Enter our cast of characters- a “mysterious” narrator, the Caesar family, and Captain Orestes James and his crew of Irregulars. On one chance night when the Caesar children attend a ball in pursuit a suitable marriages, Captain James comes to John Caesar’s rescue after defending his sister Mary from a major. One night, Mary wishes upon a star and a fairie comes to grant her one wish- literally. Now John Caesar, Captain James and his crew must transverse the mortal and non-mortal realms to put everything back to rights.

Upon requesting this book from Netgalley, I was unaware that this was a second book in a series. Luckily, this book can be read without having read the first and only chance upon a few moments that lack context for the situation. Since I had never read the first book and the synopsis of this story, the narration was quite a surprise. Since it is not everyone’s cup of tea, I will mention that this is third person omniscient and as the reader are being told a story through a mysterious narrator that is never named. All I can say is you better brush up on your Shakespearean reading.

While I didn’t love the narration style at times, it certainly was different and created a sense of being a fly on the wall rather than right in the action. However, this style does leave you less invested in what happens to the characters compared to first person style narration. With first person, you are only experiencing the world through one person at a time while you know the actions and thoughts of the characters, you are just being told them rather than feeling them.

The magical realism aspect was probably the best part of this book. The fantastical nature of the fairies and gods who played a part in the story leaves me wanting a whole book just about the world rather than the mortals that played a starring role.

Overall, while this isn’t a top book for me, at least it did something different and that counts for a lot when there are hundreds of books publishing the exact same storyline just with different names and locations over and over again. If you are looking for something unique, then this is for you.

#netgalley #confoundingoaths #randomhouse

“Confounding Oaths” is Alexis Hall’s slice of messy heaven, a good reflection of humanity’s foibles. It is a cultural commentary within a romance, within a swashbuckling tale of mortals who cross with one another, the fae, and the Gods. Never-the-less, the novel offers realistic insight into early 1800 societal pressures upon an otherwise loving family. For lesser authors, the complexities would have confused, rather than illuminated.

Premise: John Caeser defends his sister Mary’s honor, and hits Mr. Bloodworth, an officer who calls Mary homely. Fellow officer Orestes James and his “irregular troops” rescue John from the retaliatory beating ordered by Mr. Bloodworth. Orestes draws Bloodworth’s anger, as well. Meanwhile Mary, jealous of pretty sister Anne’s attention and suitors, wishes for her own beauty. A fairy grants the wish, turning Mary into an exquisite glass creature. Mary may ensnare men, but is slow starts to fracture. John and Orestes, fend off attacks on all sides to save Mary’s life.

But John and Orestes are barely peerage. John’s mother Lady Mary, married a Senegalese man, thus giving up most privileges of the ton. John has taken it upon himself to find Mary and Anne decent marriages, hoping to brighten their futures. As an enlisted man who gained rank through deeds, Orestes had less status than wealthy officers who bought their commissions in that era. Plus, as gay men, both are criminals. With everything stacked against them, how can Mr. Hall pull out a victory for our protagonists?

Hall is the master of dilemma, as shown in moments when John realizes he is more “himself” with the irregulars than in his own society. “It was disquieting to realise he was surrounded by enemies of which he knew nothing, though not, perhaps, as disquieting s being with a man who wanted him to be better.” Equally, the rivalry between Mary and Anne is achingly real. Their loving parents couldn’t prepare them for the bigotry they face, and they are only safe to show rancor towards each other.

Mr. Hall’s characterizations have depth. In Orestes and his troops, we see how people would act if no one valued their lives except one another, each with a uniquely wise response, despite their brief time on page. They will soon fight Napoleon, and Orestes discusses the paradox. “In a different world you might share a drink with a Frenchman without a second thought. But still you do your part because if you don’t another man’ll have to do it for you. A man you’ve lived and marched and fought beside for a month or a year. And who might die because of you if you’re not where your meant to be.” Note Mr. Hall’s light touch illuminating life and death. Likewise there is a light touch with romance. Unlike many of Mr. Hall’s prior novels, “Confounding Oaths” is non-explicit, leaving more emphasis on John’s whole identity.

Mr. Hall contrasts human and “capricious” magical creatures, (like Robin, our unreliable hobgoblin narrator, a delightfully humorous hold-over from “Mortal Follies,” the first in the series) and man’s arbitrariness seems greater than the fae. John’s path to genuineness is more fascinating than the plot.

“Confounding Oath’s” works as a standalone. Its deeply personal romance gently weaves insightful commentary, classical themes, humor and swashbuckling into a snug rug of entertainment. My admiration for Mr. Hall remains unparalleled.

“Confounding Oaths” is the second book in the Mortal Follies historical fiction series by Alexis Hall. “Mortal Follies,” the first book, was a 5-star read for me so I had high hopes for this one, and it did not disappoint. Five stars! Read this series!

The main story focuses on John Caesar and his two sisters, Mary and Annie. It’s 1815, and the Caesar siblings aren’t fully accepted by society since their father is Black and their mother is white. James wants his sisters happy, but he also wants to pursue his own interests: trysts with the handsome Captain Orestes James. Mary (who resembles her father) enters the marriage market, but her younger sister, Annie (who resembles her mother), gets all the attention. Mary makes a wish to be beautiful so she is noticed, and a fairy grants her wish. But wishes always come with a catch. John, Captain James, and a group of ruffian soldiers band together to rescue Mary from a terrible fate.

The book is narrated by a sprite/hobgoblin/fairy who loves to collect stories. They say they’re just observing and don’t care about anyone involved, but that’s not true. They’re arrogant but secretly a softie.

I started this thinking the love story between John and Captain James would be the main story. However, I was captivated by Mary’s story and the quest to save her. Who knew a wish to be beautiful could go so wrong? That doesn’t mean John and Captain James are shortchanged though. Their growing feelings for each other are swoon worthy.

Miss Bickle, a character from the first book, returns, and I adore her. She is incredibly earnest, open to absolutely anything (especially the supernatural world and fairies), and steadfast in her love for her friends. Sometimes she seems superficial, but there’s a hidden depth there I hope is explored later in the series.

Thank you to NetGalley and Random House for this ARC in exchange for my honest opinion.

I have an interesting relationship with Alexis Hall's books. While I've adored Boyfriend Material and its related works, Mortal Follies was a bit of a slog for me to get through when I had the opportunity to read an ARC before its release. The good news is that its sequel, Confounding Oaths, is much more intriguing, thanks in large part to more rapid pacing and a less nebulous overarching evil to combat.

Mr. Caesar, who did not particularly stand out in Mortal Follies, is interesting to follow with his struggle between doing what is right for his family, and maintaining the questionable reputation he has earned in the ton. As the mixed race oldest child (and only son) of the family, he flounders under the burdens placed upon him by his parents and society. And then he meets Captain James Orestes, black military man who is steadfast in his dedication to his friends, his country, and Mr. Caesar. The two intertwining plots, with Caesar's sister falling prey (kind of) to the Lady after a wish gone wrong, and a cult trying to find a virgin to sacrifice to Artemis for her blessing in the war against France, move at a good pace (my biggest complaint with Mortal Follies), while also building a more complete picture of this fascinating weird world of gods and faeries that Hall has created.

Robin makes for a much more intriguing narrator this time around, and the secondary characters truly have a chance to shine. Miss Bickle will forever be my favorite, from her weird theories on the supernatural to her bookclub/fanfiction club.

This regency and Paranormal novel was very interesting. The potential was there and the first half of the book was extremely well done. My main issue is the narrator. It became too wordy and too complicated I had to end up skipping large sections of the book when it came to the second half. I also need to warn people that there are animal sacrifices and that could be very upsetting. All in all I really wanted to love it but the narration just was way too much. I love the authors work and I am sure many will enjoy it even though it didn't work for me.

Personally, liked this SIGNIFICANTLY more than the first book in the series. Giving is a soft 4 out of 5. Thank you NetGalley.

I still can't quite put a finger on what about Mortal Follies just didn't jive with me, but I enjoyed Book 2 much more. There is still a bit of a disconnect for me with how the romance between John and Orestes is written, but their progression from lust to love felt more natural over the course of the story. I enjoy how Orestes challenges John to be better and pushes him to re-think his view of the world, but Orestes is either set in his ways or just doesn't get the same kind of growth from John.

There are a handful of time skips that happen between the events of the story, and I had to remind myself that this was all occurring over the course of a "Season" which is several weeks/months, especially given Mary's sudden personality shifts. I appreciate that at the end of the day, it was Mary who pulled herself out of her wish, but her decision to do so felt sudden.

Overall happy with this sophomore novel and can't wait to see where our loveable narrator takes us next!

Alexis Hall is back with a ridiculous queer Regency romantasy narrated by none other than Puck. The book is cuttingly funny: the kind of humor that doesn't make you laugh out loud but rather nod appreciatively at the wit. (I did laugh out loud once, when Puck described Shakespeare as "the bastard from Stratford.")

I like this series, but I don't LOVE them. It's interesting because the most original part of them and perhaps the device I like the most, Puck's point of view, may also be the portion that keeps me from feeling emotionally invested. Puck takes great pains not to be invested himself, and this comes across to the reader. I think I might enjoy these a little more on audio, although I don't think I'd be more emotionally into them.

Confounding Oaths focuses on a faerie wish gone wrong (as they always seem to do). The wisher is not one of the romantic leads, but rather one of their sisters. Both MMCs in this book are Black, and much of the narrative takes a narrow and hard look at how they are treated by "good society." I can't speak to the accuracy of the portrayal, but I did enjoy a historical romance set in a "diverse" Regency England a la Bridgerton but that takes the time to engage with racism, classism, etc.

This objective review is based on a complimentary copy of the novel.

Confounding Oaths is a fun, wild ride that takes what was great about its predecessor, Mortal Follies—and also suffers from some of the same issues as the first book.

There's so much to love about this book—a fun collection of characters, a lavish world that ties in magic seamlessly into our everyday world, a romance to die for. That's what I've loved most about this series—the characters and plot that allow me to not only step away for a while. It was something I thoroughly enjoyed about the first book, Mortal Follies, as well.

There's one thing about these books though that I struggled with—and that's the narrative style. While I appreciate the effort to do something clever with the narrator out of the story, weaving us between the world of magic and gods and the world of our protagonists, I found it just as distracting in this book as I did in the first.

That being said, I loved the romance in this. I guessed shortly into Mortal Follies that we would eventually follow Mr. Caesar in the sequel, and he proved an engaging main character, trying to fulfill his duties as an older brother through a saga of magic and mayhem. I liked the romance in this—but almost wish there was more of it. As someone who thoroughly loves a fantasy and isn't generally a full-on romantasy girl, I honestly found the fantasy element of the author's writing less compelling than the romance element, and wished we'd leaned on that a bit more heavily.

All in all, I loved revisiting these characters and their world—and would love to come back to visit again. (I'd just love a better narrator next time, though considering this seems to be a hallmark of this saga, I won't hinge my further reading on it!)

⭐️⭐️⭐️1/2
✨Summary✨
This book is about wishes gone wrong, when Mary Caesar makes an ill fated wish. It’s up to her brother, John Caesar, to get her out of it. John must team up with the handsome, yet poor, Captain Orestes James, to help get her out of a fae bargain.
This was a very cute book, with a fun cast of characters. This book deals with some interesting topics such as class systems, race, sexuality, and the idea of beauty.
The narrator was a nice touch and added some personality to the book.
Something I wasn’t a fan of was the two MMCs got together way too fast for my liking. I personally prefer a little bit of a slower burn. They got together within the first quarter of the book.
Overall, I did enjoy this book and I would recommend it to others.

Thank you to NetGalley, the publisher, and the author for providing the ARC and the opportunity to review this book.

I did not finish the book. I really liked the premise and was super excited to read, but I just couldn’t get into the writing. It felt very uppity in a way that reminded me of myself in high school when I wanted to pretend like I was smarter than everyone else.

thank you to netgalley and the publisher for this e-arc! 3/5 stars, witty and amusing but ultimately not my taste

I didn't read the first book in this series because I thought I wouldn't need to background context, but I think it would've helped a little when diving into this world because it took me a while to catch on to the narrative style and the characters. I do enjoy the sort of witty, third person omniscient narration style and it's always amusing to see what someone outside of the situation thinks of the people in it, but I think I actually come to enjoy that more than the going ons in the plot because there was so much personality in the narrator, though I will say sometimes there were too many asides. meanwhile, the characters felt almost plain in comparison and the plot felt like it moved glacially. I think I liked the characters as individuals but I just couldn't feel the chemistry, especially between john and the captain, which made it hard to keep on reading when I'd pause. overall, I do think hall's writing is witty and charming, but the combination of everything wasn't hitting for me and I think this just wasn't to my particular taste.

John Ceaser just wants to launch his sisters into society in peace, to navigate them through the already difficult experience of joining upper society with as few disasters as possible. However, this plan is almost immediately abandoned when John refuses to allow others to insult his sister's looks and their family. This sets off a chain of events that brings Captain Orestes James into John's life and Tatianna's court into his sister, Mary's. As Mary wish for greater beauty is answered by the fae, John and Orestes, along with the aide of Oreste's company of misfit soldiers, attempt to preserve her safety against threats both human and otherworldly.

To start this book is silly and over the top both in character and plot in a delightfully fun way. If one thing can go wrong at a party, three things will. It is a novel of trying one's best and finding that perhaps what a person thinks is best may not be right. Going into the book, I knew I did not enjoy the framed narrative structure of the first book as much as I enjoy the story. Unsurprisingly, the continued in the second which was more about a preference than anything Hall does wrong with that structure. Because I do not particularly vibe with the narrator or way in which that framing presents stories, I had difficulties as time with this sequel despite the rampant silliness of the book.

Confounding Oaths is book two in the Mortal Follies Series by Alexis Hall.
I enjoyed book one Mortal Follies. So I was eager to jump right into CO.
A charming sapphic regency fantasy romance story with characters so delightful I was sucked in so hard.
This book has the best magic, mystery, and mayhem.
I loved everything about it.

2 stars and my thank to Netgalley and the Publisher for the eARC.

The Alexis Hall Sequel Curse strikes again. It's wild how it happens every single time. They write a great first book and then the second is just...bad.

I know the narrator thinks John Caesar is dull, but god it's so hard to root for such a boring main character. Especially when nothing happens to him directly, but to those around him. The absolute negative chemistry between him and the Captain was painful.

I thought it was interesting to tell the story from the perspective of an outside voice, much like Mortal Follies. But at least in Mortal Follies, the story revolved around the main characters. For 50% of Confounding Oaths, everything was happening to everyone else BUT the mains. Idk if it changed, because 50% is where I DNF'd.

Loved this book so much, I rounded up from 4.5 stars for the first book in the series but this one was a true five stars. It got off to a much faster start now that but reader is familiar with both the characters and the narrator. The narrator really makes these books with his witty commentary and interjections throughout and I enjoyed revisiting many of the characters in the first book and hearing Mr Caesar’s love story.

Who knew that wishing on a star could bring such chaos into a family's lives? That's what happens when a representative of Titania's court grants the wish of a young Regency girl. Her older brother falls for a field commissioned officer of His Majesty's troops. Her younger sister remains as vexing as always. They all find out that the Fae are not to be trusted as Robin Goodfellow provides the narration of this tale. This is highly entertaining, especially as the "gentlemanly" language is offset by very frank soldier language. Such fun!

Confounding Oaths really feels to me like it's pushing back a bit on romance genre expectations and I am here for it. I'm so used to romance novels being centered around desire and physical attraction and all the other things that give the reader stomach swoops and swoony feels. The physical attraction between John Caesar and Orestes James is established early on but from there we get a story that is about deepening feelings for another person based on their character and actions. Expressions of kindness and care that aren't romantic per se but are the foundations of a good partner, and that push you to be a better person. It's not that the physical component isn't present, it's just off-page - in part because the narrator is uninterested in human bodies but also because John and Orestes are rarely alone.

The portrayal of John and Orestes romance dovetails beautifully with the themes of the main plot. John's younger sister Mary wishes to be beautiful and a fairy grants that wish by turning her into glass. The Caesars and Orestes and his band of Irregulars all work together to get Mary restores to human form, at first against Mary's wishes because she enjoys feeling beautiful and the attention it gets her. But ultimately she realizes that she wants men to feel attracted to her for who she is and not solely for her appearance. I was very sympathetic to Mary and her journey was moving to me. The dynamic between Mary and her younger sister Anne rang very true, and the growth of their relationship over the course of the novel was heartwarming.

All in all, I enjoyed Confounding Oaths and am crossing my fingers for a third book in this series with Miss Bickle and/or Miss Penworthy.

Confounding Oaths is the enchanting sequel to Mortal Follies. Mr. Caesar is set on helping his younger sister find a match, though things soon spiral rapidly out of control. Luckily for him, he meets the sensible and dashing Captain James. As the two work together to free his sister from a fae bargain gone wrong, sparks fly between them. Do they have a future beyond the end of the season?

Alexis Hall is incredibly witty and every sentence is packed with humor. Hall is an excellent storyteller and creates a compelling romance between Captain James and Mr. Caesar. I loved the interpretation of fairy magic (and sinister gods) in Regency-era queer romance. The characters have great banter and there is never a dull moment. The narrator is also extremely witty and I can only hope he’s nowhere near close to fulfilling his duties to Oberon.

Readers who enjoy queer romance, fairy magic with a twist, and witty dialogue should check out Confounding Oaths. I can’t wait to read what Alexis Hall writes next!

Thank you to Alexis Hall, Del Rey, and Netgalley for a free ARC in exchange for an honest review.

For publisher: My review will be posted on Goodreads, Amazon, Storygraph, and Barnes & Noble etc.

Confounding Oaths by Alexis Hall is a really unique story. I wanted to enjoy the narration and the historical aspects, but I could not force it. I love reading books that follow LGBTQIA characters. That is the best part of this book. Usually, I love reading really unique fantasy books, but I found myself unable to pick this book up. There was too much pomp and circumstance. It had a really unique premise that I loved, but I was unable to get into the story.

I had some trouble connecting to this story and becoming invested. It wasn't a bad book, just not for me.