Thank you to Atria Books and NetGalley for an advanced copy of The Crescent Moon Tearoom. I want to state upfront that I did DNF this book at 17% after realizing that I was not the intended audience for it.

This story is about a trio of witchy sisters set in Chicago in the late 1800s. Based on the cover, I expected this book to be on the relaxed side of the witch lit spectrum, perhaps with a romantic subplot. I would qualify this as cozy fantasy, as it is slower paced and has a somewhat distant narrative voice that errs on the side of telling rather than showing. I had hoped for something a bit faster-paced that dug into witchy phenomenon, rather than the more average descriptions of decor and chores.

I did enjoy the idea of a Jane Austen-esque teashop where the ladies of Chicago went to socialize and have little magics bestowed upon them, and the personality of the house is — in my opinion — a big selling point of this book.

Overall, this book was not for me but I do think that readers of authors such as Rebecca Thorne or C.S. Lewis might enjoy it.

Three sisters run a tearoom since the death of their parents, each with different abilities. When the Council of Witches
calling with three tasks to be completed or the tearoom will be closed, As the sisters deal with the challenges, each
is pulled in a different direction, putting their sisterly bond under stress. In the end, their mother's book will lead them to realize that their bond will remain as each follows her own path.
A charming story. about the bond between sisters.
#TheCrescentMoonTearoom #Atria #NetGalley

This was a well-written, well plotted book about triplet sister witches who must find thei own ways in the world and beat a magical curse. There's nothing wrong with this book. If you're looking for a lighter historical fantasy, you'll probably enjoy it. But there's nothing new or exciting about it, and it left me feeling a little meh. Sivinsky knows how to write a story, so I have hope that, much like her charcters, she'll come into her power when the time is right.

A cozy read, perfect for fall and winter where the three sisters all struggle with a curse and things probably would have gone sooner if they all just talked a little more. I loved the illustrations at the beginning of each chapter and enjoyed how all the characters were written. A great cozy read! 3.5/5

This was a cute cozy read which is my favorite kind! It made me wish I had a better relationship with my sister.

This book is a very cute, cozy story about three sisters and their magical tearoom. The star of this book is how the author built the setting. It's so easy to imagine yourself in the tea shop. Definitely check this one out if you love a cozy setting.

Firstly, a huge thank you to the publisher, Atria Books, the author, Stacy Sivinski, and NetGalley for the privilege of reading a digital ARC copy of The Crescent Moon Tearoom. It was truly a privilege, as it was a cute, cozy, and enchanting read that immerses you in the magical world of the Quigley sisters: Anne, Beatrix, and Violet. I will post my review to Goodreads and Amazon upon release.

The trio runs a tearoom together that is described with such vivid detail that you can almost smell the fragrant teas and pastries, feel the warmth of the candlelight, and sense the inviting nature, creating an atmosphere that is both mystical and comforting.
The sisters' bond and individual growth are at the heart of this captivating novel. Anne, Beatrix, and Violet each bring their own strengths to the mix. Their character development is beautifully portrayed in each of their tasks they must complete, learning to rely on one another and growing closer in the process. These tasks force them out of their comfort zone in certain ways they need, bringing new skills and personality traits to each sister in a satisfying way.

Sivinski’s writing transports readers to the enchanting Crescent Moon Tearoom, where every corner is filled with magic and charm. The world-building and attention to detail in the descriptions makes it easy to imagine yourself sitting at one of the tearoom’s cozy tables, sipping on a cup of enchanted tea, watching the sisters putter around and figure out their struggles. Beware, as it’ll make you wish there was a Crescent Moon Tearoom near you that you could pop into. This was so feel-good and sweet, with excellent plot pacing and developments that keep you turning the pages and wanting to know how it will all turn out.

In summary, “Crescent Moon Tearoom” is a delightful escape into a world of warmth, magic, and sisterly love. The Quigley sisters' journey is heartwarming, and Sivinski’s ability to create an immersive, witchy atmosphere makes this book a perfect read for anyone seeking a touch of enchantment. Would recommend this for readers of cozy fantasy, witchy fantasy, relaxing reads, feel good reads, character development, relationships, sisterly bonding, and family stories.

4.2/5 stars

An extremely cozy fairy tale for adults, I adored the tearoom and would love to visit. It did occasionally slip over the line into twee, which is why it dipped to 4 stars, but it truly is still delightful.

This book is pumpkin spice and apple cider donuts wrapped up in a comfy blanket. It is going to be the perfect cozy fantasy for the fall and I can't wait for people to fall in love with the Quigley sisters as much as I did. Though most of us don't have powers, premonitions and Fate to contend with, we still can identify with the struggle of growing up and growing apart which made this books all that more magical! I cannot wait to reread this in a few months with a cup of tea and a lavender biscuit

Thank you to NetGalley and Atria Books for an advanced copy of "The Crescent Moon Tea Room" by Stacy Sivinski.

You can find my reviews on Goodreads and Instagram:
https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/6625614572

https://www.instagram.com/s/aGlnaGxpZ2h0OjE3OTg5NjEzMjkxNjY2Mjc3?story_media_id=3408677808552172129&igsh=NHdsM3EwbTl5OTNy

Triplet witch sisters own a cozy tea room where they serve tea, pastries and fortunes. They soon discover that they are starting to forge their own paths. Anne, whose powers are the strongest any witch has seen in decades, struggles with letting go of the past. Beatrix is delving into a new power while writing a book. Violet dreams of flying. The three sisters must figure out a way to help three elderly witches find their Task all the while trying to break a curse. Will they be torn apart by these trials?

I can't believe this is a debut novel by Stacy Sivinski. This book was so heartwarming and cozy! 5 cups of tea for me. I will definitely be getting a physical copy on October 1, 2024 so I can annotate in it!

Thank you for this ARC!


The cover is what drew me into this cozy fantasy. This book is magical, including modern witches and Gould. I recommend this book to fans of cozy fantasy.

The Crescent Moon Tearoom by Stacy Sivinski is a novel about three sisters who serve tea, scones, and visions of the future in their quaint tea shop. Anne finds that her power is far stronger than she ever imagined, Beatrix realizes her dream of writing a novel is coming true, and Violet takes to the high wire to fly with the circus. Meanwhile, there’s a family curse that may drive them apart and the witches’ council may shut down their tearoom.

I would recommend this book for readers who enjoy magic, sisterhood, and a whimsical story. The descriptions of the tearoom are atmospheric and it’s easy to imagine yourself having a lovely cup of tea and learning your future. Each sister has a unique story that demonstrates their abilities as a witch and the family secrets are unraveled to reveal a magical ending.

Thank you Atria Books and Netgalley for the advanced reader copy. All opinions are my own.

4.5, rounded up to 5 stars

Many of the reviews describe this book as cozy and they are not wrong. Captivating early on, the atmosphere is rich with scent, magic, warmth, and intrigue. I love that the house is personified, giving a sense of enchantment and family ties. A beautiful novel about finding oneself, family obligation and how love changes over time. I have had many feelings while reading this, and think it is perfect to cozy up with for autumn with a warm tea once it releases Oct 1. st.

Thank you to NetGalley and Atria Books for tis ARC in exchange for an honest review.

"The Crescent Moon Tearoom" by Stacy Sivinski is a sweet, cozy fantasy following the triplets Anne, Beatrix, and Violet Quigley as they strive to stay together and challenge fate after the death of their parents.

The Quigley sisters are seers who live in a sentient house and run a tea shop. They also have a cool cat who can travel through time. Besides serving enchanted tea, they read their customers' fortunes via tea leaves. They can see anyone's future but their own. Their tranquil lives are disrupted when the Council of Witches demands that they reveal the tasks of three old witches or lose their shop. All witches have a task to complete before their death, or dire consequences will ensue.

Each sister has her own talent and personality. Anne is the most stable and powerful of the three, Violet is a creature of action, and Beatrix is the dreamy one. The plot thickens when the sisters discover there is a curse designed to separate them. They find themselves being pulled in different directions and have to find a way to stay together without losing their dreams if they can.

Overall, I enjoyed the book, but it was quite slow to start and took me a while to get into the meat of the story. Once I got in, I couldn't stop reading. I loved the premise and the idea of an enchanted tea shop and a sentient house. A house that cleans itself and does the dishes?? I want one too! And drinking tea while getting a reading is the perfect combination. I loved the writing and could envision the setting. I also loved the heading of each chapter and the descriptions beneath it, portending what is to come.

The book explores themes of sisterhood, self-discovery, fate, destiny, choices, and magic. The message that sometimes to stay close you have to let go came loud and clear. I loved the bond between the sisters, although they irritated me at times. They wanted to stay together, yet let their secrets (each has one) pull them apart. Besides Anne, the others didn't do much to overcome the curse. I did love how each found their own path, though.

The author writes the scenery and atmosphere of the Tearoom so well that you’ll be able to smell the mouth-watering scones and cakes and almost taste the flavors of tea. It certainly gave me the desire for a good cup of tea, preferably with my fortune told. If you're looking for a feel-good read that leaves you warm inside, this is your cup of tea (pun intended). This novel has great characters you can deeply connect with and care about, a great premise, and sweeping writing.

* Thank you NetGalley and (publisher) for the opportunity to read this arc. All opinions are my own.

What a cute, heartwarming story. Following each sister as they forged their own path while fighting to remain close was just lovely.

I hope this reader continues this in a series!

This was so good! I can’t believe it was a debut novel. It was so cozy and heart warming. I love the bond between the sisters but also them as individuals and the idea of self discovery. I blew through it so quickly and would highly recommend. Adding to our library 100%. Can’t wait to read what she writes next.

Super cute, cozy read about 3 sisters / witches that have been inseparable their whole lives discovering a family secret and finding their own individual paths in life.

The Crescent Moon Tearoom is a lush cozy fantasy filled to the brim with sisterly bonds, magic, and self-discovery. Fans of Howl's Moving Castle or Practical Magic will love this cozy fantasy novel from debut author Stacy Sivinski!
Each of the sisters was so unique - I loved how they all had their own voices and motivations. I did think that each sister was a little too perfect - they were all hugely successful or powerful and didn't have to work very hard to make their own dreams come true. However, I loved the overarching message of remaining true to yourself, even if it means deviating from the path you initially thought you had to follow.
The worldbuilding and writing were so beautiful. I loved the different descriptions of the tea and treats. Also, sentient beings are such a fun part of fantasy books. I just loved the way the house was characterized in this book - it felt like a part of the main cast. The narration style seemed to struggle a little bit at the beginning of - we would switch perspectives mid-paragraph, so one sentence would be from Anne, and the next from Beatrix. This was fixed early on in the book, so the chapter or paragraph would change along with the point of view. Overall, this is a perfect fall read for fans of cozy fantasy, sisterhood, and a slight touch of romance. I look forward to reading more of Stacy Sivinski's work in the future!
Thank you so much to NetGalley and Atria Books for the eARC!

Thank you NetGalley and Atria Books for the ARC. This book was a 4.5 star read for me, but I am rating it 5 stars because rounding down to 4 stars wouldn't do it justice. This is the author's debut novel and I will be picking up whatever her second book ends up being.

This is a cozy urban fantasy set in early 1900 Chicago and follows three sisters as they: solve a family mystery, discover who they are and run a magical tea shop. I don't want to spoil anything but this will tug at your heart and really make you think about what staying together means. Also, there is a sentient house that somehow is one of my favorite characters.

Together, Anne, Beatrix, and Voilet are a lot of things. Witches, sisters, triplets, seers. After their parents have passed, we find them in the Crescent Moon Tea Room, comfortable but a bit adrift, each trying to make the life that they feel is expected of them. As the story unfolds, they start to realize that they may need to look beyond those supposed expectations, beyond eachother, to find their true identities.

What a delightful debut! Cozy, like curling up with your favorite cup of tea on a chilly day. Sympathetic characters, a lovely atmosphere, just the right amount of world building, and a bit of mystery to untangle. Easy go read, even easier to reccomend!

ARC provided by NetGalley and Atria Books.