Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Maria by Michelle Moran is the real story of the Maria Von Trapp from the Sound of Music. Never could a book more meaningful to me than this because after almost 57 years on this earth, I’ve never watched The Sound of Music in its entirety. I’ve seen bits and pieces over the years, but never from start to finish, so for me, this not only led be to watch it, but also to learn so much!

This book is told in both the past and the present. Maria’s childhood, her life as a G-d’s servant, and how she came to be the nanny of the Van Trapp children is in the past, while life in the present shows her disdain for how Hammerstein, of the famed Rodgers and Hammerstein duo, was misrepresenting how her life really was. Much of the family’s escape from the Nazis was not portrayed correctly and Maria was adamant that changes be made.

Maria was a strong woman and her ability to go from nun, to nanny, to mother and wife was remarkable. Her good sense and kindness had all the kids supporting her and their father’s union. Learning about the rigorous musical touring that the family endured was eye-opening as well. This is a wonderful escape into the Von Trapp world and how the family unit was shown in the musical/movie versus how life really was! This was an easy, interesting read that I enjoyed greatly!

Was this review helpful?

Like most people my age, we grew up singing every Rodgers & Hammerstein song from the movie . The movie is a classic I'll always love. Years ago, I read Maria Von Trapp's memoir and got a different image than that of Julie Andrews version of Maria. Both were so interesting. Now author Michelle Moran has written an historical fiction version of the Von Trapp family as well as insight into Rodgers & Hammerstein's work on bringing this story to Broadway. It was very interesting learning the inside story of how we got the play, the music most still know by heart and the many books written about this family.

This book was enjoyable, interesting and enlightening. I highly recommend it! I've now ordered a physical book for my library.

My thanks to Net Galley and Dell for an advanced copy of this e-book.

Was this review helpful?

This is the story of Maria von Trapp told in part from her perspective. It is based on interactions between Maria and an associate of Oscar Hammerstein. The Sound of Music glamorized the life of her family and this novel provides a different angle. Highly recommend for lovers of historical fiction.

Was this review helpful?

What's not to love? Moran is an excellent historical fiction writer, a favorite fine, and here, the real Maria stands up to tell her story. The hills are alive. Indeed.

Was this review helpful?

Like many others, I chose to read this because I love The Sound of Music and am fascinated by the time and characters. This book took it a little deeper into the life of Maria and exposed us to the "behind the scenes' reasoning to a lot of her actions.

The way the author tangled the creation of the musical with the true life of Maria was masterful! The timeline was easy to follow and the story flowed well. Of course, I had to rewatch the musical on Disney immediately after finishing the book. It felt a little different to watch after Maria exposed some of the untruths in her story. It definitely made me do some Google searches to find out more!

Was this review helpful?

Easy, chummy read that is both informative and entertaining. Didn't know how the musical veered away from the truth, so those differences kept my interest. Perfect for any fan of the musical and a welcome break from all my fantasy reads.

Was this review helpful?

Maria by Michelle Moran is a book about the real life story of Maria Von Trapp, the woman that The Sound of Music is based on. In this story, Maria is responding to the play that is the original rendition of her story. She is offended that they have changed her story and particularly upset about the unjust portrayal of her husband, Baron Von Trapp. The book takes place during the 1950's when Oscar Hammerstein was in the process of writing the lyrics to the musical score for the musical. Maria is prevented from meeting with Hammerstein, and instead, she is redirected to meet with his secretary, Fran, who becomes intrigued by Maria and her story, and determined to get the real story to Hammerstein. Since I have been a fan of the Sound of Music movie since I first saw it as a child, I was very interested in reading this book. Ms. Moran does a wonderful job of describing the meetings between Maria and Fran, and the eventual effect that these meetings had on Maria and her family as well as on Fran's personal life. I highly recommend this book to anyone that can't get enough of The Sound of Music, or anyone interested in Historical Fiction. Thank you Netgalley and Random House Publishing for giving me the opportunity to preview this book in exchange of an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

LOVED THIS BOOK! Must read for any fans of Historical Fiction and fans of Sound of Music!!

I recently decided to rewatch Sound of Music before my trip to Austria. This led me to researching about Maria Von Trapp as I was curious as to how accurate the musical was. I ended up stumbling upon this book, and was fortunate enough to get a copy from Netgalley in exchange for a honest review.

I loved how this book was written, between Maria’s point of view and from the point of view of Hammerstein’s assistant. As a musical aficionado I loved getting an inside glimpse into the making of such an iconic production. I also loved learning about the true stories of what actually happened to the Von Trapp family after Hitler took over Austria, as well as where Maria came from. I feel like I understand more about why Maria is the way she is after learning about her childhood.
Definitely worth the read :)

Was this review helpful?

*thank you to NetGalley and Dell for an eARC of this book in exchange for my review*

If you loved The Sound of Music, you absolutely need to read this book. This fictionalized retelling of Maria Von Trapp’s life sets the record straight, where the Rogers and Hammerstein story deviated.

Michelle Moran sets up (the real) Oscar Hammerstein’s (fictional) secretary as our frame story FMC. Fran is tasked with interviewing and appeasing Maria Von Trapp when Maria storms into the rehearsal of The Sound of Music in protest of the script written to depict her life. In these interviews, we get an insightful, yet dramatized, look at Maria’s life—from her lonely and painful childhood, to her triumphant tour across America, and even the letdown of the years that followed.

Maria’s story is so captivating. While quite different from the charmed life that we all loved in The Sound of Music, Moran’s narrative paints hardship alongside the charm of her life in an honest and thoughtful way. The most difficult part of this book for me was the frame story. Fran is a lovable character, and of course I wanted to root for her. I just didn’t feel like I got to see enough of her, so it was a little difficult to empathize in her love and loss.

Overall, I really enjoyed this book. The author did a nice job of tying in a lot of information across various sources. I appreciated the care with which she presented this beloved story.

Was this review helpful?

Sound of Music fans will love this historical fiction depiction of Maria von Trapp’s well known story. Alternating between 1959 when Hammerstein was writing what would be his last musical and Maria’s life starting from an early age, Michelle Moran’s novel gives readers an in depth look in to the making of the beloved musical and the person that inspired it.
Fran Connelly is a secretary for Oscar Hammerstein and an inspiring writer. When Maria von Trapp asks for an audience with Hammerstein to correct the many errors in his upcoming musical about her life, he sends Fran instead. With rehearsals already underway Fran knows there may be little she can do to rewrite any creative liberties taken with the storyline but over many weeks she better understands Maria’s story as she tells it herself. Will Maria endorse the musical and will Fran be able to influence Hammerstein to hit the right notes of this love story?
The novel’s framework reminded me a lot of “Finding Dorothy” by Elizabeth Letts and I think historical fiction fans will greatly enjoy both novels.

Was this review helpful?

A very interesting story that changed the way I seen Maria from the sound of music. Very interesting and I love how the truth is told and they don’t shy away from sharing choices Maria made. Overall a great read for fans of Maria and her family!

Was this review helpful?

Maria by Michelle Moran offers a fascinating glimpse behind the Hollywood version of Maria von Trapp’s life, exploring the true story that inspired The Sound of Music. Set in the 1950s, the novel follows Oscar Hammerstein as he prepares to bring Maria’s life to Broadway. However, when Maria sees how her story is being altered, she sets out to confront Hammerstein, only to form an unexpected bond with his secretary, Fran.

Through this relationship, Maria shares her real experiences—revealing a life of love, hardship, and survival that is far more complex than the musical suggests. Moran’s novel is a compelling reflection on how truth is often sacrificed for entertainment, and how real life is always more nuanced than the versions we see on stage or screen. A beautifully written tale of resilience, Maria is a must-read for fans of historical fiction and The Sound of Music.

Was this review helpful?

The Sound of Music is one of my all time favorite movies and soundtracks. Maria, in short, is a historical fiction take on Maria von Trapp's life in the convent, meeting and living with the von Trapp family, and the making of the Broadway musical based on Maria's story. This book is a light read and is a charming story about a movie that has become a beloved institution.

Thank you to NetGalley and Random House Publishing Group - Ballantine for this ARC.

Was this review helpful?

I’m not usually the biggest fan of historical fiction, but I am a massive musical theatre fan, so I thought I’d give this one a try. And it didn’t disappoint!

I thought the story was very well told and all the characters leapt off the page. It also was very interesting to hear a new take on a story that we all know so well.

The dual timeline definitely aided to the storytelling instead of feeling like an overused plot device as it does in a lot of historical fiction.

I would 100% recommend this book to anyone who is a fan of “The Sound of Music”, likes historical fiction, or just wants to read an interesting story!

I received a a free copy of this book from NetGalley in exchange for my honest review. All thoughts and statements are my own.

Was this review helpful?

So. This novel was a revelation. I admit, I did a lot of unsolicited fact-sharing with my not-always-so-interested husband while I read this book, as well as quite a bit of internet-searching for confirmation. The truth, presented here (and based on several memoirs and other reference), is almost the exact opposite of what we learned from the movie, when the gruff, grief stricken disciplinarian saved the happy-go-lucky, collector of favorite things from the nunnery. So apparently he was the happy one, and she was, actually, also very much in love with God. Or something like that. I'll leave that for you to read yourself. Because you really need to read this—besides, how could you resist that cover?

There is so much to take in here. Moran has done a wonderful job with her story within a story, and I enjoyed the contemporary time (during the making of the movie) almost as much, and sometimes more, than the retelling of the actual events. The Sound of Music will always be a favorite of mine, and Moran's book did not diminish it at all for me. In fact, it may have made the whole subject that much more compelling, adding a dose of reality to a story we had to know was just too good to be true. Maria's character, it seems, was given a scripted touch-up. No matter how disappointed she was with how the whole thing turned out, I can't imagine she was sorry to hear that Julie Andrews was going to play her in the movie.

Was this review helpful?

"Maria" gives readers a fascinating look into the real life of Maria von Trapp, beyond what we know from The Sound of Music. The story goes back and forth between Maria’s early life and the creation of the Broadway musical, showing the real challenges and complexities she faced. Some fictional elements, like Fran, add another layer to the story, though a few details felt out of place. Overall, it's a great read for anyone curious about the true story behind the beloved film!

My thanks to NetGalley and Random House Publishing Group - Ballantine for this eARC.

Was this review helpful?

I felt like this book had a hard time figuring out what it was trying to do....tell about Maria von Trapp or tell about the creation of the musical based on her life. It jumped between the two rather abruptly. That being said, I watched The Sound of Music movie with my grandma numerous times and did enjoy learning more about the real person behind the story.

Was this review helpful?

3.5 stars from me! I am very glad that Michelle Moran has returned to the historical fiction world with the release of Maria. I liked that we got a 2 for 1 deal on historical settings with 1950s NYC and 1920s-30s Austria with the dual POV. I can't say I loved either of the main characters, but it was interesting to read about the making of the Sound of Music behind the scenes. Also, reading about the differences between the musical and the real Maria von Trapp's life was something!

Looking forward to future releases from Michelle Moran and am so glad I got a chance to read this book.

Was this review helpful?

Fans of the musical, "Sound of Music," will want to pick up Maria; A Novel of Maria von Trapp.

Oscar Hammerstein is finishing up his latest play regarding the life of Maria Von Trapp. He's ready to make this his next hit but he's got one issue, Maria. She's in the theater demanding changes to the play right now as it does not portray the actual events of her life. Open to hearing about the changes the play should make, Maria tells her life story to Hammerstein's secretary, Fran. How do you solve a problem like Maria? You listen to her.

I have always been a fan of the Sound of Music since my youth and was excited to dive into Maria by new to me author, Michelle Moran. I immediately pictured scenes from the movie throughout the read as I was taken into Maria's life. Moran writes in a way that the scenes come alive and then make me want to do some research, and some planning, to discover if/when these scenes occurred. I definitely will be picking up another book soon by Moran to dive into what other historical events she has taken an interest with.

Was this review helpful?

This book was a must read for me as I watch the Sound of Music once a year.

Reading Maria's back story and her love of music at an early age gave insight into this beloved and iconic character.

Was this review helpful?