Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Maria was one of my most anticipated books of the year and it did not disappoint. If you are a fan of The Sound of Music then this story of the life of Maria von Trapp is a must read.

Was this review helpful?

This novel is about the making of "The Sound of Music", and points out differences between the movie and what actually happened in the life of Maria von Trapp and her family. Before the 1965 film, there was a Broadway musical created in 1959 by Rodgers & Hammerstein, on which the hit film is based. Before even that, the Rogers & Hammerstein musical was based on a German film from 1956, "Die Trapp Familie," based on Maria's own autobiography. Thus, The Sound of Music is a retelling of a retelling of a retelling of an autobiography. As the R&H production is shaping up, Maria takes issue with the liberties and inaccuracies taken to her life story. So as to not create a media firestorm, the team sends Fran, who is tasked with hearing about Maria's concerns to the differences her story. Through Fran, we are able to see the real story of Maria Von Trapp, and what really happened to the family during the time period of the movie. The book is a great companion read for anyone who loves the movie.

Was this review helpful?

I would like to thank NetGalley and Dell for providing me with an advance e-galley of this book in exchange for an honest review. Look for it now in your local and online bookstores and libraries.

Was this review helpful?

The real story of Maria von Trapp told in a fictionalized setting. I've seen the movie Sound of Music many, many times without realizing there was more to the story. Michelle Moran does an excellent job of producing a sequel movie, even if it's only the one playing in my head. This book is made to be shared.

Was this review helpful?

Heartwarming and charming, this book was all I hoped it would be. Who doesn't love The Sound of Music? This biographical historical fiction novel offered a 'behind the scenes' look at Maria's life. While the movie offers a saccharine portrayal of Maria, this book provides insight into her difficult childhood and the role reversal in which she was the more challenging parent and Georg was the kind-hearted one. This book is perfect for fans of the movie who want to go deeper.

Was this review helpful?

I was afraid this book would be kind of dry, but I couldn't have been any more wrong. The book pointed out differences between the movie and what actually happened in the life of Maria von Trapp and her family. Still sounds sort of dry, but the author has laid the story out in a manor that makes it read like a simple fiction book. The story is smooth and not burdened by flatly given dates and names.

This historical fiction was entertaining and enlightening. We all probably think we know Maria and her story because of the musical, but liberties were taken with the script. It was extremely interesting to learn the differences in Maria's temperament and those happenings in the musical that were totally made up. This was a terrific read.

Thanks to Random House Publishing and NetGalley. All thoughts are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Michelle Moran has created a wonderful dual story with her novel Maria. Fran is a young college graduate working for Oscar Hammerstein in Manhattan. The Sound of Music is set to open soon on Broadway and Maria von Trapp is upset with the direction the musical is taking. Hammerstein assigns Fran the task of meeting with Maria and listening to her story. Moran does an exceptional job of bringing her reader into Maria's world through Maria's recounting of events. Although this plot varies greatly from the movie we all love, it is just as captivating. Coupled with Fran's story of the life of a young working woman Maria is a novel that should not be missed.

Was this review helpful?

Maria was an absolutely delightful and informative read. It takes a classic story most of us grew up with - The Sound of Music - and then gives us a more complete version of the story. Maria von Trapp is a complicated character - passionate, loving, and flawed. Michelle Moran personalized all of these aspects and gives us the parts of the story that Rogers and Hammerstein didn't in the original musical. For anyone who wonders why the von Trapps did what they did, you will thoroughly enjoy this. Finally, ecause it is a deeply factual and yet fictionalized narrative, it is extremely approachable as well.

Was this review helpful?

This story is a fictionalized account of the real Maria Von Trapp's negative reaction to Rodgers and Hammerstein's musicalization of her life story and her effort to get them to change the show to more accurately reflect her true story. Most of the book revolves around Maria telling a young woman named Fran, who works in Oscar Hammerstein's office, her true life story and trying to convince her to get Hammerstein to change the show.

Most, if not all, of what is revealed in the book about the real Maria, and her life could easily be gleaned from her own autobiography (she actually wrote several of them, and there was at least one written by one of her stepchildren too). She, in fact, devoted a whole chapter in one of her books to The Sound of Music, and she was not that unhappy with the stage show. They allegedly did incorporate some of her suggestions into the show. She had more of a problem with the film because the filmmakers seemed hellbent on making the film they wanted regardless of her feelings and/or opinion.

Her main problem with both versions was how the Captain was portrayed. She would have appreciated that he is portrayed much kinder and more likably in this book. Maria, herself, comes across less likably although her love for the children is clear, and later for the Captain as well.

It is interesting to see the real family come to life in this book. You only see them from Maria's point of view in her books, and you don't see them interacting much if at all. Unfortunately, in this book, they aren't differentiated enough so it's hard to keep them all straight plus some of them are much more a part of the story than others.

The actual creators of the show barely appear in this book. Oscar Hammerstein is more a part than any of the others. He is portrayed most lovingly. However, he is mentioned much more than he actually appears, and barely interacts with Maria. Richard Rodgers is not in the book at all. Anybody else involved with the show receives scant mention, if any. Most of the book revolves around Maria and the made-up character of Fran.

Fran has her own subplot as well. It involves her love life, and her desire to be a writer. She is a highly motivated extremely independent character who is clearly ahead of her time. It might have been nice to read more about her and see her as the primary focus of her own book. Here, her story is shoehorned in around Maria's, and thus only gets limited time and development.

All in all, the book is disappointing. It is neither a true backstage drama nor a fully developed portrait of the real Von Trapp family. It is a little of both and a lot of neither.

Was this review helpful?

If you like(d) The Sound of Music, this is a book you will enjoy reading. The famous duo of Rodgers and Hammerstein are bringing the German film Die Trapp Familie to the Broadway stage. Maria von Trapp wants to meet with Oscar Hammerstein to correct the many errors she sees in that first production. Hammerstein foists her off on his assistant Fran, and it is through these meetings that we learn of the “real” story - taking Maria from a postulant to “super nanny” to Captain von Trapp’s seven children to fleeing Austria in the early years of WWII and finally to America and the family’s Vermont resort. There is certainly a lot of truth in the basics of the story but the producers are taking too much liberty in bringing the story to the stage. And now, through the words of Maria, those of us who have seen the play and the subsequent movie know the “real” story

To quote the author, “if you're hoping to read this book, ……do so not because it’s the literary tour de force my father always believed I’d research and write, but because you've always adored warm cookies. The soft and gooey ones, in particular.” That is just what it is - a fast and enjoyable read. The Sound of Music is one of my favorites and this book just adds to that enjoyment. And the timing of receiving the opportunity to read the ARC of this book could not have come at a better time - we were touring the Alps, and though that may not have been exactly how the family left Austria, the memories it rekindled made the read even more enjoyable. My thanks to Random House/Dell for proving me with the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

You think you may know the story of Maria Von Trapp–or do you? The Sound of Music tells the story of the Maria who was sent from Nonnberg Abbey to Captain Von Trapp’s home and soon after, fell in love with him. Then World War II began and they made their escape over the Alps into Switzerland right after the Salzburg Folk Festival with Nazis chasing after them. Except…they didn’t.
In reality, they packed suitcases…and boarded a train which took them to Switzerland.

A brand new novel titled Maria by Michelle Moran has been released today. In it, we see a fictional assistant to Oscar Hammerstein, “Fran” talking to Maria Von Trapp and hearing what actually happened all those years ago.

The book also delves into Fran’s personal life, which I think detracts from the novel a bit. The novel really shines when Maria talks to Fran about her life and how different the play and film are from what actually happened.

It is amazing to me that one of Maria’s sons is still alive–Johannes, who lives at the Trapp Family Lodge in Stowe, Vermont. The Trapp family actually built the lodge themselves in 1942 and still remains open today. It was rebuilt after a storm destroyed it the following year. Jonhannes is 85 years young.

Maria by Michelle Moran is a wonderful novel. I couldn’t put the book down when Maria spoke. Her chapters are engaging and fly off the page and you can just see everything happening right in front of you. If you are a fan of The Sound of Music and want to know what ACTUALLY happened, make sure you read this book!

Was this review helpful?

I have enjoyed reading all of Michelle Morgan’s book, so I was delighted to read this one about Maria von Trapp. The musical The Sound of Music is based on the family’s lives, but is not the complete or accurate story. Moran brings more about Maria and her beloved family to life. I’ll be singing Edelweiss for days!

Was this review helpful?

Maria by Michelle Moran is the fictionalized version of the mounting of the Sound of Music on Broadway, featuring Mary Martin. It mainly consists of conversations between Fran and Maria von Trapp, who was less than thrilled with the script. She didn’t view it as accurate and thought the story didn’t really start until the von Trapps arrived in America. It also gave us a glimpse into the life of Fran, an assistant to Oscar Hammerstein and other peripheral characters. I liked it. I love the Sound of Music and much of Maria’s story mirrored that which I am used to. The play did diverge, but only to make it more dramatic, as is the play writer’s wont. It was a compelling story, not the least of which was its view into “based on.”

Moran did a fabulous job, opening this background to readers in a meaningful way. Her use of facts to round out the fiction mirrors what I have read in other places. The fictional characters add body and warmth to an already amazing story. Maria might have been right that the story began later. We tend to romanticize escapes from bad situations but too often the situation gets worse and no one ever knows that. Opened my eyes to “based on” as well as the personality of Maria who was not at all as portrayed in the movie and the play, although the rest seemed spot on. Always gotta change things. That’s what we love about “Hollywood.: Edelweiss was good, though. Thanks for opening some doors, Michelle Moran!

I was invited to read Maria by Random House Publishing Group Ballantine. All thoughts and opinions are mine. #Netgalley #RandomHousePublishingGroupBallantine #MichelleMoran #Maria

Was this review helpful?

MARIA by Michelle Moran is a fascinating, unexpectedly gripping story of the real Maria Von Trapp. Far from the fresh-faced, wild-eyed optimism of the movie I grew up adoring, this Maria is immediately engaging and heartbreaking. Truth is truly stranger than fiction -- and I deeply enjoyed learning the true dangers, heartache, and struggles of this powerful heroine, sharing her story with the one person who could listen and hold it close, the woman assisting Hammerstein in his work while he was too busy to deal with the reality of an infuriated Maria demanding that her true story be told. Immersive writing, wonderful plotting, this book is a wonderful and refreshing read. I received a copy of this book and these opinions are my own, unbiased thoughts.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley, PRH Audio and Ballantine Books,
for providing me with this book and audiobook for free in exchange for my review. @prhaudio #PRHAudio #PRHAudioInfluencer
All opinions are my own.

This was a delightful book. I grew up obsessed with The Sound of Music movie, and I live in New England so it was a pleasure to be able to read and listen to this audiobook. This book tells the true story of Maria Von Trapp's life and the making of the musical that the movie was based on. The chapters are split between Maria and Fran a fictional employee of Rogers and Hammerstein in 1959. It also flashes back to Maria's early life in Austria (her tragic childhood and her journey to the convent). It also quashes many misconceptions about the Von Trapp's life.

The book was narrated by Eileen Stevens and Natasha Soudek. They did a wonderful job bringing these lovely characters to life.

Pick this up if you are looking for a delightful historical fiction novel or if you are huge fan of The Sound of Music!


Many Thanks again to NetGalley and the publisher for providing me with this book in exchange for my honest review.

********


If you are interested in seeing more of my reviews and other content feel free to connect with me here <3:

https://linktr.ee/bookreviewsbyjules (links to my Instagram, Goodreads, TikTok, Storygraph, My blog and Substack newsletter, etc)

If you are a publisher or author who has questions about my reviews (as well as questions about my stats, reach or engagement), please free to email me. I am also open to requests for book reviews from authors or publishers. Thank you again for taking time to read my review, and I hope you have a wonderful day!

Was this review helpful?

🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟
If you like the movie, “The Sound of Music”, then this book is for you! It’s the behind the scenes action about how Oscar Hammerstein created the music. It also has a fictionalized account of the real Maria von Trapp. It was interesting to read about her early life and about what she was really like.
Many thanks to the author, Random House Publishing and NetGalley for a complimentary copy of the book. The opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own.

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed reading Maria by Michelle Moran. You will fall in love with all the characters. I received an ARC of this book courtesy of NetGalley and the publisher. All opinions expressed in this review are my own and given freely. Happy Reading!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and Random House Publishing - Ballantine for an advanced reader copy of Maria. My opinions are my own, When I saw that there was an advanced reader copy available, I knew I had to request it and read it! The Sound of Music is one of my favorite movies and I love reading about The Von Trapp Family. . This historical fiction is told in two voices; the voice of Fran, the secretary to Oscar Hammerstein, and Maria Von Trapp. The book begins with Hammerstein finalizing the lyrics for The Sound of Music musical and Maria has arrived at Hammerstein’s office to tell him he has the wrong story details. The second voice, that of Maria introduces us to her story; her upbringing, her difficult childhood, becoming a novitiate and then being sent to Captain Von Trapp’s home to be a teacher to his ill child. The story continues through Maria’s marriage to Captain Von Trapp and how they became a singing family. As Fran’s voice is interjected into the story we learn about the true story of the Von Trapp Family, not the movie version that we are all familiar with. I absolutely loved this book! I loved reading about Maria and her family and the author’s note at the end was fascinating! Don’t miss this read! Five stars for me!

Was this review helpful?

"Well, it seems to me you have a choice to make. A new family with children who need a mother or your family here. In both cases, my dear, you will still be serving God. He doesn't disappear outside the walls of this convent."

Wow! I'll be honest, I have always loved The Sound of Music. I still do, even though I now know how inaccurate it was from Maria's real story. But, I'm trying to keep the movie separate from their real story. I had no idea that Maria literally hated The Sound of Musical script when she read it the first time. There had been a German movie before the musical that really portrayed everything in a way that the family didn't appreciate and the musical was based on that. Maria really didn't like how the musical portrayed her husband as being such a strict disciplinarian that didn't have a real relationship with the kids, when he was actually an amazing father. There was so much that I learned about the Von Trapp family and I really loved every page of this book! Michelle Moran did such an amazing job clearing up some fallacies and kept the story incredibly interesting. I highly recommend this book and can't wait to read more by Moran.

Was this review helpful?

Maria will be enjoyed by those who like the Sound of Music. While this novel was considered fiction, it is based on Maria Von Trapp’s life. This novel was so interesting to discover which parts of the movie matched her life. I really liked this novel and the writing style of the author and how she allowed the fictional Maria to tell the autobiography of the real Maria.
I received a copy of Maria from NetGalley with no obligations. All opinions expressed are my own.

Was this review helpful?