Skip to main content

Member Reviews

The story of an Italian community trying to bring life back to their once vibrant village. Filled with many zany characters and crazy situations this novel is perfect for someone who is looking for a funny, lighthearted read.

Thank you to NetGalley and Grand Central Publishing for an advanced copy of this book.

Was this review helpful?

I've literally just returned from a trip in Tuscany where I had my wedding. So it's fair to say it was the perfect time to read Tartufo which is set is a Tuscan dying village where all the young people have moved away to more metropolitan areas of Italy. Tartufo is about the villagers of this small and forgotten town, and what happens when the local truffle hunter finds the world's largest Alba white truffle.

This was a charming read with a lot of heart. The villagers are wacky and reminded me of the Stars Hollow townies in Gilmore Girls. The narration jumps around to different villagers' POV as the story unfolds. I especially liked Giovanni, the truffle hunter, and his interactions with his dogs. I do think the book could've benefited from being a little longer to allow certain storylines to come to a more organic ending. There are aspects of the plot, which by the end, felt a little rushed. However, I enjoyed my time with Tartufo and would recommend it if you like stories that focus on a wide cast of characters.

I rated Tartufo 4 out of 5 stars.

Was this review helpful?

This is a hard book to describe. It's funny, has eccentric characters (including a donkey), a large white truffle, chefs, food, suspenseful high-stakes auction and a dying Italian village. But it all works and I learned a lot about truffles!!

Was this review helpful?

Tartufo tells the story of a small Tuscan village in Italy facing financial hardship. When one of the villagers discovers a record-breaking truffle, it raises the question: could this be the key to saving the struggling community? While it can be challenging to keep track of the many characters, the novel clearly reflects the author’s deep love for food, animals, nature, and humanity.

Thank you to Grand Central Publishing and NetGalley for the advance reader’s copy.

Was this review helpful?

"Tartufo" is light drama, mystery with a hint of "foodie"—a perfect fir for me.

The small Italian town, Lazzarini Boscarino, desperately needs a windfall. Often getting passed over by tourists who are headed to the more popular neighboring village of Borghese, the little town is a dying community of old people set in their ways and businesses hardly seeing the light of day. Bar Celebrita hardly sees a new face, and Nonna Amara, whose house and restaurant were destroyed by a freak avalnche, do not have the funds to rebuild. A medieval castle is in disrepair and a 20-something-year-old donkey very nearly became mayor. The public coffers are empty.

When an unexpected humongous white truffle puts the little town in the international spotlight, newly elected Mayor Delizia needs to grab the bull by its horns and uses this opportunity to raise the badly needed funds. The rural folks may find the glare a little too bright. Will all the money and fame be worth it to save the town, or will it ruin its very soul?

Told through the nose, readers will be inundated with vivid descriptions of many, many smells like with a dog sniffing for truffles, engulfed in damp woodsy smells or Umberto's memories of estranged wife Giuseppina's "heady poison of her perfume." The truffle symbolizes how something wonderful can bring a town together, but it can also be the cause for its destruction. The lead-up to the the auction is quite suspenseful and each of the town's quirky characters will have a different reaction to it—making this simple enough story a good case for character study.

Umberto, a Michelin chef, is the very farce of the pretentiousness as the chef of some high-end, avant-garde cooking. Yes, there are some that are really good (and really expensive!) restaurants, but the character of Umberto takes it up a notch. Leaving his wife and hometown, he must realize that, perhaps, like the truffle, it's good to be "grounded, rooted, ... [It exemplifies] the power of community and vibrant connection.." He needs to step up for a community that needs him, even if it means apologizing, which he describes as smelling "pickled and briny, that sometimes sewage stink of the sea."

Like a truffle, the beginning of the story took a while to unfold but once, it gets going, it gets going. It's a fun read to take to the beach this summer.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley and the publisher for the early copy.
This sounded perfect on paper and I was excited, but I am sad to say it did not work for me personally. I wanted to love it more but the writing was hard for me to sync into it and the plot was moving too slow.
Loved the settings and how authentic the writing is, it's the structure that just did not work for my brain.

Was this review helpful?

This was so much fun and a great heartwarming read! I loved the unique characters and the way they made such a vibrant tapestry of their community! The truffle related drama was always interesting and hilarious. I was so looking forward to this one and it didn’t disappoint!

Was this review helpful?

The writing and descriptions in this book were so lovely, and the characters were bright, funny, and completely loveable. I wanted to eat this up and adore every minute of it, but the story seemed to drag with the lack of stakes or a plot until way into the second half. I would suggest this book for readers of up-lit who also moonlight as foodies.

Was this review helpful?

I expected this to be more laugh-out-loud funny, but it's the kind of funny where I'm still remembering conversations and picturing incidents and chuckling later. Small town politics can be hilarious, but there was also a lot of feeling here. There was a competition that felt really important but in the end, it was the relationships that counted. It's hard when the world is moving on and leaving your small town behind, but this was realistic and hopeful.

Was this review helpful?

Tartufo by Kira Jane Buxton is a riotous, sharp-toothed delight—equal parts absurd comedy, literary satire, and heartfelt examination of art, ego, and the human (and not-so-human) condition. Buxton has a singular voice, and in Tartufo, she unleashes it with gleeful precision. The titular character—a pompous, scene-stealing dog—narrates with Shakespearean flair and a ridiculous amount of charm, skewering the world of theater and literature while accidentally revealing deep truths about love, loss, and legacy.

Buxton’s wit is razor-sharp, and her prose is bursting with clever wordplay, theatrical absurdities, and lovingly crafted chaos. Beneath the humor, though, is a surprisingly tender core. She explores the fragility of artistic ambition and the desperation to be remembered, even if it’s through the unlikeliest of narrators. The pacing is energetic, the satire lands beautifully, and somehow, amid the hilarity, Buxton manages to tug at the heartstrings without ever veering into sentimentality.

Was this review helpful?

I'm a sucker for a tale set in Italy, and I enjoyed many aspects of this book. If you're in the mood for something light and set in a quirky Italian town, this may be for you. I stumbled at times over the language and the pacing was slow in spots, but I enjoyed the escape, and thank Netgalley and the publishing company for this Advanced Readers Copy.

Was this review helpful?

This book was so bogged down by flowery language, over the top descriptions, and near constant similes that it was almost unreadable. Mix all of that with a staggering amount of characters and Hallmark movie humor and it all gets to be way too much. While I had to force myself to finish it I seem to be in the minority based on other reviews I’ve seen so maybe it just caught me at the wrong time.

Was this review helpful?

A fu sort of slapstick comedy set in a dying Italian village. The writing was love and evocative and the characters fun and the plot silly but not a lot of substance to grab onto.

Was this review helpful?

A great balance between the literary and the fluffy - it was a charming book with well-realized characters and a well-told story. Very charming and I would highly recommend it to anyone with an interest in food, Europe, or good stories.

Was this review helpful?

The Village of Lazzarini Boscarino is an absolute delight—charming, humorous, and beautifully written. With a quirky cast (including a donkey nearly elected mayor and a cat named Al Pacino), decadent food, and a heartwarming small-town atmosphere, it’s a joy to read.

Was this review helpful?

This is EXACTLY the book I needed to read in 2025. Cozy escapist setting, quirky characters, witty and charming as hell, and it made me cry. A small town in rural Tuscany seems to be on its way out; its population is aging, its money is dwindling, and tourists don't visit anymore. So when a local finds the largest truffle in history, it's exactly what the town needs. But are they ready for that kind of spotlight to be shined on their local drama? I haven't stopped thinking about Tartufo since I finished it. I already want to read it again.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Netgalley and Grand Central Publishing for the complimentary ebook. I hate to say that this was a disappointment for me, but it was not what I was expecting from Kira Jane Buxton. It was all fluff, overly long (and overly florid) descriptive prose, and no real bite. The characters were caricatures, and it all just felt silly. Quixotic books are NOT my jam, though. So if you like cozy, flowery, you know what you’re getting into at every turn and recognize the archetypes of comfort reads, this might be a great pick! It was absolutely not what I was expecting or endeavoring to read.😁

Was this review helpful?

I LOVED this book! It was a really fun little story about a small village. The characters came to life. It made me want to take a trip to Italy. The mystery was well written and the plot fast paced.

Was this review helpful?

This is the review I gave for reading the audiobook version of this. Tartufo is a beautifully written novel about one of the many Tuscan mountain towns that is facing expensive, serious challenges as their way of life no longer appeals to the young citizens who have left and the ability to generate income is minimal as the population ages. And then, a lonely truffle hunter finds what may be the largest white truffle in ever found in the world. The novel has a slapstick feel quite often and I think that's why I put it down a lot because slapstick makes me nervous. The ways the truffle is in constant danger and the incredible cast of characters including the mayor, who is taking all steps she can to save the town. She barely won the office when she ran against an old donkey. There are family feuds, numerous dreams, a wacko priest outcasts, goats, a favorite cat, a former villager who took advantage of all he learned in the town to become a world famous chef. There are old decaying buildings full of history and old decaying people: same.

I found the novel slow at times but kept picking up my phone and listening some more to Carolyn Hewitt's exceptional narration complete with accents and voices that always pleased. Overall, the novel is something of a morality tale of the best kind. Of learning what was good all along even if there had never been a truffle. Of gaining sophistication and maintaining and improving relationships through the shared experience. Think of it: Truffles deteriorate in a very short time, so the need to move quickly and what it takes to make it happen is a mix of genius, reputation, luck and cooperation. I probably would rate this 3.5 stars but up to 4. I think this was personal and had to do with things that are less my thing than it might be for others. I would definitely recommend it and it did make my think of my trip to Tuscany many years ago with pleasure.

This is a review of the audiobook..

Was this review helpful?

A warm hug of a novel, I completely and totally fell in love with the village and all of its inhabitants. I could read six more novels if Buxton turned into a series, and I can't wait to go to Tuscany one day - not only did she give voice to her characters, she gave a soul to the area and its nature. Just as brilliant as her first two books!

Was this review helpful?