Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Thank you Penguin team, Razorbill and Netgalley, for approving my 3rd ARC ever. I still find myself shocked at this opportunity.

I read this book in about 3 days and I have to say this sequel blew me away, the issues that I had with the first book where it felt like there was a lack of description for the characters or a lack of a supporting cast was not present here. There was so much more detail (or maybe I was just used to the way the author describes the characters, clothing, and architecure), but there was definitely more of a supporting cast of characters for our leads to bounce off which I appreciated because it didn't make the world feel small like it sometimes felt in House of Marionne. It also felt like Quell was actually interacting with the world and effecting it instead of the world only effecting Quell.

I appreciated having Jordan's POV in the sequel, in my previous review for House of Marionne I stated that Jordan was the second best written character, but to be honest, I think it was actually Yagrin who was the second best written for House of Marionne, but for Shadows of Perl Jordan is definitely the second best written character and is competing against Quell for first place. I think anybody who didn't feel like Jordan was much of a character or believed he was one dimensional would come with a different opinion after reading this book. Even as someone who liked Jordan in the first book, getting a chance to be in his head, learning how he thinks, how he feels, learning his backstory, made his character so much better.

The third POV, who is kind of revealed to be someone that we are sort of familiar with was definitely a surprise, and one of the things that I loved about that POV was learning more about of House Ambrose which I have to say is one of my favorite Houses for it's uniqueness and their version of a debutante and debutante culture. And I think that's what I appreciated about this book in general was learning the backstory on the world, but also on Draguns, House of Perl, and House of Ambrose.

I hope that we get to learn more about House Oralia, since they seem to be a House that doesn't really involve themselves in the politics of everything else, we were promised grey characters, so I'm sure they're hiding something as well. I also hope that we can somehow learn even more about House of Marionne because it seems the other Houses have their own distinct activities or traditions, what with Perl and the pins and Ambrose and their emphasis on intelligence and knowledge. And I'm sure House Oralia has things that focus on creativity that sets them apart from other Houses and so I would love to know what traditions House of Marionne has that makes it different others, which after the fallout of the first book and the things that happened in this book, we may never know.

This world is so unique and I am dreading the fact that it ends with the next book, I wish we could have more time in this world and yet I have to wonder after the events that took place in this book is wrapped up, what more could happen, if possible I would love to see it. As for any negatives, I wish Quell and Yagrin got to interact more, but that's not really a negative, it's more of a want.

My enjoyment was high, I have nothing to critique, this was truly a 5 star book. Thank you again Penguin team, Razorbill and Netgally for this opportunity.

Was this review helpful?

This is the second book in the series, and it was overall enjoyable. It takes a bit to get back in to the world, but worth it once you do.

Was this review helpful?

This is a great sequel to the first book, and boy, does it end on a cliffhanager to make you beg for the next one again!
I highly recommend refreshing your memory on her story if you need to prior to reading this just to make things fully flow.
Overall, I love this series so much and look forward to rereading the finished book.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this book. It is a continuation of the series and I really enjoyed it. I really loved the world that this book was set in. I would highly recommend this book!

Was this review helpful?

This was an amazing second book in the House of Marionne! It continues with Quell leaving the House of Marionne for the House of Perl, who accept her as she is. However, every house has its secrets. Meanwhile the guy she started falling for, Jordan, is now hunting her in order to protect the Sphere, which Quell can destroy. These lovers turned enemies was sad and heartbreaking as they work against each other. Quell continues to look for her mother at the same time. I loved House of Marionne, and this book definitely did not disappoint!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for allowing me to review this book.

This is the second in a series and I enjoyed it. I will say it took me a bit to get fully immersed into the story, and I was a little confused at first, but I'll say that's because it'd been a while since I read the first book. I felt as though Quill was truly coming into her own in this book. I look forward to seeing how the story continues!

Was this review helpful?

J.Elle takes it to the next level with this sequel to House of Marionne. Three points of view added to the unfurling excitement and twists and turns as Quel seeks the truth. Shadows of Perl delves into the inner workings of the politics of the Houses which made for a richer and more nuanced worldbuilding. The moments between Quel and Jordan kept me fully invested and on the edge of my seat because these two are explosive on the page together. I totally enjoyed and highly recommend this series. Thank you to Penguin Teen and Net Galley for the e-arc.

Was this review helpful?

The world of House of Marionne shines through once again like a jewel on a crown in its sequel Shadows of Perl.
The sequel takes us deeper into the magical world of grand balls and beautiful gowns. This time around we're in house Perl where Jordan was raised. With it's deeper dive we also get two additional POVs. Both add a new interesting dynamic to the tale.
Quell is just as determined as she was in the first book. She is unyielding in her determination to be herself even if that means embracing her dark magic. A magic that has been demonized.
The sequel is action packed and full of romance.

Was this review helpful?

Picking up right where book 1 left off, we see where Quell ended up. Her journey to strengthen her magic she bonded with. We also get a new POV from an unexpected character who I loved upon first meeting her, High stakes lots of danger and Quell finding herself and pushing herself to all the limits! Theres intrigue and mystery, anger and grief. ALL THE EMOTIONS! The way the story is told is dramatic and fresh! Jordan is duty bound by honor from the Dragun brotherhood and spends a good bit of the book trying to find Quell and also find himself. Quite a few scenes between Quell and Jordan had me giggling and kicking my feet! Literally gasphing for more of their banter! I also love how House Perl amd her heir do not get along. I feel like what is a story without a big bad right? We learn a lot of new information about the Houses and theor origins and also how old secrets are brought to the light! I loved that it was so unpedictable and nothing is as it seems. An excellent second act to book one and if possible i love it even more as we get even further into such a complex amd magical world!!!!!!!!!!! SUPER EXCITED FOR OTHER FANS TO READ AND SEE MORE REACTIONS!!!!!!!!!

Was this review helpful?

I felt like this book was a bit slower than the first book. It wasn’t necessarily bad, but just felt slow and almost clunky. Overall, I still enjoyed the story and if there is a third book I’ll likely read that one as well.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Netgalley, the publisher, and the author for an advanced copy of this book in exchange for my honest review. All opinions are my own.

This is a great sequel to the first book, and boy, does it end on a cliffhanager to make you beg for the next one again!

I LOVED House of Marrione, and Shadows of Peril was no letdown. This story picks up where the first book left off, following Quell and Jordan as they navigate their own missions at odd with each other. I loved that while this book could have felt very much like filler for the third book, Quell actually did a ton of traveling and finding out new things (trying not to give spoilers sorry) and the story was highly engaging the whole time. Likewise, Jordan was doing his own missions that would lead him to eventually cross paths with Quell again towards the end. I also loved that while the author could have made both MCs dispair and complain about their failed relationship, there was a very appropriate and manageable amount of emotion about it that fit appropriately with the story and didn't overshadow what was happening.

The ARC does need editing as expected, but I plan to just re-read it again when it comes out so I get the full experience. Also, I found it confusing to remember who Nore was and what her story was, and it was distracting to read her perspective in this book. I highly recommend refreshing your memory on her story if you need to prior to reading this just to make things fully flow.

Overall, I love this series so much and look forward to re-reading the finished book!!!

Was this review helpful?

It has been almost an entire year since I read House of Marionne so I have been very anxiously awaiting this sequel and it did not disappoint!
I loveeeeee that we get multi-POV throughout this. There is a surprise reveal/twist related to HOM literally in the prologue and I was shook. We get alot more Dragun- related politics and action and get to see their innerworkings as well as finding out a lot more about just how deceptive the leaders of each House is. You are really shown in this book just how much influence magic and power and status have over the actions of these houses and the head mistresses. They all do some super shady to downright deplorable things to get what they want. Quell is bloodthirsty and out for revenge after a revelation and I was HERE FOR IT. The tension between her and Jordan throughout invoked a lot of emotions and made you that much more invested in both of their outcomes. Honestly my jaw dropped numerous times in the book but especially in the last 15-20%. The last page has me wondering how the heck I am supposed to wait another year to see how everything plays out and the conclusion.
My review will be cross-posted to Goodreads now, to Amazon on release day and on my instagram in the coming weeks @thatbookishteach

Was this review helpful?

I had slightly mixed feelings about going into this read. While I enjoyed the first novel, I didn't fully connect with the characters like I wanted. But, I enjoyed it enough that I wanted to give the sequel a chance. Unfortunately, I did not enjoy this as much as the first novel. I wanted so much more world building and finally getting some answers to the way the magic system operated. The main focus was on the character dynamics, which normally would make up for the lack of world building, but in this case, I felt like an observer. It was too much surface level to truly feel like I was immersed in this universe. Some readers may enjoy this sequel, but it didn't end up being for me.

Was this review helpful?

I loved the story, the world building and meeting the different characters. I felt completely immersed in the story and couldn't stop reading it.

Was this review helpful?

Shadows of Perl picks up after the end of House of Marionne. This is a YA fantasy world where magic is hidden from the normal world and magic users are divided into houses that train them in a debutante style, One type of magic, toushana, is considered forbidden and dark magic, Users of toushana are hunted down by Draguns, Quell, our FMC, has bonded with her toushana and is now considered enemy number one by Jordan, her trainer/love interest/#2 Dragun. Both swear that they hate each other and both are completely oblivious to the fact that they still love each other.
Quell is on the hunt to find her mother and develop control over her magic. Jordan is determined to find Quell but to also save The Sphere, an object that houses the magic in the world which has started to crack, If The Sphere breaks open or magic gets out then all magic in the world will be lost. Will these two be able save magic, will Quell find her mother, will they realize where their emotions truly lie?

Thank you to Penguin/Razorbill and NetGalley for the opportunity to read and review this book which I am giving 3.5 stars. While I did enjoy this book I feel that it suffered some pacing issues and was a bit too long. I enjoyed the multiple POV chapters and I enjoy the main characters in this series I felt the addition of Nore as a POV chapter was too much, her story could have just been shortened. Generally this book is too long. I will continue this series with the third book and did already preorder a copy of this book for my home library since I already have book 1.

I will post video reviews of this book on my social medial (TikTok and YouTube) closer to the release date in September,

Was this review helpful?