Yes No Maybe by Jessica Sherry starts off with an awkward proposal answer (hence the title) that leads to a series of events that have high school English teacher, Rowan, questioning her relationship choices, buying a new home, and becoming a temporary foster parent.

I found that it takes a bit to get into the story, but the plot picks up when Rowan moves into a new neighborhood and a cute cast of characters are introduced, complete with Gilmore Girls-esque vibes and an adorable neighborhood newsletter. Things really get going when the smart and sexy writer/next-door neighbor, Jack, is introduced. Despite a testy beginning, the two develop a true friendship—and more—in this feuding neighbors-to-lovers romance.

The interactions between Jack and Rowan are equally sweet and spicy, and I couldn’t wait to see what was in store for them. Furthermore, there is true depth, especially in the character of Rowan, as we learn about her past. Rowan has burn scars covering portions of her face, neck, and hands. The history of these scars and Rowan’s resiliency makes this so much more than a feel-good romance.

Some of the plot and dialogue were lengthy/overwritten and could have been a bit more succinct, but overall, this novel was a pleasure to read. I laughed out loud a few times, and the epilogue was quite sweet.

An adorable and delightful read! This book is a romance & book lovers dream! Sherry plants titles, references & passages to favorite classic & childhood pieces of literature throughout the book. Although fictional, she uses Jack’s writing as a nod to the contemporary.

Jack is a romance writer suffering from writer’s block but after Rowan moves in he suddenly is overcome with inspiration. Jack observes, he listens & takes pieces of people & their lives to weave into his books. Rowan, has a history of trauma & bad relationships. She has difficulties trusting & allowing Jack to be part of her secrets, vulnerabilities & allowing him to weave some of her history & herself into his book. Despite what happened to Rowan, she is not afraid to try new ways to bring the love of literature to her students. Jack helps her embrace this & their strong connection continues to form.

Sherry also includes topics of family, community, close neighbors & fostering. Even with all of this, the story is beautifully written and a nice relaxing read.

Thank you to Jessica Sherry and NetGalley for a free ARC of this book in exchange for honest feedback.

I am a pretty emotional person and yet I can’t name that many books in my life that bring me to tears but this one did; the good kind of tears! The “Fix It Queen” and local school teacher Rowan moves into her dream home that reminds her of her favorite storybook. Her neighbor is a grumpy romance writer who parties late, plays his music too loud and is afraid Rowan will change the integrity of her house which holds special memories for him. In the mix are nosey though well-meaning neighbors, a moody teen who needs fostering (enter Fix It Queen Rowan) and oh, Rowan’s Yes No Maybe fiancé.

What I loved about this book is that I cared about the way the romance would play out just as much as I cared about the other things happening. Rowan’s relationship with her temporary foster Sara definitely tugged at my heartstrings. As did the moment Adam hugged her. The neighbors who became found family were so endearing. And the hot tattooed romance author checked off a lot of boxes of things I’m often attracted to in a partner. I also appreciated that Rowan’s breakup ended fairly amicable. As someone who has had primarily amicable ends to my relationships, I can attest that it is possible and I don’t feel like it’s represented enough in books. Too often it’s messy or petty or vindictive. And yes this one was a little messy but they came to an understanding they weren’t right for one another and didn’t stand in each other’s way of moving on.

Towards the end I was prompted to download a free bonus epilogue but sadly it kept telling me my email was ineligible so I’m not sure what other way to read it but I’d definitely love more Jack content.

Overall a great read and I would be more than happy to read more from this author!

There were a lot of things I loved about this book. The wide cast of supporting characters who were unique and interesting in their own right, the sense of community and fun in the neighbourhood, Rowan's dedication to teaching and connection to her students, Jack's belief in love and romance in spite of thinking he won't have it for himself, nearly all of the plot, the development of their relationship and personal emotional growth. However there were a number of small issues that added up into feeling a little irritated overall. Also, I really hated the fatphobic element of Dean's initial story of his childhood struggles and especially the way that turned out in the end. The only reason I kept reading after that was because I knew he wouldn't be the main love interest. Most of the aspects of Dean as a character were inconsistent with his final conversation with Rowan, and the love triangle aspect of the story was unbelievable to me. I found Rowan's insecurities and the way she projected onto Jack super irritating. The emotional conflict and build up of these tory really didn't need that, and personally I found it detracted from the overall story. I really wanted to like this book, but overall these issues were too much.

Jessica Sherry's novel "Yes No Maybe" is a heartwarming exploration of self-acceptance, love, and the courage to pursue true happiness, set against the backdrop of an unexpected neighborhood feud-turned-friendship. The narrative shines brightest through its protagonist, Rowan, whose depth of character is matched only by her resilience. Sherry crafts a journey of self-discovery for Rowan that is as touching as it is inspiring. The entry of Jack Graham, a bestselling romance writer and the "party-centric playboy" next door, serves not only as a catalyst for conflict but as a mirror reflecting what Rowan truly desires from life and love. Sherry's writing effortlessly balances the light and dark moments of life, weaving humor and heartache with a deftness that keeps readers engaged and invested in the outcome. The dynamic between Rowan and Jack evolves beautifully, challenging both characters to confront their fears and prejudices about love, companionship, and acceptance. In conclusion, "Yes No Maybe" is a delightful read that offers more than just a love story. It's a testament to the power of self-discovery, the beauty of opening one's heart despite past hurts, and the endless possibilities that come from saying "yes" to life's maybes. Jessica Sherry delivers a compelling, uplifting, and thoroughly enjoyable novel that will resonate with readers long after the last page is turned.

Thank you to Jessica Sherry and NetGalley for this ARC in exchange for an honest review!

You can see an in depth review on my blog here: https://leylaslibrary.wordpress.com/2024/04/12/yes-no-maybe/

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Push it through you guys! The beginning was truly a slow start and I quickly lost interest... but I'm telling you it gets 10x better! I didn't think I would get emotional reading the book but I was on the verge of bawling my eyes out. Ok, first off, Jack is such a man wh*re. He can't get jealous of Rowan being with Dean when he's basically sleeping around. 🙄 And don't get me started with Dean. When he threw Rowan the "Yes. No. Maybe" in her face, I was ready to throw some hands.🥊🥊 That was a d*ck move. Rowan's story breaks my heart. Every time she brings up the story, my heart gets stuck in my throat.

Rowan Mackey, a self-professed fix-it queen with a penchant for avoiding the spotlight, finds herself at a crossroads after a disastrous public proposal shatters her quiet existence. Seeking refuge in a quaint new home, she unwittingly becomes neighbours with Jack Graham, a bestselling romance author known for his playboy charm and lively parties. What ensues is a clash of both personalities and desires, as Rowan and Jack navigate their budding attraction amidst personal and professional upheavals.

I devoured "Yes No Maybe" in a single sitting! As a first-time reader of this author, I was captivated by the beautiful writing, compelling pace, and engaging storyline. It made me laugh and cry, crafting a rich tapestry of emotions that utterly captivated me.

Jack, the MMC, won my heart with his gruff exterior and hidden depths. As the story unfolds, his complexities and vulnerabilities emerge, shedding light on the scars of his past and the grief he’s still grappling with. I also really liked Rowan, although her tendency to be a bit of a doormat was incredibly frustrating at time I acknowledge it was a pivotal part of her story. Her journey offered a poignant portrayal of PTSD and the enduring impact of trauma, handled with remarkable sensitivity by the author. Their romance blossomed organically, a slow burn that held my attention without faltering.

The supporting cast added colour and charm to the narrative, particularly the eccentric members of the self-appointed neighbourhood watch. The theme of chosen family and family found resonated strongly throughout, depicted through the neighbourhood community and Rowan’s experience with fostering.

Overall "Yes No Maybe" was a delightful blend of sweetness and depth, offering a heartfelt exploration of love, loss, and resilience. Easy to read and with realistic and compelling characters, Jessica Sherry is definitely an author I’ll read again.

Thank you NetGalley and Jessica Sherry for the opportunity to read this ARC.

Thank you to NetGalley, the author and the publisher for giving me a free arc in exchange for an honest review.

It is 1:40 am in the morning. I have cried three times, laughed countless and related to the thoughts in this book more often than I, in my right mind, should.

I always like to start a review with the writing style as I tend to have the least thoughts. I found this to be a well-written, medium-paced book. I was sitting waiting for the next thing to happen, the next fight with Jack, the reason for her scars. It was tense, emotional, and something entirely new in a romance book. I loved all the references to famous authors and the author definitely captured the vibe of being a reader and writer very well.

Now, onto the characters. I adored Jack. I thought he was kind and genuine, if not a little misunderstood. His backstory was emotional and had real depth to it, something I tend to find lacking in main male characters in contemporary romance books. There was something about him that I both adored and something else that I just related to. I'm not sure if it was the grief, the writer's block or the fury at the world's injustice, but something about him was so real and so human.
I really like Rowan, especially at the beginning of the book. Yes, she's a huge pushover but that actually plays such a huge part in the story that it worked despite being irritating at times. I loved that there was disability representation through her PTSD and scars and I think the topic was handled exceptionally well by the author. However, the way she kept pushing Jack away, refusing to trust him or give him a chance - toward the end I was beginning to get frustrated. Especially since she trusted him enough to tell him about her past and her traumas but apparently not enough to be in the same room as another woman. I digress.

The story was super entertaining and incredibly creative. I loved the fostering element and the found family of the neighbourhood and the friendly ghost element? Beautiful. This is a must-read for anyone looking for a romance novel with representation.

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

"A rose is still a rose, even hidden under different petals."

Rowan Mackey is a teacher who prefers to stay out of the spotlight, and her boyfriend, Dean, does the unthinkable: he proposes to her onstage in front of everyone. Seeking solace in a quiet life, she moves into a new house just to find out that Jack Graham, a bestselling romance author and life-of-the-party playboy, is her new neighbor. Although Jack and Rowan initially don't get along, their unexpected relationship begins to deepen. Will they challenge their beliefs about love and commitment, or will Rowan settle for what she already has?

I adored this story. The writing flowed like conversation, making it easy and quick to read. I loved how homey the little neighborhood felt, and how much each person cared for those around them. The anticipation of love was thrilling, and I'm not usually into a slow burn. That being said, if you like slow burns, forced proximity, and found family, "Yes No Maybe" is definitely for you!

Wow! This book is so amazing. The characters are so relatable. I love the realness of the interactions and the emotions.: The guilt a parent feels when something happens to their child, the neighbors being super helpful and nosey. Teens are portrayed as teens. I invested in the idea of using the house from a favorite childhood book to make the house purchase an emotional attachment. I love that we don't t know the entire story of the burn scars until we're near the end of the book. This story beautifully incorporates family, foster care, and owning your truth. I went through all the emotions reading this book. I'm pleased to say I ended up happy. This is a great book!

Thanks to Jessica Sherry and NetGalley for an e-arc in exchange for an unbiased review.

Thank you to NetGalley and the author for an e-ARC of this title to read and review. This was such an absolute delight to read, and I just absolutely loved these characters' world. (I would happily read a series of books from other characters' perspectives, as they find their own love stories as well!) I adored that Jack was the bestselling romance author-next-door, connected with the community but also major celeb status. He was my favorite character, and was so well-rounded that I felt like I was really reading about a specific real author whose works I've devoured over the years. I loved how Jack and Rowan fell into each others' lives and really fit there, it was a joy to see them become friends and more!

I read a lot of feel-good romances, and sometimes characters' jobs or families or traumas and personal hardships are merely mentioned in an attempt to provide some backstory or story drama. Other times, all those other background details take center stage over the romance itself. But here those elements are all up-front and explored so well that the characters and the town and their professions are all wonderfully rich, they all feel like authentic, real people I may know. Traumas (around scarring, violence, foster care, etc.) were handled sensitively and added depth to the story, not distractions. I will definitely be reading more from this author and recommending Yes, No, Maybe to some friends in my life.

what an amazing book!! i'm so thankful to netgalley for letting me read this one early!! it was just so much fun and exciting and sweet!! i had a great time reading this one and you should pick it up!!!

"Yes No Maybe" swept me off my feet! Reading the book's description, I felt an immediate connection to the story, and it did not disappoint. Rowan and Jack's love story is not just about romance; it's about finding strength and learning to love oneself.
This book kept me hooked from start to finish. I laughed, cried, and I couldn't help but fall in love with the characters. Rowan's resilience and Jack's growth throughout the story were truly heartwarming.
I can't wait to see what else this author has in store! 🩷✨

this book really grabbed me at the summary, and the plot was unique and fun to read! but the MMC was really not for me, so it kinda tainted the book for me.

starting with what I liked! I loved Rowan, her whole story and development throughout the book! she is such a sweet, tender character, always wanting to help people, do the best for them, be the best version of herself for everyone else. I loved seeing her realize that she's so beautiful and worthy of love exactly as she is, and not in spite of her scars or anything. Her dedication to students and people in general is so refreshing and completely lovely. Seeing her realize she's worth so much more than her relationship with Dean, and all those rules she set, was so beautiful to read. I also really loved her who lil neighborhood of misfits: they are all so quirky and adorable and just the loveliest little community :)

I didn't love Jack's whole perspective, especially at the beginning of the book. He's rude, sexist, and downright cruel at times. I loved the way Rowan calls him out on some of it, but Jack is one of these guys whose had some legitimately terrible things happen in his life, and he uses that as an excuse to be an asshole. I love a surely grump as much as the next reader, but his asshole-ish characteristics (the "burn face" comment, still calling Rowan princess after she asked him to stop, etc.) are not redeemable to me because there really isn't any redemption for it imo. Jack did have a redemption arc in this story, especially as he starts wanting more with Rowan, but it just didn't feel authentic or sincere to me.

overall, there were many parts of this book I loved! I requested it because I loved the black cat on the cover, and Edgar Allen Poe (the cat) was definitely worth it :) just not my cup of tea, but could for sure be for others!!!

thank you for the arc :)

This book was wonderful! Great for fans of Emily Henry, and Anabel Monaghan. I actually liked both of our leads. It’s a story of healing, empowerment and above all community. Sherry writes with quick pacing and humor. I’d recommend this book to friends! Thanks to NetGalley and Jessica Sherry for this ARC! Definitely one to check out when it’s released.

The story of Rowan and Jack. An opposites attract romance. I liked how it was told from both points of view, but didn't like some of his behaviour.

I devoured this book, and it filled itself with me. I really enjoyed the budding relationship between these characters. The ways they grew in conjunction with learning each other.

I loved these characters - their passion, their edge. They felt real and flawed, yet so perfect. It was interesting getting to read about fostering, as that is something I feel strongly about too.

I can’t wait to read more from this author. An incredible novel that I won’t forget anytime soon. #NetGalley #YesNoMaybe

Yes No Maybe was an enjoyable read and the main characters, Rowan and Jack, were very likeable. I found the neighbors to get on my nerves... being in everyone's business, but aside from them, it was a well-rounded story including several topics. I appreciated The Little House reference which was a favorite book of mine when I was younger. I recommend this book!

Thank you to Netgalley and Jessica Sherry for the arc.

The formatting of this book was messed up on my Kindle, which made it extremely difficult to read. I got 17% of the way through before I gave up. I would probably try to read again if given a physical copy or file that wasn't weirdly formatted.

A book about an author and English teacher… a bookish person’s dream!! I really enjoyed this book. I was feeling all different emotions while reading. As you get to know Jack, he will eventually be everyone’s book boyfriend. Such a great read that touches on difficult topics in a great way. 4.5 stars!!