The Crescent Moon Tearoom follows sisters Anne, Violet, and Beatrix, who run a tea house in Chicago. The three are also witches who read the fortunes of ladies who come into their tea room. When the mysterious Council of Witches sets the trio a task, they have to figure out how to lift their family's curse and determine the future of their business.

I really like books with witches running shops so I was excited for this one! I generally liked the plot, characters, and magic system. It's multiple POVs with one for each sister. I both enjoyed and was confused that this was set in Chicago. I kept thinking it was Regency England and then a Chicago reference would happen and I had to reorient myself. I live in Chicago so I was happy to see it represented in a book like this that very easily could have just been in London. I'm not sure if I just missed the boat on the time period but I think it was around or pre 1920? Idk. Either way, I thought the setting was cool!

I'm not sure what my problem was but I was so distracted reading this book. I checked my phone about every 5 seconds. I think the plot just kind of dragged a little for me so it was hard to stay engaged. I'm not sure if this is a me problem or not, but it is something that I noticed!

Overall, I liked this book and recommend it if smaller stories and witches are your cup of tea! (geddit?) 3.25 stars from me rounded down to 3. Thank you to Atria Books and NetGalley for the eARC of this book, my thoughts are my own!

I was really looking forward to this, I loved the cover and was excited to read a witch fantasy. I really love books about sisters and them coming together while finding themselves. I enjoyed the scenry of the book and would recommend for a short and sweet read.

A delightful and heartwarming novel that blends magic, sisterhood, and a family curse. I loved the vivid descriptions and he magical atmosphere.
Many thanks to Atria and to Netgalley for providing me with a galley in exchange for my honest opinion.

3.75

Whimsical, endearing, and charming, The Crescent Moon Tea Room is a light read that is perfect for fall. Stacy Sivinski’s debut novel transports readers into a cozy fantasy world filled with magic, tea, and sisterly bonds.

The story follows triplet seer sisters who run a magical tearoom, offering tea readings to their community. However, they discover they are cursed—a discovery that sets the stage for an enchanting tale of mystery and self-discovery. As the sisters work to break the curse threatening to separate them, they must also solve another mystery from the coven council: determining 3 other witches life tasks. In this magical world, witches must complete their life tasks before passing on, or risk being unable to fully move on.

This cozy, witchy read is heartwarming and filled with moments of suspense, making it an ideal escape for fans of magical realism and sisterly love.

Note: At times it didn't seem to flow how it should. Certain aspects were repetitive and the character development seemed rushed and lacked maturity. The first chapter is what captured me though, the moment with Anne and her mom was really cute. I do believe this is a wonderful debut novel and look forward to future work by the author.

Cozy fantasy and mystery featuring three sister witches and a tea shop. I enjoyed this book. It was super cozy with delicious food descriptions and a touch of romance. I loved following the sisters, their close bond, and their realizations of pursuing individual wishes and dreams. Definitely check out this book if you love cozy reads, sisters, tea readings, mysterious curses, and magic.

Such a cozy fantasy, set in the early 1900s. Th Crescent Moon Tearoom felt like Little Women meets The Night Circus meets Charmed. I really loved the relationship between the sisters; it felt real and raw, perfectly balanced between the support and the tension of many sibling relationships. The overlying tensions coming from the threat to the tea room, Beatrix’s budding writing career, and Anne’s fascination with the circus. The world Sivinski created pulled me in, and I initially put the book down to finish a library book, but when I came back to it, I couldn’t put it down. Excellent work!

This book was wonderful. It was bright and fun, and so witchy and spooky. An amazing fall read, could not reccomend more!!

Audience: Adult
Plot: 3.5 out of 5
Characters: 3 out of 5
Spice: 0 out of 5

Keywords: Cozy, Fantasy, Witches, Divination, Whimsical, Family

Tea Pairing: House Blend Black Tea (Vanilla English Breakfast) by Plum Deluxe

I received a copy of this book through NetGalley from Atria Books. Thank you! All opinions are my own.

Favorite Quote: “Today I taught the girls the recipe for happiness: a strong cup of vanilla tea with two spoonfuls of sugar and enough courage to weave your own dreams into the fabric of the everyday.” (Chapter 12)

This is the debut novel by Sivinski, and it’s an absolute cozy delight. This is a feel-good, whimsical, cozy fantasy story; and, for me, it just warmed the soul. It’s the story of three sisters, Anne, Beatrix, and Violet Quigley, who own a cozy tearoom in the Chicago area. Everything is going well, until one day, a visit from the Council of Witches shakes things up. The council is requesting that the sisters help three other witches uncover their life tasks using various means of divination. The sisters agree to help, and in so doing, they awaken their own magical powers and desires. Will they be able to stay true to themselves while being pulled in multiple directions?

What a delightful read! One of the features that I enjoyed the most was at the beginning of each chapter there was an explanation of the various shapes in tea reading. The tea reading snippets applied to what was going on within each chapter, which was a nice tie-in. I also enjoyed the character of the “house,” and how it appeared sentient— helping the sisters and providing things for them. Overall, I thought that the pacing of the novel was really good. The chapters alternated between the three sisters, as readers followed along their individual paths.

I would recommend this book to anyone who may enjoy either cozy fantasy or cozy witch fiction. Readers of the Woodsmoke Women’s Book of Spells may also enjoy this novel. This novel is definitely something to dive into with a cup of tea, and let the tea leaves bring good fortune.

Such a cute and cozy read. Perfect for fall and spooky season. I loved the characters so much and was very invested in this story.

If your into cozy fantasy and family vibes this is for you. Its full of magic and witches who are separated by a curse. This is a feel good book if your looking for something to make you feel all the autumn vibes. 3.5 stars

This book is a captivating and immersive read that hooks you from the first page. The writing is beautifully crafted, with vivid descriptions and strong character development that makes the story come alive. The plot is well-paced, balancing moments of tension with quieter, reflective scenes that allow the characters to grow. The themes explored are deep and thought-provoking, resonating long after the final page. Whether it's the emotional depth, the twists and turns of the plot, or the unforgettable characters, this book is a must-read for anyone who enjoys rich, engaging stories. Highly recommended for fans of fantasy.

I absolutely loved this book! Beautifully written and a wonderful, magical story about the struggle between honoring family and wanting to forge your own path. The writing was descriptive and I felt instantly transported into the minds and hearts of the three main characters. Highly recommend and am very eager to see what is next from Stacy Sivinski after this incredible debut.

I really enjoyed this book! I love reading books that have witchy themes, and I like that this book chose reading tea leaves as its focus. When authors choose this kind of theme, tea readings are usually skipped up because there is A LOT that goes into it, so I just appreciate the care that went into. I also liked the sistery bonds that were shown in the book. I'm an only child, so I always enjoy living vicariously through family relationships like the sisters have.

A beautiful tale of the bond between sisters with an added magic spin. The Crescent Moon Tearoom is a world that I could live in for the rest of life, as long as I also had a time-traveling cat by my side.

DNF'd at 14%

There was nothing about the beginning of this book about sisters running a magical tea room that captured me or compelled me to keep reading. The setting wasn't enveloping or magical enough and I felt no connection to any of the sisters. There were no compelling plot elements to draw me in either.

Thank you to NetGalley and Atria for the advanced review copy.

So cute and whimsical! It was a great read to provide me with something lighter but intriguing enough to keep my attention and reading momentum. Characters were well developed and likable. Story was paced decent but was a slow burn for me.

A lovely October read. It had all the coziness I look for in a fall read and I appreciated that while there were "stakes" they weren't scary or super intense. The book felt like a love letter to sisterhood, home, and tea! What more could you ask for. Each sister's story was unique and engaging, though I was partial to Violet's story. The descriptions of the circus on the shores of Lake Michigan made me want to sneak away to a midnight show under the big top too. Best read while sipping a cup of your favorite tea next to a cracking fire (real or virtual)!

Triplets Anne, Beatrix, and Violet Quigley are witches who run a tea shop where they read the fortunes of their customers. As their parents were a mixed marriage (witch mother, non-witch father), they remain a bit removed from the other witches of Chicago. The the Witches' Council arrives, sets them an impossible task, and threatens to shut down their tea shop if they don't complete it.

I really liked this book. It definitely falls into the cozy fantasy genre. The whole vibe of the tea shop is delightful. It's also an interesting look at family dynamics, and how even the closest of siblings can have secrets they keep from each other. For me, it was a gentle, comforting read.

Three clairvoyant sisters in
Chicago, bound by the shared trauma of losing their parents, live and work together until they each start discovering their own independent paths. Stacy
Sivinski's debut novel is exactly what l'd hoped for—a delightful and cozy fantasy with just the right touch of mystery and whimsy. The Quigley sisters, all witches, run a charming teashop where they read their patrons' futures in tea leaves. But when strange happenings begin and the witches' council sets them a daunting challenge, the sisters find themselves questioning if they'll be able to rise to the occasion.
My absolute favorite character in this book, however, was the house itself—a warm, spirited presence that cajoles, comforts, and supports them as they navigate the unknown.
This is a story of sisterhood and friendship, but also about independence and finding your place in the world. Sivinski's writing is lovely, with many poignant lines that linger after the last page. I'll definitely be recommending this to friends who enjoy cozy fantasy! It's like a warm hug, a steaming cup of tea, and a delightful escape all in one.

Stacy Sivinski's debut is the perfect autumn read. A family story about 3 sisters who own a magical tearoom where they use their divination powers to predict their customers' futures. she wove a lovely story where each sister was equally enjoyable. it is definitely a must read if you're looking for a cozy fantasy/mystery. the writing was excellent, especially for it being a debut novel.