script writers, and so it's not surprising that their dialogue sparkles, and the teasing banter between the two sounds like a classic Hollywood film script: snappy good fun. There are obstacles to Emma and Charlie's romance, but Katherine Center doesn't resort to the all-too-typical misunderstanding that could have been solved by any attempts at normal communication.

The best parts of the novel are the characters' disagreements and arguments: honest, refreshing, and real. Most similar in tone and pacing to Center's novel "The Bodyguard," this latest effort should attract new fans and abundantly satisfy loyal readers of her previous books.

Was this review helpful?

This was a fun book! I thought that the plot was fun and believable, and I really liked the overall dialogue. My favorite parts were when the book's narrator broke the fourth wall and spoke to the reader directly. That added such a fun touch that had me literally LOLing at some points.

The reader of this audiobook was nice to listen to. She had good pacing and I liked her different voices. She sometimes sounded a little congested or something, but it was not bothersome. I would listen to her again!

Was this review helpful?

I wanted to like this so much. The premise was very promising and Katherine Center always delivers a solid rom com with some trauma dumping mixed in, in the best way. But I did not have a good time and I fear I do not have anything nice to say…

Everyone sucked. The drama and trauma was too much. There was way too much fourth wall breaking. This was a mess.

Was this review helpful?

I LOVE Katherine Center's books! With The Rom-commers, she has crafted another beautifully written, heartfelt, unforgettable love story.

Emma is an aspiring screenplay writer who has spent the last ten years caring for her dad 24/7 after his accident. She gets the chance to rewrite a rom-com screenplay with her writing idol, Charlie Yates. But, things are not straightforward, and Charlie doesn't believe in love or that love stories matter. Can Emma convince him?

This is a slow-burn, enemies-to-friends-to-lovers story set against a Hollywood backdrop. I laughed several times and cried a few, too. Both MCs have been through some very difficult things in their lives, and Center approaches these deep topics in a way that feels authentic and relatable. Their growth and emotional journey had me totally invested. It is heart-wrenching at times, but Center balances those moments with humor and a hearty dose of swoony romance.

I loved the peeks into the world of writers, the inner workings of scriptwriting, and how grumpy Charlie and sunshine Emma worked together. I also loved the forced proximity, the banter, and the romantic tension between this couple.

There's also a fun easter egg from Center's book The Bodyguard!
This gem is the perfect summer read!

I alternated between the book and the audiobook, narrated by Patti Murin and by the author herself, who reads a fantastic bonus scene from Charlie's POV. Murin delivers a wonderful and nuanced performance. Something in her voice perfectly captures Emma's energy and spark.
Murin brought out the emotions of all the characters, the deeper moments, and the wit and humor of the dialogue. I listened at 1.5x speed, and everything was clear and easy to follow.

Thank you to Netgalley, St. Martin's Press, and Macmillan Audio for the free book and audiobook!

Was this review helpful?

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
The Rom-Commers
By: Katherine Center
Narrated by: Patti Murin
Publisher: Macmillan Audio
Pub Date: 6/11/24
Another author who I wish could write faster! This was so good! I absolutely loved the bonus chapter that’s part of the audio read by Katherine herself!
Patti Murin narrates the main story. She has quickly become a favorite of mine. She truly becomes the character she’s reading.

Emma Wheeler is stuck. She has been her dad's sole caregiver for the last 10 years. After a tragic climbing accident that permanently disabled her dad and killed her mom she stepped up to take care of him. She sent her little sister to college and just kept going. When her agent and high school friend contacts her to ghost write for her absolute favorite screenwriter Charlie Yates Emma and her sister trade places and Emma heads to LA. What she quickly finds out is Charlie has the yips he hasn’t written anything in a long time and this romcom he’s trying to write is terrible. Can Emma work with the man she’s literally had a crush on for years? Can they write a good romcom when it would appear Charlie knows nothing about them?
Thanks to Macmillan Audio, Katherine Center and NetGalley for this ARC.

Was this review helpful?

5/5
SWOON! All Hail Katherine Center, the absolute Queen of romance strikes again! This novel completely falls in line with the other amazing romance books that this author has brilliantly written and shared with the world. Emma and Charlie are such fantastic MCs with such wonderful chemistry, even if it shaky and one sided at best at the beginning. I must admit that I have a weakness for books about writing books and I truly loved the details in this one.
There was:
- Forced proximity
- Family intricacies
- Deep and complex characters
- Grumpy / Sunshine
- fantastic banter

Katherine Center is such a champion of this genre and for me is a must-read every time. You will laugh, you will cry, your heart will physically ache and by the end of this, your heart will be full to bursting. What more can you possibly ask for?...more books please!?! haha!

And the narration was SOOOOOO good! 10/10!

Thank you so much to Katherine Center and Net Galley for providing me with an ARC of this novel. All my opinions are freely given and 100% my own.

Was this review helpful?

I devoured this book! You have a screenwriter writing a romcom, that happens to be a love cynic. What could go wrong? Well…what he wrote is trash and there is only one person that can fix it. Here comes Emma who loves love, but hasn’t been able to find it or put her career first since she has been taking care of her dad the past 10 years.

This book shows the insecurities of putting yourself out there and the questions you ask yourself or actions you do, when you think you are not worthy of love. Then has you laughing out loud in parts that people look in your direction to see what you are doing. I loved the banter between these two characters.

Katherine Center is a must buy for when I need a romantic comedy fix!

Thank you Net Galley for the ARC!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and Macmillan Audio for the ALC of The Rom-Commers.

"Whatever story you tell yourself about your life, that's the one that'll be true."

This book came out of nowhere and I haven't been the same since. I loved this cast of characters, even if Charlie made me so annoyed sometimes. But that's the point. The author did an incredible job of making these characters so human it hurts. From Emma's anxiety and Googling symptoms in the middle of the night, to Charlie and his self deprecating attitude. Even Cuthbert and his grief of losing his brother. I have never felt more seen in the small moments of this incredible novel.

I've dealt with anxiety for as long as I can remember, and it was a breath of fresh air to see it represented on the pages in this way. I also "feather the corners of the pages" while I read and I have not one time seen or read about anyone else who does the same. That was a pleasant surprise.

From start to finish there wasn't a time I didn't want to be reading this book. This was my first book by Katherine Center and it won't be the last. The narrator was also incredible.

"If you wait for other people to light you up, then I guess you're at the mercy of darkness."

Was this review helpful?

One thing about @katherinecenter books is that they always leave you with that feel good feeling. The Rom-Commers is no exception and a great light and fun read between some of the darker books I’d read in May.

-grumpy x Sunshine
-Forced Proximity
-A touch of Enemies to Lovers
-Complicated Families

Two writers working together to fix this movie script and testing out what makes a scene romantic? You know that’s a recipe for fun! I loved Emma right from the get go but Charlie had to grow on me a bit. He had a lot to work through but when he finally came out of his grumpy shell, I felt for him!

I started this one with the E-book and they switched back and forth with audio. I loved both versions!

The Rom-Commers comes out June 11! Thank you @macmillan.audio and @stmartinspress for my advanced copy!

Was this review helpful?

This was a cute rom-com. I have to admit I liked Emma defining what makes a rom-com as it’s not something that I’ve been able to articulate. I did have moments with both of our main characters where I was a little disgusted by their choices/responses but overall I did like them both and thought their romance worked. I liked the barrier that almost broke them apart (even if it was pretty predictable). But predictable in a rom-com works for me. I will say I had a hard time with Emma staying despite all of the horrible things said about her and I don’t love that savior/martyr complex she seemed to have going on. I loved her father and sister but didn’t like most of the other side characters much. Emma is a screenwriter but due to circumstances she couldn't control she mostly is a teacher and caretaker for her father. Her ex-boyfriend and agent calls and tells her that her writing hero Charlie Yates needs someone to help him re-write a horrible romantic comedy screenplay and after much hesitation she heads to LA. Of course nothing goes as planned (what kind of rom-com has things going according to plan?) and some sparks and conflict fly between our main characters. I listened to the first quarter of this on audiobook and liked the narrator a lot. She really brought Emma to life. Of course with impatience (and a long flight) I switched to kindle and devoured the rest. Overall I gave it 4.5 stars rounded up because I just enjoyed it.

Was this review helpful?

The Rom-Commers has been one of the biggest literary surprises for me this year. While the blurb sounded interesting, I figured it would be a fun beach type read to just sit back and enjoy. Don’t get me wrong, it’s certainly an entertaining book, but it will also feel like your heart is being ripped out at times. Kudos to Center for writing such an engaging, emotional tale. I especially loved how the story disproved the nonromantic screenplay moments one hilarious encounter at a time. At this point, the line dancing scene and awards scene will live rent free in my head. I also appreciated how well Center handled the messy and occasionally ugly moments in life from harboring guilt to saying things you don’t mean in the heat of argument, to having your whole life change in an instant. I have a deep dislike for the third act breakup trope, but in a testament to Center’s writing, it felt necessary and well handled in The Rom-Commers to the point the story would’ve felt empty without it. Other tropes you’ll find in this story include enemies to friend to lovers, forced proximity, grumpy/sunshine, and great banter. If a romcom has great banter, it’s already a winner in my book. I read this book via audiobook, and the narrator, Patti Murin, was phenomenal. No joke, this is probably one of the best narrated romcoms I’ve listened to. I highly encourage checking out the audiobook for this.

Was this review helpful?

A romcom about writing a romcom?!? I'm obsessed. Katherine Center is 100% an auto buy author for me but I simply couldn't wait for this one so I had to request some kind of advanced copy and I was lucky enough to receive both a digital ARC & ALC so I could listen and highlight a copy at the same time which is fast becoming my favorite way to read! (I of course also bought myself a physical copy for my bookshelves because I loved it, it's gorgeous and like I said she's an auto buy author so I'd already had it in my cart as soon as it was available for preorder😋)

ANYWHOOO, back to reviewing: it's an amazing, funny, heartfelt, touching, beautiful, emotional, perfect book! I laughed and cried, smiled and frowned and was frustrated at certain points: it really made me feel all the feels and I love that. I could vividly imagine each scene and character, the descriptions are topnotch and the characters are fully realized. I would just keep reading and listening to Emma & Charlie's story forever of I could. Patti Murin is a lively and engaging narrator, making the audio so easy to listen to and just a lovely experience. The story really flows so well and there's never an awkward/unintentional pause or break; the pacing is perfect and I definitely recommend this one to any audiobook lovers. Same goes for the physical book -- the writing is phenomenal and you'll feel pulled into the pages right away.

I love how the relationship between Emma and Charlie builds throughout the novel. They start off as a woman who's been taking care of her father for 10 years and put her dreams on hold because of that and her idol who is a famous screenwriter -- basically THE famous screenwriter that everyone would know -- and slowly move from reluctant partners, to friends, to more. Their banter is so fun and the way they complement each other and balance each other gives me butterflies. Everything about Emma is so big -- her personality, her dreams, even her hair and you she really pulls Charlie back into the world of the living and gets under his skin in the best way. She's funny and so real compared to his more subdued, disinterested vibes. And I like that while they're portrayed this way, Emma is really the one who's been living in a smaller world, not daring to leave her father alone even to go after her own dreams/desires, while Charlie is this larger than life, successful, rich, famous screenwriter who acts more like a cynical hermit that doesn't believe in love. This is a love story to moving on after grief and trauma -- for both of them. There's so much more I could say but I don't want to give anything away. I think any romance lover will adore this book and I highly recommend it to every single person who sees this review and is considering it -- you won't be disappointed.

*forced proximity
*screenwriter romance
*idol to enemy to lover
*slow burn
*JACK STAPLETON CAMEOS

CW: death of a parent, divorce, chronic illness.

Thank you so much to Macmillan Audio for the ALC which I voluntarily listened to and reviewed via NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

Both formats will be available June 11th so keep an eye out at your favorite bookstores or pre-order or request from your library, whatever's your preferred way to get books! You won't want to miss this one. (:

Was this review helpful?

As a big Katherine Center fan, this one did not disappoint. I loved the characters, their banter, their relationship, the tension. I listened and read this and both were amazing and I was always disappointed to have to stop... and even more disappointed when I finished it in 3 days. I was so invested in these characters and their lives. I felt actual emotions as if they were people that I really knew. I love that despite the ups and downs throughout the book, they always feel positive. Center has a way with words that makes you see the good in life and people - even when things don't seem so great. And this book was not exception to that. A must read for anyone who loves rom-coms!
Thank you netgalley for my advanced reader copy.

Was this review helpful?

One of my first introductions to Bookstagram was a review for Katherine Center’s Hello Stranger last year. Fast forward to now — I’ve been part of this community for 10 months, and I have just read my first book by KC! 🙌🏼

The Rom-Commers is an ode to love and love stories. Center’s adoration and passion for this genre is abundantly clear. I laughed. I teared up. I fell in love…with romance. 🫶🏻

I felt it all in this emotional, hope-filled story. I binged this in a day and went to sleep with all the warm fuzzy feelings of a great book. The audio for this was amazing. I felt fully immersed, and the narration had me engaged the entire time.
𝘔𝘺 𝘳𝘢𝘵𝘪𝘯𝘨: 5⭐️

I have been dabbling in the romance genre over the last year. Thanks to The Rom-Commers, I’m now all-in! Give me all the swoony romance recs for this summer. 💞

Thank you @macmillanaudio for the gifted ALC! Opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?